Mandela: Long Walk to Freedom Blu-ray Review
Score: 69
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
'Mandela' film: engaging yet flawed; Elba shines, solid AV quality.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 75
'Mandela: Long Walk to Freedom' shines on Blu-ray with a detailed, vibrant presentation, showcasing the beauty and depth of its visuals, from textures to colors, with near-flawless transfer quality.
Audio: 70
Mandela: Long Walk to Freedom boasts an excellent DTS-HD 5.1 soundtrack, merging clear dialogue, immersive soundscapes, and robust music for a dynamic and engaging audio experience.
Extra: 56
Mandela: Long Walk to Freedom DVD boasts rich extras including an insightful commentary by Director Justin Chadwick, documentaries, and tributes reflecting Mandela's profound legacy, all with optional subtitles.
Movie: 66
Mandela film evokes struggle and spirit of a hero, led by Elba's compelling portrayal, against apartheid's violence and oppression.
Video: 75
The Blu-ray presentation of "Mandela: Long Walk to Freedom" offers an exceptional viewing experience, highlighted by its high-definition transfer that brings the vivid landscapes and intricate details of South Africa and its inhabitants to life. Managed by Anchor Bay, the 1080p HD transfer in a 2.35:1 aspect ratio delivers crisp, sharp visuals that make every scene pop with clarity and depth. From the minute textures of facial expressions to the expansive, breathtaking African landscapes, every detail is strikingly presented. The film-like texture is complemented by a balanced grain structure that enhances the visual depth without compromising on detail.
Color reproduction is another area where this Blu-ray shines, showcasing a rich and robust palette that elevates the visual storytelling. Whether it's the earthy tones of rural settings, the vibrant hues of South African attire, or the dark, inky blacks of night scenes, colors are rendered with natural warmth and balance, contributing greatly to the film's immersive quality. The visual fidelity maintains natural skin tones and captures the nuanced environments, from bustling townships to serene landscapes, with remarkable precision. Although minor aliasing is noted, it does not detract significantly from the overall high-quality viewing experience.
This release demonstrates the capabilities of the Blu-ray format, with deep black levels adding to the contrast and dimensionality of each scene without losing detail. Even in darker sequences, textures and colors remain distinct and vivid. Despite the occasional visibility of makeup lines under high definition scrutiny, this does not mar an otherwise stellar presentation. The transfer is free from wear and notable anomalies, ensuring that "Mandela: Long Walk to Freedom" is showcased in the best possible light, making it a testament to the enduring power of visual storytelling when paired with cutting-edge technology.
Audio: 70
Mandela: Long Walk to Freedom" is graced with an exemplary DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 lossless soundtrack that stands out for its precision and immersive quality. The musical delivery is robust, with a notable balance between the rich, deep lows and the clarity of each note, creating an enveloping experience that extends beyond mere auditory stimulation. Ambient sound effects are depicted with remarkable vividness, from the bustling streets of Johannesburg to the subtle nuances of nature and the intensity of protests, ensuring that viewers are transported directly into the heart of each scene. The soundtrack's ability to handle a wide array of sounds, from the gentlest ambient noise to the most forceful chants and gunfire, is commendable.
Dialogue clarity is a standout feature, with each word crisply projected from the center channel, making even the most accented speech easy to follow. This clarity is matched by exceptional balance, ensuring that every spoken word is neither overshadowed by the soundtrack nor lost amidst the film's more dynamic sound effects. Sound effects themselves are delivered with a depth and richness that fill the soundscape, spilling into the surrounds especially during scenes of mass gatherings or tension-filled moments, adding a layer of realism to the narrative.
The audio mix excels in directional accuracy, allowing for an even more engaging viewing experience. The LFE channel impresses with its ability to bring a physical dimension to the on-screen action, particularly evident during scenes of conflict or when the score swells to accentuate the film's emotional peaks. With a dynamic range that captures everything from the quietest whisper to the roar of a crowd, this audio presentation enhances every moment of Mandela's story, making it not just heard but truly felt.
Extras: 56
The Blu-ray release of "Mandela: Long Walk to Freedom" enhances the viewing experience with a rich selection of extras that delve deeply into both the film's production and the life of Nelson Mandela. The array of bonuses includes a detailed audio commentary by Director Justin Chadwick, who offers insights into the challenges of portraying Mandela's spirit through Idris Elba, the meticulous recreation of historical moments, and the film's adherence to authenticity with the blessing of the Mandela family. Additionally, viewers are treated to a comprehensive Behind-the-Scenes Featurette, covering everything from production design to music, and a tribute video gallery featuring personal reflections on Mandela by notable figures. The highlight, "Mandela: The Leader You Know, the Man You Didn't," provides a captivating recap of Mandela's life, interwoven with film clips and historical archives, underlining the film's rich narrative fabric. This extra content not only enriches viewers' understanding of the film's background but also offers an intimate glance at Mandela's legacy.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary with Director Justin Chadwick: In-depth commentary covering various aspects of the film's production and historical accuracy.
- Mandela: The Leader You Know, the Man You Didn't: A detailed overview of Mandela's life, featuring celebrity insights and archival footage.
- Behind-the-Scenes Featurettes: Focuses on specific filmmaking areas including Production Design, Costumes & Makeup, Special Effects, and Music & Sound.
- Tribute Video Gallery: Personal reflections on Mandela by celebrities and activists.
Movie: 66
Mandela: Long Walk to Freedom," a film adaptation of Nelson Mandela’s autobiography, engulfs its audience in the tumultuous journey of Mandela's life, from his early days as a lawyer to his 27-year imprisonment, and eventual liberation. The narrative embodies the essence of Mandela’s struggle against South Africa's oppressive apartheid regime, intricately woven with moments of personal and political strife. The portrayal by Idris Elba as Nelson Mandela stands out, bringing a profound depth to the character with a blend of strength, vulnerability, and a gravitas that captures Mandela's spirit and unwavering resolve. Despite the film's ambitious endeavor to encapsulate Mandela's expansive life story within a limited runtime, Elba's performance alongside Naomie Harris as Winnie Mandela, remains a linchpin for the movie’s emotional resonance and historical reflection.
The movie traverses a fine line between depicting the violent resistance against apartheid and Mandela’s eventual advocacy for peace and reconciliation. It neither shies away from the brutality of the struggle nor simplifies the moral quandaries faced by those in the fight for freedom. The transition from violence to peaceful resistance is portrayed with nuance, highlighting the evolution of Mandela’s tactics in achieving racial equality and justice. The film's pacing, under Justin Chadwick’s direction, attempts to maintain a balance between the historical scope and the intimacy of personal battles, but occasionally skims over complex events and transformations within South Africa’s socio-political landscape.
Visually, "Mandela: Long Walk to Freedom" benefits from its cinematic craftsmanship, blending the raw beauty of South Africa with the harsh realities of its socio-political climate. However, critiques have pointed out that the film, while encompassing a wide array of significant events, at times feels rushed and touches only superficially on some aspects of Mandela’s life and the broader struggle against apartheid. Despite these shortcomings, Elba’s towering portrayal infuses the film with a sense of authenticity and emotional depth. His embodiment of Mandela, along with Harris's fiery representation of Winnie, elevates the narrative beyond its potential constraints, making it a compelling watch for those seeking both an introduction to Mandela’s life and an inspiring depiction of resilience and leadership.
Total: 69
Mandela: Long Walk to Freedom" emerges as a cinematic representation that refuses to mythologize its central figure, opting instead to portray Nelson Mandela as a deeply committed human being, willing to endure profound sacrifice in his quest for liberation from systemic discrimination. Idris Elba's portrayal is nothing short of magnetic, lending considerable weight to a film that, despite its brisk pacing and dramatic flair, might not cover the exhaustive depth of Mandela's autobiography. However, it succeeds in weaving a narrative rich in perseverance against daunting state and societal challenges. The Blu-ray edition by Anchor Bay enhances this experience with superior video and audio quality, complemented by an array of satisfying extras that deepen the viewer's engagement with both the film and the real-life story it seeks to tell.
That said, while "Mandela: Long Walk to Freedom" shines in its visual splendor and boasts remarkable performances, notably from Elba, it occasionally falters in its narrative pacing and focus, extending its duration in parts without adequately exploring certain critical aspects of Mandela’s journey. This element might slightly dilute its overall impact for viewers familiar with Mandela's life story. Nevertheless, the technical execution remains commendable, with the Blu-ray presentation offering great video and audio alongside noteworthy, informative supplements. This aspect makes it a valuable resource for those newly acquainted with Mandela's legacy or seeking a cinematic exploration of his life.
In conclusion, although "Mandela: Long Walk to Freedom" may not unconditionally capture the exhaustive scope of Mandela's autobiography or resonate with the same intensity throughout its runtime, its strengths lie in Elba’s powerful performance, the film’s visual storytelling, and the quality of its Blu-ray release. It stands as an instructive, if not entirely comprehensive, cinematic piece that not only pays homage to Mandela's indomitable spirit but also serves as a springboard for further exploration into the life of one of history’s most enduring figures for freedom and equality.
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 100
From complex facial textures to worn building fa�ades, from intricately stitched clothing to brick, every surface shows a very well defined structure that showcases what Blu-ray is all about....
Audio: 90
Whether din on the streets of Johannesburg, light blowing winds and rustling grasses, driving rain, angry chants, automobiles pushing through the back, or airplanes zipping about the stage, Anchor Bay's...
Extras: 70
Mandela: The Leader You Know, the Man You Didn't (HD, 22:04): A capsule recap of Mandela's life, intercut with shots from the film, historical archives, and more....
Movie: 90
In essence, he's a rock in a turbulent world, capturing a command of emotions, a steadfast spirit, and a settled soul that certainly conflicts amongst itself between the yearning for peace and the need...
Total: 90
It's not so thorough as the autobiography on which it's based, but Mandela: Long Walk to Freedom nevertheless tells a full, compelling tale of one man's steadfastness in the face of incredible government,...
High-Def Digest review by Bryan KlugerRead review here
Video: 80
The detail is very sharp and vivid, with well-defined closeups of the actor's faces that show each scar, drop of blood, and makeup blemish very nicely....
Audio: 80
The LFE is excellent and the dynamic range is very wide here, with the bass rumbling during some of the action scenes when Mandela stages war on his country....
Extras: 50
Each one has interviews with the cast and crew talking about each particular part of the movie with some behind the scenes footage, and clips from the movie....
Movie: 50
From this point, we slowly see Mandela age, all the while still having a strong presence, as he can move stone, rock, as well as people’s views on freedom....
Total: 70
It just drags in several spots for too long and doesn't focus on certain things as much as it should....
Director: Justin Chadwick
Actors: Idris Elba, Naomie Harris, Terry Pheto
PlotThe film chronicles the life of Nelson Mandela, beginning with his early days in the rural Eastern Cape as the son of a tribal chief. It follows his move to Johannesburg where, as a young and vibrant lawyer, he becomes engaged in the political struggle against the brutal apartheid regime. His activism leads him to join the African National Congress (ANC), advocating for the rights and freedom of the black population in South Africa. Mandela's commitment to justice and equality results in numerous arrests and leads to his growing national and international reputation as a leader in the fight to end racial segregation and discrimination.
Faced with increasing government oppression, Mandela and his colleagues in the ANC make the difficult decision to fight apartheid with acts of sabotage against military and government targets. As a result, Mandela becomes a wanted man and eventually is captured by South African authorities. After a trial that captures the world's attention, Mandela is sentenced to life imprisonment for his actions against the apartheid system, and he is sent to Robben Island, where he spends many years. The story thus far not only explores Mandela's political and personal struggles but also delves into his family life, including his relationships with his wife and children who endure their own hardships due to his commitment to South Africa's liberation.
Writers: William Nicholson, Nelson Mandela
Release Date: 25 Dec 2013
Runtime: 141 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: United Kingdom, France, South Africa
Language: English, Afrikaans, Xhosa