Spider-Man 3 4K Ultra HD Blu-ray Review
Score: 82
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Sony's Spider-Man releases offer varied packages, but for the full experience, the Legacy Collections with exclusive extras shine despite the critique.
Disc Release Date
True 4K
HDR10
Dolby Atmos
DTS-HD MA
Dolby TrueHD
Video: 89
Spider-Man 3's 4K UHD Blu-ray dazzles with its finest franchise visuals, HDR, and WCG enhancement, despite being the trilogy's weakest link, showcasing unprecedented detail and color depth.
Audio: 89
Spider-Man 3's Dolby Atmos soundtrack delivers unparalleled aural perfection, with meticulous details, dynamic effects, and immersive cinematic experience, setting a new benchmark for the series.
Extra: 76
Spider-Man 3's Ultra HD Blu-ray release lacks essential extras, notably the 3.1 cut, relegating content to separate discs or sets, showing a dismissive attitude towards comprehensive fan experience.
Movie: 46
Raimi's Spider-Man trilogy ends on a low note with Spider-Man 3, overloaded with villains and lacking focus, leading to Raimi's exit and a reboot. Meanwhile, all three films receive a 4K HDR upgrade, available in special releases.
Video: 89
Spider-Man 3 marvelously weaves its tapestry in the realm of 4K Ultra HD Blu-ray, boasting a pristine presentation with a resolution of 3840 x 2160p, a widescreen 2.4:1 aspect ratio, enriched further by 10-bit video depth, the wider color gamut (WCG), and High Dynamic Range (HDR), all meticulously encoded using the HEVC (H.265) codec. This review was conducted on cutting-edge viewing equipment, namely a Samsung UE55KS8000 Ultra HD TV paired with a Samsung UBD-K8500 Ultra HD Blu-ray player, ensuring that every visual nuance was captured in its full glory. Despite being the trilogy's narrative underdog, this installment shines the brightest in terms of visual fidelity, a testament to the advancements in mastering technologies and dedication to preserving the film's original cinematic beauty.
The leap from its predecessors is palpable, with Spider-Man 3 benefiting immensely from the groundwork laid by the Mastered in 4K Blu-ray releases, now augmented with HDR and WCG to deliver a visually stunning experience. The native 4K source does wonders for detail clarity, from the intricate textures of Spider-Man's suit to the complexities of the urban landscape, ensuring that everything from the grittiness of Sandman to the sleek menace of Venom is portrayed with unprecedented sharpness and color vibrancy. The film's use of grain is tactful, enhancing its cinematic texture without overshadowing the clarity brought forth by its 4K presentation. This installment not only celebrates the zenith of visual effects in the trilogy but sets a new standard for film-based 4K releases.
The enhancement brought about by HDR is particularly noteworthy, refining black levels and shadow detail to impressive extents while ensuring skin tones remain natural and accurately replicated. The HDR-infused color palette subtly amplifies depth and saturation, enriching the viewing experience without altering the film’s original aesthetic intention. With no significant wear or encode issues to detract from its splendor, Spider-Man 3’s Ultra HD presentation is a showcase of technical prowess and a vivid testament to the potential of UHD technology, achieving a visual quality that not only surpasses its Blu-ray counterpart but stands as a pinnacle within the Spider-Man series and beyond.
Audio: 89
The audio presentation of "Spider-Man 3" on 4K UHD Blu-Ray sets a new standard for home cinema, showcasing an exceptional Dolby Atmos track that builds upon the already formidable Dolby TrueHD 7.1 mix. This installment not only matches but surpasses its predecessors with its meticulous attention to detail and technological advancements, propelling it to the forefront as the new benchmark in aural cinematic experiences. The dialogue is crystal clear, projected flawlessly across the front channels, ensuring that every line, no matter how subtle, is discernible. However, it's the dynamic range of the effects and the vibrant score that truly steal the show, enveloping the viewer in a deeply immersive soundscape where both action and atmosphere are rendered with pinpoint accuracy.
The soundtrack distinguishes itself with how it manages to give a unique sonic identity to each villain, enhancing the narrative with a textured aural backdrop that complements their on-screen presence. From Sandman's granular swirls to Venom's sinister alien tonality, each character’s thematic elements are given life through sound, offering an enriched sensory experience. The improvements are not solely character-based; even environmental and action sequences benefit from the Atmos mix, providing an expansive soundstage where cityscapes feel astonishingly real and action sequences, such as debris from a destructive crane incident, showcase the system’s capacity for depth and spatial precision.
This superior audio presentation extends beyond just technical achievements; it creates an enveloping ambiance that brings the movie's high-stakes drama and thrilling action sequences to life. With effects that traverse smoothly across the sound space and a musical score that resonates with sweeping emotion, the Atmos track ensures that "Spider-Man 3" not only sounds fantastic but also serves as an exemplary demonstration of what modern home theater audio should be. Moreover, the inclusion of an expansive selection of languages and subtitles, along with an alternate score version in DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1, adds significant value to this 4K UHD release, making it a must-have for both audiophiles and Spider-Man enthusiasts alike.
Extra: 76
The 4K UHD Blu-ray release of "Spider-Man 3" has sparked considerable debate among enthusiasts, notably for its approach to extra content. Unlike its predecessors in the Sam Raimi trilogy, it outsources all additional materials to a separate Blu-ray disc, neglecting to include the notable 3.1 cut in its standalone edition— a move criticized as a missed opportunity for both collectors and fans. While the extras, comprehensive and engaging, are relegated to this secondary disc or found within the broader Legacy box sets, their absence directly on the 4K disc itself is disappointing. The available extras consist of legacy content including insightful audio commentaries with the film’s major players and creators, multiple featurettes highlighting characters, visual effects, and production challenges, as well as standard offerings like bloopers and music videos. This decision undeniably detracts from the direct 4K experience but does not wholly diminish the richness of the supplementary materials for aficionados of the series.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary 1: Features Sam Raimi and main cast members discussing their experiences and insights.
- Audio Commentary 2: A more technical perspective with producers, an editor, and a VFX expert.
- Featurettes: Cover various topics such as Sandman, Venom, Goblin, Gwen Stacy, production stunts, the love triangle, editing, and sound.
- Bloopers: A collection of on-set mishaps.
- Music Video: Includes the theme song.
- Trailers: Promotional trailers for the film.
Movie: 46
In the cinematic world of superhero sagas, "Spider-Man 3," presented in a visually stunning 4K UHD Blu-ray format, embarks on an ambitious yet tumultuous journey that ultimately challenges its own soaring aspirations. As the third installment in Sam Raimi's Spider-Man trilogy, the film grapples with an overladen plotline, endeavoring to weave a complex tapestry of characters and narratives that, despite its noble intentions, succumbs under its own weight. The battle with an encumbered storyline ensues, as the filmmaker attempts to juggle multiple villains including a misinterpreted Venom, a conflicted Sandman, and the emergent New Goblin alongside tangled romantic entanglements. This congested narrative landscape compromises the movie's pacing and clarity, consequently diluting the franchise's previously celebrated cohesion and charm.
Technical enhancements in this 4K UHD release serve as a silver lining, attempting to rejuvenate the film's appeal with meticulously upgraded visual and audio quality. Sony's commitment to revitalizing the original trilogy is evident through the new 2160p/HDR-enhanced video transfer and immersive Atmos audio track encapsulated in both Steelbook and DigiBook editions. These technical refurbishments strive to enrich the viewing experience, highlighting the film's high-production values and detailed cinematography. However, even the most adept technological touch-ups struggle to elevate a narrative beleaguered by excessive characters and unsteady editorial decisions, leaving fans to ponder what could have been if the creative vision had not been mired by the push for more content at the expense of storytelling precision.
Ultimately, "Spider-Man 3" in 4K UHD Blu-ray incarnation endeavors to pay homage to its predecessors while reaching for new cinematic heights. Yet, it serves as a cautionary tale of franchise expansion, illustrating the pitfalls of overextension and creative compromise. As viewers traverse through this visually enhanced yet narratively cluttered superhero odyssey, they are left with mixed feelings — admiration for its ambitious scope and technical prowess alongside lament for its missed opportunities in narrative finesse and character development.
Total: 82
The 4K UHD Blu-ray presentation of "Spider-Man 3" delivers a compelling argument for the film's visual and auditory spectacle, despite its often-debated position as the weakest link in the Tobey Maguire Spider-Man series. Sony's release of the first five Spider-Man movies provides fans with several purchasing options, including comprehensive 5-movie sets and segmented collections, with a noteworthy emphasis on the "Spider-Man 3" standalone inclusion in the Legacy Collections. These particular sets not only house the movie but also feature an abundance of extras, among which is the "Spider-Man 3.1" cut—a marginally improved version of the film.
The native 4K resolution upgrade marks a significant improvement over its predecessors and peers, presenting what could arguably be described as the franchise's pinnacle in audio-visual quality. The film's delivery in this format boasts a remarkable sharpness and depth, enhanced by a dynamic Dolby Atmos soundtrack that eclipses what many of its digital contemporaries manage with their 2K Digital Intermediates. However, this release falls short in its treatment of additional content. The absence of new extras and the notable exclusion of the "Spider-Man 3.1" cut from the standalone release detracts from what could have been a comprehensive package for enthusiasts seeking to explore beyond the film's surface.
In conclusion, while "Spider-Man 3" on 4K UHD impresses with its superior visual and audio presentation, making it a reference-quality example of home cinema technology, the overall package leaves something to be desired for fans and collectors aiming for a complete exploration of the film's world. The limited inclusion of extras and the decision to reserve certain content for more expensive sets might disappoint those hoping for an exhaustive compendium of "Spider-Man 3" materials. For those satisfied with pure audio-visual excellence, this release warrants attention; yet, aficionados craving depth and detail beyond the screen will need to consider investing in the broader Legacy Collections to fulfill their interests.
avforums review by Casimir HarlowRead review here
Video: 100
Frustratingly given it's the weakest entry, it looks the best of the lot As with the first two, this third film's presentation is founded upon the solid work done for the Mastered in 4K Blu-ray line a...
Audio: 100
Near aural perfection Dialogue gets given clear and coherent dissemination across the frontal array, taking priority where necessary, although clearly frequently taking a back seat to the explosive effects...
Extras: 60
Sure, Spider-Man 2 only delivered the 2.1 cut on the accompanying Blu-ray, and sure neither of the first two movies ported any of the extras over onto the Ultra HD Blu-ray discs themselves, but Spider-Man...
Movie: 50
The Spider-Man saga had already established plenty of ongoing character arcs, including the birth of the New Goblin here which had been brewing across all three films, and there was just too much going...
Total: 70
If you want almost every extra available the Legacy Collections are your best bet because, in addition to providing everything in these standalone releases, they offer two further Blu-rays with extras,...
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 100
Details are firm and steady, with all of the usual elements, such as complex skin and clothing textures, varied urban landscapes, and the Spider-Man suit (regular and dark alike) revealing incredible,...
Audio: 100
The upper layer of sound offers some positive moments of stage domination, such as that mentioned prior, but for the most part it's a complimentary, added piece in better shaping music and environments...
Extras: 100
Spider-Man 3's 4K UHD disc contains no supplements beyond the usual Sony "cast and crew" photo tab and collection of categorized "moments:" (2160p/HDR/Atmos): The Symbiote, Villains, Spider-Man, and Amazing...
Movie: 50
Sony has released all three of the Tobey Maguire/Sam Raimi 'Spider-Man' films to the UHD format with new 2160p/HDR-enhanced video and new Atmos audio....
Total: 0
The oft-debated Spider-Man 3 is generally regarded as the "least" of the Tobey Maguire films, but still enjoys a few highlights....
Director: Sam Raimi
Actors: Tobey Maguire, Kirsten Dunst, Topher Grace
PlotPeter Parker has finally managed to strike a balance between his devotion to M.J. and his duties as a superhero. But this stability is short-lived when his Spider-Man suit mysteriously turns black, enhancing his powers but also amplifying the darker qualities of his personality that he struggles to control. As the suit's influence grows, Peter becomes arrogant and neglects those he cares about most. Meanwhile, the city heralds Spider-Man as a hero, leaving Peter basking in uncharacteristic public adulation.
Outside of Peter's personal challenges, new foes emerge to threaten New York. Flint Marko, an escaped convict, becomes engulfed in a freak accident that transforms him into the shape-shifting Sandman. Marko's desperate attempt to save his critically ill daughter leads him on a collision course with Peter's alter-ego. Additionally, Peter must contend with Harry Osborn, who continues to seek vengeance against Spider-Man, believing him responsible for his father's death. Harry adopts the mantle of the new Goblin, utilizing his father's technology to challenge Peter both personally and as Spider-Man. As Peter fights these battles, another adversary, Eddie Brock, a rival photographer, jockeys for position at the Daily Bugle and becomes entangled in the web of conflict. The arrival of an alien organism sets the stage for the emergence of an even greater threat that challenges the foundation of Peter's world.
Writers: Sam Raimi, Ivan Raimi, Alvin Sargent
Release Date: 04 May 2007
Runtime: 139 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: United States
Language: English, French