Mister Roberts Blu-ray Review

The Blu-ray presentation of "Mister Roberts" marks a notable achievement in restoring this classic film. Filmed in an ultra-wide Cinemascope aspect ratio with the early implementation of the single-strip Eastmancolor process, the visuals are both striking and faithful to its original 2.55:1 aspect ratio. The 1080p transfer, utilizing the AVC codec, showcases inviting Pacific footage, with blue skies and waters that are vividly captured. The restoration by Warner Bros. Motion Picture Imaging, sourced from a 4K scan of the original camera negative, brings an exceptional level of detail to the ship exteriors and the colorful attire of South Pacific islanders.

Despite a handful of shots that exhibit occasional softness or minor blurring on the left side of the frame, these moments are minimal compared to the overall excellent quality. Contrast is superbly handled, free from age-related scratches or spots. Skin tones appear natural, and bursts of vivid colors like pinks, greens, and yellows are aptly vibrant. With no significant registration issues present, Warner Archive's effort has resulted in Mister Roberts's finest home video presentation to date.

The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track for "Mister Roberts" is an impressively nuanced offering, skillfully adapted from the original four-track stereo recording that garnered an Academy Award nomination. The mix exhibits a notable attention to detail, with Franz Waxman's robust score taking prominence in the front channels, presenting remarkable separation and a substantial dynamic range. Dialogue is predominantly clear and given priority over the score, except for a few instances of poorly synchronized ADR clips. The sparse yet effective use of the rear channels contributes subtle ambient touches such as periodic loudspeaker announcements and the nuanced sounds of ocean waves, enriching the auditory experience. Additionally, sporadic rowdy scenes, including welcoming South Pacific islanders, are well integrated.

The audio mix maintains a harmonious balance, with dialogue centralized and Waxman’s musical compositions extending across the front soundstage and occasionally permeating the rear channels. This spatial arrangement allows for certain sound effects to enhance the listening experience significantly, particularly a notably powerful explosion that will resonate distinctly in any competent sound system. Remarkably, the track is devoid of age-related anomalies such as hiss, crackle, flutter, or pops, ensuring a pristine and immersive audio presentation. Integrated English (SDH) subtitles are available and impeccably formatted without any synchronization issues, making this audio presentation of "Mister Roberts" a technically proficient and engaging experience.

The Blu-Ray edition of "Mister Roberts" includes a range of informative and engaging bonus features, although it falls short compared to Warner Bros.' 2001 DVD edition. The audio commentary by Jack Lemmon is insightful, offering anecdotes about on-set conflicts, John Ford’s direction, and Lemmon's friendship with co-star James Cagney. However, it is scene-specific with significant gaps, mitigated by narrator instructions. The theatrical trailer adds a nostalgic promotional touch but is also accessible via Warner Archive's YouTube channel. The packaging is standard with poster-themed cover art but lacks additional inserts or tributes featured in previous versions.

Extras included in this disc:

• Audio Commentary: Commentary by Jack Lemmon providing insights about the film-making process.
• Theatrical Trailer: Original promotional piece available in HD.

"Mister Roberts," under the expert direction of John Ford and later Mervyn LeRoy, stands as a celebrated entry in classic World War II cinema, notable for its unique focus on camaraderie and internal conflict aboard a U.S. Navy cargo ship, "The Reluctant." The narrative centers around the dynamic Lieutenant Doug Roberts, portrayed masterfully by Henry Fonda, whose desperate efforts to transfer from an uneventful post to combat zones are continually thwarted by the vindictive Lieutenant Commander Morton (James Cagney). This tension is the heart of the story, encapsulated by Roberts’ regular insubordination and ultimate sacrifice for his crew's well-being. Supporting performances from William Powell as Doc, and a scene-stealing Jack Lemmon in an Oscar-winning turn as Ensign Pulver add to the film's rich tapestry of character interactions and interpersonal drama.

The film's authenticity is enhanced by a faithful adaptation of its source material – the 1946 novel by Thomas Heggen and the highly successful Broadway play. Despite the turmoil during production, including significant directorial changes due to John Ford's health issues and emergency surgery, the final product seamlessly blends contributions from Ford, LeRoy, and an uncredited Joshua Logan. The pristine visual and auditory quality of Warner Archive's Blu-ray release further preserves this classic's legacy, providing a cinematic experience that rivals contemporary war dramas. The interplay between Roberts and Morton achieves an almost electric tension, while the script’s ability to magnify key dramatic sequences offers an expansive feel far removed from typical stage-to-film adaptations.

"Mister Roberts" remains a compelling depiction of duty versus desire, buoyed by stellar performances and deftly handled direction that brings every element of its source material vibrantly to life. Its enduring charm lies within its rich character studies, the palpable friction of its central relationships, and its poignant exploration of military life’s often overlooked monotony and longing for purpose.

Mister Roberts, directed by John Ford and Mervyn LeRoy, is a distinguished wartime comedy-drama that still resonates powerfully over 65 years since its original release. The film, rooted in its compelling source material, remains engaging through its smooth direction and the immaculate performances of an all-star cast. Notably, the climactic ending leaves a lasting impression, provoking both reflection and admiration.

The Blu-ray release from Warner Archive does exceptional justice to this classic with a 4K-sourced restoration that magnificently captures the film's CinemaScope visual splendor. The high-definition video presentation is crisp and richly detailed, ensuring that viewers can appreciate the meticulous cinematography and period-accurate production design. The accompanying six-channel surround track enhances the auditory experience, delivering clear dialogue and an immersive soundscape that complements the on-screen action.

Additionally, the package includes two valuable bonus features from the DVD era, enrichening the viewing experience with historical context and behind-the-scenes insights. Fans of "Mister Roberts" will find this release to be a treasured addition to their collection, while newcomers are afforded a premium introduction to this war comedy gem.

As scrappy as its source material implies, John Ford and Mervyn LeRoy's Mister Roberts still plays great over 65 years later, thanks to smooth direction and an all-star cast of talented performers. And what an ending! Warner Archive's Blu-ray follows suit with another outstanding 4K-sourced restoration that showcases the film in all its CinemaScope glory, which is also supported by a very strong six-channel surround track and two DVD-era bonus features. It's a very nice package for fans of this forgotten war comedy and comes heartily recommended to newcomers as well.