A Poem Is a Naked Person Blu-ray Review
Score: 69
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
A unique music documentary experience with magnetic Russell footage, compelling extras, and strong technical merits; highly recommended.
Disc Release Date
Video: 67
A Poem Is a Naked Person's Blu-ray presents a remarkable 1080p visual experience, with a 1.33:1 aspect ratio from a 2K resolution digital transfer. The organic look captures deep black levels, vivid colors, and preserved grain despite occasional clarity and tonality variations due to source elements.
Audio: 67
The LPCM Mono track on 'A Poem Is a Naked Person' is expertly remastered at 24-bit from a 16mm magnetic stripe, achieving impressive fidelity despite its inherent narrowness. While lacking a 5.1 option, manual removal of clicks and hum enhances clarity, and dialogue consistently remains crystal clear.
Extra: 66
The Blu-ray extras offer a captivating journey through the making of "A Poem Is a Naked Person," featuring an unrestrained interview between Harrod Blank and Leon Russell, heartfelt Q&A with Les Blank, insightful documentaries on the film’s production challenges, and rare Super 8 footage, all accompanied by a comprehensive Criterion booklet.
Movie: 91
"A Poem Is a Naked Person," a long-delayed release, reveals Leon Russell's raw musical genius amidst Les Blank's distinct, tangential documentary style. The Blu-ray showcases vibrant concert segments, albeit with Russell feeling overshadowed by seemingly unrelated folkloric and rural motifs—a critique on Blank's broader cultural explorations.
Video: 67
The video presentation of "A Poem Is a Naked Person" on Blu-ray, courtesy of the Criterion Collection, is captured with a 1080p transfer in its original 1.33:1 aspect ratio. Using a 2K resolution digital transfer sourced from the original 16mm reversal check print, this edition gracefully balances the innate charm of its early 70s footage with modern-day clarity. The natural grain structure, though fluctuating in certain scenes, contributes significantly to the organic aesthetic. It's clear that various elements, such as shooting conditions and film stocks, influenced the visual texture, with some shots exhibiting a more gritty appearance than others. Despite these variances, there are no major compression issues apparent.
From a technical standpoint, Criterion's meticulous restoration work allows the documentary's colors to shine, predominantly with outdoor scenes displaying vibrant reds and blues. The palette does occasionally skew towards pinkish tones, which can be attributed to the original source material. However, these nuances do not detract from the overall visual impact. Closeups commendably capture intricate details like individual beard hairs and the scales of a snake, while wide shots maintain a commendable level of depth and detail.
Overall, the presentation successfully encapsulates the film's historical essence while delivering commendable picture quality. The black levels are deep and skin tones remain natural, providing a harmonious viewing experience throughout. Some minor print damage remains visible but does not disrupt the presentation's integrity. Criterion has evidently upheld their reputation for quality restoration, emphasizing both the vividness and subtleties that make this release a noteworthy addition for collectors and enthusiasts.
Audio: 67
The audio presentation of the Blu-ray release of "A Poem Is a Naked Person" features an LPCM Mono track, remastered with precision and care from a 16mm monaural mixed magnetic stripe track at 24-bit. The restoration process involved meticulous manual removal of clicks, thumps, hiss, hum, and crackle using advanced Pro Tools HD and iZotope RX4 software. Despite the mono's inherent narrowness, the track delivers surprisingly full-bodied fidelity, particularly notable during outdoor interviews enriched by ambient environmental sounds. The musical sections are well-balanced, maintaining integrity without distortion or dropouts, though some may find the absence of a 5.1 mix as a limitation for an immersive concert experience.
This sound mix, while true to its original recording constraints from the early '70s, exhibits variable quality across different scenes. Some moments showcase pristine dialogue clarity and vibrant soundscapes, whereas others occasionally appear muddled or soft, likely due to source constraints rather than transfer errors. The mono track capably supports the significant amount of talking head content within the film, providing an authentic aural backdrop that complements the visual storytelling. Though not perfect, the attention to detail in its restoration makes for an adequate auditory experience that aligns with the film's historical context.
Extras: 66
The Blu Ray extras for "A Poem Is a Naked Person" provide a comprehensive and insightful look into the film's history and creative process. "Harrod Blank and Leon Russell" offers a candid and enthralling dialogue between Leon Russell and Harrod Blank, exploring significant anecdotes including those from Shelter Records. The "Les Blank" segment captures a poignant Q&A just weeks before the filmmaker's passing, offering rare insights. "A Film's Forty Year Journey" meticulously charts the tumultuous path to the film's release, highlighting production challenges. "Out in the Woods" is an intriguing compilation of Super 8 footage showcasing early production moments by Maureen Gosling. Additionally, multiple trailers provide various perspectives on the film's promotional approach, supplemented by an informative accordion-style foldout insert with an essay and transfer details.
Extras included in this disc:
- Harrod Blank and Leon Russell: An engaging interview discussing the film's delayed release.
- Les Blank: A Q&A session with Blank detailing his experiences during filming.
- A Film's Forty Year Journey: Insights into the production struggles and eventual release of the film.
- Out in the Woods: Super 8 behind-the-scenes footage from the film's production.
- Trailers: Collection of promotional trailers.
- Criterion Booklet: Contains essays, cast and crew information, and details about the transfer.
Movie: 91
Les Blank's "A Poem Is a Naked Person" offers a unique, if non-traditional, documentary experience on Leon Russell, capturing his life and times without adhering to standard documentary storytelling. Highlighting footage filmed from 1972 to 1975, the film remained unreleased for decades due to creative differences between Blank and Russell. Known for enriching viewers' understanding of cultural landscapes rather than just individuals, Blank's approach diverges significantly from typical artist documentaries. This feature is both a strength and a caveat; Leon Russell's iconic status might lead viewers to expect a focus squarely on the musician himself, yet the film branches into a vivid tapestry of associated personalities and local cultures.
Russell's discomfort with the original focus likely stemmed from Blank's interest in the broader narrative environment instead of exclusive spotlighting. The documentary captures not just Russell but a series of tangential and peculiar moments—unexpected snippets involving surrounding life, fellow musicians like Willie Nelson and George Jones, and surreal imagery hinting at subtexts of the music industry and artistic collaboration. Concert performances and candid studio sessions offer glimpses of Russell's musical prowess, yet there’s an undeniable lack of direct personal exploration or interviews.
Ultimately, "A Poem Is a Naked Person" is characterized by Blank’s signature style—an intricate interplay between subject, setting, and artistic interpretation. Its unconventionality may bewilder those seeking a straightforward biographical account, while simultaneously providing a rich, abstract mosaic reflecting the complexities of Russell's world. The film successfully underscores broader cultural influences beyond the primary figure, making it an intriguing, multifaceted viewing experience for audiences open to its avant-garde storytelling structure.
Total: 69
Les Blank’s "A Poem Is a Naked Person" stands as a unique entry in the music documentary genre, capturing the intricate essence of its subject, Leon Russell, without conventional narrative structure. Blank’s approach deviates from the norm, offering an unconventional yet mesmerizing experience that reflects a free-spirited artistic journey. This documentary splendidly immerses viewers into a time capsule of 1970s rock culture through engaging and magnetically raw footage. While some scenes might seem tangential, they add layers of charm and eccentricity to the broader canvas of this film.
The Blu-ray release by Criterion is a commendable presentation that enhances the visual and auditory flavors of the documentary. The video transfer maintains a crisp, vibrant quality that preserves the film’s authentic aesthetic, while the audio perfectly complements the viewing experience, capturing the essence of Russell’s musical prowess. The supplemental features on this disc are robust, adding significant value through exclusive insights and behind-the-scenes glimpses that enrich the overall understanding and appreciation of Blank’s work.
In conclusion, "A Poem Is a Naked Person" transcends the conventional bounds of musical documentaries, embodying a unique union of visual poetry and sonic richness. This film offers a fascinating exploration of Leon Russell’s artistry through Blank’s innovative lens. It is both an important historical document and an artistic triumph that resonates with originality. The Criterion Blu-ray release underscores these qualities with its strong technical and supplementary offerings, making it highly recommended for collectors and music enthusiasts alike.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 80
This is a generally very nice, organic looking presentation of the documentary, though there are rather wide variances in clarity, detail levels and grain structure, as can perhaps be made out by looking...
Audio: 80
While the mono track is obviously inherently narrow, fidelity is surprisingly full bodied throughout, including everything from outdoor interviews, where some sweet countryside ambient environmental sounds...
Extras: 60
Out in the Woods (1080p; 12:59) is an interesting assortment of Super 8 footage shot by frequent Blank collaborator and editor Maureen Gosling, done at the time of the film's production....
Movie: 90
As Russell (a sweet if tart curmudgeon as evidenced by a supplement with Harrod) states, one of his issues with the piece is that it seemed to be more about Les Blank than about Russell himself, and some...
Total: 90
A Poem is a Naked Person is another completely unique offering from Blank, a kind of provocateur in the music documentary field, who here may have "poked" the wrong "bear", so to speak, at least as evidenced...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
The picture as a whole doesn't look like a 2016 sci-fi film in terms of clarity, but there is some great depth and vivid detail to notice throughout....
Audio: 80
I wish this had a 5.1 option, so that we could be fully immersed in the concert sequences to have a fuller sound, but the mono mix here serves up well, despite some small issues....
Extras: 80
- This is a great extra that has Harrod Blank (Les's son), the sound recordist and editor, artist Jim Franklin, and a couple others, discussing what it was like during the two year production of the film....
Movie: 100
So, Les, being the filmmaker he is, started filming the people surrounding Leon, including other musicians, friends, and neighbors, in addition to some very surreal imagery that he edited into a very poetic...
Total: 80
Never have I seen a music documentary about a musician, where the film doesn't actually contain a whole lot of its subject....
Director: Les Blank
Actors: Leon Russell, Eric Andersen, Richard V. Armstrong
PlotThe film provides an intimate and eclectic glimpse into the life of a musician immersed in the American counterculture of the 1970s. It follows a talented and enigmatic artist known for his work in multiple genres, capturing his dynamic performances and the environments he inhabits. The camera navigates through various scenes including vibrant concert footage, behind-the-scenes moments in recording studios, and interactions with fans and peers. This allows the audience to witness both the public spectacle and private intensity of his musical life, shedding light on his creative process.
In addition to focusing on its central figure, the film broadens its scope to explore the eccentricities of those in his circle, as well as the broader cultural landscape of the time. Diverse characters such as local artists, craftsmen, and even random passersby contribute to a rich tapestry of everyday life, peppered with unpredictable and often humorous moments. The documentary format is freewheeling and organic, avoiding structured narrative in favor of capturing raw, unfiltered slices of reality. Thus, it presents not just a portrait of an artist, but a fragmented and colorful snapshot of a broader artistic community.
Writers: Les Blank
Release Date: 08 Jul 2016
Runtime: 90 min
Rating: Not Rated
Country: United States
Language: English