Albert Nobbs Blu-ray Review
Score: 55
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
'Albert Nobbs' intrigues with stellar acting and class themes, yet lacks emotional punch.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 68
'Albert Nobbs' Blu-ray features a splendid 1080p transfer with vibrant colors, sharp detail, and consistent contrast, capturing both the beauty and melancholy of its settings.
Audio: 63
'Albert Nobbs' features a restrained yet immersive DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 soundtrack, capturing subtle environmental effects and Brian Byrne's score with high fidelity, reflecting the film's quiet, intimate narrative.
Extra: 16
The Blu-ray of 'Albert Nobbs' features a unique commentary by Close and Garcia, highlighting the film's humor and production insights, along with HD deleted scenes focused on Helen and Joe, and an HD theatrical trailer.
Movie: 56
Glenn Close and Janet McTeer shine in 'Albert Nobbs,' a melancholic yet compelling tale of hidden identities and unfulfilled dreams, overshadowed by Meryl Streep's success.
Video: 68
The Blu-ray presentation of "Albert Nobbs," courtesy of Lionsgate, boasts an AVC encoded 1080p transfer in its original aspect ratio of 2.35:1, showcasing a level of detail and color saturation that is both sumptuous and highly impressive for viewers. The video quality allows for an exceptional display of the film's diverse settings, from the intricately designed interiors to the wide range of outdoor scenes depicted throughout the story. Notably, the careful attention to detail is so precise that viewers can observe the minutiae of Glenn Close's remarkable makeup, bringing an extraordinary level of realism to her character. While most of the film maintains this high degree of sharpness and clarity, it's worth mentioning that there are sporadic moments where the image appears softer or slightly less defined compared to the overall high standards this transfer sets.
The cinematography, purposefully stylized by Michael McDonough, benefits greatly from the Red One digital cameras' capabilities, enhancing both the bleak, somber exteriors with their bluish-gray tones and the warmer, more vibrant interiors where secondary hues come to life. This deliberate choice in color grading supports the narrative's atmosphere without compromising on video fidelity. Despite these shifts in tone, contrast remains stable and consistent, ensuring that blacks are deep and true across various lighting conditions. This contributes to an image depth that is both pleasing to the eye and faithful to the cinematic intent.
Overall, this Blu-ray release faithfully reproduces the visual experience of "Albert Nobbs" with a high-quality transfer that will satisfy videophiles. From the outstanding level of detail in both the sweeping landscapes of 19th-century Ireland and the intimate interior scenes to the careful handling of color and lighting, the presentation represents a harmonious blend of technology and artistic expression. Though minor inconsistencies in sharpness are noted, they do little to detract from what is an exemplary showcase of Blu-ray video quality.
Audio: 63
The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 soundtrack accompanying 'Albert Nobbs' is an exemplar of auditory finesse, perfectly mirroring the film's nuanced and restrained narrative. It's evident that the audio design prioritizes clarity and subtlety over bombastic sound effects, crafting an intimate soundscape that excels in delivering whisper-soft dialogues with impeccable fidelity. Despite a limited dynamic range and a nearly absent low-frequency extension (LFE), the audio track shines through its thoughtful integration of ambient sounds, particularly in scenes set outdoors where the soundscape blossoms with realistic environmental cues, thereby enhancing the viewer's immersion into the movie's setting. Brian Boyle’s delicate score is deftly woven into this mix, further enriching the film's audio presentation without overwhelming it.
In scenes bustling with life, such as those set within the hotel, the soundtrack offers an impressive sense of space and movement, elevating the viewing experience by seamlessly integrating background activities and directional sounds that perfectly mimic the acoustics of a busy establishment. These elements are counterbalanced by moments of solitude outdoors, where the faint hum of Dublin's life adds layers to the film's atmosphere, delivering an audio experience that is both enriching and evocative. The front channels carry the weight of the mix, presenting dialogues and music with a warm resonance and a modest bass response that encapsulates the viewer in a cocoon of sound that is both engaging and emotionally resonant.
Overall, the audio track for 'Albert Nobbs' is a study in auditory refinement, striking an exquisite balance between foreground dialogue and background ambiance. Its successful execution in providing a lifelike and enveloping sound environment, without relying on aggressive sound dynamics, deserves commendation. The soundtrack not only pays homage to the film's subtle storytelling but also stands as a testament to how restrained audio design can significantly elevate the cinematic experience.
Extras: 16
The "Albert Nobbs" Blu-ray extras provide an intimate behind-the-scenes look into the making and conception of the film, primarily through the commentary featuring actor Glenn Close and director Rodrigo Garcia. This commentary, while somewhat reserved, sheds light on Close's extensive efforts to bring this story to the screen and offers scene-specific insights that occasionally highlight the understated humor of the film. The additional deleted scenes offer a glimpse into alternate character interactions, mainly involving Helen and Joe, enriching the narrative context. Furthermore, the theatrical trailer, alongside other Lionsgate film previews, rounds out the collection, providing a broader promotional perspective. These extras, preserving technical details regarding their high-definition quality, contribute significantly to understanding the film's production and thematic depth.
Extras included in this disc:
- Commentary with Actor Glenn Close and Director Rodrigo Garcia: Insightful discussion on the making of the film and Close's personal connection to it.
- Deleted Scenes: Three additional scenes focusing on character development.
- Theatrical Trailer: The original movie trailer along with trailers for other Lionsgate films.
Movie: 56
Albert Nobbs," starring Glenn Close, delves into the compelling but solemn life of its titular character, intricately exploring themes of identity and survival in 19th-century Dublin. Close's transformative and nuanced performance as a woman masquerading as a man to navigate the male-dominated, Victorian-era workplace is remarkable, standing out as a testament to her unmatched dedication and talent. Paired with Janet McTeer's equally impressive portrayal of Hubert Page, another woman in disguise, the film offers a rich, albeit heart-rending, character study. Directed by Rodrigo García, "Albert Nobbs" strives to navigate through its historical context with empathy and finesse, albeit somewhat falling short in emotional engagement.
The storyline pivots around Albert's secretive and isolated existence within an upscale boardinghouse, which becomes increasingly complicated following an encounter with Hubert Page. This meeting not only ignites a friendship but also prompts Albert to confront personal truths and unrealized aspirations. Despite Close and McTeer's stellar performances providing fleeting moments of hope and kinship, the narrative succumbs to a melancholic undertone, accentuated by the dour realities faced by both characters. A subplot involving a love triangle between Albert, a young maid, and the hotel's repairman introduces additional drama but ultimately dilutes the film's poignant exploration of its core themes.
In essence, "Albert Nobbs" stands as a distinguished period piece, bolstered by outstanding performances and a thoughtful, albeit bleak, examination of gender and societal constraints. The film's meticulously crafted atmosphere, combined with Rodrigo García's empathetic direction, renders it a noteworthy, albeit somber viewing experience. While it admirably encapsulates the struggles of living against the grain in a repressive society, it struggles to fully resonate, leaving audiences appreciative of its artistic merits but longing for a deeper emotional connection.
Total: 55
Albert Nobbs," set in a time slightly preceding the events of "Downton Abbey," offers a poignant exploration of class disparities and sexual inequality, mirroring the challenges faced by women in Victorian society. Despite not quite achieving the dramatic intensity of the famed British television series or delving as deeply into the lives of its characters, "Albert Nobbs" stands out for its critical portrayal of societal norms through the stellar performances of Glenn Close and Janet McTeer. The film, however, suffers from a sense of detachment, failing to fully engage the audience in its narrative. This, coupled with the movie's somewhat reserved emotional delivery, makes for a viewing experience that is intellectually stimulating but emotionally distance.
The Blu-ray presentation of "Albert Nobbs" excels in technical quality, boasting exceptional video and audio clarity that enhances the viewing experience. Despite this high-quality presentation, the package is somewhat lacking in additional content, offering only a scant selection of special features. This scarcity notwithstanding, the film is recommended for viewers who appreciate nuanced screen acting and are interested in a cinematic critique of gender and class constraints during the Victorian era. Fans of period dramas and devotees of Glenn Close's and Janet McTeer’s work will find much to admire here, even if the film does not quite leave the lasting emotional resonance one might expect.
In conclusion, "Albert Nobbs" is a compelling study of character and societal expectation, anchored by outstanding performances and a superior technical presentation on Blu-ray. While it may not fully bridge the emotional distance to its audience or offer a comprehensive suite of extras, it remains a noteworthy entry in the genre of period dramas. Its exploration of complex themes such as gender identity and social hierarchy, alongside top-notch audiovisual quality, makes it a worthwhile addition to the collection of any aficionado of earnest cinema.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 90
Black levels are also deep and consistent, and the entire presentation offers a really nice recreation of a cinematic experience....
Audio: 80
There are some very nice ambient environmental effects placed throughout the film, and when Albert ventures outside, the sound field opens up considerably, subtly immersing the listener in all kinds of...
Extras: 30
One of the more interesting aspects to this commentary is the emphasis Garcia and Close place on the supposed humor of Albert Nobbs, an element which may be decidedly in the eye of the beholder....
Movie: 60
And in some ways, that's one of the major problems with the well intended Albert Nobbs, despite the fact that the film is built around a central conceit that working class men in the 19th century had an...
Total: 70
Though it takes place a generation or so before the events of Downton Abbey, fans of that British television series may well find Albert Nobbs fascinating in terms of its portrayal of class differences,...
High-Def Digest review by M. Enois DuarteRead review here
Video: 80
Black levels, on the other hand, are very deep and true, providing the image with some incredibly dark shadows and some appreciable depth....
Audio: 80
Directionality and movement is effortless and fluid, generating a convincing feeling of being in the middle of a natural space....
Extras: 10
While explaining the story's origins and history, particularly Close's personal involvement for the last three decades, the two share memories on the production, some challenges encountered and praise...
Movie: 60
This is their show, and they carry the entire film with astounding grace and captivating poise, demonstrating once again the Academy's missed opportunity for honoring a pair of truly outstanding performances....
Total: 60
Although the film doesn't finish with the sort of emotional impact it probably aimed for, the brilliant performances of Glenn Close and Janet McTeer make it a worthwhile, memorable watch....
Director: Rodrigo García
Actors: Glenn Close, Mia Wasikowska, Aaron Taylor-Johnson
PlotIn 19th-century Ireland, a woman named Albert Nobbs leads a double life, dressing and living as a man to work and survive in the oppressive societal conditions of the time. Underneath her male facade, Albert works tirelessly as a butler at a luxury hotel in Dublin, scrimping and saving diligently. Her ultimate goal is to escape a life of servitude and open a tobacco shop where she can live freely and independently. Albert's life is one of solitude and secrecy, her true identity carefully locked away from the world's judgmental eyes.
Albert’s carefully constructed world begins to unravel when she meets a charming painter named Hubert Page, who is hired to do some work at the hotel. After a turn of events, Albert discovers that Hubert, much to her surprise, is also living a similar lie, disguising as a man to work and be with his wife. Encouraged by Hubert’s apparent domestic happiness, Albert starts dreaming of a life where she could openly live as a woman and love whom she desires. She becomes increasingly enamored with a young hotel maid, Helen, who is preoccupied with her own romantic entanglement with a reckless handyman named Joe. Albert's growing ambitions for personal freedom and affection set the stage for a poignant exploration of identity and the pursuit of happiness in a rigid and unforgiving society.
Writers: Gabriella Prekop, John Banville, Glenn Close
Release Date: 22 Feb 2012
Runtime: 113 min
Rating: R
Country: United States, Ireland, United Kingdom, France
Language: English