Fatman Blu-ray Review
Score: 72
from 5 reviewers
Review Date:
Fatman delivers a unique yet flawed experience, buoyed by Mel Gibson's gritty portrayal and solid technical Blu-ray specs, but with limited lasting appeal.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 83
Paramount's Blu-ray of 'Fatman' delivers a sharp, detailed, and color-rich image with standout facial textures, crisp whites, and deep blacks, though some minor digital noise and banding in darker scenes present slight issues. Overall, it pushes Blu-ray quality to near perfection.
Audio: 81
Fatman’s DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 soundtrack excels in clarity and spatial balance, delivering an engaging auditory experience with detailed environmental effects, robust gunfire sequences, and precise dialogue placement, creating a well-rounded yet occasionally bass-limited soundstage.
Extra: 43
Fatman’s Blu-ray extras deliver a solid package with a lively and informative commentary from Mel Gibson, the Nelms brothers, and crew, alongside 12 minutes of deleted scenes with optional directors' commentary, and a 10-minute storyboard-to-film comparison, ensuring fans are well-engaged technically and creatively.
Movie: 65
Fatman delivers an unconventional and darkly humorous narrative with standout performances from Mel Gibson as a grizzled Santa and Walton Goggins as a vengeful hitman, but suffers from uneven pacing, excessive exposition, and underdeveloped themes, diminishing its potential impact.
Video: 83
Paramount’s Blu-ray disc of "Fatman" impressively excels in delivering a clean, sharp, and digitally crisp image that showcases the native material with remarkable precision. The snow-covered landscape portrays an impeccably brilliant white, especially during the climactic gun battle, where daylight details such as individual splinters on stacked firewood and Mel Gibson’s rugged facial features come alive. Close-up shots of Chris Cringle reveal a stunning level of depth and nuance, bringing out every wrinkle and hair with razor-sharp definition. The elves’ vibrant green and red outfits are eye-catching and pop against the winter scenery. Minor digital noise in the darker underground scenes and typical color banding in shadows are present but minimal and not overly distracting.
The entire presentation thrives from corner to corner, maintaining a high level of clarity and detail in both expansive outdoor environments and intimate indoor settings. Sequences filmed at the North Pole capture the intricate textures of pine trees and Gibson's graying beard exceptionally well, with visual consistency maintained from close-ups to distance shots. Colors are robust, featuring warm holiday tones and a noteworthy contrast between the crisp whites of the snow and the stark reds of blood, all within the SDR spectrum. Black levels excel without distracting artifacts, providing vital image depth, although some night shots exhibit slight video noise due to constrained production pickups.
Technical specifications are robust with MPEG-4 AVC encoding at 1080p resolution and a 2.39:1 aspect ratio on BD-50 layers. Whether it's the snowy expanses outside Santa's workshop or the plush estate interiors, every frame reveals a high level of detail, devoid of softness. Depth is well-managed, giving a palpable sense of dimension to both foregrounds and backgrounds. The contrast remains consistently spot-on, never blooming even in the brightest white settings. Overall, Paramount has produced a near-perfect Blu-ray image, marked by rich, natural skin tones and detailed textures that enhance the film's gritty yet festive aesthetic.
Audio: 81
The "Fatman" Blu-ray is equipped with an impressive DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track, delivering a robust and immersive auditory experience. The soundtrack effectively utilizes the entire sound stage, blending in various ambient noises such as winter surroundings and factory activity to enhance immersion. Footsteps on snow sound crisp, while the bustling noises of the elves at work resonate clearly within the surrounds. Gunshots are particularly noteworthy, with each shot from Chris's colt wheel gun reverberating powerfully, adding weight and depth to action scenes. The low-end frequencies, though not overwhelmingly dominant, are adequately supportive during more intense moments such as car engines and dynamic musical stings.
Dialogues are firmly anchored in the center channel, maintaining clarity and precision throughout. The mix's directional effects shine during the climactic shootout, with the blaring alarm and gunfire's pitch and depth amplifying the tension. This high-intensity sequence demonstrates an excellent balance between spatial effects and environmental echoes, especially when action moves outdoors, creating a full-bodied auditory experience.
Overall, "Fatman"'s DTS-HD MA 5.1 track is meticulously crafted, offering solid directionality and well-balanced imaging. Although ambient effects subtly weave into the audio tapestry rather than dominate it, they proficiently draw the listener into various environments. While the bass may not be as pronounced as in larger blockbusters, it provides sufficient low-frequency support where necessary. The Mondo Boys' score transitions seamlessly from family movie melodies to action-packed themes, complementing the narrative arc effectively. This audio presentation ensures a captivating listening experience that enhances the film's atmosphere and storytelling.
Extras: 43
The Blu-ray release of "Fatman" delivers a concise but enriching set of bonus features sure to please aficionados and casual viewers alike. The highlight is the engaging audio commentary featuring Mel Gibson, directors Eshom and Ian Nelms, producer Michelle Lang, and cinematographer Johnny Derango, offering deep dives into photography, color timing, casting, performances, and more. Additionally, the set includes six deleted and extended scenes with optional directors' commentary, providing intriguing context and character moments that didn't make the final cut. A compelling storyboard-to-film comparison rounds out the extras, showcasing two key scenes with insightful director commentary on the filmmaking technique.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary: Comprehensive insights from the cast and crew on various aspects of the film.
- Deleted and Extended Scenes: Includes scenes like "Forgotten Milk" and "Stealing Checks" with optional commentary.
- Storyboard to Film Comparison with Director's Commentary: Features "Breaking the News" and "The Showdown" with visual comparisons and director insights.
Movie: 65
In "Fatman," filmmakers Eshom and Ian Nelms blend a novel concept with unconventional festive themes. The story revolves around a grizzled Santa Claus, Chris Cringle (Mel Gibson), who becomes the target of a young, vengeful Billy Wenan (Chance Hurstfield) after delivering coal to his stocking. Enraged, Billy hires hitman Jonathan Miller (Walton Goggins) to eliminate Santa. Beneath this darkly comedic premise, the film juxtaposes a mischievous child and a hitman scarred by unsatisfactory Christmases, revealing a cynical view of societal expectations during the holidays. The unusual distinction of Santa’s government contracts adds a contemporary twist, hinting at broader social critiques.
Mel Gibson and Walton Goggins are the film's shining virtues. Gibson portrays a tough, battle-hardened Santa whose interactions embody both stoicism and moments of humor, whereas Goggins delivers a menacing yet darkly amusing performance. Unfortunately, despite these strong lead performances, "Fatman" suffers from inconsistent pacing and a lack of cohesive tone. The film teases supernatural elements without fully committing, leaving the audience with questions about Chris's true nature. Moreover, while the final shootout is well-executed and climactic, the extensive exposition detracts from the overall experience, resulting in a film that never fully commits to its action-comedy potential.
Visually, "Fatman" lacks holiday vibrance, opting for a more utilitarian aesthetic. Chris's workshop, typically imagined as a whimsical space, is pragmatically Spartan, aligning with the film's serious undertone. While the limited budget is evident, the meticulous designs for some scenes, particularly the final duel set against snow-covered scenery, stand out. Despite these intentional choices, the movie sometimes wanders through less compelling subplots, diluting its initial allure. Ultimately, “Fatman” presents an intriguing yet uneven exploration of holiday revenge, bolstered by stellar performances but hindered by its disjointed narrative and underdeveloped themes.
Total: 72
"Fatman" presents an unconventional twist on the Santa Claus mythos, infusing it with a dark comedic tone that diverges from classic holiday fare. Mel Gibson delivers a formidable performance as the gritty, disillusioned Chris Cringle, while Walton Goggins provides a solid, though somewhat subdued, counterpoint as the film’s antagonist. The narrative suffers from an overburdened script that hinders its potential, yet the film’s unique premise and capable casting inject moments of refreshing originality.
Technically, Paramount's Blu-ray release excels in delivering a visual and auditory experience that complements the film’s thematic elements. The picture quality is sharp within the 2.39:1 AVC aspect ratio, and the English DTS-HD MA 5.1 audio track captures both the subtle and intense moments effectively. Additional features such as English, English SDH, and Spanish subtitles offer accessibility, while an array of bonus material, including insightful commentary tracks, enriches the viewing experience.
In conclusion, "Fatman" is a polarizing yet intriguing addition to the dark comedy genre. While it may not ascend to the ranks of timeless Christmas classics, it provides sufficient entertainment with its original take on Santa lore. Paramount's Blu-ray presentation is robust, making it a valuable addition for collectors and those interested in holiday films with a twist. For viewers who enjoy their seasonal cinema with a darker edge, "Fatman" offers a solidly fun watch worth considering. Recommended.
AV Nirvana review by Michael ScottRead review here
Video: 90
The snow covered landscape of the North Pole (or whatever is meant to simulate the North Pole) is brilliantly white at times, with the gun battle at the end of the flick showcasing stunning daylight details,...
Audio: 90
The crunch of footsteps on the fresh snow is sharp and clean to the ear, and the underground factory where the elves work hustles and bustles with the cacophony of busy work noises....
Extras: 40
Audio Commentary with actor Mel Gibson, Directors Eshom Nelms and Ian Nelms, Producer Michelle Lang, and Cinematographer Johnny Derango • Deleted and Extended Scenes • Storyboard to Film Comparison with...
Movie: 70
The hitman (only credited in the film as “the skinny man”) has had a sordid affair with Santa over the years himself, also being a bit of a bad boy and not getting the presents that he so desperately wanted...
Total: 70
Either way, fun enough movie, despite the flaws, and Paramount’s Blu-ray is more than good for collector’s....
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 90
Certainly winter clothes, natural environments, barroom interiors, and the plush estate where Billy lives all thrive, too, each of them revealing corner-to-corner sharpness and allowing the audience to...
Audio: 90
That shootout is easily the film's sonic highlight, surpassing even some of the edgier and more intensive musical cues scattered throughout the film, which do boast excellent clarity, spatial balance,...
Extras: 40
Actor Mel Gibson, Directors Eshom Nelms and Ian Nelms, Producer Michelle Lang, and Cinematographer Johnny Derango thoroughly dissect the film: photography and color timing, cast and performances, story,...
Movie: 60
Goggins' character has more upside but it's explored only in bits and pieces and without much of a satisfying feel for his motivations beyond the superficial, try as the film might to build him beyond...
Total: 70
Mel Gibson's turn as Chris Cringle won't be remembered in the same breath as his roles as Martin Riggs and William Wallace, but he does serviceable work as the tough-as-nails, and not so jolly or fat,...
DoBlu review by Matt PaprockiRead review here
Video: 80
Either way, the dilution keeps Fatman purposefully dull, that extending into black levels....
Audio: 80
...
Extras: 40
For an additional 19 Fatman screenshots, early access to all screens (plus the 120,000+ already in our library), 120 exclusive 4K UHD reviews, and more, subscribe on Patreon....
Movie: 60
A fine statement, suited to the tone, but Fatman never does anything with it; that thread dangles there, unfulfilled in the end, and the point saunters off, unmade....
Total: 65
Conceptually fantastic, Fatman can’t escape an overburdened script even as the casting works its magic....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
I'm not sure of the final scale of the Digital Intermediate, but during the audio commentary one of the directors clarifies to Mel Gibson they're looking at 4K. As this movie didn't muster up a large theatrical...
Audio: 80
From Billy's warm and inviting home with the scurrying sounds of servants milling about to Chris's arctic snow-covered homestead, there are subtle details in the track to keep the surrounds active and...
Extras: 60
At the top of the pack is the great audio commentary featuring the writer/director Nelms brothers, Mel Gibson, Producer Michelle Lang, and director of Photography Johnny Derango....
Movie: 80
While it may not be as strong a viewing the second time out, the sense of familiarity was already pretty strong, the humor still hit....
Total: 80
Fatman may not be the greatest new Christmas Classic to come around, but after a dark and rough 2020, it was the coal-black comedy I needed....
Why So Blu?Read review here
Video: 100
There are no dull blacks, and the overall look dictates that in the warmer interior scenes, the darkness should be integral....
Audio: 90
Surround Sound Presentation: The sounds of ambient nature, elf chatter and factory noise come through in the surrounds most of all....
Extras: 40
Extras are:Audio Commentary by Actor Mel Gibson, Directors Eshom Nelms and Ian Nelms, Producer Michelle Lang, and Cinematographer Johnny Derango12 Minutes of Deleted Scenes (1080p) All with optional commentary,...
Movie: 60
So first, a little background on the film, thanks to this synopsis:A rowdy, unorthodox Santa Claus is fighting to save his declining business....
Total: 60
A sleeper if there ever was one, Fatman is a rent before you buy kind of film and one that I’m not personally sure warrants a second viewing.<br />...
Director: Eshom Nelms, Ian Nelms
Actors: Mel Gibson, Walton Goggins, Marianne Jean-Baptiste
PlotChris Cringle, a grizzled and disillusioned Santa Claus, struggles to keep his gift-giving operation afloat amid declining belief and financial woes. Living in a small town with his devoted wife Ruth, Chris accepts a government contract to produce materials for the military to make ends meet. Meanwhile, Billy Wenan, a spoiled and vengeful child who feels wronged by Cringle's Christmas present, hires a hitman known only as the Skinny Man to kill Santa. The assassin has his own grudge against Santa and sets off on a mission to eliminate him.
As Skinny Man gathers intel and closes in on his target, Chris deals with his mounting frustrations and tries to rediscover his purpose. Ruth provides steadfast support, believing in Chris's mission despite their difficulties. In a series of tense build-ups, the paths of the determined hitman and the weathered Santa inevitably cross. With stakes high and tensions escalating, the story unravels towards an intense culmination as both adversaries brace for their inevitable confrontation.
Writers: Ian Nelms, Eshom Nelms
Release Date: 24 Nov 2020
Runtime: 100 min
Rating: R
Country: United Kingdom, Canada, United States
Language: English