The Dark Tower 4K Ultra HD Blu-ray Review
Score: 76
from 6 reviewers
Review Date:
The Dark Tower's film adaptation lacks depth but shines in 4K UHD quality and extras.
Disc Release Date
True 4K
HDR10
Dolby Vision
Dolby Atmos
Dolby TrueHD
Video: 87
The Dark Tower's 4K UHD Blu-ray dazzles with unparalleled detail, HDR vibrance, and lifelike textures, setting a new standard for visual excellence.
Audio: 82
The Dark Tower's Dolby Atmos mix offers a vibrant, immersive audio experience with precise sound placement, robust low-end, and dynamic action sequences, enhancing the overall atmosphere.
Extra: 63
The Dark Tower's Ultra HD release boasts solid extras on the Blu-ray, featuring interviews with Stephen King, key cast insights, action choreography, and deleted scenes, but lacks direct inclusions on the UHD disc.
Movie: 43
After years of anticipation, The Dark Tower's adaptation disappoints, unable to capture the depth of King's series despite solid acting, leaving fans longing for what could have been.
Video: 87
The 4K Ultra HD Blu-ray release of "The Dark Tower" sets a high standard with its HEVC / H.265 encoded 2160p transfer, showcasing the film in its original theatrical aspect ratio of 2.40:1 widescreen. The utilization of sources shot at resolutions from 3.4K to 6.5K, coupled with a true 4K digital intermediate, results in an impeccably detailed and visually stunning presentation. The depth of detail is astonishing, highlighting textures in skin, hair, and environments with a clarity that is both sharp and naturally rendered. This transfer makes the most of the film's stylized look, from its alternating Western and modern settings to its meticulously crafted CG elements, all enhanced by HDR and Wide Colour Gamut (WCG) for added vibrancy.
Color reproduction benefits significantly from HDR, presenting a palette that complements the thematic elements of the film. Blacks are deep and inky, offering substantial shadow detail that contributes to the overall depth and dimension of the image. The presentation's Dolby Vision support adds an extra layer of visual splendor, with brighter colors like orange and red displaying remarkable luminosity and saturation. Meanwhile, environmental details and textures, from urban landscapes to natural rock formations, are reproduced with exceptional clarity and fidelity.
Despite some moments where heavy CGI might reveal the limitations of visual effects work, these instances do not detract from an otherwise outstanding video quality. Flesh tones appear natural across the board, with close-ups revealing minute details such as pores and facial hairs with striking precision. The encoding ensures a clean presentation free from noise or artifacts, maintaining the integrity of the film's rich visual tapestry. Overall, "The Dark Tower's" 4K UHD presentation is a testament to the capabilities of the format, likely to be referenced as a benchmark for exceptional video quality in home media releases.
Audio: 82
The "The Dark Tower" 4K UHD Blu-ray's Dolby Atmos track is a robust upgrade from its Blu-ray counterpart, enhancing the audio landscape to a degree that immerses you deeper into its unique blend of genres. Spearheaded by a base of Dolby TrueHD 7.1, it deftly balances clarity, depth, and spatial dynamics, elevating both atmospheric and action sequences to new heights. Dialogue remains crisply prioritized within the frontal spectrum, ensuring that the film's narrative clarity is uncompromised amid the expansive soundscape. The blend of steampunk, Western elements, and supernatural powers translates into a dazzling array of sound effects, from gunfire enriched with LFE to the more subtle nuances of environmental sounds. This meticulous attention to auditory detail crafts a captivating atmosphere, reinforced by a score that seamlessly bonds with the array of sounds to underscore the cinematic experience.
Key improvements heralded by the Atmos mix include a more pronounced use of overhead channels and enhanced spatial capabilities, providing an enveloping sense of environment whether in quiet dialogue scenes or amidst the cacophony of battle. This does not merely add volume but introduces a level of immersion that is both palpable and engaging, making full use of the audio spectrum to bring the film's expansive settings to life. Even in moments not dominated by action, the soundtrack utilizes these additional channels to flesh out the world, offering audio cues that enhance the visual storytelling.
Despite criticisms towards its Blu-ray counterpart for its less impactful use of surround sound and a perceived restraint in audio dynamics, the UHD release counters these points effectively with its Atmos track. It showcases intricate sound placements and dynamic shifts that faithfully reproduce every aspect of the scene's intended atmosphere. Sub-woofer usage excels in delivering potent LFE support, ensuring that each gunshot and supernatural event is felt as much as it is heard. Ambient sounds are meticulously captured, from background chatter to the supernatural, adding layers to the scene without overwhelming the essential dialogue, which remains clear and nuanced throughout. This audial presentation not only supports but elevates "The Dark Tower," making it a reference-quality example of how Atmos can enhance the home cinema experience.
Extras: 63
The 4K UHD Blu-ray release of "The Dark Tower" excels in delivering a comprehensive collection of supplementary materials, all housed on the accompanying Blu-ray disc, for an enhanced viewing experience. Noteworthy for its exclusion of extras from the UHD disc itself, this package nevertheless impresses with its depth of content aimed at fans and newcomers alike. Viewers will appreciate the engaging featurettes led by Stephen King, where he delves into the origins of the story and its adaptation for the big screen. Additional insights from key cast members Idris Elba and Matthew McConaughey, alongside detailed explorations of the film’s action sequences, production design, and the mystical realm of Mid-World, enrich the narrative. The inclusion of deleted scenes, a blooper reel, and story readings further complements the main feature, despite the absence of a director's commentary. The collection strikes a balance between technical aspects and creative insights, ensuring a well-rounded appreciation of this cinematic endeavor.
Extras included in this disc:
- Deleted Scenes: Original Walter Intro, Original Dream, Diner/Post Diner, and Walk and Talk.
- Blooper Reel: Collection of on-set errors.
- A Look Through the Keyhole: Vignettes narrated by Roland (Elba) and the Man in Black (McConaughey).
- Last Time Around: Stephen King discusses story origins and transitioning the story to the screen.
- Stephen King Inspirations: King looks at audience expectations and differences from his other works.
- The Gunslinger in Action: Focus on Idris Elba's approach to creating key scenes.
- The Man in Black: Exploration of McConaughey's portrayal and character work.
- The World Has Moved On…: Close-up on Mid-World's sets and locations.
- Digital HD Copy: For portable viewing options.
Movie: 43
Despite the vast and complex world Stephen King created in his magnum opus, "The Dark Tower," this cinematic rendition falls disappointingly short of capturing the essence and deep narrative that enthralled generations. Directed by Nikolaj Arcel, the film attempts to distill thousands of pages and several decades' worth of storytelling into a concise 90-minute movie. The result is an overly simplified adaptation that feels rushed and barely scratches the surface of its source material. With illustrious actors Idris Elba and Matthew McConaughey cast as The Gunslinger and The Man in Black, respectively, their performances add a glimmer of hope to an otherwise diluted portrayal, managing to breathe life into their characters amidst a backdrop of hurried plot developments and underexplored worlds.
Character development suffers greatly due to the film's brisk pacing, with pivotal characters reduced to mere shells of their literary counterparts. Fans of the book series might find themselves disoriented by the lack of depth and backstory, with Stephen King's richly imagined universe compressed into a string of action sequences that, while visually stimulating, leave much to be desired in terms of narrative cohesion and emotional engagement. The attempt to merge modern cinematic elements with King's intricate lore results in a confused tone, oscillating between a teen fantasy and an epic battle between good and evil without fully committing to either.
Despite these shortcomings, "The Dark Tower" movie is not without merit for those unfamiliar with the books, presenting an accessible entry into King's world with its high-stakes plot and straightforward good-versus-evil dynamic. However, for fans and newcomers alike, the film feels like a missed opportunity to truly explore the complexities and nuances of The Dark Tower series. What remains is a visually appealing but ultimately unfulfilling experience that hints at the epic tale it could have been, had it been afforded the necessary time to faithfully adapt such a beloved and expansive story.
Total: 76
Stephen King’s expansive and intricate universe of "The Dark Tower" series, rich in character and lore, unfortunately receives a middling film adaptation that struggles to capture the essence and depth of its source material. The transition into a concise, 90-minute narrative results in a product that feels overly simplified and lacking in the thematic complexity and character development that fans of King’s work might expect. That said, the movie does manage to deliver a visually engaging and serviceable entertainment experience, albeit more appealing to casual viewers than die-hard King enthusiasts. The primary redeeming feature of this release is not the film itself but its technical presentation.
Sony Pictures Home Entertainment’s 4K Ultra HD Blu-ray edition of "The Dark Tower" significantly elevates the viewing experience with stunning video quality and an immersive Dolby Atmos audio track. The exceptional clarity and vividness of the 4K resolution, combined with dynamic sound design, provide a home cinema experience that showcases what modern home entertainment technology is capable of. The addition of a fan-friendly selection of extras adds value, offering insights into the making of a film that struggled to fully realize the potential of its source material. While the film adaptation falls short in many respects, its ultra-high-definition release sets a high standard for audiovisual presentation.
In conclusion, "The Dark Tower" 4K UHD Blu-ray represents a paradoxical case where the exceptional quality of the physical release overshadows the film it presents. The adaptation fails to do justice to Stephen King's complex world, delivering a simplified narrative that might leave fans wanting. However, for those able to look past the movie's shortcomings, the 4K UHD release offers a visually and sonically impressive experience that ranks among the year's best in terms of technical presentation. It stands as a recommended purchase for audiovisual enthusiasts and completionists but may not hold the same appeal for those seeking a faithful and fulfilling adaptation of King's masterwork.
avforums review by Casimir HarlowRead review here
Video: 100
A fantastic presentation, likely to soon go on many top lists for 2017 Ultra HD Blu-ray releases Detail is absolutely stunning, at times staggering, picking up on the minute textures of skin, hair, clothing...
Audio: 100
Demo and reference in terms of audio as well Dialogue gets clear prioritisation across the frontal array, whilst the steampunk-esque fusion of a Western-style setting and special powers and weaponry, and...
Extras: 60
A solid package of extra material The highlights are probably a couple of short Featurettes featuring Stephen King himself, discussing his source works and the work done to adapt them for the screen....
Movie: 50
It's such a rich fantasy environment and yet you only get a hint of this, with ideas desperate to shine through but stifled at every turn, and fans left taking solace in flashy visuals and exciting gunfights....
Total: 70
King's world has so much more to offer that whilst this makes for a nominally entertaining ride, it's still a distinctly shallow one However, Sony's 4K Ultra HD Blu-ray release of The Dark Tower affords...
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 100
Colors enjoy a slight, but crucial, uptick in density and vibrancy, appearing more real and occasionally even leaving otherwise pleasing and even punchy shades on the Blu-ray looking a bit dull by comparison....
Audio: 90
While the listens are not fundamentally different -- both maintain heightened clarity, attuned positioning, strong low end support, enveloping surround usage -- the added channels, both rearward and overhead,...
Extras: 90
Stephen King: Inspirations (1080p, 4:25): Another piece in which King discusses his stories, including some identical clips from the previous piece....
Movie: 60
Elba, one of the better actors working today, embraces the character and does what he can with a part that's been all but erased down to its very essence....
Total: 50
But even at a very fast 90 minutes that's more or less the story's most unadulterated, no-frills and few-details essence, it makes for a serviceable, and even often enjoyable, surface-level entertainer....
DoBlu review by Matt PaprockiRead review here
Video: 100
Dark Tower’s high-contrast source only helps, even if there’s a loss in the brightest whites....
Audio: 80
It’s effective, certainly when in the middle of a battle scene, but leaves the rest of Dark Tower sounding restrained....
Extras: 40
For an additional 12 Dark Tower screenshots, early access to all screens (plus the 8,000+ already in our library), exclusive UHD reviews, and more, support us on Patreon....
Movie: 40
Since Walter killed his father, there’s a smidgen of the revenge western here, but Roland is the plainest of screen good guys....
Total: 65
Stephen King’s seven-part novel series The Dark Tower is adapted into this dull, simple tale of good versus evil and misses critical context....
High-Def Digest review by Bryan KlugerRead review here
Video: 80
Brighter colors such as the orange and red gun blasts, explosions, and electric light in the sky are bold and all have a great shine to them....
Audio: 90
Sound effects are very loud and robust when it comes to the gun blasts; each fired shot is immersive and has solid dynamics that account for the blast itself, flying bullet f, the debris, and impact....
Extras: 0
Movie: 20
Where King's novels are dark, suspenseful, full of character development, and told from The Gunslinger's POV, this PG-13 adaptation focuses on Jake, who must learn the truth about the universe, how to...
Total: 60
While Idris Elba tuns in a good performance, he is gravely underused and, instead, we follow an annoying kid around....
AVSForum review by Ralph PottsRead review here
Video: 93
The Dark Tower was shot digitally, derived from a mix of 3.4K and 6.5 K sources, and rendered from a 4K DI for its presentation in Ultra HD....
Audio: 92
This is done to very good effect and creates a tangible level of immersion that coincides with the onscreen events nicely....
Extras: 70
...
Movie: 40
The last Gunslinger, Roland (Idris Elba), has been locked in an eternal battle with the Man in Black (Matthew McConaughey), determined to prevent him from toppling the Dark Tower, which holds the universe...
Total: 74
It comes to Blu-ray from Sony Pictures Home Entertainment in this Ultra HD Combo Pack that enhances the image quality while invigorating the listening experience with a solid Dolby Atmos immersive sound...
Why So Blu?Read review here
Video: 100
Details are pretty rampant, from the distinct coloring and texturing of the bricks on a building to the fabric, patterns and feel of clothing like a battered leather jacket or a cloth tunic....
Audio: 90
Low-Frequency Extension: The subwoofer gives boom to the guns, explosions, paranormal magical forces, heartbeats in music, crashes and more....
Extras: 60
The Man In Black (4K, 9:26) Jake (4K, 17:44) Mid-World (4K, 17:39)Blu-ray DiscBlooper Reel (HD, 2:50)Deleted Scenes (HD, 6:22)Last Time Around (HD, 9:14) – Stephen King and the filmmakers talk the novels...
Movie: 50
As I’m taking in and looking around at things (Trying to find positives and unique things this film delivers), I keep being reminded of other things that are much better than The Dark Tower or that this...
Total: 60
The Dark Tower feels like something best seen or caught when it comes to HBO or like a TNT one tired Sunday morning or afternoon and you just sort of stop on it....
Director: Nikolaj Arcel
Actors: Idris Elba, Matthew McConaughey, Tom Taylor
PlotIn a vast multiverse containing various parallel worlds, a mythical structure known as the Dark Tower stands at the nexus, maintaining the balance of the cosmos. The dark sorcerer Walter o'Dim, also known as the Man in Black, seeks to collapse the tower and unleash chaos across the universes by torturing psychic children whose "shine" possesses the power to destroy the tower. Opposing him is Roland Deschain, the last of the Gunslingers, a group of elite warriors dedicated to protecting the tower. Roland is driven by a quest for vengeance against the Man in Black, who is responsible for the downfall of his world and the deaths of his loved ones.
In modern-day New York City, a young boy named Jake Chambers experiences haunting visions of the Dark Tower, the Man in Black, and Roland. His dreams, dismissed as troubled fantasies by those around him, propel him on a quest to find the truth. His search leads him through a portal to Mid-World, where he encounters Roland. Despite Roland's initial indifference to the tower's fate, Jake's conviction and unique abilities persuade him to join forces with the Gunslinger. Together, they journey through desolate landscapes, battling the Man in Black's minions, as they seek to protect the tower and save the universes from destruction.
Writers: Akiva Goldsman, Jeff Pinkner, Anders Thomas Jensen
Release Date: 04 Aug 2017
Runtime: 95 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: United States
Language: English