No Blu-ray Review
Score: 57
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
'No' captivates with its smart visual style and gripping political narrative, though the Blu-ray's special features are somewhat lacking. Recommended.
Disc Release Date
Video: 59
The Blu-ray video presentation of 'No' meticulously replicates the filmmaker's vision, using an old standard definition quality and a 1.40:1 aspect ratio, resulting in a hazy, de-saturated picture with subdued colors, frequent visual anomalies, and a low contrast that effectively mirrors 1980s campaign videos.
Audio: 64
The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track of 'No' presents a dynamic and sometimes low-key soundstage, balancing crisp dialogue with immersive atmospheric elements. While it occasionally outshines the visual presentation, moments of crowd noise and intense street-level action utilize rear channels effectively, creating a memorable listening experience.
Extra: 31
The Blu-ray extras of 'No' offer a highly enjoyable and comprehensive commentary by Gael García Bernal and Pablo Larraín, in English, covering technical, thematic, and historical aspects of the film, while a Q&A session at the Toronto International Film Festival adds insight into the film's reception and political nuances.
Movie: 76
"No" captures the pivotal 1988 Chilean plebiscite by ingeniously blending archival footage with a raw documentary style, illustrating the impact of media manipulation. Reviewers praise its technical authenticity and powerful narrative led by Gael García Bernal's riveting portrayal of ad executive René Saavedra.
Video: 59
The video presentation of "No" on Blu-ray is an intriguing case of filmmaker intent meeting modern technology. The film, photographed to emulate late 1980s analog video recordings, retains an aspect ratio and visual quality characteristic of standard definition television from that era. Consequently, it diverges significantly from contemporary high-definition standards. Details remain soft and muddy, colors are muted, and the palette often appears murky with instances of bleeding. Random anomalies such as halos, stray vertical lines, and false colors frequently populate the screen. However, this visual aesthetic is intentional, designed to simulate the look and feel of period-specific campaign videos. Thus, the Blu-ray transfer scores high marks for authenticity, delivering a faithful representation of the director's creative vision.
The deliberate blurring and de-saturation serve to reinforce the thematic elements of the film, creating a seamless blend between fiction and reality. Fine detail remains mostly absent, with texture being almost completely negated. Hot colors, particularly whites, bleed into surrounding areas while blacks swallow up details in low-light scenes. Though this presentation departs from the crispness and clarity typically associated with Blu-ray, it effectively enhances the film’s period authenticity. The 1.40:1 aspect ratio further contributes to its vintage feel, likening it to a 30-year-old television commercial. Despite these choices, the film retains a cinematic quality that supports its narrative and artistic intent.
Overall, viewers should approach the Blu-ray of "No" with an understanding of its deliberate stylistic choices that prioritize period accuracy over conventional high-definition visual excellence. The transfer's ability to capture the essence of a bygone era underscores its success in delivering not just a film, but an immersive historical experience.
Audio: 64
The Blu-ray release of No features a striking DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 lossless soundtrack that surprisingly outshines its visual presentation. The audio experience is engineered with precision, providing a dynamic range that oscillates between subtle atmospheric details and intense action sequences. Ambient sounds are meticulously crafted, from the nuanced background noises like clinking silverware in a restaurant to the bustling environment of an office dominated by ringing phones and typewriter keys. Thoughtful soundscapes like ocean waves or a toy train contribute further to the immersive experience. During scenes of heightened tension, such as street-level riots, the track brims with energy, filling the stage with aggressive alarms, crashes, and other impactful sound effects.
Dialogue clarity remains consistently smooth and accurate from the center channel, ensuring that spoken words are never lost amidst the surrounding commotion. The mix skillfully balances spoken exchanges with ambient elements, enhancing the overall listening experience. Notably, during pivotal moments such as the intense clash following a celebratory event, the soundtrack fully exploits its potential, creating a profound sense of impending danger that underscores the visuals. This judicious use of sound transformation underscores key narrative beats and heightens viewer engagement, demonstrating that a restrained yet deliberate approach to audio can effectively amplify emotional impact.
Overall, the careful engineering of this DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track significantly enriches the film No, offering an audio experience that is both immersive and technically impressive. The contrast between the subdued and highly active sequences showcases the versatility of the soundtrack, making it a standout feature despite its occasional misalignment with the visual style.
Extras: 31
The Blu-ray extras for "No" provide substantial insights into both the technical and thematic elements of the film. Gael García Bernal and Pablo Larraín offer a thorough audio commentary that covers the visual style, technical achievements, real era elements, and political undertones of the movie. Their discussion ranges from detailed technical attributes to character development, making it highly informative and engaging for fans. Additionally, a Q&A session with García Bernal, recorded at the Toronto International Film Festival, gives viewers a deeper understanding of the film’s reception in Chile and the actor's perspective on its political aspects. The inclusion of the theatrical trailer and previews of other Sony titles rounds out this impressive package of extras.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary: In-depth discussion on various aspects of the film.
- Q&A with Gael García Bernal: Insights from a TIFF session.
- Theatrical Trailer: Preview of the film.
- Previews: Additional Sony titles.
Movie: 76
Pablo Larraín's "No" serves as a vivid time capsule, transporting audiences to 1988 Chile through innovative storytelling and technical authenticity. This period drama, centered on the plebiscite that challenged Augusto Pinochet's military dictatorship, captures the essence of a defining historical moment. Gael García Bernal stars as René Saavedra, an advertising visionary tasked with transforming the 'No' campaign into a compelling and optimistic movement. Saavedra's modern strategies, injecting themes of hope and future aspirations into the campaign, starkly contrast the more traditional approaches of both political spectrums. The film's brilliance lies in its nuanced exploration of the power struggle between factual political discourse and the manipulative allure of advertising.
Larraín’s decision to shoot the film using the same video format as the original 1980s election campaigns significantly enhances the authenticity of "No." This choice immerses viewers in the era’s visual texture, blending historical footage with the narrative seamlessly. Additionally, the film cleverly incorporates actual news clips and appearances by real-life politicians, further blurring the lines between historical documentation and cinematic technique. This stylistic choice creates an immediate and visceral connection to the events onscreen, allowing audiences to experience the raw dynamics of political advertisements and their impact on public opinion.
The narrative intricately portrays the duality of political and commercial advertising. Saavedra’s creativity and youth-oriented campaign strategies clash with those of his conservative boss, Lucho Guzmán (Alfredo Castro), who supports Pinochet's 'Yes' campaign. Their professional relationship underscores the dichotomy between personal political convictions and professional responsibilities. By filming in a documentary style and using humor and self-awareness, "No" offers a poignant reflection on how media shapes political climates, revealing the manufactured nature of political promises and sparking contemplation on the lasting effects of media manipulation in shaping public behavior and opinion.
Total: 57
"No" presents a compelling narrative about political messaging and the transformation of public persuasion, capturing the essence of a pivotal moment in history with a contemporary resonance. The film explores how the medium of advertising can turn political movements from dry, statistical debates into dynamic and appealing campaigns. The retro visual style and authentic performances punctuate the story, making the experience both intellectually stimulating and emotionally engaging. These elements reflect how modern political landscapes were first reshaped by strategic advertising.
Sony's Blu-ray release of "No" offers commendable video and audio quality that preserves the unique aesthetic of the film. The picture achieves a nostalgic feel while maintaining sharpness, and the sound design effectively balances dialogue with its evocative score and period-specific audio. However, the Blu-ray edition lacks substantial special features, which slightly diminishes its overall value as a collector's item. Despite this, the core content—the film itself—remains a powerful testament to both historical events and the craft of filmmaking.
In conclusion, "No" transcends simple political storytelling by delving into the complexities of media influence and public sentiment. With its smart direction, engaging performances, and distinctive visual style, it appeals to a wide audience and encourages reflection on current political strategies. Although the Blu-ray release could benefit from additional extras, it still comes highly recommended for those interested in cinematic narratives that merge history with incisive social commentary.
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 90
The picture, then, doesn't meet modern high definition standards of visual excellence, but that's balanced out by filmmaker intent and the Blu-ray's capture of the movie's natural appearance....
Audio: 80
Ocean waves gently roll into the stage in one scene, a toy train encircles it in another, and the track often finds a good, precise posture for most of its sound effects....
Extras: 30
They speak on the technical attributes, the real era elements used in the film, the politics and culture of the era, post-production tricks, character development, themes, the cast, and plenty more....
Movie: 80
While the outcome isn't in doubt -- whether audiences are familiar with the real history behind the campaign and the Pinochet regime's fate or not -- that full sense of immersion into the "No" campaign...
Total: 70
It's a movie that shows the power of political persuasion and manipulation not through hard facts and figures -- and sobering ones at that, in this case -- but rather a change in tone that makes it hip...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 60
While this may not be what we traditionally have come to think of in regard to film and, more specifically, high-definition, the trade off is an unabashed representation of the director's artistic vision,...
Audio: 80
Still, the mix makes the most of the dialogue by ensuring it sounds crisp and clear in every scene and that it plays nicely with other elements when need be....
Extras: 40
During the session, Bernal fields several questions about how the film was perceived in Chile, as well as his views on the more politicized bits in the film....
Movie: 80
Yes, it's a film about the creation of something as ultimately trite and meaningless as Facebook, but due to the overwhelming influence that trite and meaningless website has had on all of our lives (users...
Total: 60
Regardless of an individual's knowledge of the events that led to the successful ousting of a despot, 'No' speaks to its audience in a manner nearly everyone can relate to by making the conversation as...
Director: Pablo Larraín
Actors: Gael García Bernal, Alfredo Castro, Antonia Zegers
PlotIn 1988 Chile, the military dictatorship of General Augusto Pinochet is forced to hold a national plebiscite on whether he should extend his rule for another eight years. The "Yes" campaign supports Pinochet's continuation, while the newly-formed opposition "No" campaign seeks to end his rule. René Saavedra, a talented but apolitical advertising executive, is approached to spearhead the "No" campaign's efforts. Despite his initial reluctance and personal risks, René eventually agrees and begins to craft a marketing strategy that focuses on creating a hopeful and optimistic vision for Chile’s future, tapping into his innovative advertising skills.
As René and his team work tirelessly, they face harassment and intimidation from the government, as well as internal conflicts from the fractured opposition about the tone and content of their campaign. The "No" team decides to use a positive and creative approach with slogans, jingles, and television spots designed to resonate emotionally with the populace. Their unorthodox campaign generates significant public attention and discourse, setting the stage for a historic moment in Chile's political landscape.
Writers: Pedro Peirano, Antonio Skármeta
Release Date: 09 Aug 2012
Runtime: 118 min
Rating: R
Country: Chile, France, Mexico, United States
Language: Spanish