While We're Young Blu-ray Review
Score: 53
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
While We're Young is a shrewdly perceptive comedy-drama with stellar performances and first-rate technical merits, though supplemental features may disappoint.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 56
While We're Young's Blu-ray presentation by Lionsgate Films, featuring an AVC encoded 1080p transfer in 1.85:1, offers a digitally shot, stylized cinematography with muted earth tones and saffron hues. The heavily stylized, aged look results in an intentionally flat, somewhat washed-out image with generally excellent detail but occasionally anemic contrast.
Audio: 66
While We're Young's DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track provides impressive vocal clarity, immersive urban soundscapes, and excellent channel separation, creating a dynamic mix with engaging presence and accurate bass, perfectly complementing the film's character-driven narrative and visually deliberate style.
Extra: 16
The Blu-ray extras for 'While We're Young' feature detailed cast and crew interviews, insight into director Noah Baumbach's methods, and analysis of technology's thematic role, alongside brief segments on specific scenes, all meticulously presented in high-definition.
Movie: 66
"While We're Young" is an insightful comedy-drama exploring generational conflict and self-evaluation. Baumbach skillfully navigates tonally imbalanced scenes with sharp dialogue, leveraging relatable characters and situational humor. Despite some narrative contrivances and uneven structures, it remains engaging with adroit performances, notably from Stiller and Watts.
Video: 56
The Blu-ray presentation of "While We're Young" by Lionsgate Films features an AVC encoded 1080p transfer in a 1.85:1 aspect ratio. Shot with the Arri Alexa Plus, the title offers a visual experience that is both intentional and stylized. The palette is dominated by shades of beiges and yellows, occasionally enriched by saffron hues. This color grading approach gives the film a distinctive, buttery look that enhances its intended antiquated appeal. However, this stylistic choice also results in a slight softness in the image, which differentiates it from similarly shot content that usually offers sharper detail.
In terms of technical specifics, the Blu-ray's contrast and brightness are deliberately subdued, creating a faded and somewhat washed-out aesthetic. While daylight exteriors and well-lit scenes showcase clean whites and fairly good sharpness with well-defined lines, darker scenes suffer from murky blacks that obscure finer details. The overall contrast appears anemic, adding a hazy overlay to some scenes and diminishing the sense of depth in shadowy environments. Despite these creative limitations, facial complexions are detailed and natural-looking, contributing to an engaging yet reserved visual palette. The deep-focus cinematography further supports a sense of space and distance, with earth tones and yellow-amber tints contributing to the film's unique visual identity.
Audio: 66
The Blu-ray presentation of "While We're Young" features a lossless DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track that seamlessly integrates into the film’s urban settings, providing excellent immersion. Dialogue prioritization is first-rate, ensuring that conversations are clear and intonation remains precise. This character-driven story, supported by a deliberate audio style, achieves superb vocal clarity with notable attention to tone and fidelity. Although presented in a front-heavy manner, suggesting stereo origins, the lossless mix does not feel constrained, offering impeccable channel separation and balance across all three channels.
The soundtrack's imaging is impressive, creating a broad and expansive soundstage with dynamic mid-range frequencies that contribute clear and detailed highs. The selection of music, including numerous cues from Vivaldi’s works, resides comfortably in the surrounds, adding a rich layer to the auditory experience. This deliberate audio design fills the overall soundstage with energy, supported by responsive and accurate bass which enhances scene depth. Despite its front-oriented focus, the track maintains continuous background activity, keeping an engaging and wide sense of spatiality.
Extras: 16
The Blu-ray extras for "While We're Young" provide insightful and engaging behind-the-scenes looks at both the film’s production and its thematic elements. The featurettes are presented in high definition and divided into four segments that can be viewed sequentially or independently. Each featurette offers a combination of cast and crew interviews, with in-depth praise for the actors and director Noah Baumbach, and includes a specific look at Charles Grodin’s role. Additionally, there is a discussion about the influence of technology on the film's characters and plot. The behind-the-scenes sections are concise but informative, detailing specific scenes such as the Ayahuasca ceremony and hip hop class via interviews with key cast members, including Naomi Watts and Amanda Seyfried.
Extras included in this disc:
The Cast: Interviews discussing the performances of the ensemble cast.
Director Noah Baumbach: Insights into the director's vision and process.
Charles Grodin: Focus on Grodin's contribution to the film.
Generation Tech: Exploration of technology's impact within the movie.
Ayahuasca Ceremony: Behind-the-scenes look at the filming of this pivotal scene.
Hip Hop Class: Insight into another key scene from the film.
Trailers: Promotional material for the film.
Movie: 66
Noah Baumbach's "While We’re Young" is a shrewdly perceptive comedy-drama seamlessly intertwining generational subtext with a nuanced depiction of adult life crises. Ben Stiller and Naomi Watts deliver adroit performances as Josh and Cornelia Srebnick, a middle-aged couple grappling with childlessness and the mundanity of routine existence. Their inertia is disrupted by the entrance of Jamie and Darby (Adam Driver and Amanda Seyfried), a hip young couple embodying an idealized vision of spontaneity and retro aesthetics, which Josh and Cornelia initially find refreshing. Baumbach explores the inherent comedy and somber undertones of Josh's desperate attempts to reclaim lost youth, augmented by Jamie’s seemingly honorable yet subtly manipulative ambitions as a documentary filmmaker.
Baumbach masterfully navigates the film's tonal imbalances, highlighted by scenes like Josh and Cornelia’s psychedelic journey, which are imbued with unexpected dramatic depth. The narrative subtly shifts through acute observations on the generation gap, rendering Josh's realizations poignantly relatable while layering Jamie’s schmoozing with growing suspicion. The juxtaposition of digital-age Josh and nostalgic Jamie elucidates shifting values and postmodern disillusionment, hauntingly culminating in a climax that exposes personal insecurities.
Touting a cleverly structured script, "While We’re Young" meticulously alternates between vignettes rich in microcosmic detail and overarching themes of existential conflict. Cinematographer Sam Levy and editor Jennifer Lame ensure Baumbach's direction remains candid and genuine, leaving viewers with a final image resonant in its complexity through simplicity. Ultimately, the film offers incisive commentary on finding meaning amidst mundanity, propelled by stellar performances and Baumbach's incisive dialogue.
Total: 53
Noah Baumbach's "While We're Young" presents a shrewdly perceptive comedy-drama that navigates the complexities of midlife crises and self-discovery with both humor and honesty. Starring Ben Stiller and Naomi Watts, the film captures the essence of middle age through its relatable characters and their interactions with a younger, contrasting pair. The aging protagonists are portrayed with a low-key, accessible realism that grounds the film, while the supporting cast enhances the narrative with commendable performances.
Technically, the Blu-ray offers a stylized yet pleasing audio and video presentation. The visual fidelity is first-rate, capturing Baumbach’s nuanced direction and the film's intimate moments with clarity and vibrancy. The audio mix complements the visuals effectively, ensuring dialogue is clear and the comedic beats land as intended. However, the Blu-ray's supplemental materials are somewhat lacking, offering little beyond the basic expectations for such releases. Despite this, the core presentation's quality makes it an excellent rental choice, potentially warranting a purchase for dedicated fans of Baumbach or the film's stars.
Baumbach begins "While We're Young" with an excerpt from Henrik Ibsen's "The Master Builder," setting a thematic tone that ebbs and flows throughout the narrative. His comedic touch is evident in the film’s one-liners, though his dramatic impulses occasionally falter. Still, the movie delivers a thoughtful exploration of self-reinvention amidst a comedic backdrop. In conclusion, despite a few missteps, "While We're Young" offers a compelling watch and comes Recommended for its authentic performances and technical proficiency.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 80
Adding to a generally buttery look is color grading in some scenes which favors saffron hues....
Audio: 80
While We're Young features a lossless DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track, one which offers good immersion courtesy of some of the urban settings, and which also supports dialogue effortlessly....
Extras: 20
Featurettes (1080p; 7:30) include: The Cast Director Noah Baumbach Charles Grodin Generation Tech Behind the Scenes (1080p; 2:27) includes: Ayahuasca Ceremony Hip Hop Class...
Movie: 60
Josh and Cornelia rationalize their situation, saying that it's all really for the best, and that being childless at least affords them the opportunity to be spontaneous�except that there's a notable lack...
Total: 60
That feeling comes and goes as the actual film proceeds, with Baumbach's comedic chops offering solid one liners, but his dramatic impulses sometimes leading to less felicitous results....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 60
Presented in its original 1.85:1 aspect ratio, the image intentionally appears flat and drained, but the deep-focus photography manages to give a sense of space and distance....
Audio: 80
Although feeling more like a stereo track, the mix comes with plenty of background activity that's continuous and engaging, maintain a wide sense of space throughout....
Extras: 0
Featurettes (HD, 8 min) — Broken into four segments that can be watched separately or sequentially, each showing a collection of cast & crew interviews praising the cast, the director and Charles Grodin....
Movie: 80
While Josh strains to find the dramatic, emotional core, the smug but talented Jamie manufactures a drama to make the real more interesting — a commentary on modernity and this very film itself, the irony...
Total: 60
With excellent performances from the entire cast, the film is an endearingly thoughtful but also honest tale on the road of a midlife crises towards self-discovery....
Director: Noah Baumbach
Actors: Ben Stiller, Naomi Watts, Adam Driver
PlotJosh and Cornelia, a childless married couple in their mid-forties, are feeling stuck in their routine and creatively stagnant. Josh is a documentary filmmaker who has been struggling with his latest project for years, while Cornelia produces documentaries alongside her father, a celebrated filmmaker. Their complacency is upended when they meet Jamie and Darby, a free-spirited, energetic young couple in their mid-twenties. Enamored by the youthful enthusiasm and unorthodox lifestyle of Jamie and Darby, Josh and Cornelia find themselves invigorated, plunging into activities they had long abandoned. They attend hip-hop dance classes, try on new fashion trends, and even take part in drug-fueled adventures.
As Josh grows closer to Jamie, he finds inspiration to rework his stalled documentary project. However, this revitalization also brings an unsettling realization as he starts to notice discrepancies in Jamie's motives and ethical approach to filmmaking. While navigating this new friendship, Josh and Cornelia must confront the growing divide between their past ideals and present realities. In their attempt to reclaim their youth, they begin to question what authenticity truly means to them, leading to tensions and self-reflection that challenge the foundations of their marriage and careers.
Writers: Noah Baumbach, Henrik Ibsen, Wallace Shawn
Release Date: 17 Apr 2015
Runtime: 97 min
Rating: R
Country: United States
Language: English