The Valiant Ones Blu-ray Review
忠烈圖 Zhōng li� t� | Masters of Cinema
Score: 79
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
A captivating wuxia adventure, 'The Valiant Ones' is visually stunning with generally solid technical merits and exceptional supplements.
Disc Release Date
Video: 85
"The Valiant Ones," now on Blu-ray, showcases a near-miraculous restoration with a 2160p transfer from a 4K scanned negative, vibrantly capturing King Hu's vision. The digital restoration via Italy’s L’Immagine Ritrovata yields realistic, rich colors and deep blacks, preserving fine detail and intricate wuxia costumes amid stabilized film elements.
Audio: 60
The Valiant Ones' LPCM Mono track in Mandarin offers decent dialogue clarity and effective percussive scoring, though it suffers from a boxy, slightly brash sound and filtered ends. Optional English subtitles are provided.
Extra: 96
The Blu-ray of "The Valiant Ones," #288 in Eureka's Masters of Cinema series, debuts in North America with extensive new and archival content. It features detailed commentary by Frank Djeng, analyses by Tony Rayns, and insights into King Hu's work, complemented by a collector’s booklet by Jonathan Clements.
Movie: 86
The Valiant Ones, a visually stunning wuxia film by King Hu, blends epic historical storytelling with dynamic choreography from Sammo Hung. Despite being less recognized than Hu's earlier works like A Touch of Zen, its lively narrative of heroes battling Japanese pirates showcases Hu's mastery, making it a compelling yet underappreciated entry in his filmography.
Video: 85
Eureka! Entertainment's Blu-ray release of "The Valiant Ones" under the Masters of Cinema imprint provides an impressive visual experience, meticulously restored from director King Hu's original 35mm negatives. The 2160p AVC encoded transfer in a 2.35:1 aspect ratio showcases a vibrant and pristine palette, achieved through digital color grading based on the original timing sheets. Reds and blues exhibit stunning vibrancy, and the intricate designs of wuxia costumes are beautifully rendered. The digital restoration, completed by L'Immagine Ritrovata, effectively removes scratches, spots, and flickering while reducing audio background noise for an enhanced viewing experience.
The restoration process involved painstaking cleaning and repair of the elements, maintaining the integrity of the film's visual depth. Despite past damages such as loose splices and faded dyes, the result is a vivid presentation occasionally marked by slight inconsistencies in density and clarity, especially in some midrange and wide shots. Nonetheless, textures of fabrics and set details resolve exceptionally well, revealing significant fine detail, particularly in close-ups which offer sharpness and depth.
The film benefits from exceptional color correction and stabilization, with maintained grain structure that resolves smoothly without significant issues. Although grain becomes more pronounced during optical sequences, it is managed skillfully. The color palette, rich in primary tones, supports exterior action scenes with deep blacks and strong contrasts. The 1080p and 4K restorations both deliver high-quality visuals; however, the Blu-ray’s appearance is consistent and engaging throughout, constituting a nearly flawless transfer that does justice to the original cinematic intention.
Audio: 60
The audio presentation of "The Valiant Ones" on Blu Ray is anchored in an LPCM Mono 1.0 track, preserving the original Mandarin dialogue. The sound quality reveals some noticeable constraints, notably a tendency toward boxiness and brightness in higher frequencies, which can verge on brashness, particularly in the musical score. Despite these characteristics, the track is devoid of pervasive damage, maintaining overall clarity.
Dialogue is a particular strength of this audio track, presented cleanly and distinctly, ensuring the original performances are conveyed with accuracy. The percussive elements of the score and accompanying sound effects resonate effectively, though they share the mono track's inherent boxy texture. The soundtrack appears to have undergone a restoration process; however, it doesn't reach the same level of improvement seen in the visual restoration. Parts of the audio may seem filtered at both ends of the spectrum.
Subtitles are available in English, displayed in a clear white font within the scope’s presentation, enhancing the accessibility without detracting from the viewing experience. Overall, while not flawless, the Blu Ray’s audio component appropriately matches the film's historical and atmospheric tone, offering a respectful homage to its original release.
Extras: 96
The Blu-ray release of "The Valiant Ones" by Eureka Entertainment offers a robust collection of extras that deeply enrich the viewing experience. This edition, making its debut in North America, is thoughtfully packaged with a slipcase featuring striking artwork by Grégory Sacré and accompanied by an insightful collector’s booklet penned by Jonathan Clements. The disc itself is equipped with a region-coded feature for both A and B regions, strategically catering to a broad audience of wuxia enthusiasts. The extras meticulously dissect elements of Hong Kong cinema, with Frank Djeng providing an authoritative audio commentary. The inclusion of both new interviews and archival materials ensures a comprehensive exploration of King Hu's influence. Additional content includes reflective segments with industry veterans, underscoring the historical and cultural significance of the film.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary by Frank Djeng: Expert insights on the film and its context.
- Tony Rayns on The Valiant Ones: Discusses King Hu and significant industry rivalries.
- Tsar of all Wuxia: David Cairns’ essay focuses on director Hu.
- The Life of a Lucky Stuntman: Interview with stuntman Billy Chan.
- My Father and I: Ng Ming-choi, son of King Hu, shares personal insights.
- Memories of Hu: Archival interview with Roger Garcia on the film's legacy.
- Frédéric Ambroisine 2003 Interview with Hsu Feng: Features insights from the celebrated actress.
- Frédéric Ambroisine 2016 Interview with Ng Ming-choi: Shares further reflections from Hu’s son.
Movie: 86
"The Valiant Ones," a masterful work by renowned director King Hu, is a visually arresting film that captures the essence of the wuxia genre while subtly branching into broader narrative territories. Set during the late Ming Dynasty, the plot delves into the intricate web of political intrigue and piracy as Japanese pirates, led by Hakatatsu played by a young Sammo Hung, wreak havoc along China's coast. The storyline follows General Zhu Wan's endeavor to curb this menace by assembling a group of exceptional martial artists, including the notable couple Wu Ji-yuan and Wu Ro-shi.
With dynamic swordplay choreography from Hung, "The Valiant Ones" stands as one of King Hu's exemplary forays in wuxia cinema. The film showcases a harmonious blend of action and storytelling that highlights Hu’s artistic craftsmanship. Although less philosophically intense than "A Touch of Zen," it retains a compelling narrative marked by stunning cinematography that captures sweeping landscapes and vibrant battle sequences. Despite its commercial nature aimed at mass audiences, the film subtly reflects Hu’s personal statement against the prevalent industry powers, embracing an epic scope that contrasts the simpler, frenetic action pace often found in contemporaneous wuxia films.
Despite not achieving the widespread acclaim of Hu’s earlier works, "The Valiant Ones" deserves recognition for its innovation and contribution to the genre. The historical context woven into its plot provides a rich, immersive experience, complemented by Hung's choreography that hints at the emerging kung fu cinema era in Hong Kong. Although this might have been one of the last significant wuxia endeavors from Hu as the genre waned in comparison to modern kung fu cinema, it remains a testament to his significant impact on the genre and cinematic artistry.
Total: 79
The Blu-ray release of "The Valiant Ones" offers a remarkable presentation of King Hu's notable wuxia film, drawing audiences into a captivating narrative about Japanese pirates and government corruption in coastal China. The film stands as one of Hu's last masterpieces, maintaining his signature flair for combining action-packed sequences with intricate storytelling. The Blu-ray transfer is generally solid, ensuring that the breathtaking visuals and deftly choreographed action scenes are presented with clarity, though it's worth noting that it may lack some of the refinements seen in its 4K UHD counterpart from Eureka.
On a technical note, this Blu-ray version delivers reliable audio quality, complementing the film's rich musical score and dynamic sound effects. Although not flawless, the restoration endeavors to uphold the film's visual integrity, rendering it both a historically and aesthetically meaningful addition to any collection. The attention given to the film's visual and auditory elements underscores its enduring appeal and cinematic legacy.
In conclusion, "The Valiant Ones" Blu-ray release is both an elegiac tribute to King Hu's oeuvre and a testament to his enduring influence on the wuxia genre. The film’s aesthetic beauty and compelling narrative resonate strongly, likely overshadowing any technical inconsistencies present in this format. The exceptional supplementary content enhances the viewing experience, offering valuable insights into Hu's creative process and the film’s contexts. Therefore, despite minor technical variances, this release is highly recommended for both enthusiasts of King Hu's work and newcomers to wuxia cinema.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 80
There are some very noticeable ebbs and flows with regard to densities and clarity levels in particular, though having now watched the film in both 1080 and 4K UHD, the 1080 version probably offers an...
Audio: 70
The track definitely shows some boxiness and a bit of brightness bordering on brashness in the highest frequencies (most noticeable in some of the score), but there are no really pervasive signs of damage....
Extras: 100
Audio Commentary by Frank Djeng Tony Rayns on The Valiant Ones (HD; 23:58) also addresses a number of related subjects like King Hu and the rivalry between Shaw Brothers and Golden Harvest....
Movie: 80
All of this left Hu with a perhaps enviable reputation but still not a lot of opportunities, which ultimately led to a two film deal back in Hong Kong with Golden Harvest, then seen as a kind of "upstart"...
Total: 80
As is discussed in some of the supplements included on this release, The Valiant Ones is often considered to be Hu's last "real" wuxia film, and as such it may be appropriately elegiac...
DoBlu review by Christopher ZabelRead review here
Video: 100
The film elements are in fantastic condition after the restoration, completely stabilized and bursting with startling definition....
Audio: 60
This is a solid, serviceable recording which sounds to my ears a bit filtered on both ends....
Extras: 100
Making its Blu-ray debut for the first time in North America, the disc is coded for regions A and B. First pressings include a slipcase featuring artwork by Grégory Sacré and a collector’s booklet featuring...
Movie: 100
Sadly for King Hu’s talents as a master filmmaker, The Valiant Ones was nearly the final gasp of wuxia for many years as the genre receded in popularity....
Total: 90
One of King Hu’s last great films, the wuxia master delivers a rousing adventure about Japanese pirates attacking coastal China and government corruption...
Director: King Hu
Actors: Feng Hsu, Ying Bai, Roy Chiao
PlotDuring the Ming Dynasty, coastal Chinese officials grapple with the escalating threat of Japanese pirates who raid villages and disrupt trade. In response, the imperial court assigns a courageous and skilled general to lead a small yet formidable team to counter these incursions and restore peace. The group is composed of diverse and talented individuals, each bringing unique tactical prowess and combat skills. Among them are a seasoned martial artist, a strategic tactician, and a fierce female warrior whose unparalleled skills add an unexpected edge to the team.
As they embark on their mission, the team travels across treacherous landscapes, facing ambushes and uncovering betrayals that complicate their journey. They employ a mix of clever strategies and brute force to battle the pirates, gradually earning the villagers' trust and support. With each confrontation, the bond between the team members strengthens, revealing their deep motivations and personal stakes in this perilous quest. Their mission reaches a climax as they prepare for an ultimate showdown, risking everything to deliver justice and reclaim their nation's honor, knowing the price of failure could be catastrophic.
Writers: King Hu
Release Date: 19 Feb 1975
Runtime: 102 min
Rating: N/A
Country: Taiwan, Hong Kong
Language: Mandarin