The Disappearance of Alice Creed Blu-ray Review
Score: 58
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
The Blu-ray of 'The Disappearance of Alice Creed' offers exceptional video quality and a gripping, yet sometimes flawed thriller packed with twists and tension.
Disc Release Date
Dolby TrueHD
Video: 70
The Blu-ray of 'The Disappearance of Alice Creed' features an exceptional 1080p transfer, showcasing sharp and detailed visuals with accurate colors and solid black levels. It handles low light scenes well, revealing fine textures and details with minimal noise and only minor banding issues.
Audio: 58
The Dolby TrueHD 5.1 soundtrack for 'The Disappearance of Alice Creed' is characterized by its proficiency and suitability for the film's minimalist sound design. Dialogue remains clear, with some minor issues, while the music provides excellent clarity and dynamic range, balancing limited LFE and surround usage effectively.
Extra: 40
Extras on the Blu-ray of 'The Disappearance of Alice Creed' feature standard content available also on DVD, including a dry but informative commentary by Director J Blakeson, a brief deleted scene, an overly extended scene, a storyboard comparison, outtakes, and the theatrical trailer, all in varying resolutions with no Blu-ray exclusives.
Movie: 53
A tense psychological thriller with numerous plot twists and intensive character development, 'The Disappearance of Alice Creed' surprises and engages despite occasional drops in tension and some controversial directorial choices, making it a standout debut for J Blakeson on Blu-ray.
Video: 70
The Blu-ray release of "The Disappearance of Alice Creed" from Anchor Bay is a testament to high-quality video presentation. The 1080p MPEG-4 AVC encoded transfer (aspect ratio: 2.40:1) superbly captures the film, handling low light levels with finesse. This transfer, crafted directly from the digital source, sidesteps the issues often found in film-based transfers, ensuring a noise-free visual experience. The meticulous attention to details is evident in every frame—from the defined textures of facial pores and makeup streaks to the intricate patterns of soundproofing materials adorning the kidnappers' hideout.
Colors are meticulously balanced, neither too vibrant nor too muted, with skin tones appearing lifelike and natural. While the overarching color palette leans towards subdued greens and grays, instances of more vivid colors still manage to pop effectively. Black levels are consistently strong, enhancing the film’s visual depth, and every shot is composed to showcase sharp detail—a notable highlight being the clear visibility of wrinkles and pores on characters' faces.
Overall, the transfer exudes a filmic quality despite its 2K digital origins, free from technical imperfections such as excess noise or fussy intermediates. The Blu-ray cuts no corners in delivering a visually engaging experience, complete with a glossy sheen characteristic of top-tier digital presentations. Some minor banding might intrude in a few scenes, but it doesn’t detract significantly from the overall visual quality. This Blu-ray ranks among the better releases on the market, particularly for those sourced from native digital formats, offering a sharp, detailed visual spectacle for viewers.
Audio: 58
The Dolby TrueHD 5.1 soundtrack on "The Disappearance of Alice Creed" delivers an adept audio experience that perfectly suits the film's workmanlike nature. The track might not boast the dynamics of blockbuster action films, but it makes efficient use of its sound design. Primarily centered on dialogue, the mix keeps most of the action front and center with limited yet effectively used surround activity. Music emerges as a strong highlight, with excellent clarity and lush, sweeping dimensions that enhance the film’s atmospheric tone. However, the LFE and surround channels are sparingly utilized, providing subtle enhancements without overwhelming the primary audio elements.
Listeners will note that the dialogue remains clear and center-focused for the most part, with only occasional instances of low volume that detract slightly from the overall experience. Despite these minor issues, such as an instance of hollow dialogue in chapter three, the track impressively balances quiet and loud dynamics, contributing to a compelling auditory experience that supports the film's mood-driven design. The isolated use of impactful sound effects like gunshots, though not up to blockbuster standards, does deliver noticeable and effective moments within the mix.
Overall, this Dolby TrueHD 5.1 mix complements the film’s narrative approach while delivering an enjoyable audio track. Though the surrounds and LFE channels are underused, their restrained implementation aligns well with the film’s budget-conscious production. Accompanying this proficient audio option are subtitles in English SDH and Spanish, catering to a wider audience. This sound mix, though not extravagant, is both smooth and effective, providing a solid listening experience that aligns well with the film's atmospheric nuances.
Extras: 40
The Extras section of "The Disappearance of Alice Creed" Blu-ray offers a standard yet insightful collection of bonus features. The highlight is the exclusive audio commentary from Writer/Director J Blakeson, who delivers an informative and candid account of the film's production challenges, the minimalist dialogue opening, and the impactful use of music. Blakeson’s commentary also delves into his directorial strategies and homages, making it an educational listen for fans and budding filmmakers alike. The disc also includes a storyboard comparison which interestingly juxtaposes preliminary sketches with final scenes, showcasing Blakeson’s adherence to his initial vision. Extended and deleted scenes are presented in standard definition with optional commentary, offering additional context though they may not add significantly to the narrative. While the outtakes provide some behind-the-scenes levity, the theatrical trailers enhance the overall extras package without offering unique Blu-ray exclusives.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary on Extended and Deleted Scene: Insights from Director J Blakeson.
- Extended and Deleted Scene: Additional footage with optional commentary.
- Storyboard Featurette: Comparisons between storyboards and final scenes.
- Theatrical Trailer: Original movie trailer.
- Trailers: Previews for Altitude, I Spit on Your Grave & Spartacus: Blood and Sand.
Movie: 53
"The Disappearance of Alice Creed," a debut feature-length film by J Blakeson, distinguishes itself within the Thriller/Kidnapping genre with its gripping narrative and minimalist setting. The film revolves around three characters and is primarily confined to a single, meticulously prepared location. Two kidnappers, Vic (Eddie Marsan) and Danny (Martin Compston), abduct Alice Creed (Gemma Arterton), the daughter of a millionaire, with an intricately detailed plan. This tightly wound scenario sets the stage for a taut psychological conflict infused with shifting allegiances and high-stakes tension. With a unique approach that veers away from typical genre conventions, the film manages to deliver a profound impact despite its micro-budget origins.
The movie establishes its intense atmosphere early on via a brilliantly executed opening sequence underscored by Mark Canham's propulsive musical score. The suspense generated in these initial moments, as Vic and Danny prepare and execute their plan, is palpable and engaging. However, the early introduction of a contentious scene where Alice is stripped serves as a problematic point for some viewers. Although intended as an act of degradation, the scene's execution, which avoids full nudity through selective coverage, feels clumsy and detracts from Alice’s characterization. Despite this misstep, the film continues to build suspense through numerous plot twists and revelations that keep the narrative dynamic and compelling.
Blakeson's direction effectively maintains tension throughout the film despite some fluctuations. The script is punctuated by significant plot developments that consistently re-energize the story, preventing it from falling into predictability. While it may not achieve the relentless intensity of top-tier thrillers, "The Disappearance of Alice Creed" remains compelling due to its strong characterizations and narrative ingenuity. Supported by exceptional performances from its lead actors and a proficient technical crew, the film transitions from a high-concept premise into a noteworthy thriller that stands out in its genre, ensuring an engaging experience for its audience.
Total: 58
"The Disappearance of Alice Creed" is a well-executed thriller that effectively combines tension with unpredictable twists. The film, centered around three characters and mostly shot in one primary location, manages to maintain a high level of engagement despite its limited budget. Although the narrative does seem a bit overdrawn by the third act and falls into less original territory towards the end, the strong direction and compelling acting bring it back on track for a satisfying conclusion. The film’s atmosphere is complemented by a wonderful and detailed video presentation on Blu-ray, enhancing the overall viewing experience.
Despite some narrative shortcomings, "The Disappearance of Alice Creed" offers a solid balance of raw suspense and plot twists that keep redefining the story. The gut-wrenching tension rarely dissipates, but it doesn't reach the peak discomfort of cinema's most disturbing entries. The Blu-ray edition boasts a quality technical presentation, notably strong video quality, though the audio and extra features are somewhat underwhelming. One standout extra is the storyboard comparison, providing intriguing insight into the director's vision before filming.
In conclusion, while "The Disappearance of Alice Creed" may not achieve the status of a quintessential British crime classic, it remains a commendable effort with its combination of strong performances and engaging direction. The Blu-ray release enhances the film's technical aspects, making it recommended for fans of taut thrillers. For those in search of a deeply engrossing experience, it might not completely meet expectations, but for a low-budget thriller, it delivers a captivating and potent movie-watching experience.
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 90
Additionally, the general griminess seen around the main locale and the textures on the soundproofing materials and any of the other pedestrian furnishings seen around the structure used by the kidnappers...
Audio: 80
The surrounds don't enjoy too much activity, though; a few external atmospherics find their way into the mix later in the movie, but as a general rule, most of the action plays out up front....
Extras: 40
Audio Commentary: Writer/Director J Blakeson mans the disc's lone commentary track, offering up his thoughts on the film's structure, shooting in the primary location, little secrets and nuances visible...
Movie: 80
Audiences interested in a movie that deviates from the norm and piles on the suspense and the plot twists will find plenty to like about Director J Blakeson's debut feature-length film that's an oftentimes...
Total: 70
It's not so intense that it's unbearable, but combined with the constant revelations that are always redefining the entirety of the plot, The Disappearance of Alice Creed delivers a potent movie watching...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
While the general color scheme is quite subdued (there are a lot of pale greens and grays), there is still a feeling of definition and depth throughout the movie, with great details (you can count the...
Audio: 60
There isn't a whole lot of surround sound stuff, and even when there is, it doesn't sound all that tremendous, and the movie is a talky little thriller, so the majority of action is front and center, but...
Extras: 40
Deleted and Extended Scenes There's really only one of each, but they're accessible with commentary from the first-name-less J. Blakeson – "Phones" (SD, 1:43) is the lone deleted scene, which doesn't add...
Movie: 20
The movie is now antiseptic and safe and, what's more, shortchanges the character of Alice to a huge degree....
Total: 40
It has a certain degree of technical polish, but that can't overcome its narrative shortcomings (instead, rent something like Shane Meadows' 'Dead Man's Shoes' instead and really get blown away)....
AVSForumRead review here
Video: 92
Besides some noise peeking up in blacks, which almost looked like exacerbated grain, this was a sharp and detailed encode....
Audio: 86
LFE and surround were not paramount here, nor were they needed--however when used, the latter was smooth and pleasing and the former never overdone....
Extras: 50
Audio Commentary on Extended and Deleted Scene by Director J Blakeson (HD) Extended and Deleted Scene (HD) Storyboard Featurette (HD) Theatrical Trailer (HD) Trailers:...
Movie: 70
Written and directed by J Blakeson, on a suburban street, two masked men seize a young woman....
Total: 75
The story does get a bit overdrawn by the time the third act hits, but does pick itself for the end, though treading some unfortunately less original territory....
Director: J Blakeson
Actors: Gemma Arterton, Eddie Marsan, Martin Compston
PlotTwo men, Vic and Danny, meticulously plan and execute the abduction of a young woman named Alice. They transform a secluded apartment into a soundproof prison, taking every precaution to ensure their crime remains undetected. After kidnapping Alice, they strip her of her dignity and dress her in a tracksuit, binding her to a bed. Alice struggles and fights, but the men remain resolute, intimidation and violence keeping her subdued. Their motivation is purely financial; they intend to ransom her back to her wealthy father. Despite their careful planning, tensions arise between Vic and Danny as their personalities and motivations clash.
As the days pass, the situation becomes increasingly volatile. Alice, determined and resourceful, looks for any possible means of escape, taking advantage of every opportunity to outsmart her captors. The dynamics shift rapidly, secrets unravel, and trust erodes among the trio. The intense psychological battle of wits among the characters propels the narrative forward, each action leading to increasingly unpredictable outcomes. The precarious balance of power continuously shifts, leading to mounting suspense and unforeseen twists, escalating the tension to its boiling point.
Writers: J Blakeson
Release Date: 30 Apr 2010
Runtime: 100 min
Rating: R
Country: United Kingdom
Language: English