Dead in Tombstone Blu-ray Review
Score: 61
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Despite commendable performances and top-tier Blu-ray video/audio quality, 'Dead in Tombstone' falters due to poor direction and script, making it better suited for a rental.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 65
Though 'Dead in Tombstone' may struggle with overly glossy digital photography and severe contrast, Universal’s 1080p/AVC-encoded video presentation excels with impressive detail, sharp close-ups, well-saturated colors, and deep black levels, free from major compression issues.
Audio: 65
Dead in Tombstone's DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track impresses with bold LFE output, dynamic range, and immersive directionality. Dialogue remains crystal clear, while booming gunshots, bombastic explosions, and a strong score energize scenes, despite some front-heavy instances typical of direct-to-video sound design.
Extra: 61
The Blu-ray extras for Dead in Tombstone provide a robust supplementary package including an energetic audio commentary by director Roel Reiné, 16 minutes of non-essential deleted scenes and a shot montage, a standard behind-the-scenes featurette, specialized segments on VFX and set design, and multiple trailers, albeit with some redundancy in the unrated cut.
Movie: 36
"Dead in Tombstone" attempts to meld a Western with supernatural revenge, featuring grizzled Danny Trejo and Mickey Rourke's quirky Lucifer. Despite intriguing elements and some entertaining sequences, the film falters with underdeveloped characters, poor dialogue, and lackluster action scenes punctuated by a few standout visuals.
Video: 65
The Blu-ray video presentation of "Dead in Tombstone" is notably robust, delivering a technically proficient 1080p/AVC-encoded image in a 1.78:1 aspect ratio. Universal has crafted a transfer that excels in capturing fine details, evident in the meticulously sharp close-ups that reveal every scar on Danny Trejo's body and the intricate textures of makeup effects. Facial features, including minutiae, are rendered with exceptional clarity, enhancing the immersive experience.
Color representation is both well-saturated and balanced, managing to faithfully convey the film's intended aesthetic despite its somewhat glossy digital photography. Predominantly featuring tones of brown, yellow, and deep reds, the colors maintain a natural look while still allowing for striking visual elements, particularly during more intense scenes. The black levels are deep and consistent, contributing to the overall depth and enhancement of on-screen imagery.
The video is largely devoid of common distractions such as macroblocking, banding, or aliasing, providing a seamless viewing experience. However, minimal instances of noise appear in scenes heavily reliant on visual effects. Despite potential limitations in atmospheric grit due to its overly polished appearance, the presentation successfully aligns with Reiné's visual intentions, ensuring an engaging and technically sound viewing experience.
Audio: 65
"Dead in Tombstone" features a robust and raucous DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 surround mix. The track is impactful, with booming LFE output enhancing the explosive guns and brawny action sequences. The rear channels effectively capture the dynamic elements of the film, with smooth cross-channel pans and directional clarity, allowing for bullet whizzes and town commotion to fill the room convincingly. While there is some front-heavy bias inherent to the direct-to-video sound design, it doesn't detract significantly from the overall immersion. Dialogue remains consistently clear and well-prioritized throughout.
The lossless DTS-HD 5.1 audio mix excels with clean, intelligible dialogue devoid of anomalies such as pops or hisses. The mix offers a commendable dynamic range, ensuring both subtle sounds and intense action sequences are delivered with fidelity. Surround channels get ample use during high-octane scenes, immersing the listener with precise effects of gunfire and explosive impacts. The score by Hybrid occasionally comes on strong but effectively maintains the film's suspense and energy. The bass is periodically powerful, rounding out an audio presentation that will not disappoint fans seeking a potent and engaging auditory experience.
Extras: 61
The Blu-ray edition of "Dead in Tombstone" offers a robust suite of extras, thanks to director Roel Reiné’s impressive curation. The package includes both an unrated and R-rated cut of the film, albeit with minimal distinction. Notably, an engaging audio commentary by Reiné provides valuable insights into the film's low-budget production, character development, and the contributions of stars Danny Trejo and Mickey Rourke. The 21-minute collection of deleted scenes and a deleted shots montage offer additional content, though they do little to enhance the narrative. Behind-the-scenes featurettes, such as "The Making of Dead in Tombstone," "Horses, Guns & Explosions," "Roel Reiné: The Leader of the Gang," "A Town Transformed," and "Creating Hell: The VFX," deliver an informative glimpse into the film’s production challenges and visual effects design.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary: Insightful commentary from director Roel Reiné.
- Deleted Scenes: Nine deleted scenes plus a deleted shots montage.
- The Making of Dead in Tombstone: Behind-the-scenes featurette with cast and crew interviews.
- Horses, Guns & Explosions: A focused look at the film's action elements.
- Roel Reiné: The Leader of the Gang: Featurette on the director.
- A Town Transformed: Details on setting up and dressing the film's locations.
- Creating Hell: The VFX: Examination of visual effects.
Movie: 36
"Dead in Tombstone" offers an intriguing but ultimately flawed venture into the supernatural western genre. Directed by Roel Reiné, the film features Danny Trejo as Guerrero de la Cruz, a vengeful gunslinger who strikes a deal with the Devil, played by Mickey Rourke, to avenge his betrayal and death by his own gang. The narrative premise shows promise as Guerrero returns from Hell for a 24-hour window to hunt down his killers, but is hampered by an undercooked script and a cast that struggles to rise above their one-dimensional roles. The plot includes numerous elements such as gold mine conspiracies and the involvement of local power players, but these subplots are often poorly developed and only serve to muddle the story further.
Roel Reiné is known for his direct-to-video repertoire, and "Dead in Tombstone" exemplifies the limitations of this domain. The action sequences, although frequent, lack the necessary coherence and excitement, often feeling flat and sporadic. Reiné's technique of using multiple cameras to film scenes in a single take results in a disjointed and chaotic presentation. While Trejo delivers a typically grizzled performance, he and co-star Anthony Michael Hall, portraying half-brother Red Cavanaugh, fail to carry the film on their own. Rourke's Lucifer shows occasional flair but is underutilized, leaving much potential untapped.
Despite these shortcomings, the film does provide some highlights, including impressive visual effects, notably in explosive set pieces and hauntingly stylized imagery. However, these moments are not enough to anchor the film amidst its evident flaws. Overall, "Dead in Tombstone" had the ingredients for an engaging supernatural western but ends up being a mostly incoherent mishmash due to its poor execution and insufficient character development.
Total: 61
"Dead in Tombstone" assembles a reliable trio of leading men but neglects to build a sharper, more cohesive revenge western around them. Danny Trejo offers a committed performance but loses ground due to his character's poorly cast gang. Anthony Michael Hall delivers menacing leers but is saddled with dreadful dialogue, while Mickey Rourke, despite an engaging presence, is largely constrained to the shadows. If only this film had benefited from more capable direction, it might have provided a more memorable experience.
From a technical standpoint, the Blu-ray release of "Dead in Tombstone" excels. The video presentation is excellent, offering crisp visuals that highlight the film's high-production values. The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 surround track delivers a robust and immersive sound experience, effectively bringing the action sequences to life. Additionally, the supplemental package is surprisingly generous, making this release noteworthy despite the film's shortcomings.
However, the film itself never rises above mediocrity. It offers enough to be a decent rental for a rainy day but lacks the polish needed for repeated viewings or ownership unless you are an ardent Danny Trejo fan. With an unrated version that barely extends beyond the R-rated cut, the movie's potential remains largely unfulfilled.
In conclusion, "Dead in Tombstone" leverages strong leading performances and top-notch Blu-ray specifications but falls short in its overall execution. With an excellent video and audio presentation and a solid array of extras, this title is best sampled through a rental service before deciding on a purchase.
Blu-ray.com review by Kenneth BrownRead review here
Video: 80
There also isn't any serious macroblocking, banding or aliasing to worry over; just a bit of occasional noise within scenes and elements that rely on VFX....
Audio: 80
Dialogue is clean and clear at all times too, and there aren't any real prioritization issues to speak of....
Extras: 70
The Making of Dead in Tombstone (HD, 10 minutes): Go behind the scenes in this EPK-style production featurette, complete with interviews with key members of the cast and crew....
Movie: 40
But its bland supporting cast, undercooked script and over-seasoned genre dialogue keep this one from being a more filling, satisfying and enjoyable main course....
Total: 70
Dead in Tombstone assembles a reliable trio of leading men but neglects to build a better, more sharply penned and capably shot revenge western around them....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
You can see every scar of Trejo's body and face, along with every hair follicle on Anthony Michael Hall's face....
Audio: 80
During the heavier action sequences, the surrounds get a great workout with some great sound effects of guns blasting, explosions, and other screams....
Extras: 60
The Making of 'Dead in Tombstone' (HD, 10 mins) - Here is a typical behind the scenes featurette that shows some onset footage mixed with the cast and crew discussing the film....
Movie: 40
Hall does a good job as always with what he's given, and Trejo is always a brute force on screen, but with some of this film, he is more stale....
Total: 60
if only it was made by a better director, then this movie might have made some decent money....
Director: Roel Reiné
Actors: Danny Trejo, Mickey Rourke, Anthony Michael Hall, Dina Meyer
PlotIn a ruthless Wild West town, Guerrero De La Cruz leads the notorious Blackwater Gang, which includes his half-brother Red. Upon successfully executing a daring jailbreak, Guerrero plans their next heist: a massive gold scheme in the mining town of Edendale. However, Guerrero finds himself betrayed and murdered by Red, who craves leadership and control over the gang. Guerrero's soul descends to Hell, where he encounters the Devil, who offers him a deal: return to Earth and collect six souls within 24 hours in exchange for reclaiming his own and avoiding an eternity of damnation.
Resurrected with hellish powers, Guerrero returns to the realm of the living, determined to exact revenge on Red and his traitorous gang members. He arrives back in Edendale and begins his relentless pursuit, confronting each member with brutal justice. As the night progresses, Guerrero's vengeance puts him in direct conflict with local law enforcement and residents of the town, leading to escalating chaos. With time running out, Guerrero faces increasing challenges and moral dilemmas, forcing him to reconcile his quest for vengeance with the dark pact that binds his soul's fate.
Writers: Shane Kuhn, Brendan Cowles
Release Date: 22 Oct 2013
Runtime: 100 min
Rating: R
Country: USA
Language: English