The Inspector Wears Skirts III Blu-ray Review
Huang jia du chuan 皇家賭船
Score: 53
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Inspector Wears Skirts III delivers broad humor akin to a sitcom, with solid yet variable technical merits and action-packed final moments.
Disc Release Date
Video: 61
The Blu-ray of 'The Inspector Wears Skirts III' is presented with an AVC encoded 1080p transfer in 1.85:1, leveraging a 2K remaster exhibiting vibrant outdoor scene colors and stable black levels. Despite minor age-related flaws and a heavy grain field, the palette remains commendable, though grain occasionally affects fine detail resolution.
Audio: 61
The Inspector Wears Skirts III's LPCM 2.0 Mono presents a somewhat boxy sound typical of Asian productions but boasts a fuller midrange and low end. Dialogue is clear, though dubbing may affect sync. Gunfire effects are decent, with optional English subtitles available for the Cantonese track.
Extra: 26
The Blu-ray's extras include an HD deleted scene, a Hong Kong trailer, and an insightful audio commentary by Frank Djeng, all complemented by a folded double-sided poster and a sleek slipcover.
Movie: 46
This third installment of "The Inspector Wears Skirts" series leans heavily on disjointed comedy that struggles internationally, overshadowing limited action with awkward, gender-based humor that fails to land. The film's unique direction under a new production company results in a mixture of sitcom-like sketches and slapstick, lacking the cohesive plot and choreography of its predecessors.
Video: 61
"The Inspector Wears Skirts III" is offered on Blu-ray by 88 Films with an AVC encoded 1080p transfer at a 1.85:1 aspect ratio. This release boasts a 2K remaster sourced from the original negatives, which brings notable improvements to the visual presentation. The color palette is one of the highlights, delivering well-defined primaries and impressive vibrancy, particularly in outdoor scenes. However, viewers may notice variances in color temperature and slight fluctuations in color suffusion throughout the film. The grain structure is predominantly heavy, but it does not significantly impact resolution. Any age-related imperfections are minimal and do not detract from the overall experience.
The bright new 2K master provides vivid contrast that stands out, despite some occasional clipping. Black levels are solid and stable, maintaining a consistent balance. Colors generally maintain a slightly faded appearance, though this only modestly tempers the vibrancy of hues. Flesh tones remain accurate and natural. Unique visual moments include the villains' suits illuminated under natural light aboard the boat, which appear especially vibrant. Issues arise primarily from the grain structure, which can be noisy and exhibit a digital quality at times. Instances where grain adheres to moving actors or overwhelms the frame are apparent, indicating an inconsistent encode that affects the fine detail reproduction.
Overall resolution is moderate with steady sharpness but limited texture, a characteristic that stems from the available resolution and grain management. While the remaster presents an improved viewing experience, it is clear that some technical limitations persist, specifically related to grain definition and encoding fidelity.
Audio: 61
The audio presentation of "The Inspector Wears Skirts III" on Blu-ray features an LPCM 2.0 Mono track in Cantonese, offering a sound experience characteristic of many Asian productions. This track, while somewhat boxy, benefits from a noticeably fuller midrange and low end compared to other Asian material recently reviewed. Despite the inherent constraints of the original audio format, the film provides a commendable level of clarity, with dialogue delivered cleanly and distinctly. It should be noted that some actors are dubbed, which can result in slightly loose sync during playback. For those who prefer it, optional English subtitles are available.
In terms of dynamic effects, such as gunfire, the reverberation provides decent but not overwhelming force, fitting within the limitations of the mono format. The fidelity is appropriate for its era, comparable to other titles in the series, though it may present a slightly puffy low-end that affects dialogue clarity at times. The film remains available only in its original language with subtitles, which might not alter the viewing experience significantly but is worth mentioning for potential viewers seeking audio alternatives. Overall, the audio presentation is reliable and satisfactorily supports the film's nostalgic mood.
Extras: 26
"The Inspector Wears Skirts III" Blu-ray extras showcase a thoughtful collection that complements the main feature with interesting insights and additional content. The highlight is the audio commentary by Frank Djeng, accessible under the Setup Menu, offering a comprehensive analysis that fans and cinephiles will appreciate. Djeng's expertise in cinema, particularly Hong Kong action films, adds depth and context. The inclusion of a deleted scene offers a glimpse into the creative process and provides additional character development. The Hong Kong trailer offers nostalgic value for long-time fans, preserving the original cinematic appeal. The packaging is noteworthy, with a double-sided poster and a slipcover, catering to collectors who value presentation.
Extras included in this disc:
- Deleted Scene: A snippet offering further insight into narrative development.
- Hong Kong Trailer: The original promotional trailer from Hong Kong.
- Audio Commentary by Frank Djeng: An expert-led commentary accessible via the Setup Menu.
Movie: 46
Inspector Wears Skirts III attempts to blend comedy and action, but struggles to strike a coherent balance between the two. While the series previously leaned into comedic elements, this installment exaggerates the humor with skits that come across as disjointed and unfunny. The plot, revolving around Inspector Kan (Stanley Fung) and Madame Wu (Sibelle Hu) navigating their new marriage dynamics, delays significant action until the climactic final act on a casino cruise ship. Unfortunately, the humor often stems from uncomfortable and outdated gender stereotypes, detracting from potential comedic efficacy.
The film’s comedic approach relies heavily on slapstick and awkward gender dynamics, creating a sitcom-like atmosphere that quickly devolves. Attempts to depict strong female characters are overshadowed by exaggerated femininity and clumsy interactions that fail to empower. The absence of Golden Harvest’s signature choreography is palpable, contributing to a lack of compelling action scenes until the very end. The lack of cohesive direction results in episodic scenes that undermine any narrative depth.
Inspector Wears Skirts III might aim for humor and empowerment but falls short, resulting in scenes that oscillate between being slapstick and uncomfortable without achieving genuine comedic impact or narrative coherence. The film closes with a feeling of missed opportunity, sacrificing engaging action and insightful humor for a flawed exploration of gender roles and awkward comedic attempts.
Total: 53
"The Inspector Wears Skirts III" on Blu-Ray is an intriguing mixture of slapstick comedy and sporadic action, emblematic of its late 80s cinematic roots. The third installment of this series attempts to weave humor with action but often defaults to exaggerated comedic elements, bordering on slapstick. It's evident that the film strives to entertain through its situational comedy style, which may resonate with some viewers while potentially alienating others seeking more balanced narratives.
Technically, the Blu-Ray release offers a competent presentation, balancing vibrant visuals with acceptable audio quality. The picture clarity is generally solid, though slight inconsistencies may occasionally emerge. The soundscape complements the visual elements, albeit at times lacking the depth expected from contemporary remastering efforts. One of the standout features of this edition is Djeng’s commentary. It provides a treasure trove of insights and adds substantial value for fans of the series, delving into both the technical and creative facets of the film's production.
In conclusion, "The Inspector Wears Skirts III" delivers a predictable yet entertaining mix of comedy and action typical of its era. Though its humor might seem abrasive to some, it finds redemption in its energetic and informative commentary track. Prospective buyers may find it a worthy addition to their collection, especially if they have a penchant for nostalgic, comedic escapades. Overall, it’s a competent Blu-Ray iteration that maintains the charm of the original while providing valuable context through its supplemental content.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 70
The palette is one of the strong points here, with clearly defined primaries and some commendable vibrancy in the outdoor scenes in particular, though there are definitely color temperature variances along...
Audio: 70
This has the same somewhat boxy sound that seems to attend a lot of Asian productions in particular, though that said, the midrange and low end are both considerably more fulsome than on some of the "lesser"...
Extras: 20
...
Movie: 60
As Frank Djeng addresses in yet another of his almost patented mile a minute commentary tracks, this third effort in the series is something of an outlier, at least insofar as some of its production masthead...
Total: 60
The humor here is often very broad, to the point of almost being slapstick (slapshtick?), and the action is largely consigned to the last half hour or so....
DoBlu review by Matt PaprockiRead review here
Video: 60
Any issues stem from the grain structure, which is noisy and messy, even with a tinge of digital-ness....
Audio: 60
PCM mono sounds sufficient aside from a puffy low-end that responds to blown out dialog in spots....
Extras: 40
...
Movie: 40
Soon, Inspector Wears Skirts III turns on itself, the cartoon-like central logic trying to cover up how cruel so much of this activity is....
Total: 50
A dismal purported comedy, Inspector Wears Skirts III tries to be playful but ends up uncomfortably aggressive....
Director: Wellson Chin
Actors: Sandra Kwan Yue Ng, Sibelle Hu, Kara Ying Hung Wai
PlotA special paramilitary police unit composed solely of women embarks on a mission to safeguard a high-profile film crew that's shooting a movie on location in Hong Kong. Among them, there's Gao, the tough and disciplined leader; May, a sprightly new recruit eager to prove herself; and Amy, the tech-savvy yet clumsy member who often finds herself in humorous predicaments. Tensions and camaraderie develop among the group as they train intensively to uphold their duty while facing the unique challenges of a male-dominated field. The inclusion of a male officer, Monkey, adds a layer of comic friction and subtle rivalry as he tries to integrate with the team.
As the operation proceeds, the unit must protect the film crew from a series of escalating incidents that suggest more sinister undertakings than anticipated. Behind the glitz of the movie production, they uncover clues hinting at criminal threats targeting the crew and possibly tying back to a larger conspiracy. Navigating through rivalry, developing friendships, and moments of levity, the women use their specialized skills to investigate the conspiracy. The plot thickens as the unit encounters unexpected obstacles requiring them to rely on each other’s strengths to diffuse dangers. Complex dynamics within the team evolve as they balance personal stakes with professional obligations, setting the stage for intense confrontations and demanding physical challenges—all of which test their mettle as they strive to thwart those threatening their mission.
Writers: Man Choi Lee
Release Date: 20 Oct 1990
Runtime: 96 min
Rating: N/A
Country: Hong Kong
Language: Cantonese