The Sea of Trees Blu-ray Review
Score: 59
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Gus Van Sant's 'The Sea of Trees' is technically impressive but stumbles dramatically, offering a commendable message lost in an uneven execution.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 71
The Blu-ray presentation of 'The Sea of Trees' features a 1080p AVC encoded transfer in 2.40:1, capturing the film's intentional cooler palette with satisfying primary colors and stable contrast. Close-ups showcase superb fine detail, though some forest scenes exhibit slight digital murk without noise or compression artifacts, maintaining high-quality encoding.
Audio: 75
The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track excels in creating a haunting atmosphere with immersive surround effects, especially in forest sequences and an evocative score, while ensuring clean, clear dialogue throughout.
Extra: 21
The Sea of Trees: A Story of Beauty and Tragedy (1080p; 8:17) offers a standard EPK with some engaging interviews from McConaughey, Watts, and Van Sant at Cannes, highlighting the mixed reception of the film.
Movie: 41
"The Sea of Trees" features a faltering narrative and awkward juxtaposition of supernatural ambiguities with maudlin melodrama, yet boasts striking cinematography by Kasper Tuxen and a memorable score by Mason Bates. Despite commendable performances from Matthew McConaughey and Naomi Watts, the film's diffuse storytelling undercuts its thematic aspirations.
Video: 71
The video presentation of "The Sea of Trees" on Blu-ray, distributed by Lionsgate Films, delivers a commendable visual experience. Encoded in AVC 1080p and presented in a 2.40:1 aspect ratio, the film captures its intended aesthetic effectively. Despite the lack of high gloss and ultra-sharp imagery, the colors are rendered satisfying, with a cooler overall palette that complements the film's somber settings. Complexions are lifelike, showcasing textural details that enhance tonality. The resolution stands out particularly in mid-level and close-up shots, revealing fine subtleties in both characters and objects, while wide-angle shots maintain average delineation due to the film’s inherently softer elements. Contrast is well-balanced, and blacks remain stable without being overly dynamic.
Technically, the Blu-ray has no glaring issues with video anomalies or compression artifacts, indicating a high-quality encoding. The film employs digital capture, as indicated by the closing credits’ mention of the Red Epic Dragon and the Arri Alexa XT cameras, with a final 2K digital intermediate (DI) finish. While some scenes, especially darker forest sequences, exhibit minor contrast issues with a digital murkiness, these instances are minimalistic and do not detract significantly from the overall sharpness and definition. Forest footage often has a greenish-blue tint that can slightly reduce detail in midrange shots. Conversely, flashback sequences provide a warmer palette with yellows and browns, displaying excellent detail levels and exhibiting fewer distractions or noise. Overall, this Blu-ray presentation retains the film's intentional visual style, ensuring an immersive viewing experience.
Audio: 75
The audio presentation of "The Sea of Trees" on Blu-ray is delivered through a DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track, effectively enhancing the cinematic experience. In particular, the forest sequences stand out with meticulously crafted surround effects. Constant breezes are rendered through the side and rear channels, creating an evocative and haunting atmosphere that immerses the viewer deeply into the scenic environment. Additionally, the elegiac score comfortably resides in the surround sound, augmenting the emotional undertones that the screenplay occasionally underdelivers. This sophisticated audio design does an exceptional job of conveying the film’s intended ambiance.
Flashback sequences, though more subdued, offer moments of impressive immersion, such as an early party scene where background noises and conversations flow naturally, enhancing the realism of the scenario. Dialogue throughout the presentation is clear and clean, with no discernible issues, ensuring that every line is audible and precise. This meticulous attention to detail in sound design contributes significantly to the overall viewing experience, making this audio track a commendable aspect of "The Sea of Trees."
Extras: 21
The Blu-ray of "The Sea of Trees" provides a modest but insightful selection of extras that complement the film nicely. Central among these is "The Sea of Trees: A Story of Beauty and Tragedy," an 8-minute featurette in high definition, offering a standard EPK package. It includes interviews with key figures such as Matthew McConaughey, Naomi Watts, and director Gus Van Sant, providing a glimpse into their thoughts and experiences at Cannes, despite the film's mixed reception. This brief yet informative segment successfully captures the essence and behind-the-scenes insights of the movie's creation.
Extras included in this disc:
- The Sea of Trees: A Story of Beauty and Tragedy: 8-minute featurette offering interviews with McConaughey, Watts, and Van Sant at Cannes.
- Digital HD Copy
Movie: 41
Gus Van Sant’s “The Sea of Trees” presents a complex narrative intertwining themes of despair, redemption, and the supernatural. Matthew McConaughey stars as Arthur Brennan, an American professor in the throes of a personal crisis who travels to Japan's infamous Aokigahara Forest. The film sets an eerie tone with the forest's reputation as a suicide hotspot. Upon intending to take his own life, Arthur encounters Takumi Nakamura (Ken Watanabe), a severely injured man. Their ensuing journey is marked by spiritual and survival elements, presenting both men with opportunities for reflection and emotional revelation.
Visually, "The Sea of Trees" benefits from the evocative cinematography of Kasper Tuxen, who skillfully captures the mystique of the forest. The aesthetics are enhanced by a poignant score from Mason Bates, which complements the film’s attempt to blend elements of psychological turmoil and supernatural ambiguity adeptly. However, the narrative strikes an uneasy balance, precariously shifting between Arthur’s troubled marital past, marked by melodramatic sequences with his wife Joan (Naomi Watts), and the surreal survival journey with Takumi. This combination of elements results in a disjointed storyline that strains believability and coherence.
Despite the film’s inherent flaws, it commands attention with strong performances from McConaughey and Watts. The melancholic tone and Van Sant’s introspective direction strive to explore existential depths but are often overshadowed by implausible plot points and overwrought emotional beats. Scenes invoking deep philosophical reflections on life and death might come across as overly sentimental, detracting from the overall impact. Ultimately, while “The Sea of Trees” endeavors to be a meditative exploration of grief and salvation, its execution leaves it fragmented and struggling to convey a cohesive and potent message.
Total: 59
The Sea of Trees, directed by Gus Van Sant, showcases both his unique directorial prowess and a notable stumble in his otherwise impressive filmography. While the narrative is fraught with inconsistent dramatic elements and occasionally loses its core message of redemption and salvation, it still holds some appeal, particularly for fans of the talented cast. However, what it lacks in storyline coherence, it somewhat compensates with strong technical execution.
The Blu-ray release impresses in terms of audiovisual quality. The high-definition visuals are well-rendered, maintaining clarity and depth throughout, which is pivotal for a film set amidst the dense, atmospheric locale of Japan’s Aokigahara forest. The color palette, although somber, is accurately reproduced, presenting the intended gloomy aesthetic effectively. Moreover, the audio quality is superbly balanced, providing clear dialogue delivery and an immersive soundscape that enhances the overall viewing experience.
In conclusion, while The Sea of Trees may not stand out as a triumph in Gus Van Sant's career, it remains a technically proficient piece that could be appreciated by dedicated fans and those interested in high-quality home theater experiences. Despite its narrative flaws, the Blu-ray edition offers an engaging visual and auditory presentation making it a worthy consideration for collectors and aficionados of the genre.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 80
There are a few contrast issues at play at various points throughout this presentation, with a bit of digital murk creeping into several dark sequences in the forest, but generally speaking, this is a...
Audio: 90
The aforementioned elegiac score also resides quite comfortably in the surrounds and helps to create a bit of the emotional ambience that the actual screenplay isn't ever really able to....
Extras: 20
The Sea of Trees: A Story of Beauty and Tragedy (1080p; 8:17), is a pretty standard EPK, though it contains a few interesting interviews, including some with McConaughey, Watts and Van Sant at Cannes,...
Movie: 40
Van Sant is an interesting director if not always a consistent one, and both of those aspects are on display in this film, one which wants to weave together a kind of supernaturally tinged tale of an American...
Total: 40
Fans of the cast may well want to check this out, with an understanding that dramatically the film is all over the place and its commendable message of salvation kind of gets lost in the morass....
AVSForum review by Ralph PottsRead review here
Video: 86
This video presentation offers little in the way of high Gloss, razor sharp imagery but it seems to represent the film’s elements well....
Audio: 84
Universal Disc/3D capable Blu-ray Player Samsung UBD-K8500 Ultra HD Blu-ray Player Sony Playstation 3 Blu-ray disc Player System Controller: Apple iPad/iRule Pro HD Universal Remote Control Canton "Ergo"...
Extras: 30
(HD) The Sea of Trees: A Story of Beauty and Tragedy – 8 minute featurette Digital HD Copy...
Movie: 50
The two embark on a spiritual, life-changing journey of friendship and survival that reconnects Arthur with his love for his wife....
Total: 63
Universal Disc/3D capable Blu-ray Player Samsung UBD-K8500 Ultra HD Blu-ray Player Sony Playstation 3 Blu-ray disc Player System Controller: Apple iPad/iRule Pro HD Universal Remote Control Canton "Ergo"...
Director: Gus Van Sant
Actors: Matthew McConaughey, Naomi Watts, Ken Watanabe
PlotArthur Brennan, a grief-stricken American man, travels to Japan's Aokigahara Forest, famously known as the "Suicide Forest," with the intention of ending his life. Wandering deep into the dense wilderness, Arthur encounters a Japanese man named Takumi Nakamura, who is also contemplating suicide. The two men, despite their language barrier, form a desperate bond as they decide to navigate the perilous forest together, seeking a way out. Throughout their journey, they share their stories and reasons for their sorrow, which creates a deeper connection between them.
As they struggle to survive against the harsh elements and their own emotional turmoil, Arthur begins to reflect on his life back in the United States, including his tumultuous relationship with his wife, Joan. The journey through the forest becomes a path of self-discovery and redemption for both men, unraveling deeply buried emotions and leading them to a critical realization about their lives. Their newfound friendship transforms their perspective on life and death, driving them to find meaning and hope in the most unexpected of circumstances.
Writers: Chris Sparling
Release Date: 26 Aug 2016
Runtime: 110 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: United States
Language: English, Japanese