Shadow Blu-ray Review
影
Score: 76
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Shadow is a visually stunning film with rich, intertwining storylines, excelling in technical execution on Blu-ray, despite limited extras. Highly recommended.
Disc Release Date
Video: 90
Shot with Phantom Flex 4K and Red Weapon cameras, 'Shadow' on Blu-ray is visually stunning, presented in a 4K master with deep, inky black levels and minimal banding. The monochromatic palette punctuates the brilliant detail and subtle color hints, making it a captivating visual experience.
Audio: 85
Shadow's Blu-ray boasts a nuanced and dynamic Dolby Atmos track in the original Mandarin, with immersive effects ranging from melodic Guqin music to powerful battle sequences and ambient rain. Though overhead usage is subtle, the surround sound delivers an exquisitely balanced audio experience.
Extra: 31
The Blu-ray extras for 'Shadow' offer rich content including making-of featurettes in 1080i, trailers in 1080p, and seamless automated playback, enhancing the viewer’s understanding of the film's intricate production details and key figures like director Zhang Yimou and actor Deng Chao.
Movie: 81
Blending artistic costume drama with political action thriller, 'Shadow' offers breathtaking monochromatic cinematography and intricate fight scenes. Despite a complex plot, it remains surprisingly easy to follow, showcasing Yimou Zhang's return to form. A visual tour de force with nuanced character dynamics.
Video: 90
"Shadow" benefits immensely from its meticulous production, utilizing Phantom Flex 4K and Red Weapon digital camera systems in 8K before transferring to a native 4K master for Blu-ray. The result is an impeccable presentation marked by a predominantly monochromatic palette interspersed with muted colors, typically blood or skin tones. This non-traditional approach to black and white cinematography boasts deep, velvety blacks that reveal extensive shadow details and nearly absorb light. Fine details are sharply defined, highlighting every cut, bruise, and piece of intricate costuming.
Presented by Well Go USA with an AVC encoded 1080p transfer in a 2.39:1 aspect ratio, "Shadow" exhibits extraordinary clarity throughout its runtime. Despite initial concerns about banding during the Well Go USA masthead, these issues do not persist once the film begins. The detail retains its sharpness even in dimly lit scenes filled with rain or set in secret caverns. The striking monochromatic color grading is occasionally warmed by subtle shifts in the palette that elevate the visual storytelling. The digital effects are impressive, seamlessly blending Deng Chao’s dual roles within the same frame without noticeable flaws.
Audio: 85
The Blu-ray of "Shadow" presents a near flawless Dolby Atmos track, an unusual offering from Well Go USA which traditionally favors DTS:X tracks for its next-gen mixes. Available on both the Blu-ray and 4K UHD discs, this audio track is available exclusively in the original Mandarin, with an English Dolby Digital 5.1 track providing a lossy alternative. The Atmos track is nuanced, agile, and deeply immersive; it transitions seamlessly from the melodic sounds of the Chinese Guqin to the intense clashing of blades and distinct rasping of footsteps on stone floors. The movie’s pervasive rain sequences make substantial use of the overhead channels, effectively enveloping the listener in a symphony of droplets that enhance the atmospheric depth. However, while the bass is powerful, judiciously used, and integrates superbly with other track elements, it is notable that the overhead channels are underutilized during high action scenes.
The Atmos mix delivers fantastic immersion throughout the film, though it sometimes employs a surprisingly subtle approach given the dramatic nature of certain sequences. The surround channels are effectively engaged during key moments, from delicate sounds like a character’s interaction with a metal lock to the striking wild zither music. Dialogue is rendered cleanly and clearly, ensuring clarity in storytelling amidst intricate soundscapes. The constant rainfall provides a consistent ambient presence that engages the Atmos channels comprehensively, yet it is notable that during pivotal scenes such as battles, discrete effects in the overhead plane are notably sparse. This slight shortcoming does not overshadow the overall exceptional quality of the audio track, but it is a detail worth noting for those anticipating extensive overhead channel activity.
Extras: 31
The Blu-ray extras for "Shadow" offer a comprehensive behind-the-scenes look into the film's production and its key contributors. The supplementary materials feature detailed interviews with Director Zhang Yimou, explore the unique approach to character doubling, and provide personal insights from cast members like Deng Chao and Zheng Kai. The disc is structured for continuous playback, enhancing the viewing experience, with automatic transitions between segments and trailers for other Well Go USA releases. This thoughtful design ensures an uninterrupted and immersive exploration of the film’s creation.
Extras included in this disc:
- Making Of: In-depth production insights.
- About the Double: Details on character doubling.
- The Director: Interview with Zhang Yimou.
- The Unknown Side of Zhang Yimou: Personal insights on the director.
- Behind the Scenes: Production footage.
- Heroes: Cast reflections.
- Deng Chao: Interview with the actor.
- Zheng Kai: Actor's perspective.
- International Trailer: Global promotional trailer.
- U.S. Trailer: American promotional trailer.
- Well Go USA Trailers: Additional release previews.
Movie: 81
"Shadow," directed by Yimou Zhang, is an artful return to his established mastery of the wuxia genre, blending political intrigue with high-stakes action. The film captivates with its striking monochromatic cinematography, presenting almost black-and-white visuals that differ radically from Zhang's earlier vibrant palettes in films like "Hero" and "House of Flying Daggers." This unique visual design, meticulously crafted by cinematographer Zhao Xiaoding, layers the narrative with a philosophical depth symbolized by the yin-yang motif, enhancing the audience's engagement through its stylistic clarity. The film's tale, essentially a slow-burn political thriller, interlaces intricately detailed fight sequences, transforming them into dance-like choreography.
Set against the aftermath of a pivotal duel between the kingdoms of Pei and Yang, the plot revolves around Commander Zi Yu (Deng Chao), secretly replaced by his doppelgänger, Jing. With a grievous wound from his initial defeat driving him towards madness, Zi Yu orchestrates a rematch behind King Pei Liang’s back. This plot point unveils a web of deception and power struggles, each character's motives dissecting themes of loyalty, identity, and legacy against the backdrop of epic political drama. The complicated dynamic between Zi Yu, his doppelgänger Jing, and his conflicted wife Madam (Sun Li) adds personal stakes to the grandiose battles over territory and honor.
Despite the film's intricate narrative and multiple subplots, "Shadow" remains surprisingly accessible. Its twists fall between predictability and unexpected revelations, maintaining a coherent storyline without sacrificing its intricate character development or thematic richness. The film's climax crescendos into a visceral blend of battles and betrayals, delivering an engaging mix of visually arresting spectacle and deeply human conflict. Though not as relentless as some wuxia counterparts like "Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon," "Shadow" thrives on its deliberate pacing and artistic flair, making it a compelling entry in Yimou Zhang’s illustrious repertoire.
Total: 76
Yimou Zhang's "Shadow" is an arresting cinematic experience that seamlessly blends elements of costume drama, political intrigue, and period action. The film follows in the grand tradition of Zhang’s other classics like "Hero" and "House of Flying Daggers," though it falls just short of matching their epic scale. The narrative juggles multiple storylines involving key characters with precision, adding a textured complexity that enriches the overall plot. Despite a few predictable moments, the interwoven lives of the main and supporting characters provide a compelling tapestry that engages the audience throughout.
Visually, "Shadow" is nothing short of ravishing. The monochromatic palette and striking imagery create a mythic, folkloristic atmosphere that amplifies the storytelling. Cinematographically, the film stands out with its meticulous composition and exceptional attention to detail, designed to leave viewers in awe. The Blu-ray release retains this visual finesse with an aspect ratio of 2.39:1 AVC, ensuring a crisp, immersive viewing experience.
Technical specifications further bolster the film’s merits. With Dolby Atmos (Dolby TrueHD 7.1) Mandarin audio and English Dolby Digital 5.1 options, the audio landscape is as rich and immersive as the visual narrative, bringing every scene to life with remarkable clarity. Subtitles in both simplified and traditional Mandarin provide accessibility without compromising on content integrity. While the Blu-ray is somewhat sparse on extras—limited to trailers and a making-of feature—the technical excellence makes it worthwhile.
In conclusion, "Shadow" is a striking film that is lovingly handled both technically and narratively. It may not achieve every epic ambition Yimou Zhang aspires to, but it remains a solid entry in his oeuvre and a beautiful visual experience. Both the Blu-ray and its superior 4K counterpart are highly recommended for their technical brilliance and engaging storytelling. Definitely worth checking out.
AV Nirvana review by Michael ScottRead review here
Video: 100
Well Go USA is usually pretty heavy on the banding, but this presentation only shows a minimal amount of banding in the darkness, and it’s not very noticeable unless you’re looking for it....
Audio: 90
The bass is powerful and judiciously used throughout the movie, and while it hits hard and low, the LFE is never over aggressively mixed and blends seamlessly with the rest of the music, ambient noises...
Extras: 30
...
Movie: 80
Yimou Zhang appears to be doing the same thing in terms of style, making something so classic and so well used his own, and the cinematography world may never be the same....
Total: 90
As much costume drama as period piece political action thriller, Shadow tries to fall along with the classics like Hero and House of Flying Daggers in scope and execution, only falling short JUUUUUST barely...
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 100
Things are toyed with, however, and there is one noticeable instance late in the film where the palette becomes at least a little warmer....
Audio: 100
Everything from Madam futzing with a metal lock on a door (in an image and sound effect moment that bookends the film) to the absolutely wild zither music to the well staged if admittedly relatively infrequent...
Extras: 40
The Director (1080i; 3:17) The Unknown Side of Zhang Yimou (1080i; 3:03) Behind the Scenes (1080i; 2:43) Heroes (1080i; 4:06)...
Movie: 90
Zhang may have experienced something of a major misfire with his attempt to appeal to Western audiences with The Great Wall, but he seems thrillingly in control of Shadow, even if the film is perhaps too...
Total: 90
The story has some predictable aspects, but it's quite interesting how it manages to interweave the lives of at least four major characters (five, if you include both "versions" of Commander Zi Yu), as...
Director: Yimou Zhang
Actors: Chao Deng, Li Sun, Ryan Zheng
PlotIn a kingdom ruled by a young and unpredictable king, a great military commander has been defeated and is in exile, plotting his return. Unbeknownst to all, the commander has a "shadow," a look-alike who can be used as a decoy to confuse his enemies and the king himself. The kingdom is on the brink of war with a rival city, and the tension between the king and the commander further escalates the dangerous political environment. Amid this setting of deception, the shadow trains in a unique fighting style in preparation for the commander's intricate plans of revenge and reclaiming honor.
While the shadow maneuvers through a game of political chess, the commander's wife becomes an unwitting pawn in his machinations. The wife, who yearns for her husband’s return, finds herself drawn to the shadow due to his uncanny resemblance to her spouse. As the plot thickens and battles loom on the horizon, every character must confront their loyalties and the blurred lines between their identities, desires, and duties. Their fates become intertwined with the kingdom's future, setting the stage for an epic confrontation where strategy, courage, and betrayal will decide the fate of all involved.
Writers: Wei Li, Yimou Zhang, Sujin Zhu
Release Date: 30 Sep 2018
Runtime: 116 min
Rating: Not Rated
Country: China, Hong Kong
Language: Mandarin