Mean Girls Blu-ray Review
SteelBook So Fetch! Limited Edition
Score: 65
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Mean Girls' SteelBook is visually appealing with its film-inspired design, though content remains unchanged from the 15th Anniversary Edition.
Disc Release Date
Dolby TrueHD
Video: 69
The Blu-ray transfer of 'Mean Girls' is solid, with sharp colors and strong details in its AVC encoded 1.85:1 ratio, but a new remaster or 4K disc would have elevated the visual experience significantly.
Audio: 64
The Dolby TrueHD track on the 'Mean Girls' Blu-ray delivers clean vocals and clear background ambiance, maintaining a straightforward but effective soundscape that complements the film's setting.
Extra: 61
Mean Girls' Blu-ray Extras offer a mix of engaging features, though lacking fresh content—still featuring the lively audio commentary by Director Mark Waters, Tina Fey, and Lorne Michaels, insightful features like 'Only the Strong Survive,' and amusing segments such as 'Plastic Fashion' and bloopers dubbed 'Word Vomit.'
Movie: 66
Paramount's 15th-anniversary Blu-ray SteelBook of 'Mean Girls' revives the 2004 cult favorite with its original 2009 disc, wrapped in a new vibrant pink case. This engaging teen comedy by Tina Fey still resonates today, showcasing Lindsay Lohan at her peak amidst a stellar comedic ensemble, now a classic alongside 'Clueless' and 'Heathers.'
Video: 69
The Blu-ray release of "Mean Girls" presents a competent yet slightly dated video experience. While the transfer remains solid, offering sharp colors and strong details, it is clear that the presentation could benefit from a new remaster or even a 4K release. The existing disc features an AVC encoded 1.85:1 aspect ratio that holds up well, but a fresh update would have undoubtedly enhanced the viewing experience of this iconic film staple.
Despite the absence of a contemporary remaster, the colors on this Blu-ray disc are vibrant and detailed, maintaining the lively aesthetic essential to the film's narrative. The sharpness is commendable, capturing fine textures and subtle visual cues critical to the movie's high school setting. However, those accustomed to the enhanced clarity and depth of modern 4K releases might find this version lacking the technological upgrades that newer formats offer.
In summary, while the current Blu-ray disc for "Mean Girls" is satisfactory and renders the beloved film with a degree of visual quality, it leaves potential for improvement. A remaster or 4K version could amplify the film's visual appeal, enriching its already dynamic color palette and intricate details. Nonetheless, for fans and collectors, this Blu-ray remains a reliable option, ensuring a respectable and enjoyable viewing experience.
Audio: 64
The audio presentation of the "Mean Girls" Blu-ray features a Dolby TrueHD track that maintains its straightforward quality as seen in previous releases. This audio format complements the film's narrative by providing a coherent and balanced sound experience. Background elements, such as school hallways and cafeteria banter, are well-captured, adding layers to the scenes without overtaking the primary dialogue. The vocals are notably clear, ensuring that dialogues are intelligible and free from distortion or other auditory distractions.
Technical execution of the Dolby TrueHD track serves the film's comedic and dramatic elements effectively, though it lacks the dynamic range found in more action-oriented films. While the track avoids flashy sound effects, it captures the film’s lively environment with precision. Every laugh, gossip, and altercation within the high school setting is delivered with clarity and depth, engaging viewers through the subtlety of its audio design.
Overall, this audio track is suitably sufficient for a dialogue-focused film like "Mean Girls." Though it doesn’t leverage extensive surround capabilities or cutting-edge technology like DTS or Dolby Atmos might, the Dolby TrueHD track fulfills its purpose effectively. For those interested in purely enjoying the narrative without distraction from audio shortcomings, this mix provides an appropriate match. This Blu-ray release ensures that audio fidelity meets expectations consistent with the film's context and style.
For a full Blu-ray audio review, please click here.
Extras: 61
The Blu-ray extras for "Mean Girls" maintain consistency with the previously released version. While there are no new additions, the existing supplements provide valuable insights and entertainment. The Audio Commentary features an engaging discussion by Director Mark Waters, Tina Fey, and producer Lorne Michaels, offering a blend of humor and informative tidbits about the film's production. The documentary-style features delve into various aspects of the movie and its source material. Despite the lack of fresh content, the collection remains a useful resource for fans eager to explore the film's production nuances.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary: Insights from Director Mark Waters, Tina Fey, and producer Lorne Michaels.
- Only the Strong Survive: A 24-minute feature on the film's origins.
- The Politics of the Girl World: Explores the book behind the movie.
- Plastic Fashion: Discusses character costumes.
- Word Vomit: Bloopers.
- Deleted Scenes: Nine fun but non-essential clips.
- Interstitials: Television ads.
- Trailer: Original film trailer.
Movie: 66
The re-release of "Mean Girls" on Blu-ray celebrates its enduring appeal, reinstating the 2009 disc with a new, eye-catching pink SteelBook case. Directed by Mark Waters and headlined by Lindsay Lohan at her career's pinnacle, the 2004 film crafted by Tina Fey continues to resonate with audiences. As a lighter companion to cult classic "Heathers," "Mean Girls" brilliantly captures the zeitgeist of its era, underscored by a nuanced narrative about high school hierarchies and identity struggles. Lohan's portrayal of Cady Heron, a girl navigating the treacherous waters of high school cliques after moving from Africa, serves as the film's compelling core. Supported by a stellar cast, including Rachel McAdams, Amanda Seyfried, and numerous "Saturday Night Live" alumni, the film deftly balances humor with social commentary.
Despite being fraught with behind-the-scenes shifts in Lohan's career trajectory, "Mean Girls" enjoys a steadfast position in teen film lore alongside works like "Clueless." This Blu-ray edition meticulously preserves its successful elements, offering a timeless exploration of adolescent behavior intertwined with humor and relatability. Notably, the film remains relevant today, reflecting changes in society while maintaining its place as a culturally impactful piece from the early 2000s.
For fans and newcomers alike, this release serves not only as a nostalgic revisit to Lohan's early prominence but also as a testament to Tina Fey's writing prowess and Lorne Michaels' production vision. While slightly tinted by Lohan's post-"Mean Girls" career decline, the film benefits from her shining performance and confirms its status as a defining moment in comedic cinema. The continued allure of "Mean Girls" lies in its sharp wit and authentic depiction of high school experiences, ensuring its place as a staple of its genre.
Total: 65
The Blu-ray release of "Mean Girls" through Paramount's SteelBook edition is a visual treat that aligns perfectly with the iconic film's aesthetic. The SteelBook exterior features a striking metallic reproduction of one of the movie's key props, capturing the essence and vibrancy of the movie's design. This presentation caters to collectors and fans alike, offering a tangible nod to the much-adored film from 2004.
However, it is noteworthy that the disc itself remains unchanged from previous editions, persisting as the same edition from the 15th Anniversary release. This means that those hoping for new content or improved audio/visual upgrades may find this edition lacking in innovation. The absence of a 4K upgrade in this release is somewhat disappointing for enthusiasts who crave the latest in home entertainment technology. Despite this, for those prioritizing aesthetics and collectability, the SteelBook case can be a desirable addition.
In conclusion, while the Blu-ray disc does not present any new features or enhancements apart from its striking physical packaging, it remains a recommended purchase for avid collectors of SteelBook editions. The film itself continues to endure over the years both in popularity and relevance, ensuring its place in collections. For individuals seeking new technical or supplemental content, it may be worth waiting for a future 4K edition. Nevertheless, the current SteelBook edition stands as a testament to "Mean Girls'" lasting impact. Recommended for collectors and fans who appreciate thoughtful packaging design.
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 70
...
Audio: 70
...
Extras: 50
The inner print is a two-panel spread that features a pink background holding a couple of Polaroid pictures with various written captions on the bottom....
Movie: 70
See the 'Special Features and Extras' section of the review below for more on the SteelBook's look and feel....
Total: 70
...
Blu-ray Authority review by Matt MaloufRead review here
Video: 80
This is the same disc and certainly some fresh paint, so to speak, would’ve been nice for a film like this, but that wasn’t meant to be....
Audio: 70
The Dolby TrueHD track is pretty straightforward as it was on the previously-released Blu-ray....
Extras: 80
The Politics of the Girl World – This is a shorter program, but one that’s still informative, telling about the book on which the film is based and other aspects....
Movie: 0
She then had a string of successes with The Parent Trap and Confessions of a Teenage Drama Queen and even modest success with 2006’s Herbie Fully Loaded but ever since then it’s been a steep decline....
Total: 80
Unfortunately, this disc offers nothing new, outside of a steelbook (even the disc is the same from the 15th Anniversary Edition)....
Director: Mark Waters
Actors: Lindsay Lohan, Jonathan Bennett, Rachel McAdams
PlotCady Heron, a 16-year-old girl who has spent her entire life being homeschooled in Africa, moves to the United States and enrolls in a public high school for the first time. This transition introduces her to the complex social hierarchies and cliques that define high school life. She initially struggles to find her place, befriending social outcasts Janis and Damian, who guide her through the school's social landscape. Together, they concoct a plan to infiltrate the school's most exclusive and ruthless clique, The Plastics, led by the charming yet manipulative Regina George.
As Cady becomes more integrated into the group, her initial intentions begin to fade, and she starts to absorb the group's superficial values and backstabbing behavior. Her newfound popularity strains her relationships with Janis and Damian, and she slowly starts to lose sight of her true self. The dynamics within The Plastics and the broader school community lead to escalating tensions, prompting Cady to reevaluate her priorities and the consequences of her actions.
Writers: Rosalind Wiseman, Tina Fey
Release Date: 30 Apr 2004
Runtime: 97 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: United States, Canada
Language: English, German, Vietnamese, Swahili