Vicky Cristina Barcelona Blu-ray Review
Score: 46
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Solid Woody Allen film with great visuals, decent audio, but no extras.
Disc Release Date
Video: 70
Vicky Cristina Barcelona's Blu-ray dazzles with a golden, detailed transfer capturing Spain's allure, retaining filmic texture without digital flaws, in Allen's preferred 1.85:1 ratio.
Audio: 40
Despite packaging errors, Vicky Cristina Barcelona features only a PCM 3.0 channel soundtrack emphasizing clear dialogue and music, mostly in mono, without the Dolby options claimed.
Extra: 0
Vicky Cristina Barcelona's Blu-ray reflects Woody Allen's preference for letting films speak for themselves, lacking even basic features like trailers.
Movie: 71
Woody Allen's film 'Vicky Cristina Barcelona' mingles romance and turmoil in Spain, showcasing strong performances amid critiques of his repetitive themes but noting a notable effort in his filmography.
Video: 70
The Blu-ray presentation of "Vicky Cristina Barcelona" showcases a stunning video quality that brings Woody Allen and Cinematographer Javier Aguirresarobe's vision to life with a remarkable clarity and aesthetic appeal. The film is presented in its original theatrical aspect ratio of 1.85:1, employing a 1080p/VC-1 transfer that elegantly captures the lush, warm golden tones that bathe every scene, from the vibrant Spanish landscapes to the intimate interior moments. This visual style, a deliberate choice by the filmmakers, lends the movie an almost timeless feel, enveloping viewers in the beauty and warmth of its setting.
From a technical standpoint, this Blu-ray is a testament to high-quality transfer work. The colors are deeply saturated and beautifully defined, while the contrast remains robust without overshadowing the intricate details that are crisply and cleanly rendered across scenes. One notable aspect is the absence of common digital artifacts such as edge enhancement or noticeable digital noise reduction side effects, ensuring a pure and undisturbed viewing experience. This is particularly impressive given the film's almost complete lack of apparent film grain, likely a result of being shot on very fine-grained film stock to achieve its glossy, picture-postcard aesthetics.
Moreover, the sharp details, vibrant colors, and silky smooth textures contribute to an exceptionally high-definition imagery that does justice to Javier Aguirresarobe’s stunning cinematography. Despite some viewers' potential for preference conflicts due to the unique visual style or the surprisingly minimal film grain, it's hard to overlook the technical prowess and artistic intention behind this transfer. Both enthusiasts and critics alike should find the video presentation of "Vicky Cristina Barcelona" on Blu-ray highly commendable and illustrative of the capabilities of high-definition media to enhance and respect cinematic artistry.
Audio: 40
The audio presentation of "Vicky Cristina Barcelona" on Blu-ray offers a technically functional but modest experience, primarily focusing on dialogue and a minimal musical score. Contrary to the packaging claims, the Blu-ray does not feature Dolby Digital audio options but rather delivers an uncompressed PCM 3-channel soundtrack. Such mislabeling may lead to initial confusion, however, upon careful inspection and testing across various systems, it becomes apparent that this configuration is predominantly a mono mix that utilizes the front center channel for both dialogue and music, sparingly extending to the front left and right channels.
Despite indications of an available 5.1 PCM track, the reality is a 3.0 setup where only the front three channels are active. This aligns with Woody Allen's traditional approach to sound design, which eschews flashy audio techniques in favor of clear, straightforward dialogue delivery and a singular musical theme that echoes throughout the film. The dialogue maintains excellent clarity across different setups, ensuring that every word is precisely conveyed. Although the music does faintly reach the front stereo speakers, it predominantly resides within the center channel, reinforcing the movie's mono characteristic.
In conclusion, while the audio component of "Vicky Cristina Barcelona" on Blu-ray does not dazzle with an expansive or immersive soundstage, it succeeds in delivering a clean and precise aural experience. The sharp focus on verbal communication over auditory spectacle reflects Allen’s directorial preference and serves the film's narrative well. However, those expecting a dynamic or multi-dimensional audio environment might find the audio presentation to be decidedly average, despite its technical proficiency in handling what it sets out to achieve with its PCM 3.0 mix.
Extras:
The Blu-ray release of "Vicky Cristina Barcelona" remains consistent with director Woody Allen’s philosophy towards extras and behind-the-scenes content, offering a stark experience true to his belief in letting the film stand on its own merits. This choice reflects Allen's distinctive stance on supplemental material, highlighting his intent to preserve the cinematic purity of his work without the distraction of additional features. Consequently, the Blu-ray is devoid of any special features, making-of documentaries, or even trailers, placing its entire focus on the film itself. This deliberate omission serves as a reminder of Allen's artistic ethos and his approach to filmmaking, where the narrative and performances are intended to solely captivate the audience’s attention.
Extras included in this disc:
- There are no extras included on this disc.
Movie: 71
In "Vicky Cristina Barcelona," Woody Allen transports audiences to the vibrant landscapes of Spain, charting new territory both geographically and thematically. As his European adventures unfold, Allen delves into the tangled web of love, desire, and artistic inspiration with a narrative that's as leisurely as a Spanish summer yet punctuated by moments of intense emotional clarity. The film's protagonists, Vicky (Rebecca Hall) and Cristina (Scarlett Johansson), are the embodiment of contrasting desires and ideologies, offering a rich canvas on which Allen paints a story of self-discovery against the backdrop of Barcelona's seductive beauty.
Central to the film's exploration of love and lust is Javier Bardem's Juan Antonio, a character whose complex past relationships, especially with the fiery Maria Elena (Penélope Cruz), carve out a narrative that's as unpredictable as it is enticing. The dynamics between the characters evolve in a manner that's quintessentially Allen—mixing humor, drama, and a keen observation of human follies. Scarlett Johansson shines as Cristina, reaffirming her status as Allen's muse, and elevates the material with a performance that perfectly captures her character's restless spirit. The film’s handling of relationships, especially through the lens of Bardem and Cruz’s characters, adds layers of complexity that challenge conventional romantic narratives.
Despite a few narrative quirks and an occasionally intrusive narration style, "Vicky Cristina Barcelona" is a testament to Woody Allen's resilience as a storyteller. The picturesque setting of Barcelona, coupled with the compelling interplay of characters, makes for a film that is both visually stunning and thematically rich. It's a narrative imbued with the nuances of desire, art, and the elusive quest for happiness, marking another notable entry in Allen's illustrious career. This film may polarize viewers with its unconventional storytelling and character dynamics, but therein lies its allure—a film that provokes thought, demands attention, and captures the complexities of the human heart with an unflinching honesty.
Total: 46
Vicky Cristina Barcelona," Woody Allen's 43rd venture into the complexities of human relationships and miscommunications, showcases his enduring flair for crafting engaging narratives with a touch of introspection and sly wit. Departing once again from his preferred New York City backdrop for European landscapes, Allen's storytelling prowess remains undiminished in his seventies. The film, while it may not reach the iconic status of his earlier works, exemplifies his prolific nature and ability to captivate audiences with quirky, thought-provoking content. The Blu-ray release by The Weinstein Company does justice to the film's vivid cinematography with an impressive video transfer that brings out the lush visuals of the setting. However, the audio presentation is somewhat unconventional with its three-channel setup, which, while adequate, may leave audiophiles longing for more.
Despite the Blu-ray’s distinct lack of supplements - a choice seemingly in line with Allen's known preferences for home media releases - the disc's presentation does not falter in delivering a worthwhile viewing experience. This aspect, coupled with the high-quality picture resolution, ensures that the film can be appreciated in a home viewing context, closely mirroring its cinematic essence. Critics and fans looking for a wealth of behind-the-scenes content might find the release lacking, but this doesn't detract from the inherent value of the film itself or the quality of its physical release.
In conclusion, "Vicky Cristina Barcelona" on Blu-ray presents a solid case for Woody Allen's undying charm and cinematic appeal, despite being in the latter stages of his career. The superior visual quality significantly enhances the movie's picturesque settings and nuanced performances, making it a commendable addition to any collection. While it might not signify a major rejuvenation of Allen's career in the eyes of some viewers and critics, it stands as a testament to his ability to produce compelling and visually appealing works that continue to draw audiences. This Blu-ray edition, despite its simplicity and absence of extras, is recommended for those who appreciate the artistry of Allen's cinema and the beauty of his chosen locales.
Blu-ray.com review by Ben WilliamsRead review here
Video: 90
While some may find that the film's visual style conflicts with their personal tastes, most would be hard pressed to find fault of any kind with Vicky Cristina Barcelona....
Audio: 60
In fact, for all intents and purposes, there's not much more to this track than monaural material that rarely utilizes anything other than the center channel speaker - - for dialogue and music....
Extras: 0
...
Movie: 80
I couldn't even begin to tell you how grounded in reality these two women are, but Mr. Allen's special brand of clever dialogue and efficient storytelling is immensely effective in shrouding the sometimes...
Total: 80
In his third trip across the pond, away from his normal New York City settings, Mr. Allen continues to create quirky material that features a small dose of introspection and a sly wit....
High-Def Digest review by Joshua ZyberRead review here
Video: 90
However, the disc doesn't have the typical side effects of excessive Digital Noise Reduction....
Audio: 60
However, only the front three channels have any activity in them, making this actually a 3.0 configuration....
Extras: 0
...
Movie: 70
Thankfully, the director has taken a step back from acting this time to let Bardem play the object of their desire....
Total: 60
I wouldn't quite call it the career rejuvenation that some fans and critics labeled it, but 'Vicky Cristina Barcelona' is better-than-average for a late-period Woody Allen movie....
Director: Woody Allen
Actors: Rebecca Hall, Scarlett Johansson, Javier Bardem
PlotTwo young American women, Vicky and Cristina, travel to Barcelona for a summer vacation. Vicky, who is practical and engaged to be married, is finishing her master's in Catalan identity, while Cristina, a free-spirited and searching soul, is looking to soak up the artistic and cultural ambiance of the city. Their differing philosophies towards love and life set the stage for the unfolding events.
Their stay becomes complicated when they meet Juan Antonio, a charismatic painter, who boldly invites them to spend the weekend with him in Oviedo. His offer includes sightseeing, fine food, and the potential for a romantic encounter. Despite Vicky's initial reluctance and Cristina's excitement, the two agree to join him. As the weekend unfolds, the trio's interactions begin to reveal the complexities of love, attraction, and self-discovery.
Writers: Woody Allen
Release Date: 15 Aug 2008
Runtime: 96 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: Spain, United States
Language: English, Spanish