Our Idiot Brother Blu-ray Review
Score: 58
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
Our Idiot Brother's Blu-ray features exceptional video, strong audio, and a great mix of humor and heart, bolstered by Paul Rudd's charming performance. Recommended.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 71
"Our Idiot Brother" on Blu-ray offers an exceptional 1080p transfer with vibrant, natural colors and fine details, captured in HD on a Red One MX camera. Though occasional banding and minor softness in some scenes are present, the overall video quality is pristine with stable colors and pitch-perfect blacks.
Audio: 57
Anchor Bay's Blu-ray presentation of *Our Idiot Brother* boasts pristine DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1, providing clean dialogue and clear music with balanced spacing, although surround activity is limited, reflecting the film's subtle and dialogue-centric nature.
Extra: 30
Our Idiot Brother Blu-ray offers a balanced and insightful commentary from Director Jesse Peretz, exploring story, characters, and production intricacies, accompanied by engaging deleted scenes and a standard but charming 'Making Of' featurette. All extras are in standard definition with Dolby Digital 2.0 sound and optional English subtitles.
Movie: 73
Our Idiot Brother balances humor and heart with Paul Rudd's endearing portrayal of Ned, an optimistic organic farmer causing unintentional chaos in his sisters' lives. The Blu-ray's solid presentation features predictable yet charming storylines, enhanced by a strong ensemble cast and well-crafted family dynamics.
Video: 71
Anchor Bay’s Blu-ray release of "Our Idiot Brother" provides an impressive visual presentation, reflecting the film's vibrant and cheery aesthetic. Utilizing a 1080p/AVC MPEG-4 transfer in the 1.78:1 aspect ratio, this digitally-shot feature presents eye-popping colors with fantastic vibrancy and stability. Black levels are consistent and robust, without any crushing or hints of gray. The fine detail is exceptional, revealing intricate textures on clothing, wooden beams, and hardwood floors, contributing to a look that maintains a filmic quality despite being shot on an HD Red One MX camera. The spectrum of colors remains uniformly saturated and vibrant, popping off the screen without appearing unnatural.
The overall image clarity is striking, enhancing the finest details and providing strong depth in several scenes. Although banding appears occasionally and some shots show minor blooming whites and haloing, these instances are infrequent and negligible, likely indeed due to the shooting methods themselves rather than the transfer. Even in darker scenes and moments, the color accuracy remains consistent, and fine details do not falter. Faces can appear slightly pasty and flat on rare occasions, but the sharpness and crispness of the image overall remain unblemished by noise or compression artifacts.
"Our Idiot Brother" achieves a near-reference quality with its visually engaging presentation. The bright, colorful transfer deftly complements the tone of the film and its happy-go-lucky feel. Only a few nighttime scenes fall slightly short of this high benchmark. This Blu-ray showcases the pristine source material excellently, offering viewers a lush and pristine image that enhances the enjoyment of this delightful film.
Audio: 57
The audio presentation of "Our Idiot Brother" on Blu-ray, provided by Anchor Bay, features a DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track that, while not groundbreaking, is perfectly suitable for this type of film. This release handles the movie's requirements with ease. Dialogue is consistently clear and well-balanced, remaining the focal point throughout the film with no instances of distortion or crackle. The soundtrack offers mild ambiance and incorporates subtle audio cues such as birds chirping in outdoor scenes or light background chatter in a restaurant. These ambient sounds typically emerge through the front channels, with limited use of the surrounds.
Front soundstage activity is solid, with impressive directional separation for both effects and music. The score enjoys superb clarity, delivering balanced and robust sound without being overpowering. The rear channels contribute minimally, primarily supporting minor echoes of music and ambiance, but these elements seldom steal the spotlight. The overall soundstage is airy, light, and effective for the film's subdued tone. Dynamic range is adequate for the content, although there's negligible bass activity save for a brief party scene.
In conclusion, while the mix might not be overly immersive or dynamic—befitting "Our Idiot Brother"—it provides a clean and clear audio experience. This professional presentation fulfills its purpose, complementing the video presentation and adding to the viewing pleasure with crisp dialogue delivery and a well-balanced score. This DTS-HD MA 5.1 track proves to be a focused and seamless audio companion to the film.
Extras: 30
The Blu-ray of "Our Idiot Brother" offers a well-rounded selection of extras that complement the main feature. The included audio commentary by Director Jesse Peretz is engaging and thorough, covering aspects such as character development, casting insights, and thematic elements, with notable mentions of Paul Rudd's dedication to his role. The deleted and extended scenes provide additional context with intriguing subplots and an alternate ending. The "Making Of" featurette is a standard addition, interspersing behind-the-scenes footage with insightful interviews from the cast and crew about the film's production. While the quality is standard definition, these extras are informative and enjoyable, adding value to the viewing experience.
Extras included in this disc:
- Feature Commentary With Director Jesse Peretz: Detailed insights on the film's creation, story, and characters.
- Deleted and Extended Scenes: Additional scenes providing more context and an alternate ending.
- Making Of Our Idiot Brother: Interviews and behind-the-scenes footage exploring the film's production.
Movie: 73
"Our Idiot Brother" presents an endearing exploration of family dynamics, propelled by Paul Rudd's charming portrayal of Ned, a well-meaning, hapless organic farmer. The story kicks off with Ned's comedic misjudgment—offering marijuana to a uniformed police officer—which lands him briefly in jail. Upon his release, Ned's naiveté and unrelenting optimism lead to a series of mishaps as he navigates living with his three sisters, Miranda (Elizabeth Banks), Natalie (Zooey Deschanel), and Liz (Emily Mortimer). The film deftly balances humor and heartfelt moments, capturing the essence of familial bonds that bend but never break.
Rudd's performance is the film's heart and soul, depicting Ned as a beacon of innocence in a cynical world. His interactions with his sisters and their partners, portrayed by a talented ensemble including Steve Coogan, Rashida Jones, and Adam Scott, provide rich, comedic interplay and genuine emotional beats. The narrative unfolds with Ned's well-meaning actions inadvertently creating chaos, yet also offering moments of reflection for his family to re-evaluate their high-strung lives. Director Jesse Peretz skillfully combines light-hearted comedy with deeper emotional undercurrents, creating a narrative that, despite its simplicity, resonates on a universal level.
The underlying charm of "Our Idiot Brother" lies in its message about kindness and unconditional love. Ned's optimistic outlook and genuine care for his dog, Willie Nelson, along with his honest if clumsy actions, contrast sharply with the fast-paced lives of those around him. The film gently nudges audiences to slow down and view life through Ned’s eyes, fostering appreciation for life’s simpler joys. Though it may follow predictable plot lines and feature some uneven tonal transitions, the movie’s overall warm-heartedness and Rudd’s standout performance make it a delightful watch that underscores the strength of family ties and the power of goodwill.
Total: 58
"Our Idiot Brother" is a heartwarming comedy that artfully blends humor and real-world drama, emphasizing the complexities of family dynamics. The film centers on a well-meaning but socially inept protagonist, encapsulated by Paul Rudd’s endearing performance, who inadvertently disrupts the lives of his family members. Despite its predictability, the movie shines through its genuine portrayal of heartfelt interactions and the importance of understanding and forgiveness within familial relationships. Explored through its charming yet flawed characters, the narrative underscores the power of empathy and the significance of finding a common ground amidst differences.
Anchor Bay’s Blu-ray presentation enhances the viewing experience through exceptional video quality that accurately captures the film's bright and vibrant visual style. The HD image is crisp with rich color representation, making the most of the movie’s warm palette. Complementing the visual clarity, the audio quality is steadfast, providing clear dialogues and an immersive soundtrack that fits the film's light-hearted yet poignant tone. The Blu-ray also includes some supplementary content, although limited, it offers insightful behind-the-scenes glimpses that add to the viewing experience.
Overall, "Our Idiot Brother" is a delightful film that succeeds in delivering both laughs and touching moments. The combination of a solid technical presentation, an amiable lead performance, and a compelling narrative makes this Blu-ray a worthwhile addition to any collection. Highly recommended for those seeking a feel-good movie with substance and sincerity.
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 90
This digitally-shot movie just flat-out sparkles, featuring eye-popping colors, wonderful details, and a general consistency that puts it near the top of the Blu-ray heap....
Audio: 80
Minor ambience -- chirping birds in outside scenes, the light din of a restaurant, or other assorted small elements -- nicely works its way into the proceedings, though often through the front channels....
Extras: 40
The picture's themes, the benefits of making a lower budget movie, the assemblage of the script and ideas, and more, are all discussed....
Movie: 80
The cast gels effortlessly together, and the movie is a pleasure from the top down, all the way down to pooch Willie Nelson who immediately feels like a member of the fictional family, and when it's all...
Total: 80
It's also a movie that preaches the importance of heart and not just the power of words and deeds, whether deliberately mean-spirited or goodhearted yet misunderstood....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
Shot in high definition, this is a very nice transfer that shows off the film's colorful, cheery design work and cinematography well....
Audio: 60
Given the modest content, dynamic range is more than adequate and the sweet, catchy score comes through with nice fidelity....
Extras: 20
While the ending included in the film features my favorite line of the entire movie, this alternate conclusion is home to some fun material as well....
Movie: 80
The character is almost completely devoid of judgment and cynicism, and while his almost impossibly good-natured behavior can sometimes be comically dumb, Rudd always manages to give Ned a certain level...
Total: 60
With a very likeable protagonist, a nice blend of humor and drama, and a solid technical presentation, this disc is definitely recommended....
AVSForumRead review here
Video: 94
There was mild ambiance in the effect channels, and the sound-stage seemed right on for what was happening on screen....
Audio: 82
There was mild ambiance in the effect channels, and the sound-stage seemed right on for what was happening on screen....
Extras: 40
Feature Commentary With Director Jesse Peretz Deleted and Extended Scenes Making Of Our Idiot Brother...
Movie: 70
Thankfully this "idiot" lightens his load when selling a bag to a police officer, and when I say police officer I mean in uniform plain as day....
Total: 72
CinemaScope Screen Denon AVR 4311 Pre/Pro Sunfire Theater Grand 7201 Amplifier Sony PS3 Slim Blu-ray Player (HDMI Audio/Video)...
Director: Jesse Peretz
Actors: Paul Rudd, Elizabeth Banks, Zooey Deschanel
PlotNed Rochlin is an overly trusting, kind-hearted organic farmer who ends up in jail after naively selling marijuana to a uniformed police officer. Upon his release, he finds himself homeless and decides to rely on his three sisters: Miranda, an ambitious journalist; Natalie, a bisexual, free-spirited stand-up comic; and Liz, a stressed-out mother of two. Each sister reluctantly takes him in, only to find that his unfailing honesty and childlike optimism turn their lives upside down. They struggle to deal with the chaos he brings into their meticulously planned existences.
Ned's innocence inadvertently reveals secrets and truths within his sisters' lives, leading to conflict and miscommunications. Despite their frustrations, they each come to realize that Ned's simple, sincere approach to life has impacted them in profound, positive ways. His unwavering belief in the goodness of people ultimately encourages them to reevaluate their own values and relationships. Through the arresting combination of humor and heart, the story explores the themes of trust, honesty, and family, concluding with the idea that sometimes the most seemingly foolish person can offer the greatest wisdom.
Writers: Jesse Peretz, Evgenia Peretz, David Schisgall
Release Date: 26 Aug 2011
Runtime: 90 min
Rating: R
Country: United States
Language: English