The Bat Blu-ray Review

The Blu-ray presentation of "The Bat" by The Film Detective provides a remarkable viewing experience, though not without its caveats. The 1080p AVC encoded transfer, framed at 1.85:1, offers an impressive detail resolution that highlights the intricate costume designs and facial features such as freckles on Moorehead's forehead. The film’s elements appear well-cared for or restored to a good standard, maintaining consistency in contrast and black levels. Unfortunately, the application of Digital Noise Reduction (DNR) techniques has led to a perceptible loss of grain and a somewhat smoothed, digital look that may not appeal to purists seeking an authentic cinematic texture. Despite this, the resulting clarity and detail are commendably consistent across scenes.

The transfer, sourced from original 35mm archive elements, showcases a pristine print free from visible damage, yet technical constraints are apparent. The excessive DNR has resulted in a subtle waxy appearance and some digital residue on the imagery, impacting the depth and richness traditionally associated with film grain. Although this sacrifices some authenticity, the bright and well-balanced grayscale compensates, offering a comprehensive range from deep blacks to bright whites, albeit with clipped highlights. While mid-gray tones lack some definition, the overall contrast maintains a youthful vigor.

In conclusion, even though smoothing techniques have led to an artificial feel at times, the transfer remains satisfactory for a film of this era. The preservation of fine details and the careful handling of DNR ensure a polished aesthetic that enhances facial textures and production design elements. Overall, despite not reaching archival perfection, this Blu-ray presentation is commendable for its modernized aesthetic while respecting the cinematic heritage of "The Bat."

The audio presentation of "The Bat" on Blu-ray features a DTS 2.0 Mono track that effectively supports the film's simplistic sound design. The audio mix, while not groundbreaking, delivers dialogue, voiceovers, and sound effects like hysterical screams efficiently, ensuring an unimpeded listening experience. Unique to this track is its score—a quirky blend of big band, nascent rock 'n' roll, and a subtle Hawaiian influence—although occasionally whimsical, it complements the film's tone. Additionally, optional English subtitles are provided for accessibility.

Interestingly, the audio track is not presented in DTS-HD, rather just DTS, yet this decision has minimal impact on the overall experience. While dialogue remains largely clear and intelligible, there is a noted struggle with musical elements in the higher registers and an absence of deep lows. Although vintage in its delivery, the track remains adequate for conveying the narrative and atmospheric elements.

In contrast, another review appreciates "The Bat" for its DTS-HD MA 2.0 audio track, highlighting its capability to render dialogue in a crystal clear manner. The sound effects, encompassing ambient noises like lightning crashes and creaking window shutters, effectively intensify the film's thriller essence. Longevity issues such as hiss or pops are remarkably absent, suggesting a well-preserved mix that maintains its integrity without age-related distortions. Overall, this amalgamation of tracks ensures an immersive listening experience that remains faithful to the film’s period appeal while supporting its narrative elements.

The Blu-ray extras for "The Bat" present a thoughtful curation of supplementary materials that enrich the viewing experience. A standout feature is the detailed 22-minute documentary "The Case for Crane Wilbur," which offers insightful exploration into the career and impact of the multifaceted actor, playwright, and director, narrated by filmmaker Larry Blamire. Film scholar Jason A. Ney provides a compelling audio commentary and contributes a well-composed essay in the included booklet, enhancing the contextual understanding of the film. The disc is further bolstered by an appealing compilation of classic radio episodes featuring Vincent Price, complete with engaging audio renditions matched with imaginative visuals. These historical broadcasts deliver charming performances and nostalgic thrills, and they are seamlessly integrated into the extras content, providing a comprehensive auditory journey. Collectively, these features elevate the cultural and historical appreciation of "The Bat" beyond its original narrative.

Extras included in this disc:

• Audio Commentary: Featuring Jason A. Ney, offering deep analysis.
• The Case for Crane Wilbur: Documentary narrated by Larry Blamire about Crane Wilbur's career.
• Classic Radio Episodes Featuring Vincent Price: Nostalgic audio classics set to an animated visual of a bat.
  • The Strange Case of Charles Umberstein
  • Fugue in C Minor
  • Hunting Trip
  • Present Tense
  • Three Skeleton Key
  • Blood Bath
  • Angel Street
  • The Lodger
  • Speaking of Cinderella

"The Bat" (1959) is an intriguing yet flawed adaptation of Mary Roberts Rinehart's classic mystery. Featuring a notable literary lineage, the film stands as the fourth cinematic iteration of the narrative, previously presented in various adaptions since 1915. The film portrays the exploits of mystery writer Cornelia Van Gorder (Agnes Moorehead) as she confronts the eerie villainy of a masked killer, "The Bat". Accompanied by her quirky assistant Lizzie Allen (Lenita Lane), Cornelia navigates a mansion rife with suspense and theatrical horror. Vincent Price, while marketed as a significant draw, is underutilized in a minimal role as Dr. Malcolm Wells, contributing to the film's uneven pacing and limited character depth.

Structurally, the film leans heavily on its stage play origins, presenting scenes with a certain stodgy theatricality that detracts from potential tension and scare factors. Although there are clever visual nods to classic horror cinema, such as strategic use of shadows and silhouettes, much of the storytelling feels flat. Predictable plot devices hinder any real mystery, and despite plenary of misdirection attempts, some symbols such as Price's unexpected early murder don't engage as intended.

Despite flaws, Moorehead delivers an engaging performance, enhancing scenes with Lane via comedic timing that stops short of overpowering the thriller elements. While Price remains a charismatic figure when on screen, the narrative fails to capitalize fully on his presence. "The Bat" ultimately struggles to balance its horror and comedic elements, settled into a niche within its era's genre conventions. While it may not completely satisfy as a gripping mystery or chilling thriller, the film offers nostalgia-drenched entertainment—an apt choice for cozy viewings on brisk fall evenings.

The Blu-ray release of "The Bat" offers an intriguing blend of vintage charm and classic performances by icons like Vincent Price and Agnes Moorehead. While the film's pacing and suspense fluctuate, and the central mystery might seem overly simplified for some, its moments of whimsy and nostalgia make it an enjoyable viewing experience. The murders, though mildly intriguing, fail to deliver genuine chills or mystery. Despite these shortcomings, "The Bat" emerges as a pleasant, if not fully engaging, addition to Price’s catalog, serving as an ideal easy-on-the-eyes entertainment for leisurely viewing.

The special edition Blu-ray by The Film Detective presents a commendable effort in restoring the film's visual and audio quality. The video presentation retains adequate detail, resembling vintage prints with an acceptable level of clarity. Audio, although lossy, remains functional, serving the film adequately without any significant disruptions. The package is enriched by a collection of well-curated bonus features, notably featuring Vincent Price's radio show appearances which provide fascinating insights into his enduring appeal.

In conclusion, while "The Bat" might not stand as a definitive classic within Vincent Price's oeuvre due to its inconsistent tone and lackluster thrills, it is still worth a watch for its nostalgic appeal and occasional engaging moments. The effective restoration and comprehensive bonus content enhance its value, making this Blu-ray edition a recommended purchase for fans of Price and vintage thrillers alike.