Passion Blu-ray Review
Score: 53
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
Passion revisits De Palma's themes with compelling performances despite its soap-opera pitfalls; Blu-ray boasts solid video and audio but lacks substantial extras.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 62
Passion's Blu-ray features an AVC encoded 1080p transfer that excels in detail and vibrant colors, particularly reds, though some scenes suffer from banding, flickering noise, and overly bright elements that impact the black levels and color consistency. Despite minor noise, the film retains a sleek, grainy aesthetic reminiscent of 35mm.
Audio: 69
Passion’s lossless DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 offers superb spatial placement, especially in Pino Donaggio's score and key scenes, although low frequency effects are underutilized. Despite minor issues with dialogue during specific scenes and an overall front-skewed mix, it delivers clear, immersive sound suitable for the film's needs.
Extra: 11
The Blu-ray of 'Passion' offers minimal extras, primarily a 7-minute interview featurette in 1080i with Brian De Palma, Rachel McAdams, and Noomi Rapace that feels more like a promotional video, paired with a high-definition theatrical trailer. The lack of substantial special features is notably disappointing.
Movie: 47
Brian De Palma's 'Passion' attempts to recapture his stylistic flair with voyeuristic themes and split-screen sequences, fueled by strong performances from Noomi Rapace and Rachel McAdams, but ultimately suffers from a convoluted plot and moments of melodrama that undermine its potential as a compelling thriller.
Video: 62
The Blu-ray presentation of "Passion" by Entertainment One boasts an AVC encoded 1080p transfer, set in a 1.78:1 aspect ratio. This high-definition transfer showcases remarkable clarity and fine detail, with vivid, saturated colors that stand out conspicuously. Notably, the reds are striking, from Christine's vibrant lipstick and platform heels to her bright boardroom attire. However, while fine details, such as the threads of luxe outfits and facial pores, are spectacularly rendered, there is some compromise in shadow detail due to heavy blue color grading during scenes involving drug use.
On the technical front, while the encode is MPEG-4 AVC with 1080p resolution, the presentation is somewhat flawed due to noticeable band-filled shots, flickering noise, and aliasing issues. While close-ups reveal substantial detail like bangs and stubble, overly bright scenes undermine this detail, with inconsistent contrast affecting wider shots. This excessive brightness sometimes leads to inaccuracies in color representation, like McAdams' dress appearing different shades between exterior and interior scenes. Additionally, black levels in darker scenes can appear as gray rather than deep black, which detracts from the overall depth.
Despite these issues, "Passion" maintains a sleek and immersive visual style. The grain structure hints at a potential 35mm film origin, contributing to its depth and creative perspectives. Contrast and sharpness levels are generally satisfactory, although slight softness is present. The film's color usage is deliberate yet limited, effectively contrasting the cold-toned ambiance with elements like golden hair and red lipstick. Although there are occasional instances of noise and minor artifacts, these do not severely impact the overall viewing experience.
Audio: 69
The Blu-ray audio presentation of "Passion" is anchored by a lossless DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track, with an additional, yet comparably lesser, 5.1 Dolby Digital option. The DTS-HD MA track delivers a pleasantly immersive experience, especially during Pino Donaggio’s evocative score which permeates the surround channels excellently. While not action-heavy, the dynamics are aptly suited to the film's sleek and tense aesthetic. Dialogue remains crisply presented throughout, though there is a notable instance during a fashion show rehearsal where background music obscures conversation between Isabelle and Christine.
Sound effects, while sporadic, are finely crafted to enhance their respective scenes. The sound design during a gala scene vividly captures the atmosphere with the resonance of high heels on marble and scattered conversations echoing through the channels. Despite occasional imbalances where audio skews towards the front and a prominent lack of LFE presence, the audio fulfills its role adequately, emphasizing the film’s atmospheric tension rather than explosive dynamism.
The surround sound presentation chiefly utilizes ambience and music to encompass the viewer, supporting the film's dialogue-driven nature rather than relying on intense action sequences. The track does exhibit excellent spatial placement in key scenes, such as a large party or a crucial moment involving a persistently ringing phone. Overall, the sound design caters effectively to "Passion's" narrative needs, achieving a solid if not groundbreaking audio experience.
Extras: 11
The Blu-ray release of "Passion" includes minimal extra features, which is a notable disappointment for fans expecting more in-depth content. The primary feature is an EPK-style promotional video comprising interviews with Brian De Palma, Rachel McAdams, and Noomi Rapace. However, the interviews are brief and largely uninformative, mostly offering generic insights into character motivations and plot breakdowns. De Palma appears somewhat terse, adding little value to the experience. This limited offering could have greatly benefited from additional features such as audio commentaries or deleted scenes, but unfortunately, these are absent.
Extras included in this disc:
- Interviews with Brian De Palma, Rachel McAdams, and Noomi Rapace: Brief promotional video discussing characters and plot.
- Theatrical Trailer: The official trailer presented in high definition.
Movie: 47
Brian De Palma's Passion reignites his signature blend of voyeuristic intrigue and stylistic bravado, packed with the elements of rivalry, lust, manipulation, drugs, and violence. The film sees Noomi Rapace as Isabelle, a subordinate in a posh Berlin advertising firm, and Rachel McAdams as her manipulative boss Christine. Their complex relationship starts with strange, intimate meetings that rapidly devolve into a vicious power struggle characterized by betrayal and psychological warfare. Though their characters exhibit strikingly different presentations—Isabelle being seemingly reserved compared to Christine’s overt glamour—the narrative blurs these distinctions as both characters reveal cunning depths.
From the film’s onset, the inceptive voyeurism characteristic of De Palma remains palpable, with camera angles that intrude like an unseen spy. Notably, a split-screen sequence juxtaposes a ballet performance with a gruesome murder, blending the elegance of Debussy’s Afternoon of a Faun with visceral violence. This visual duality underscores the film’s thematic dichotomies. De Palma doesn’t shy away from referencing his cinematic influences directly, making specific nods to Hitchcock’s Vertigo, which may delight long-time fans but could seem derivative to others.
Passion flirtatiously dances on the line between high art and trashy paperback material. The filmmaker embraces his known penchant for stylized storytelling, yet here it may teeter more into style overshadowing substance. Performances by Rapace and McAdams veer dramatically between compelling and overly melodramatic, reminiscent of 1960s thrillers, adding to the film's lurid charm. Despite its potential absurdities and implausible plot twists—particularly after a pivotal murder scene involving kinky subtexts—the narrative remains hypnotically engaging due to De Palma's cinematic flair and Rapace's enigmatic presence.
Ultimately, while Passion might strain credulity with its convoluted storyline and exaggerated interpersonal drama, it offers a visually arresting experience that blends sensual undercurrents with a sense of impending doom—an unmissable concoction for De Palma aficionados.
Total: 53
Brian De Palma's "Passion" on Blu-ray provides a mixed bag of experiences for viewers. Visually, the Blu-ray is competent with above average video quality, though some technical shortcomings, such as blown-out brightness, cannot be ignored. The film's audio quality remains consistently decent, offering a reliable listening experience throughout. However, the disc is substantially limited in supplemental content, providing only a brief seven-minute promotional reel which fails to add significant value to the release.
From a cinematographic standpoint, "Passion" revisits many of De Palma's beloved themes with a directorial confidence that longtime fans will find familiar and engaging. Rachel McAdams and Noomi Rapace deliver captivating performances that capture attention despite the film's occasionally teetering narrative quality. For enthusiasts of film-noir and neo-noir genres, the aesthetic and thematic elements of "Passion" present an alluring if not fully satisfying experience.
Conclusion
There seems to be a newfound interest in De Palma (yet again), due perhaps in part to the remake of his legendary Carrie. The director's fortunes have waxed and waned through the years, and Passion was met with at best mixed reviews when it played theatrically. I'd wholeheartedly recommend this film to longtime De Palma aficionados, for it revisits some of his favorite themes in an often excitingly visceral way. Those who aren't quite so well acquainted with some of De Palma's eccentricities may find the film occasionally laughable, though even those folks will more than likely be transfixed by the performances of McAdams and (especially) Rapace. This Blu-ray offers great video and audio, and even without much in the supplements department, comes Recommended.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 90
Fine detail is also exceptional, revealing seemingly every thread of the often luxe outfits Christine wears (or, for a non-costume example, take a look at Rapace's face in the second screenshot accompanying...
Audio: 90
Passion's lossless DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 is rather low key at times, but Pino Donaggio's score wafts through the surround channels magnificently, and a couple of fantastic set pieces, including a large...
Extras: 20
Interviews with Brian De Palma, Rachel McAdams and Noomi Rapace (1080i; 7:02) may be the same supplement my colleague Dr. Svet Atanasov mentioned in his review of the French Blu-ray release, as despite...
Movie: 70
Ultimately, Passion may not even make much sense, but it careens along almost hypnotically on the combined force of the riveting performances by McAdams and Rapace, and to a lesser extent Herfurth and...
Total: 70
Those who aren't quite so well acquainted with some of De Palma's eccentricities may find the film occasionally laughable, though even those folks will more than likely be transfixed by the performances...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 60
Quite a bit of flickering noise is riddled throughout the picture that not only covers dark sections of the screen, but it dusts the entire frame....
Audio: 80
Sure, the track occasionally skews to the front and there's a lack of bass which not only removes some of the audio's depth, but caused my sub-woofer to shut off due to inactivity, but this isn't the type...
Extras: 0
Considering this is the only "real" special feature of the disc, it's quite a disappointment....
Movie: 20
Isabelle's arrogance seems like a put-on the next morning as we see that she truly has the talent to succeed in her industry....
Total: 40
And as if that's not bad enough, the mediocre video quality and blown out brightness make the film a giant eye sore....
Why So Blu? review by Gerard IribeRead review here
Video: 80
Passion has a few scenes that take place at night in addition to some dark interior shots – crush and compression artifacts were never a problem during any of those scenes....
Audio: 80
Low Frequency Extension: The LFE channel is given little to do here and is only utilized during the scenes of brutal violence to give the proceedings an extra push....
Extras: 10
I would have loved an audio commentary by Brian De Palma, with the cast, deleted scenes, and all of those supplemental special features that we’re accustomed to but the Blu-ray Gods have denied us....
Movie: 60
Betrayal and compliance seem to walk hand in hand at this advertising firm, which is weird, because even though Isabelle is an executive and Christine is her boss, you never really get that impression,...
Total: 60
A very attractive cast and assured direction make Passion a lovely romp that film-noir and neo-noir fans should take....
Director: Brian De Palma
Actors: Rachel McAdams, Noomi Rapace, Karoline Herfurth
PlotChristine, a powerful and manipulative executive at an advertising agency, takes a young and talented employee, Isabelle, under her wing. Christine's influential presence in the company and outward charm mask a sinister nature as she exploits Isabelle's ideas and presents them as her own. Isabelle initially admires Christine and seeks her approval but gradually becomes aware of Christine's deceptive practices. Their professional relationship becomes increasingly strained as Christine's ambition blinds her to the ethical boundaries she frequently crosses.
Tensions mount when Isabelle starts to assert herself, leading to a complex game of psychological warfare between the two women. Christine, feeling threatened by Isabelle's growing confidence and abilities, resorts to extreme measures to maintain her dominance. As the power struggle intensifies, trust erodes, and betrayal becomes more palpable. The narrative builds up to a series of mind games that blur the lines between reality and imagination, setting the stage for a climactic confrontation that pivots on the intricate dynamics of manipulation, jealousy, and revenge within the high-stakes world of corporate power plays.
Writers: Brian De Palma, Natalie Carter, Alain Corneau
Release Date: 30 Aug 2013
Runtime: 102 min
Rating: R
Country: France, Germany
Language: English, German