Mountains May Depart Blu-ray Review
山河故人
Score: 59
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
'Mountains May Depart' explores cultural loss and isolation with ambition, but ultimately lacks the dramatic focus needed to achieve greatness.
Disc Release Date
Video: 57
The Blu-ray of 'Mountains May Depart' offers an AVC-encoded 1080p presentation with varying aspect ratios and strong colors, despite minor issues like artifacting in older footage and occasional contouring and pixelation. The modern scenes shine with excellent detail, natural skintones, and bold primaries.
Audio: 72
The 5.1 DTS-HD MA sound mix delivers an intimate yet engaging audio experience, featuring booming explosions, thumping pop music, and effective atmospheric elements. Dialogue is clear but sometimes challenging due to broken English and Australian accents, and English subtitles are inconsistently available.
Extra: 46
The Blu-ray extras for 'Mountains May Depart' include a comprehensive but somewhat prolonged 73-minute discussion with director Jia Zhangke, translated from Mandarin, offering insight into his career, an engaging but slightly misleading trailer, and a 10-page essay by Aliza Ma, adding appreciable contextual depth.
Movie: 51
Jia Zhangke's 'Mountains May Depart' ambitiously spans 25 years, tactfully exploring the intersection of Chinese cultural evolution and personal growth through shifting aspect ratios and poignant performances; however, the film's thematic depth and narrative structure may feel disjointed and contrived to some viewers, especially in its latter acts.
Video: 57
The Blu-ray presentation of "Mountains May Depart" offers an intriguing visual experience that aligns with its unique narrative structure. The AVC encoded 1080p resolution captures the essence of three distinct time periods, each defined by its own aspect ratio. While scenes shot in 2014 showcase excellent clarity and detail—with vibrant colors, natural skintones, and crisp facial particulars—the sequences from 1999, captured during that era, present a deliberately rough video state, replete with noticeable artifacting. This intentional contrast underscores the film’s thematic evolution over time.
Modern cinematography in the film is highlighted by a bright, clean image quality that excels in portraying textures and environmental details. Colors are bold and primary hues are handled deftly, contributing to a visually rich experience. However, brightness levels fluctuate throughout the film in accordance with the director’s vision. Delineation remains acceptable, though some minor issues such as banding and false contouring do arise. Notably, during a scene where Tao visits her sick friend, there is noticeable false contouring in her black hair, and some of the disco scenes with strobe lights reveal brief instances of pixelation and blurring.
Despite these minor flaws, the high-definition transfer successfully conveys the cinematographic artistry of "Mountains May Depart," particularly in its scenic depictions of China and Australia. Overall, while some technical imperfections are present, they are unlikely to detract significantly from the viewing experience for most audiences.
Audio: 72
The "Mountains May Depart" Blu-ray boasts a 5.1 DTS-HD Master Audio track that adeptly maintains the film's intimate tone while delivering moments of immersive auditory engagement. The mix effectively utilizes the surround channels during pivotal scenes, such as a helicopter's takeoff at a Melbourne airport and beach waves enveloping the listener. These instances reveal the dynamic range and depth of the sound mix. Dialogue throughout is clear and intelligible, though the final act's broken English can render some exchanges challenging to follow. Notably, English subtitles are available only for the 1999 and 2014 segments, which might be insufficient, especially when Australian accents are prominently featured.
Despite being predominantly a subdued drama, the stereo separation is executed with precision, particularly enhancing the pop music sequences that seep into the surround channels and atmospherics convincingly. Explosions and thumping music are delivered with palpable impact, adding layers of dynamism to the otherwise restrained soundscape. While this presentation may not achieve reference-quality status, it nonetheless impresses by elevating an otherwise monophonic film into an engaging auditory experience, featuring a center channel that ensures dialogue remains front and center. Overall, the audio mix strikes a commendable balance between subtlety and sophistication, suitable for the film’s dramatic narrative context.
Extras: 46
The Blu-ray edition of "Mountains May Depart" offers a concise selection of extras that deliver valuable insight into the film and its creation. A notable highlight is the extensive discussion in New York Film Festival: A Conversation with Jia Zhangke, a 73-minute featurette showcasing a Q&A session with the director. While informative, the dual translation process and static camera work may challenge viewer engagement. Additionally, the Theatrical Trailer is a well-produced preview that, despite its focus on secondary characters, effectively captures the film's essence. Lastly, an insightful essay by Aliza Ma can be found in the Booklet, providing a deeper understanding of the film’s themes.
Extras included in this disc:
- New York Film Festival: A Conversation with Jia Zhangke: Extended Q&A session with the director.
- Theatrical Trailer: Brief preview encapsulating key elements of the film.
- Booklet: An essay by Aliza Ma offering thoughtful analysis of the movie's narrative.
Movie: 51
In "Mountains May Depart," director Jia Zhangke intricately weaves a tapestry that spans 25 years of Chinese cultural and economic transformation. The narrative follows Tao (Tao Zhao), Jinsheng (Yi Zhang), and Liangzi (Jing Dong Liang) across three distinct periods: 1999, 2014, and 2025. The film captures the ambitions and disillusionments of its characters through a nuanced portrayal of evolving relationships, particularly emphasizing Tao’s journey from youthful exuberance to isolated maturity. The shift in aspect ratios—4:3 for 1999, 16:9 for 2014, and 2.35:1 for 2025—effectively mirrors the characters' changing lives, although some may find the transitions confusing. The production excels in its visual storytelling, with poignant performances enhancing the portrayal of grief and the inevitable passage of time.
Central to the film is a love triangle, illustrating the diverging paths of Tao, Jinsheng, and Liangzi. Using beautifully composed shots, Zhangke delves into themes of personal growth juxtaposed with societal change. Supporting characters and subplots, such as Dollar’s relationship with his father in Australia and his search for maternal connection, add depth to the overarching narrative. Despite occasional lapses into melodrama and moments where pacing may falter, the film’s emotional core remains compelling. The actors deliver powerful performances, although some critics argue that character development, particularly with male leads, occasionally suffers from stereotypical portrayals, diminishing empathy for their plights.
Overall, "Mountains May Depart" successfully explores generational shifts in China amidst a backdrop of economic progress and cultural erosion. While the film's format and storytelling style may not resonate with all audiences, Zhangke’s artistic intent is clear and resonant, underscoring the profound impact of time on human relationships and societal norms. The Blu-ray presentation by Kino Lorber complements this intricate film with thoughtful packaging and insightful extras, enriching the viewing experience.
Total: 59
The Blu-ray release of "Mountains May Depart" offers a visually and thematically intriguing narrative, bearing promise through its ambition and cultural exploration. Known for Jia Zhangke's distinctive directorial style, the film aims to traverse personal and socio-political landscapes from 1999 onwards, encapsulating China's rapid transformations along the way. The Blu-ray transfer reproduces the film's nuanced cinematography with impressive clarity, faithfully rendering the shifts in aspect ratios that parallel the story's temporal movements. However, some viewers may find this technical execution a distraction, feeling it could disrupt the immersion in the film's emotional resonance.
Key thematic strokes—loss of tradition, familial estrangement, and the quest for identity—come through with a contemplative finesse, reflecting Zhangke's signature depth. Yet, as the story advances to its 2025 segment, set in Australia, the film appears to waver in its otherwise sharp focus. The narrative expansion into a broader scope tends to dilute the poignancy of individual character arcs, making portions of the storyline feel somewhat disjointed and overly ambitious. The absence of a more intimate calibration in these moments is noted, hampering the connection to both character and plot that had been initially established.
The 2025 segment takes the story to Australia to explore the loss of Chinese culture and the pain of isolation, but "Mountains May Depart" loses concentration on the details of drama, going broad as a way to conclude a story that feels like it began as a small idea to help understand national growth and blossomed quickly, just beyond the helmer's control. A disorienting shift toward the obvious doesn't destroy "Mountains May Depart," but it does leave it lacking where it counts the most. The Blu-ray itself is admirably executed, but overall, this release may not satisfy those seeking a tightly woven narrative journey.
Blu-ray.com review by Brian OrndorfRead review here
Video: 80
Modern cinematography fares much better, delivering a bright, clean image that's excellent with detail, seizing facial particulars and location textures....
Audio: 90
The 5.1 DTS-HD MA sound mix retains the feature's intimacy quite well, but some active elements manage to attract attention, including booming explosions and thumping pop music, which also seeps into the...
Extras: 60
"New York Film Festival: A Conversation with Jia Zhangke" (73:06, HD) is an extended discussion with the filmmaker about his career and creative choices, filtered through two rounds of translation for...
Movie: 70
The production samples teary heartache, but it's most profound during depictions of grief, with literal and symbolic death touching these lives as the characters grow to understand their place in the world....
Total: 80
The 2025 segment takes the story to Australia to explore the loss of Chinese culture and the pain of isolation, but "Mountains May Depart" loses concentration on the details of drama, going broad as a...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 60
Colors are strong throughout, but brightness varies as the movie progresses in accordance with the director’s intent....
Audio: 80
While the Blu-ray offers English subtitles when Chinese is spoken, I could not access English subtitles for the entire movie, especially during scenes where Australian accents are nearly as impenetrable....
Extras: 40
While nicely produced with portentous dialogue and alluring images, the preview is slightly misleading as it focuses greatly on the younger and English-speaking Dollar, whose character as an adult does...
Movie: 40
However, the fate of the Jinsheng and Liangzi is pretty much left without any final resolution, even though one contracts a life-threatening illness and the other finds himself with suicidal and homicidal...
Total: 60
I was hoping that as a Chinese production, 'Mountains May Depart' would result in something truly inspiring in both character and story, and further confirm that when it comes to art, foreign and independent...
Director: Zhangke Jia
Actors: Tao Zhao, Yi Zhang, Liang Jingdong
PlotIn early 1999, in a small town in China, a young woman named Shen Tao is courted by her two childhood friends, Zhang and Liang. Zhang, an ambitious entrepreneur, and Liang, a humble coal miner, both vie for her love. Faced with a difficult choice, Tao's decision sets off a chain of events that impact their lives for decades. She chooses to marry Zhang, propelling herself into a life of wealth and prosperity, while Liang remains heartbroken and continues his modest lifestyle. These choices reverberate through to the lives of their children, dictating their future paths.
Years later, as the new millennium unfolds and China's economy evolves, the past decisions dramatically shape the destinies of all involved. Tao grapples with the consequences of her choices and reflects on lost opportunities and the impact on her present life. Meanwhile, Zhang's success brings unforeseen challenges, and Liang attempts to move forward despite lingering heartache. Personal aspirations collide with familial expectations as generational shifts bring about new complexities. Through these intertwined lives, the narrative explores themes of love, fortune, and the passage of time amid China's rapid transformation.
Writers: Zhangke Jia
Release Date: 30 Oct 2015
Runtime: 126 min
Rating: Not Rated
Country: China, France, Japan
Language: Chinese, Mandarin, Cantonese, English