Lebanon Blu-ray Review
Score: 62
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
Lebanon's superb A/V presentation, psychological depth, and immersive tension make it a highly recommended Blu-ray release, despite minimal extras.
Disc Release Date
Video: 64
The 1080p Blu-ray of 'Lebanon' impresses with its gritty and detailed transfer, capturing the tank's grimy environment and superb shadow detail. Despite minor issues like occasional black crush and ghosting, the DTS-HD MA 5.1 Surround Sound excels, enhancing the film’s tension with precise panning and dynamic audio.
Audio: 73
The DTS-HD MA 5.1 Surround Sound track of 'Lebanon' offers an immersive, explosive, and dynamic audio experience with precise panning, deep LFE, and crisp dialogues, effectively capturing the intense and claustrophobic atmosphere of a modern warzone.
Extra: 27
Lebanon's Blu-ray extras are sparse but notably include 'Notes on a War Film,' a 24-minute behind-the-scenes Hebrew-language featurette that explores the challenging and creative filming techniques inside a tank, plus theatrical and promotional trailers for other Sony releases, all in HD. BD Live is enabled.
Movie: 83
In 'Lebanon,' director Samuel Maoz immerses viewers into a claustrophobic tank setting, capturing the psychological and emotional turmoil of modern warfare with gripping realism and an impactful narrative, crafted through intense performances and vividly detailed scenes.
Video: 64
The 1080p Blu-ray presentation of "Lebanon" from Sony is a commendable showcase of the film’s inherent visual intensity and grimy aesthetic. The transfer effectively captures the details within the confined, dark spaces of the tank, from instrument gauges to the various grime, dents, and scratches on its metallic surfaces. Shadow detail is pivotal in such an environment, and this Blu-ray delivers with remarkable clarity. Facial details and the texture of uniforms are rendered with pinpoint precision. Colors are intentionally muted, showcasing a balanced palette where flesh tones remain natural and honest. The fidelity of this transfer ensures that there are no distracting artifacts like banding or noise reduction, thereby preserving the director’s vision intact.
However, the presentation isn't without its caveats. The pervasive darkness that blankets the film can sometimes lead to blacks being overly intense, which may result in crushing some finer details. There are also instances of ghosting, particularly noticeable during sudden and quick movements in the dark confines of the tank. Colors remain bland, though this is reflective of the film's setting rather than a flaw in the transfer process. Soft shots occasionally detract from the overall sharpness, yet closeups reveal an impressive level of detail, emphasizing the characters' anxiety and emotions.
One of the most visually striking elements is the view through the tank's scope. Scenes observed through this perspective are exceptionally detailed, from the distressed expressions to intense action sequences, such as a rocket propelled grenade headed directly for the tank. Despite minor drawbacks, this Blu-ray presentation superbly encapsulates "Lebanon’s" gritty atmosphere and brooding aesthetic, making it an essential acquisition for fans seeking a faithful high-definition portrayal of this uniquely intense film.
Audio: 73
The audio presentation of the Blu-ray for "Lebanon" is a paramount showcase for discerning audiophiles and sound enthusiasts. Featuring a 5.1 Hebrew DTS-HD Master Audio track, the surround sound experience is nothing short of extraordinary. The track captures the intense atmosphere inside a tank during warfare, with thunderous tank and helicopter sounds that are both impressively dynamic and deep. The heavy, rattling clanks of metal and shrapnel are crisp and precise, ensuring the viewer is enveloped in the gritty realism of the battlefield. The overall use of surround sound adds significantly to the claustrophobia and tension inherent in the film, making for a visceral and engaging auditory experience.
The sonic details are handled masterfully, with subtle nuances that enhance the immersion. From the rumbling engine and screeching sound effects to the background radio chatter, every element contributes to a realistic soundscape. Gunfire erupts with pinpoint accuracy from various points in the soundstage, delivering a sense of immediate danger and chaos. The LFE channels are particularly robust, bringing life to the tank's low-frequency noises with powerful depth that rivals modern action flicks. Dialogue remains clear and centered, though occasionally challenged by the surrounding cacophony, further contributing to the authentic chaotic atmosphere.
Additionally, the auditory elements such as the scope’s whirring and the hull creaking offer a full-bodied portrayal of life inside the tank. The dialogue retains precision through the center and front channels, even amidst chaos, and directional effects like zooming jets or hovering helicopters add a layer of cinematic grandeur. This compelling audio presentation perfectly complements the film's intense visuals and themes, making "Lebanon" a noteworthy example of superior sound engineering on Blu-ray.
Extras: 27
The Blu-ray extras for "Lebanon" offer a modest selection but include a valuable behind-the-scenes featurette and several trailers. The standout is Notes on a War Film, presented in SD and running for 24 minutes, providing an insightful look into the filmmaking process of "Lebanon". It is a Hebrew-language piece with English subtitles, exploring how the crew managed to shoot in the constrained environment of a tank, featuring creative camerawork and candid perspectives from the cast and crew. The collection is rounded out by the original Lebanon theatrical trailer and additional promotional materials for other Sony Blu-ray releases. While concise in content, the depth of the main featurette compensates for the overall brevity.
Extras included in this disc:
- Notes on a War Film: Behind-the-scenes look at the making of "Lebanon".
- Lebanon Theatrical Trailer: Original trailer for "Lebanon".
- Trailers: Previews for other Sony Blu-ray titles.
- BD Live enabled: Internet-based content.
Movie: 83
In "Lebanon," director Samuel Maoz crafts a gripping, immersive portrayal of warfare experienced from within a claustrophobic tank during the First Lebanon War. The film, based on Maoz's personal experiences, provides an unflinching depiction of the psychological and physical tolls of combat on a novice Israeli tank crew. Set primarily inside the confines of a tank, viewers witness the chaos outside through the lens of a periscope, intensifying the sense of entrapment and the visceral nature of the war. The gunner, Shmulik, exemplifies the internal conflict faced by soldiers as he hesitates to pull the trigger, leading to devastating consequences. The movie's realistic portrayal of war, with its focus on mental anguish over graphic violence, echoes the emotional rawness seen in films like "Saving Private Ryan."
The strength of "Lebanon" lies in its ability to make viewers feel like participants in the tank's harrowing journey. By never leaving the tank’s interior, Maoz provides an unsettling sense of claustrophobia and invincibility-turned-dread, effectively translating the visceral experience of warfare. This approach allows the story to unfurl within a confined space while still conveying the broader horrors outside. The tank’s interior captures the grime and discomfort endured by the soldiers, amplifying their psychological torment. The narrative shifts focus from traditional depictions of battle to the personal battles faced by each crew member, making "Lebanon" a uniquely personal war story.
Rounding out the film's efficacy are its meticulously crafted settings and an outstanding cast. The bombed-out exteriors visible through the tank’s scope enhance the stark reality of war, juxtaposed against the intimate setting of the tank’s interior. The periscopic view offers a chilling glimpse of war's devastation while maintaining a powerful connection to the soldiers' internal struggles. The cast convincingly embodies their roles, drawing viewers into their plight and underscoring the theme: "Man is steel, the tank is only iron." Overall, "Lebanon" stands as an intensely emotional and aesthetically distinct war film that emphasizes psychological realism over conventional war tropes.
Total: 62
Review of "Lebanon" (Blu-ray Release)
"Lebanon" is an exceptional war film that brings a raw, immersive experience of the 1982 Lebanon War inside the claustrophobic confines of a tank. Directed by Samuel Maoz, this film is a psychologically intense and visually stunning portrayal of warfare, emphasizing both the inner turmoil of the soldiers and the physical atrocities they endure. The cinematography masterfully builds on these themes, making viewers feel the oppressive heat and tension from start to finish.
Sony Pictures Classics' Blu-ray release offers a technically superb presentation, particularly excelling in audio. The sound design is impeccable, pulling the viewer into the relentless chaos of war with each reverberating explosion and anguished shout. The video quality stands strong, although not quite reaching reference-level perfection. The disc’s extra feature, 'Notes on a War Film', provides valuable insights into Maoz's deep personal connection to the subject matter and his passion for authentically depicting the theater of war. Despite the overall limited selection of supplementary material, this feature alone adds significant value to the package.
"Lebanon" is an essential addition to any war film collection. It admirably balances the psychological depth and visceral impact of war, crafting an unforgettable viewing experience. Although light on additional content, the high-quality audiovisual presentation more than compensates, ensuring that this Blu-ray is highly recommended for both casual viewers and serious cinephiles.
Conclusion: "Lebanon" is one of the best war films I have seen. The A/V presentation is beautiful, as is the cinematography. This is a highly recommended Blu-ray release by Sony that I will be watching again. The way the film made you part of the experience, building claustrophobia and tension was masterful. From watching the film then the extra feature 'Notes on a War Film', Director Samuel Maoz's passion on the subject and understanding of war was obvious and shined through in spades. I would love to see more of his work in the future.
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 90
Detail is fantastic, too; though the film is gritty and oftentimes dark, the Blu-ray allows all of the tank -- whether instrument gauges or the grime, dents, scratches, and general wear-and-tear on its...
Audio: 100
The heavy, rattling, clanking sounds of the tank seem incredibly precise; the rumbling of the engine and the screeching sound effects fill the soundstage with deadly precision....
Extras: 20
Notes on a War Film (480p, 24:24): This Hebrew-language (with English subtitles) piece takes viewers on a candid behind-the-scenes look at the making of Lebanon from several perspectives and through several...
Movie: 100
The film so effortlessly pulls the viewer into the action that the life-and-death decisions; the disagreements; and the wars that are raging inside the men's souls, around the interior of the tank, and...
Total: 70
Winner of the Golden Lion at the 66th Venice International Film Festival, Lebanon is an important, well-made, and psychologically challenging motion picture that's sure to disturb audiences in the way...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 60
As we see what's happening outside through the tank's scope, details are brought out from the distressed looks on people's faces to the slow motion shot of a rocket propelled grenade heading straight for...
Audio: 80
It's a very different type of audio presentation, but it works perfectly in creating the claustrophobic atmosphere the movie is trying to achieve....
Extras: 20
This featurette covers the making of 'Lebanon' and talks about how they filmed those crammed scenes and how the actors were able to do their thing inside such small quarters....
Movie: 80
'Lebanon' doesn't have much to add to the "War is Hell" genre, but it does tell its story in a creative manner, which helps us realize that even though wars cover vast swaths of land, the real drama is...
Total: 60
The video is fairly strong, but the audio here is stupendous as it sucks you right into the film and doesn't let you go....
AVSForumRead review here
Video: 94
The use of surrounds added to the claustrophobia and tension, filling the room with perfect ambiance and precise panning....
Audio: 92
The use of surrounds added to the claustrophobia and tension, filling the room with perfect ambiance and precise panning....
Extras: 50
(HD) Notes on a War Film (HD) Theatrical Trailers (HD) Trailers: A Woman, A Gun and A Noodle Shop, Animal Kingdom, Inside Job, I Get Low, Anoher Year BD Live enabled...
Movie: 80
Young men who have never fought before are now placed inside of a killing machine and thrown into a situation that quickly spins out of control, testing the mental toughness of the men inside of a confined...
Total: 79
The way the film made you part of the experience, building claustrophobia and tension was masterful....
Director: Samuel Maoz
Actors: Yoav Donat, Itay Tiran, Oshri Cohen
PlotA group of young Israeli soldiers is deployed in the early days of the 1982 Lebanon War. They are tasked with mission support in a solitary tank. Isolated, claustrophobic, and engulfed by the wartime chaos surrounding them, the soldiers communicate with the outside world solely through their periscope and radios. The ever-present feeling of confinement within the tank heightens their anxiety and deepens their existential dread. Their initial mission, seemingly straightforward reconnaissance, quickly grows harrowing as they confront the violent realities of war and their own inner fears.
As tensions rise, the crew's mental and physical endurance is put to the test with each encounter with enemy forces, civilians, and allied troops alike. Personal conflicts and commanding decisions inside the tank reflect the broader ambiguity and moral complexity of the conflict outside. The soldiers navigate their limited visibility and fractured communication lines while grappling with the ethical implications of their actions and orders. This balance of survival, duty, and humanity underscores their struggle against the war's brutal impact and their own psychological unraveling, edging them ever closer to a breaking point.
Writers: Samuel Maoz
Release Date: 15 Oct 2009
Runtime: 93 min
Rating: R
Country: Israel, France, Germany, United Kingdom
Language: Hebrew, Arabic, French, English