Tobor the Great Blu-ray Review
Score: 48
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Tobor the Great, though simplistic and dated, offers a charming robot design by Kinoshita and solid Blu-ray transfer, making it a worthwhile, nostalgic watch.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 54
The AVC encoded 1.67:1 1080p transfer for *Tobor the Great* delivers a bright, clear view with valuable detail for the robot, secure whites, heavy yet filmic grain, and a spot-on greyscale with controlled contrast, despite some persistent softness.
Audio: 49
Tobor the Great's 2.0 DTS-HD MA sound mix reflects its age with thin, tinny audio and mild volume fluctuations, especially in the last reel. Dialogue and sound effects are serviceable but lack depth. Despite the stable volume, the audio remains flat without notable hiss, pops, or cracks.
Extra: 31
The bonus features, while not abundant, offer a valuable audio commentary by film historian Richard Harland Smith and a selection of trailers from similar sci-fi classics, maintaining the standard quality expected from Studio Classics releases.
Movie: 61
"Tobor the Great" is a charming 1954 B-movie sci-fi film that balances Atomic Age fears, space travel ambitions, and emotional intelligence themes with a lighthearted, optimistic approach. Despite its use of cheap effects, stock footage, and mediocre characters, it offers warming nostalgia and memorable robotic antics, ideal for 50s sci-fi lovers.
Video: 54
The AVC encoded, 1.67:1 aspect ratio presentation of "Tobor the Great" on Blu-ray offers a bright and relatively clear image, effectively bringing the robotic antics to life. While some softness persists throughout, the film's finer details, especially those involving Tobor, are commendable. Human characters' close-ups and clothing textures maintain traditional qualities, offering a satisfactory visual experience. The set designs are also shown in more defined views, with good delineation and secure whites. The film grain is heavier but retains a filmic quality, contributing to an authentic cinematic feel. The source material is in decent shape, marred only by mild scratches and speckling.
The 1080p transfer does a remarkable job capturing the film's greyscale, demonstrating strong light and shadow usage. Black levels are impressive, with controlled contrast that enhances depth within the image. Middle shots and close-ups appear the most detailed, while the wide and establishing shots experience some loss in detail. Despite the occasional softness, the presentation upholds a good visual standard. Minor imperfections, such as nicks and speckling, do not detract significantly from the overall viewing experience. The textures on facial features, clothing, and production design elements provide a satisfying level of detail across most scenes.
Audio: 49
The audio presentation of "Tobor the Great" on Blu-ray features a 2.0 DTS-HD Master Audio mix that effectively captures the film’s vintage essence while revealing its age-related limitations. Despite being generally clear, the sound has a tinny, hollow quality that diminishes the vibrancy of dialogue and hinders the fullness of the musical score. The dialogue is accurately represented but lacks depth, sounding somewhat lifeless. Sound effects are present yet blunt, and music scores support the scenes adequately without standing out prominently.
The mix demonstrates some mild fluctuations in volume, most noticeably in the film's final reel, where it becomes distinctly quieter. This drop in volume, although not severe, may require viewers to adjust their volume settings to maintain consistent audio levels. Commendably, the track is free from notable hiss, pops, or cracks, ensuring a clean listening experience without extraneous noise. Overall, the audio mix is serviceable, delivering an acceptable portrayal of dramatic exchanges and robotic interactions while simultaneously drawing attention to its flat and somewhat artificial sound profile.
Extras: 31
The Blu-ray release of "Tobor the Great" features a modest but engaging array of extras typical of Studio Classics editions. While not abundant, the included bonus features do provide some notable insights and entertainment value. The primary highlight is the informative audio commentary by film historian Richard Harland Smith, enriching the viewing experience with historical context and detailed analysis. Additionally, a selection of vintage trailers offers a nostalgic snapshot of classic sci-fi cinema.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary: Featuring film historian Richard Harland Smith.
- Invisible Invaders Trailer: Classic sci-fi trailer.
- Journey to the Seventh Planet Trailer: High-definition trailer.
- Gog Trailer: Standard definition trailer.
- The Magnetic Monster Trailer: Standard definition trailer.
- Donovan's Brain Trailer: Classic sci-fi trailer.
Movie: 61
"Tobor the Great" is a quintessential example of 1950s B-movie science fiction, blending earnest ambition with the charm of a low-budget production. Directed by Lee Sholem and starring Charles Drake, the film juxtaposes nuclear fears with the burgeoning space race between the United States and the Soviet Union. While Tobor, the titular robot equipped with emotional capabilities, is intended for space exploration, a plot involving foreign spies and a curious young boy soon takes precedence. The narrative struggles to fill even its brief 77-minute runtime, frequently relying on stock footage and clumsy edits to pad out the story.
Despite its limitations, "Tobor the Great" stands out for its optimistic approach amidst an era dominated by paranoia. The key characters, portrayed by Charles Drake, Taylor Holmes, and Karen Booth, ground the film in emotional intelligence, presenting an empathetic counterpoint to the otherwise fear-driven plot. Tobor himself, though awkwardly designed, brings a memorable presence to the screen, rivaling other iconic cinematic robots of the era. The film's depiction of Tobor as a sentient being capable of empathy adds a layer of depth to an otherwise straightforward narrative.
Overall, "Tobor the Great" offers a nostalgic look at B-movie sci-fi, complete with recycled sets, cheap effects, and thematic explorations of artificial intelligence and human empathy. Its reliance on stock footage and predictable plot points may limit its impact, but for enthusiasts of 50s sci-fi schlock, it remains an endearing artifact of its time. The film’s light-hearted approach ensures it doesn’t take itself too seriously, making it an enjoyable watch for fans of the genre.
Total: 48
"Tobor the Great" offers an intriguing glimpse into 1950s science fiction, delivering a charmingly nostalgic journey, albeit with some limitations. The robot design, courtesy of Robert Kinoshita, who later designed Robby the Robot for "Forbidden Planet" and Robot in "Lost in Space," stands as one of the film's highlights, capturing the imagination through Tobor's on-screen antics. The film thrives on its simple yet enjoyable narrative, carried by a compelling performance from a solid cast that brings the titular robot to life in a manner that is both entertaining and endearing.
For aficionados of classic sci-fi rooted in the era’s political landscape, "Tobor the Great" hits the mark with its earnest presentation, complete with stock footage and melodramatic exposition. Despite not being the most intellectually stimulating piece of cinema, it excels in providing straightforward, enjoyable entertainment. The inclusion of a runaway robotic giant injects an element of chaos and excitement that propels the storyline, making the film enjoyable even if it isn’t groundbreaking.
The Blu-ray release by Kino Lorber Studio Classics enhances the experience with a commendable video transfer that brings clarity to this decades-old film. While the audio mix reflects its age, it remains serviceable and does not detract significantly from the viewing experience. Additionally, the disc garners value from a comprehensive audio commentary and a series of engaging trailers, offering enthusiasts more context and content.
In conclusion, "Tobor the Great" may not achieve cinematic greatness, but its blend of nostalgic charm and simplistic fun renders it a worthwhile endeavor. Its appeal lies in its ability to transport viewers back to an era of earnest sci-fi filmmaking, making it a recommended addition for collectors and fans of classic B-movie science fiction.
Blu-ray.com review by Brian OrndorfRead review here
Video: 70
Some softness remains, but detail is valuable for Tobor particulars, getting a close look at the makings of the metal giant, while his human co-stars offer more traditional textures on clothing and close-ups....
Audio: 60
The 2.0 DTS-HD MA sound mix displays its age with thinner, less pronounced listening event, and one with mild fluctuations in volume, most noticeably in the last reel, which gets quieter....
Extras: 30
...
Movie: 70
Nuclear fears open "Tobor the Great," but they're soon replaced with space travel ambition, offering a plot that finds Tobor, a robot, equipped with emotional capabilities to best serve his mission to...
Total: 60
"Tobor the Great" is dull, but it's not a complete waste of time, showcasing an appealing robot design from Robert Kinoshita, who would go on to create Robby the Robot for "Forbidden Planet" and Robot...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 60
The film's greyscale is spot on with great use of light and shadow with great black levels and controlled contrast to give the image a notable sense of depth....
Audio: 60
Sound effects can be a bit muffled and music scoring is present but doesn't exactly lift out of the mix....
Extras: 40
As is the case with most Studio Classics releases, bonus features aren't very plentiful here, but the audio commentary is a pretty great listen....
Movie: 60
Even as the film tries to tackle serious themes about emotional intelligence and the need for an empathetic understanding of one another - including our enemies - the film never forgets that it's about...
Total: 60
The film may not be the smartest reel of celluloid in the room, but it has an earnest heart and works well with relevant themes....
Director: Lee Sholem
Actors: Charles Drake, Karin Booth, Billy Chapin
PlotDr. Ralph Harrison, a scientist disillusioned with the human cost of space exploration, teams up with Dr. Gustav Schaefer to create a robot designed for space missions. Their creation, a massive and powerful robot named Tobor, is capable of being controlled through both traditional means and telepathy, making it an ideal candidate for the dangerous task of piloting space probes. The scientists demonstrate Tobor's capabilities to military officials, emphasizing its potential to save human lives by taking on hazardous space operations. Intrigued by their invention, the military expresses strong interest but simultaneously attracts the attention of foreign spies seeking to exploit Tobor's advanced technology for their own purposes.
Dr. Harrison and his family, including his young, inquisitive grandson, Brian, soon find themselves under threat from these nefarious forces. As the tension escalates, Brian forms an emotional bond with Tobor, discovering that the robot possesses a greater range of abilities and intelligence than initially apparent. Suspense builds as Dr. Harrison and his allies must protect Tobor and prevent its capture, while also exploring the robot's true potential. The narrative weaves themes of technological advancement, ethical considerations in scientific discovery, and the dangers posed by espionage.
Writers: Philip MacDonald, Carl Dudley
Release Date: 01 Sep 1954
Runtime: 77 min
Rating: Approved
Country: United States
Language: English