Rolling Thunder 4K Ultra HD Blu-ray Review
Score: 81
from 5 reviewers
Review Date:
Shout Studios' 4K UHD of *Rolling Thunder* delivers a superb restoration with outstanding picture quality and comprehensive extras, making it a must-have for fans.
Disc Release Date
True 4K
HDR10
Dolby Vision
DTS-HD MA
Video: 90
Rolling Thunder's new 4K UHD Blu-ray release by Shout! preserves its gritty 1970s essence and showcases vastly improved visuals with a solid 1.85:1 framing, consistent grain, and enhanced detail through Dolby Vision and HDR10, making it an essential upgrade despite minor imperfections in interior scenes.
Audio: 72
The 4K UHD Blu Ray of 'Rolling Thunder' features a DTS-HD Master Audio Dual Mono mix that, while maintaining a limited frequency response and some roughness in dialogue, offers appreciable clarity. Highlights include Barry De Vorzon’s 'San Antone,' effective bass in action scenes, and comprehensive English SDH subtitles.
Extra: 81
The 4K UHD release of "Rolling Thunder" features robust extras, including two newly recorded audio commentaries, insightful interviews, and comprehensive retrospective featurettes. However, it omits some key materials from previous editions, such as the Heywood Gould moderated commentary. Overall, it offers a substantial package for fans and collectors.
Movie: 83
Combining gritty narrative and raw 1970s honesty, the 4K UHD Blu-ray of John Flynn's *Rolling Thunder* offers a visceral revenge thriller with stellar performances and brutal intensity, enhanced by a potent visual remaster, making it a grim yet captivating cinematic experience.
Video: 90
The new 4K UHD Blu-ray release of "Rolling Thunder" is a remarkable improvement over previous editions, showcasing the film in its original 1.85:1 aspect ratio derived from the 35mm original camera negative. This release benefits greatly from Dolby Vision and HDR10 grading, which brings a new level of depth and vibrancy to the picture. The HDR grading renders richly saturated colors, notably enhancing the vivid reds of the 1973 Cadillac convertible, while maintaining a natural look for skin tones. The grain is consistently tight and filmic, no doubt a testament to the limited grain reduction applied during restoration, allowing for a pleasing amount of fine detail that highlights the film’s gritty 1970s aesthetic.
Cinematographer Jordan Cronenweth's use of natural and practical lighting creates interiors with stark shadows and deep blacks, meticulously preserved in this new transfer. The high bitrate averaging 84.8 Mbps ensures that even the most demanding scenes are rendered without any noticeable compression artifacts, while remaining true to Cronenweth’s original lighting intentions. Exteriors and wide shots exhibit sharpness and detail that defy the film’s late '70s origins, offering a more cinema-like appearance that breathes new life into this decades-old classic. Minor artifacts such as speckles are almost non-existent, showing just how well the restoration process has been executed.
Outdoor scenes particularly benefit from this restoration, presenting crisp and clean visuals. The opening title sequence, derived from dupe elements, understandably remains softer, but this doesn’t detract from the overall presentation. This meticulous 4K restoration by Shout Select is not just an upgrade but a revelation, allowing "Rolling Thunder" to visually “sing," with stellar resolution and dynamic range that enhance every frame of the film. This release is an essential addition for collectors and film enthusiasts alike who seek the best possible presentation of this classic thriller.
Audio: 72
The 4K UHD Blu-ray of "Rolling Thunder" comes equipped with a DTS-HD Master Audio Dual Mono mix (1982 kbps, 24-bit) across both discs, which preserves the film's original audio integrity while providing a suitable listening experience for enthusiasts. Dialogue is delivered with a degree of pitch variability, maintaining the authentic texture of the source material without any noticeable EQ adjustments. While Denny Brooks's performance of Barry De Vorzon's "San Antone" adds a warm richness to the center channel, the track itself lacks deep bass, noticeable primarily in action-heavy scenes, such as shotgun blasts and shootouts. Importantly, there were no pops, crackles, or dropouts detected during playback.
The DTS-HD mono mix underscores the film’s age with certain rough edges, revealing an inherently fuzzy source. Dialogue occasionally exhibits a thin and muffled quality, though it remains intelligible. Barry De Vorzon’s musical score is presented with adequate clarity despite resting in a bright treble zone, lacking the refinement modern audio mixes might offer. Furthermore, the gunshots and action sequences, while loud and impactful, do not achieve extreme dynamism.
Overall, the audio mix for "Rolling Thunder" on this 4K UHD Blu-ray is respectable given the vintage nature of the material. It captures the essence of the original mono audio while managing to do justice to key elements such as dialogue clarity and music presentation. Film aficionados will likely appreciate the authenticity of this mix, even if it retains some aged imperfections.
Extras: 81
The 4K UHD Blu-ray release of "Rolling Thunder" includes a comprehensive set of extras that are sure to delight film enthusiasts. The standout additions are the newly recorded audio commentaries. The first features screenwriter Heywood Gould alongside film historian C. Courtney Joyner, delving deeply into the script's development and production nuances. The second commentary by filmmakers Jackson Stewart and Francis Galluppi enthusiastically dissects the movie’s influences and its connections to other works. Complementing these are interviews with pivotal figures like composer Barry De Vorzon and historian C. Courtney Joyner, further enriching the viewer's understanding of the film. While some elements from previous releases are missing, this robust collection is a significant enhancement, making it a must-have for collectors.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary: Heywood Gould and C. Courtney Joyner provide an in-depth conversation on the film.
- Audio Commentary: Jackson Stewart and Francis Galluppi share their exuberant analysis.
- Lean and Mean: The Early Films of John Flynn: An interview with C. Courtney Joyner.
- Coming Home to War: Scoring Rolling Thunder: An interview with composer Barry De Vorzon.
- The Making of Rolling Thunder: Featuring interviews with William Devane, Tommy Lee Jones, Paul Schrader, and Heywood Gould.
- Trailers from Hell: Filmmaker Eli Roth discusses "Rolling Thunder."
- Theatrical Trailer
- TV Spot
- Radio Spots
- Still Gallery
Movie: 83
John Flynn’s 1977 film Rolling Thunder is a visceral exploration of the "disgruntled Vietnam vet meets revenge thriller" genre, remaining a seminal influence on filmmakers like Quentin Tarantino. With William Devane in the lead as Major Charles Rane, the narrative delves deep into the psyche of a POW returning home to a broken family and a community that celebrates him superficially. The relentless drive for vengeance begins when a gang assaults his family, leaving him maimed and bereft. Rane’s journey, fueled by unquenchable rage and a cold detachment absorbed from years of torture, is a stark, violent portrayal of a man whose only remaining purpose is retribution.
Flynn's direction ensures that Rolling Thunder maintains a granular, gritty tone throughout. The film avoids the introspection seen in The Deer Hunter, opting instead for savage grindhouse aesthetics akin to early Rambo. Devane’s performance as the embattled Major Rane is both harrowing and subdued, revealing the haunting damage within a soldier. Tomy Lee Jones, though sparingly featured, delivers an unforgettable portrayal of Sgt. Johnny Vohden, whose final act shift from impassiveness to grim joy underscores the characters' emotional torpor and ultimate embrace of violence.
The cinematography capitalizes on shadows and gloom, enhancing the morose atmosphere pervading Rane's world. It employs tight scripting and methodical pacing to highlight the bleakness of reintegration for its protagonists. Scenes of brutal violence punctuate the narrative with explosive force, contrasting sharply with the film's otherwise quiet and somber tone. The dissonance between patriotic overtures and the characters' indifference serves to critique both societal assimilation efforts and the inadequacy of these gestures. Ultimately, Rolling Thunder stands as a grim masterwork in revenge cinema, unflinching in its portrayal of trauma and singular in its grinding, brutal execution.
Total: 81
Shout! Studios' 4K UHD Blu-ray release of "Rolling Thunder" is a meticulously crafted package that demonstrates the due diligence in preserving this quintessential revenge film. John Flynn's direction, anchored by strong performances from William Devane and Tommy Lee Jones, is given a significant visual and audio upgrade in this release. The new 1.85:1 HEVC encode ensures the film’s grim textures and poignant scenes appear as vivid as ever, while the DTS-HD MA 2.0 Mono track faithfully retains the original theatrical experience. Shout! Studios supplements this with comprehensive extras including two new commentaries, each offering valuable insights into the film's creation and its enduring impact on the genre.
The restoration work is impeccable, far surpassing previous Blu-ray editions. This 4K UHD presentation feels akin to viewing the film in its original theatrical run, with notably enhanced contrasts and color fidelity. The addition of Barry De Vorzon’s interviews offers further depth, providing context to the film's atmospheric score. While some extras from previous releases—such as various commentaries and interviews—are absent, the current set still boasts an extensive array of supplemental material, such as theatrical trailers, TV and radio spots, and a Trailers from Hell feature with Eli Roth. The newly recorded commentary tracks augment the already rich viewing experience, making this edition indispensable for collectors and new viewers alike.
Conclusion
"Rolling Thunder" deserves all of the praise heaped upon it over the years. It may not be perfect cinema, but it is a solidly executed film that effectively uses the revenge motif, resonating deeply with an America grappling with the aftermath of the Vietnam War. Shout! Studios’ 4K UHD disc is impressive, featuring a fantastic new encode for both the 4K and included Blu-ray, along with the lossless theatrical 2.0 Mono track. Despite a few missed extras, this package is an all-around excellent offering and well worth picking up. Highly recommended for both long-time fans and newcomers.
AV Nirvana review by Michael ScottRead review here
Video: 90
Black levels have a bit of crush in it, but it’s more of a problem with the low light and the cameras used back then vs. an encoding problem, as Shout has given the disc a VERY beefy 84-85mbps bitrate...
Audio: 80
And Author/Film Historian C. Courtney Joyner • NEW Audio Commentary With Filmmakers Jackson Stewart And Francis Galluppi • NEW "Lean And Mean: The Early Films Of John Flynn" – An Interview With Author/Film...
Extras: 80
It may not have the nuance of Taxi Driver , or the somber introspection of The Deer Hunter , but Rolling Thunder is a gritty, nasty, ROUGH revenge thriller that uses all of the blunt force honesty of the...
Movie: 90
The 1970s was home to a lot of genres that have fallen by the wayside over the years, and the biggest of them would probably have been the old “disgruntled Nam vets returning home” genre that was so close...
Total: 90
Shout Studios 4K UHD disc is impressive, with a fantastic new encode for both the 4K and the included Blu-ray, as well as the theatrical 2.0 Mono track in lossless....
Blu-ray.com review by Dr. Stephen LarsonRead review here
Video: 100
In perusing screen captures Svet and Jeff retrieved for their reviews, the EM disc seems struck from the same master....
Audio: 80
I haven't heard the DTS-HD MA monaural mixes on the Studio Canal and the older Shout disc, but this one sounds rather similar to the English track on Explosive Media's Blu-ray....
Extras: 80
It also contains a still gallery of 38 distinct images, which is a different gallery from the one on the two Shout releases....
Movie: 90
John Flynn's fourth feature Rolling Thunder (1977) has been covered by two of my colleagues: Dr. Svet Atanasov reviewed Studio Canal's Blu-ray + DVD "Special Edition" in 2012 and Jeff Kauffman wrote about...
Total: 90
I hope Rolling Thunder continues to gain a following as it's one of the better coming-home films in the war genre....
Blu-ray Authority review by Matt Brighton and Jake KeetRead review here
Video: 80
Shout’s offering of this film in Blu-ray left a lot to be desired, but the good news is that parts of this transfer look fantastic....
Audio: 70
People who love the film will enjoy this mix, as it did not have any problems with clarity that I noticed....
Extras: 80
Lean and Mean: The Early films of John Flynn – Film Historian C. Courtney Joyner, who also contributed on the commentary track, gives us a crash course in anything and everything that is John Flynn (the...
Movie: 0
Essentially the film is a revenge story, and some of the actions in the film make it a very good revenge story, but the movie is also extremely strange....
Total: 70
Along with the upgraded picture quality we also get two new commentary tracks as well as two new features....
The Digital Bits review by Stephen BjorkRead review here
Video: 90
That extends to the HDR grade, but it’s worth noting that Cronenweth lit the interiors with very limited practical light sources like sunlight through the windows or table lamps, and he didn’t use much...
Audio: 80
The overall frequency response is a bit limited, with not much in the way of deep bass, but Barry De Vorzon’s score sounds good....
Extras: 90
They discuss the story and the changes that it underwent, the cast, and many other details about the making of the film....
Movie: 80
On the surface, John Flynn’s incendiary 1977 revenge drama Rolling Thunder may seem like one of many such films that followed in the wake of the success of Death Wish three years earlier, but its actual...
Total: 85
There are a few extras from previous releases that aren’t offered here, including a different commentary with Heywood Gould (paired with Roy Frumkes) that was offered on the 2012 Region B Blu-ray releases...
DoBlu review by Matt PaprockiRead review here
Video: 100
Also helping is a generous Dolby Vision pass, giving depth to the black levels and a steady spark to light....
Audio: 60
The music rests in a bright treble zone that lacks refinement, but offers enough clarity to get by....
Extras: 80
Over on the Blu-ray, new interviews begin with Joyner returning, followed by composer BarryDe Vorzen....
Movie: 80
Devane’s Charles Rane returns to Jones’ home, and with few words, the two begin loading suitcases with weapons; Jones has rarely expressed such joy on screen – these men are going in for another fight,...
Total: 80
...
Director: John Flynn
Actors: William Devane, Tommy Lee Jones, Linda Haynes
PlotReturning home to Texas after enduring years of torture as a POW in Vietnam, Major Charles Rane is celebrated as a hero. His hometown presents him with gifts of gratitude, including a silver-dollar collection. However, Rane's return is marred by his struggles to readjust to civilian life and reconnect with his young son and estranged wife. The horrors of war have left him emotionally distant, finding it hard to express his feelings and reintegrate into a society that seems alien to him now. His stoic and unflappable demeanor is both a fortress and a prison, reflecting the deep scars that torment him internally.
Tragedy strikes when a gang of thugs, learning of the silver dollars, invades Rane's home, believing him to be an easy target. The encounter turns violent, leaving Rane severely injured and his family deeply affected by the brutality of the attack. Motivated by a relentless quest for vengeance, Rane decides to take matters into his own hands. Drawing on his wartime experiences and skills, he embarks on a meticulous and dogged pursuit of justice. His mission attracts the attention of an old friend from the war, who joins him in his crusade, setting the stage for a relentless hunt that tests the limits of their friendship, their resolve, and their very survival. Their journey is a harrowing descent into the heart of darkness within themselves and the adversaries they face, blurring the lines between right and wrong, hero and villain.
Writers: Paul Schrader, Heywood Gould
Release Date: 06 Feb 1978
Runtime: 95 min
Rating: R
Country: United States
Language: English, Spanish