Appassionata Blu-ray Review
Limited Edition to 3000 3,000 copies
Score: 41
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Appassionata's conflicting genres and disturbing themes are partly salvaged by strong performances, but the Blu-ray offers only adequate A/V quality and a single notable isolated score track.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 47
Appassionata's Blu-ray presentation in 1080p 1.85:1, showcases a purposefully soft image with moments of digital filtering and occasional oversaturation, creating an Impressionistic feel. Colors are vibrant with good saturation, while fine detail pops more in well-lit scenes despite light grain and minor instability.
Audio: 47
'Appassionata' offers DTS-HD MA 2.0 mono tracks in Italian and English, both presenting some sync issues and a slightly boxed sound, with the Italian track feeling more natural and balanced due to its original language. The isolated score track notably provides a fuller sound compared to the dialogue tracks.
Extra: 16
Appassionata's Blu-ray extras consist solely of an Isolated Score Track in DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0, offering no additional content or supplementary features.
Movie: 51
Appassionata, a 1974 film by Gian Luigi Calderone, attempts to navigate a fine line between character-driven drama and Eurocult sexploitation but ultimately falls short in both areas. The Blu-ray presentation by Twilight Time comes with a Region Free BD50 disc and an insightful booklet by Julie Kirgo, though the film's explicit content and lack of thematic focus result in a confusing and unsatisfying experience.
Video: 47
The Blu-ray presentation of "Appassionata" manifests an AVC encoded 1080p transfer framed in a slightly window-boxed 1.85:1 aspect ratio. While the intent behind this aesthetic choice remains debatable, the execution reveals a predominantly soft visual quality that imbues the film with a dreamlike ambiance. This softness is intermittently interrupted by moments of heightened clarity, particularly in close-up shots where detail and texture become more pronounced. However, occasional image instability during the opening credits and sporadic scenes detracts from the overall visual coherence. Despite this, color saturation remains a notable high point, with a vibrant palette bringing scenes to life, though at times this vibrancy borders on oversaturation, as evidenced by colorful elements like Emilio’s bright red sweater.
Grain is present but selectively applied, suggesting the potential use of digital noise reduction (DNR) to enhance the film’s ethereal visuals. While this contributes to the dreamlike quality, it also leads to some issues with image stability and definition, particularly in darker scenes where black levels struggle. This might be exacerbated by some contrast adjustments, resulting in whites blooming more than intended. Nevertheless, exterior scenes and brightly lit environments, such as the dental office, showcase finer detail and a more convincing depth. Overall, while the visual presentation of "Appassionata" underscores its artistic vision with a somewhat Impressionistic feel, it may not align with traditional expectations of high-definition sharpness and clarity.
Audio: 47
"Appassionata" features DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 mono tracks in the original Italian and a dubbed English version. Given that no native dialogue audio was recorded on set, both tracks exhibit an inauthentic, post-looped quality typical of Italian cinema from the era. This results in occasional sync issues and a slightly canned auditory experience. Nonetheless, both language options are free of age-related anomalies such as hiss or pop.
The Italian DTS-HD MA 2.0 track, accompanied by English subtitles, is recommended for its more authentic tonal balance compared to the English dub. While both tracks possess a boxiness, especially noticeable when the underscore appears, toggling between the spoken language tracks and the isolated score track reveals a fuller, more enriched sound in the isolated music. The spread of dialogue, sound effects, and music is better balanced in the Italian version, lending it a more natural feel despite the inherent limitations of post-looped audio.
Extras: 16
The Blu-ray edition of "Appassionata" lacks the typical array of bonus features common to releases by Twilight Time. Unfortunately, buyers expecting in-depth behind-the-scenes content or interviews will find the selection limited. Specifically, the isolated score track stands as the sole supplement, which for audiophile enthusiasts serves as a valuable addition, presented in high-quality DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0. However, the absence of additional content like director commentaries, making-of documentaries, or deleted scenes leaves much to be desired for comprehensive collectors.
Extras included in this disc:
Isolated Score Track: Presented in DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0.
Movie: 51
Appassionata, directed by Gian Luigi Calderone, offers an unapologetically provocative narrative that firmly straddles the line between drama and Eurocult sexploitation. The story centers around Emilio Rutelli (Gabriele Ferzetti), a middle-aged dentist entangled in an illicit relationship with his daughter's best friend, Nicola (Eleonora Giorgi), against the backdrop of his wife Elisa's (Valentina Cortese) deteriorating mental state. Calderone attempts to craft a hybrid of character-driven drama and salacious content, yet the film stumbles as it tries to balance explicit sexuality with nuanced storytelling.
Calderone's directorial approach features a curiously clinical examination of disquieting themes. While the performances stand out—Gabriele Ferzetti convincingly portrays a man ensnared by midlife crises, and Valentina Cortese shines in depicting lucid moments amidst dementia—the film's inconsistent tone detracts from its potential impact. The plot often meanders, oscillating between lurid intrigue and dramatic intent without committing fully to either, resulting in a disjointed narrative experience.
The thematic depth that should arise from such provocative material is undermined by the film's overly explicit focus on sexuality and underdeveloped character arcs. Scenes meant to explore inner turmoil tend to dissipate into salacious spectacle, leaving questions of motive and engagement unresolved. Appassionata straddles an uncomfortable line, neither satisfying as an intense psychological character study nor as an unabashedly bawdy piece of entertainment. This indecisiveness ultimately results in a film that feels incomplete and leaves its audience questioning its purpose.
Total: 41
"Appassionata" is a film that grapples with unsettling sexual content and complex psychological issues, creating a unique yet disjointed viewing experience. The movie navigates through conflicting genres, being too dramatic for the sexploitation label while simultaneously too sensational to fully explore its dramatic ambitions. This blend leads to an odd, albeit fascinating narrative landscape that is underscored by strong performances from its primary cast. Despite these commendable performances, the story struggles to find a cohesive direction that can fully engage the audience.
The Blu-ray release by Twilight Time showcases the film with good to very good technical merits. The audio/visual presentation is competent, effectively capturing the film’s vivid cinematography and detailed soundscapes. However, it’s worth noting that the only supplementary feature is an isolated score track—a noteworthy inclusion but not substantial enough to elevate this release to a must-have status, especially considering Twilight Time's premium pricing.
In conclusion, "Appassionata" is a peculiar blend of compelling performances and disjointed storytelling. Its sanguine approach towards provocative material adds an element of intrigue, but also leaves much unresolved. The Blu-ray transfer does justice to the original film, but the lack of additional features makes it hard to recommend as a blind buy. While it may appeal to collectors and aficionados of unconventional cinema, general viewers might find it more puzzling than satisfying.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 60
The overall appearance of this transfer is on the soft side, and there are a certain moments where things get even softer for a while, leading at times to an almost Impressionistic ambience (see screenshot...
Audio: 60
In fact, toggling between the two spoken language tracks and the isolated score track is an eye (and/or ear) opener, with the isolated track offering a much more full sounding accounting of the music....
Extras: 20
...
Movie: 50
This part of the film may make it a personal favorite of middle aged dentists everywhere, but it begs a question (one which the film asks in other, potentially even more disturbing ways, with regard to...
Total: 50
I'm tempted to describe Appassionata as Lolita had it been directed by someone like Erroll Morris (with maybe someone like Douglas Sirk stepping in to handle the wife material), but that doesn't adequately...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 60
There is some fine film grain on display, but it's only intermittently apparent leading me to wonder if some slight DNR was applied to amplify the dreamlike quality of some scenes, in particular, the dream...
Audio: 60
Because this is an Italian production and no native dialogue audio was recorded on set, both tracks have a bit of an inauthentic "canned" quality to them....
Extras: 0
...
Movie: 60
It's too sexually explicit to be dramatically interesting as the film lumbers from one scenario to the next, including an incredibly awkward and baffling dream sequence....
Total: 40
It isn't a terrible film, as there are some incredible performances by its primary cast, but there's only so much that can be done with great performances....
Director: Gianluigi Calderone
Actors: Gabriele Ferzetti, Ornella Muti, Eleonora Giorgi
PlotIn a serene Italian town, Dr. Emilio, a middle-aged and esteemed dentist, leads a seemingly idyllic life with his mentally unstable wife, Elisa. They are part of a close-knit community where appearances and reputations are paramount. The story begins to unravel when two beautiful, adolescent friends, Eugenia and Nicola, provoke shifts in their tranquil world. Initially, the girls’ youthful beauty and charm captivate the doctor and Elisa, fueling an atmosphere tinged with envy and admiration. The intimacy between the couples grows as the innocence of the young women cloaks underlying tensions and unresolved desires.
As time progresses, a complex web of emotions begins to emerge among the four characters, raising questions about fidelity, trust, and emotional boundaries. Dr. Emilio becomes increasingly drawn to the vivacious spirit and unbridled energy of Eugenia and Nicola. His once stable existence begins to falter under the weight of his burgeoning obsessions and the palpable strain in his marriage. The fragile balance within their relationships starts to teeter, marking the onset of personal and moral dilemmas that threaten to upend their lives. The story takes a turn that reveals hidden depths within each character, setting the stage for inevitable confrontations and revelations.
Writers: Gianluigi Calderone, Alessandro Parenzo, Domenico Rafele
Release Date: 01 Apr 1985
Runtime: 96 min
Rating: N/A
Country: Italy
Language: Italian, English