Grave of the Fireflies Blu-ray Review
Score: 62
from 1 reviewers
Review Date:
Grave of the Fireflies: a profoundly moving anti-war film, highly recommended for its expressive depth.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 63
Grave of the Fireflies' Blu-ray release by Sentai Filmworks offers a sharp, natural presentation with occasional fading and less saturation compared to typical Ghibli works, reflecting quality concerns and a painterly aesthetic.
Audio: 63
Grave of the Fireflies' Blu-ray offers DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 with a new English, original Japanese, and a damaged 1988 English track, the latter suffering from low amplitude and quality issues, unlike the excellent fidelity and dynamic range of the new English and Japanese options.
Extra: 46
The collection features complete storyboards for 'Grave of the Fireflies' in HD, two deleted scenes in SD, and the Japanese trailer in HD, offering an in-depth look at the film's development.
Movie: 86
Grave of the Fireflies, a haunting anime about children navigating war's devastation in WWII Japan, melds horror with lyrical beauty.
Video: 63
Grave of the Fireflies" on Blu-ray, available via Sentai Filmworks, showcases an AVC encoded 1080p transfer in the aspect ratio of 1.85:1. This particular edition might slightly diverge from the pristine curation expected of official Studio Ghibli iterations, a notion subtly suggested through the comparison with the original English audio quality. Despite these nuances, the high definition presentation remains largely commendable. Viewers will encounter a slight fading in colors, which doesn't quite reach the vibrant saturation synonymous with many Ghibli classics. However, this does not significantly detract from the viewing experience, as the movie still offers a sharp and well-defined image quality, ensuring that the artistic intent and the crystalline clarity of line detail are preserved.
The physicality of the film is commendably captured, maintaining a very natural and filmic appearance that enhances its emotional resonance. This restoration manages to adeptly balance the sharpness of the animation with the intended aesthetic of the film's more stationary backgrounds. Such scenes, expected to be teeming with movement like flickering fire or swirling smoke, are instead presented in a manner that evokes a painterly quality, beautifully rendered in this Blu-ray edition. This technique underscores the film’s thematic focus and artistic value, complementing the narrative’s gravitas rather than diminishing it.
Overall, while this Blu-ray release of "Grave of the Fireflies" may exhibit minor color fading and lacks some of the deep color saturation seen in other productions from Studio Ghibli, it compensates with its exceptional line detail and naturalistic portrayal of the animated world. The release aptly captures the haunting beauty and emotional depth of the film, presenting it in a format that, while slightly imperfect, remains evocative and impactful for viewers.
Audio: 63
The audio presentation of "Grave of the Fireflies" on Blu-ray offers viewers a choice between three DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 mixes, encompassing a newly recorded English track, the original Japanese track, and a 1988 English audio track. The preservation of the movie's auditory legacy falls short with the original English track, where it was disclosed that the original masters are lost, leading to a reliance on a deteriorated duplicate track. This has resulted in noticeable amplitude issues, making it difficult for viewers to discern certain dialogues without straining, alongside other minor defects such as pops and cracks that periodically disrupt the listening experience.
Despite these shortcomings with the 1988 English track, the Blu-ray shines with its presentation of the new English and original Japanese tracks. Both of these options showcase exceptional fidelity, elevating the auditory experience significantly compared to the compromised older English version. The new English track, in particular, is distinguished by its adept use of wide stereo separation, offering a more immersive ambiance that encapsulates viewers within the poignant narrative woven by the film.
Additionally, both the newly recorded English and the Japanese tracks demonstrate commendable dynamic range, providing an auditory clarity that allows for the nuanced conveyance of emotion and atmosphere integral to "Grave of the Fireflies." However, viewers might note a distinct variance in voice work between the two English tracks, reflecting the evolution in dubbing practices and preferences over the years. Overall, while the audio presentation has its flaws, particularly with the historical 1988 English track, the alternative options afford listeners a rich and high-quality experience that complements this cinematic masterpiece.
Extras: 46
The Blu-ray extras for "Grave of the Fireflies" offer a comprehensive peek behind the curtain of this animated masterpiece. The inclusion of the entire movie in storyboard form, presented in high definition, allows enthusiasts to intimately understand the creative process, revealing how initial concepts were visualized. Additionally, the storyboard versions of two deleted scenes offer a glimpse of what could have been, providing insight into the editing process and narrative decisions. The inclusion of the original Japanese trailer adds a nostalgic layer, rounding off a well-curated collection of extras that not only complement the main feature but enhance the overall understanding and appreciation of the film's artistic endeavor.
Extras included in this disc:
- Storyboards for Grave of the Fireflies: The entire movie presented via storyboards.
- Deleted Scene 1 Storyboards: Storyboard version of a deleted scene.
- Deleted Scene 2 Storyboards: Storyboard version of another deleted scene.
- Japanese Trailer: Original trailer for the movie.
Movie: 86
Grave of the Fireflies," Studio Ghibli's 1988 adaptation of Akiyuki Nosaka's semi-autobiographical novel, emerges as a profoundly striking and emotionally stirring portrayal of war through the innocent eyes of two children, Seita and Setsuko. Amidst the backdrop of a war-torn Kobe in the closing days of World War II, the narrative delves deep into the harrowing realities of conflict, transcending the conventional bounds of animated storytelling. The film adeptly captures the juxtaposition of childlike innocence against the brutalities of war, presenting a tonal complexity that vacillates between sheer horror and poignant reflection on the siblings' plight. Their struggle for survival, after losing their mother to a devastating firebombing raid and being let down by a distant aunt, unfolds with a raw intensity, offering an intimate glimpse into the often overlooked civilian struggles during warfare.
Unlike the more familiar dystopian themes prevalent in anime, "Grave of the Fireflies" grounds its narrative in the historical realism of World War II's impact on Japan, setting it apart in the realm of war-themed cinema. Beautifully animated by Studio Ghibli, the film maintains the studio’s renowned artistry yet diverges into darker, more somber territory, delivering a narrative that is as visually captivating as it is emotionally wrenching. Themes of resilience, the fragility of life symbolized by the recurrent firefly motif, and the tragic beauty of nature serve as a haunting counterpoint to the desolation wrought by war.
Remarkably, without divulging its transformative framing device—a narrative choice best discovered firsthand—the film presents an unforgettably poignant exploration of loss and despair, juxtaposed with fleeting moments of tenderness and beauty amidst chaos. This duality propels "Grave of the Fireflies" into the pantheon of not just great war films but also as a masterpiece of animated cinema that challenges and expands the storytelling potential of the medium. Through its heartrending depiction of Seita and Setsuko’s journey, the film leaves an indelible mark, cementing its place as a uniquely profound and emotional examination of the human cost of war.
Total: 62
Grave of the Fireflies" on Blu-ray offers an immersive experience into one of the most poignant anti-war narratives ever produced. The film's ability to weave an emotionally charged story without focusing on the battlefield itself is a testament to its unique narrative strength, aligning it with classics like "Johnny Got His Gun" in its exploration of the devastating impacts of war on the innocent. The portrayal of the central characters, rendered helpless by the war's aftermath, is compelling and heart-wrenching, marking the movie as not just a viewing experience but an emotional journey. The technical aspects of this Blu-ray release further enhance this journey, boasting fine visuals and superior sound quality that amplify the film's expressive and lyrical storytelling.
The Blu-ray presentation captures the essence of the film's stunning animation and its meticulous attention to detail, ensuring that every frame conveys the deep emotional undercurrents of the story. The audio quality complements this visual finesse, creating an immersive atmosphere that draws viewers deeper into the poignant narrative. While the emotional weight of the movie necessitates a supply of tissues, the technical superiority of this release makes it a must-have for both fans of the film and newcomers to this heartrending story.
In conclusion, the Blu-ray release of "Grave of the Fireflies" is highly recommended, not only for its technical excellence but for its ability to present a profoundly moving anti-war story in a remarkably expressive manner. This version stands as an essential addition to any collection, underscoring the film's legacy as a powerful meditation on innocence lost in the chaos of war. With its combination of visual and auditory excellence, this release invites viewers into an evocative narrative journey, leaving a lasting impact long after the screen goes dark.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 80
While this is often an extremely pleasing high definition presentation, the elements here do seem to be just slightly faded at times, without the deep saturation that tends to define a lot of other Ghibli...
Audio: 80
Fidelity on both the new English track as well as the Japanese track is excellent, and the English track especially makes some rather good use of wide stereo separation....
Extras: 50
...
Movie: 90
It routinely floats between the outright horrors of the conflict�things like burned bodies heaped in destitute city streets� and a more elegiac, almost meditative, approach that focuses on Seita's awareness...
Total: 90
This film manages to be as resolutely anti-war as Johnny Got His Gun, with the same general avoidance of actually concentrating on battle that the Dalton Trumbo outing did....
Director: Isao Takahata
Actors: Tsutomu Tatsumi, Ayano Shiraishi, Akemi Yamaguchi
PlotIn the final months of World War II, in Japan, two siblings, 14-year-old Seita and his 4-year-old sister Setsuko, find their lives irrevocably changed by the devastating wartime conditions. After their mother succumbs to severe burns suffered during an American firebombing raid, the children are left to fend for themselves. Faced with the indifference and inability of their distant relatives to provide care, the desperate duo decides to rely on each other to survive. They struggle to find food and shelter, and as society crumbles around them, the harsh realities of war begin to take a toll on their spirit and hopes.
As they move into an abandoned bomb shelter, the siblings create a temporary place of enchantment, with fireflies illuminating their dark world and the natural environment providing a short-lived respite from the brutality of their circumstances. But even as they strive to create moments of childlike innocence, they cannot escape the growing food scarcity and malnutrition that mark the dire nature of life during wartime. The two children navigate a landscape scarred by the consequences of conflict, showing both the resilience of the human spirit and the heartbreaking vulnerability of youth in the face of overwhelming adversity.
Writers: Akiyuki Nosaka, Isao Takahata
Release Date: 26 Jul 1989
Runtime: 89 min
Rating: Not Rated
Country: Japan
Language: Japanese