Among the Living Blu-ray Review

The Blu-ray presentation of "Among the Living," offered by Kino Lorber, showcases a significant enhancement with its AVC encoded 1080p transfer in a 1.37:1 aspect ratio. Particularly for cinephiles familiar with the film's elusive nature pre-internet, this release marks a substantial improvement over previous versions. Historical context aside, the transfer highlights detailed preservation efforts, although not devoid of imperfections. Among these are prominent scratches and nicks, coupled with occasional frame instability and warping that may catch the viewer's eye. Notably, contrast remains largely stable, though blacks can fluctuate between inky and milky, particularly evident during character introductions.

Despite its flaws, the Blu-ray edition impressively elevates detail quality, especially in fabric textures, offering a more authentic viewing experience of this lesser-known cult classic. Grain maintains a natural appearance throughout, indicating a successful resistance to compression artifacts. The intricate detailing and relative stability make it a commendable upgrade from previously available versions. While imperfections persist, primarily due to source material challenges, this presentation stands as a testament to the enduring effort to restore and preserve forgotten cinematic gems.

The Blu-ray release of "Among the Living" presents an English 2.0 Mono DTS-HD Master Audio track. While this audio format offers a clear and precise dialogue reproduction, it is notably constrained by the dated recording technologies inherent to its era. These limitations result in a somewhat boxy aural experience that cannot be entirely alleviated despite the high-definition treatment. The soundtrack, while sufficiently detailed, reveals its age through a brash and occasionally strident quality in musical scoring, likely due to the condition of the preserved elements. Optional English SDH subtitles are provided, enhancing accessibility and comprehension of the film's dialogue.

In terms of character dialogue, the audio presentation effectively allows for a nuanced portrayal of the voices, particularly notable in Dekker's dual role as two brothers. His performance is audibly distinct, capturing varying emotional tones—John's cultured and confident articulation contrasts with Paul's mixture of wonderment and fear, showcasing the range of vocal nuances well-preserved by the mono track. This separation is crucial for conveying the character's psychological complexities, such as Paul's overwhelming experience with ambient noises like nightclub chatter, which adds depth to his disorientation. Although background sounds, such as club noise and environmental effects, are well-rendered, they occasionally compete with dialogue clarity when multiple layers of sound converge.

Overall, the audio track for "Among the Living" maintains professional fidelity within the constraints of its original mono recording. While it may not rival modern multi-channel presentations, its clarity in dialogue and attention to character-specific vocal distinctions contribute meaningfully to the film's narrative delivery.

The Extras section for the Blu Ray of "Among the Living" enriches the viewing experience through detailed insights and supplemental materials. Jason A. Ney's audio commentary provides a comprehensive analysis of the film, exploring Paramount's situation during production and offering extensive background on key figures involved. The commentary serves not just as a guide but also integrates personal research insights, inviting further exploration into related topics, such as the life of Frances Farmer. Additionally, a selection of trailers for other Kino Lorber releases is available, enhancing the historical context of the film within the distributor's catalog. This collection of extras is particularly valuable for enthusiasts interested in the deeper narrative and production nuances of "Among the Living," aligning well with its noir and horror elements.

Extras included in this disc:

• Audio Commentary by Jason A. Ney: Comprehensive discussion on the film's context, including insights into Paramount's situation and key personnel.
• Trailers: Selections from other Kino Lorber releases.

"Among the Living" delivers an intriguing cinematic experience, embedding elements of Southern Gothic and early film noir. Directed by Stuart Heisler, the film capitalizes on its atmospheric dark visuals, with Theodor Sparkuhl's cinematography enveloping the narrative in moody chiaroscuro and German Expressionist influences. This visual flair accentuates the film's exploration of duality and madness through Albert Dekker's impressive portrayal of twins John and Paul Raden. The production supports its genre-blending story with an engaging pace, maintaining tension despite its underdeveloped narrative.

Albert Dekker's dual roles as the upright John and his homicidal twin Paul are the film's primary draw. His skillful contrast between stolid restraint and manic volatility brings depth to a plot centered around madness and identity. Susan Hayward adds a lively presence as a flirtatious woman unknowingly entangled in danger, while Harry Carey's role as a duplicitous doctor injects another layer of intrigue. Frances Farmer’s performance, though limited by screen time, stands out for its nuanced delivery amid a minor role, showcasing her resilience as an actress amidst personal and professional turmoil.

Though positioned as a B-picture for Paramount, "Among the Living" overcomes limitations with brisk pacing and a taut atmosphere. It cleverly blends horror elements with social commentary on mental illness, reflecting society's historical marginalization of such conditions. The film encapsulates themes of secrecy and societal judgment, entwined with the Southern Gothic tradition akin to Poe. Despite some narrative shortcomings, it remains a captivating piece of cinema marked by standout performances and stylistic finesse, appealing to both cult film enthusiasts and classic noir aficionados.

"Among the Living" presents a compelling blend of classic film noir style and Gothic storytelling, engaging audiences with its atmosphere of unease and mystery. Directed by Stuart Heisler, the film provides a fascinating narrative of duality as Albert Dekker masterfully portrays two contrasting characters. This thematic focus on the duality of human nature is paralleled in its exploration of class tensions and mental illness, evident in its nods to literary works such as "Jane Eyre" and Poe stories. Though originally released at an inopportune time just after Pearl Harbor, which affected its commercial success, its unique stylistic elements and gripping plot have gradually earned it a place among cult classics.

The Blu-ray release, while not perfect, offers a significant visual upgrade over previous versions, making it the most accessible copy for legacy cinema enthusiasts. The film's settings enhance its Gothic ambiance – cobwebbed decor and dim lighting juxtaposed with thunderous soundscapes underscore the film's chilling narrative. In addition to the visual impact, the commentary by Professor Jason A. Ney adds depth by contextualizing the film within the larger realm of noir cinema and shedding light on the talents like Frances Farmer and Susan Hayward, who despite their subdued roles, contribute substantially to the film's textured narrative.

In conclusion, "Among the Living" may not have initially captured box office success, but its enigma and rich cultural undertones ensure its enduring appeal. The Blu-ray iteration brings this hidden gem into sharper focus, offering film scholars and noir aficionados an invaluable opportunity to re-evaluate its significance. Recommended for those who appreciate films that challenge social norms and delve into the complexities of human nature.