Carol Blu-ray Review
Score: 68
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
Carol features a touching narrative, exceptional lead performances, and superb technical execution, making its Blu-ray release highly recommended.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 74
Carol's 1080p Blu-ray transfer, sourced from 16mm film, is meticulously detailed and film-like with rich color reproduction, strong black levels, and minimal artifacts. This presentation preserves the movie's intended grainy, period-specific visuals beautifully, maintaining clarity and depth throughout.
Audio: 74
Carol's DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track is meticulously designed, featuring rich instrumental definition and supportive surround work. Ambient effects and pinpoint dialogue clarity immerse the listener, while LFE provides subtle but effective enhancements. Spanish 5.1 Dolby Digital and subtitles available.
Extra: 40
Carol's Blu-ray extras offer a comprehensive behind-the-scenes look through detailed cast and crew interviews, featuring segments on key contributors like Cate Blanchett, Todd Haynes, and Carter Burwell, plus engaging Q&A highlights from various 2015 events.
Movie: 80
Carol dazzles with a compelling narrative, where Mara and Blanchett's performances shine in an evocative 1950s romance. The Blu-ray’s meticulous Super 16 cinematography amplifies the film's period-authentic, grainy texture, and muted color palette. With masterful direction and award-worthy cinematography, Carol encapsulates emotional depth and aesthetic finesse.
Video: 74
The Blu-ray presentation of "Carol" delivers an exquisite 1080p transfer that beautifully encapsulates the film's 16mm origins. The 1.85:1 aspect ratio remains true to the theatrical release, ensuring a rich, film-like aesthetic. The grain inherent to Super 16mm adds texture and depth to the image, enhancing its period feel. Remarkably detailed, the transfer captures every nuance of fabric, from luxurious furs to delicate gowns, and architectural elements like brick and wood with precision. Skin tones are accurately presented, although they tend to warm under specific lighting conditions. The palette, while not overly vibrant, is superbly rendered, with strong yet consistent black levels providing clarity even in shadows. Notably, compression artifacts and film flaws are virtually nonexistent.
From a technical standpoint, the encoding using MPEG-4 AVC ensures a high-quality visual experience. The clarity and detail throughout the film are striking, with each frame offering a lush display of colors and textures. Movements appear smooth and cinematic, showcasing impressive background detail and depth in various scenes, such as intense confrontations. Rich black levels maintain depth but occasionally obscure minor details in darker scenes. However, the minimal loss does not detract significantly from the overall visual experience. Color reproduction stands out as the highlight of this Blu Ray release, offering a vibrant yet controlled presentation that allows individual hues to shine distinctly. Flesh tones remain consistent with a slightly cooler undertone, capturing facial features down to the finest details.
Overall, "Carol" on Blu-ray presents a stunning visual transfer that honors its original filmic quality while providing a refined, artifact-free viewing experience for home audiences. The film's subtle color palette, accurate skin tones, and detailed textures are faithfully reproduced, making this presentation a near-perfect reflection of its theatrical release.
Audio: 74
The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 lossless soundtrack for "Carol" is exceptionally well-crafted, enriching the narrative with a nuanced and immersive auditory experience. Despite being a dialogue-heavy film, the track excels at incorporating ambient sounds and Carter Burwell's haunting score. The front stage features a wide-spanning instrumental definition supported by mild, yet effective, surround work. Each locale within the film is vividly brought to life through a meticulous assortment of ambient noises like city streets bustling, restaurant chatter, and department store clamor. Such attention to detail ensures that audiences are deeply engrossed in the film’s period setting. Dialogue reproduction in this track is flawless, with every line delivered clearly and without a hint of muddiness, firmly anchored in the center channel.
Surround sound presentation is laudable, with rear speakers enhancing ambient effects to create an engaging auditory landscape. This includes the adult public address announcements and elevator music in a department store, which transitions smoothly across the home soundstage. Each component is distinct and well-balanced, from nuanced Foley effects to the pronounced low-frequency extensions such as engines humming and doors closing. The rich layers of sound design ensure viewers can immerse themselves fully within the narrative framework of "Carol". The Blu-ray also includes a Spanish 5.1 Dolby Digital track and offers subtitles in English SDH and Spanish, further supporting accessibility without compromising audio quality.
In summary, "Carol's" audio presentation deftly balances clarity, environmental detail, and musical richness, bringing each scene to life while ensuring dialogue remains precise and intelligible. This orchestration of clean and well-layered elements makes it an exemplary DTS-HD Master Audio track worth experiencing.
Extras: 40
The Blu-ray extras for "Carol" include comprehensive behind-the-scenes featurettes and insightful Q&A sessions with the cast and crew. The "Behind the Scenes Gallery" dives into various aspects of the film's production, presenting interviews with key figures such as Cate Blanchett, Rooney Mara, Director Todd Haynes, and more. Each segment offers in-depth insights, covering performances, costume design, cinematography, screenplay development, and production design. The "Q&A Highlights with Filmmakers & Cast" compile interview clips from several events, including discussions in Los Angeles and New York. The Q&A sessions provide valuable context and elaborate on the filmmaking process. Alongside these featurettes, viewers receive a UV digital copy voucher.
Extras included in this disc:
- Behind the Scenes Gallery: Comprehensive making-of featurettes focusing on different aspects of production.
- Q&A Highlights with Filmmakers & Cast: Highlights from post-screening interviews featuring cast and crew discussions.
Movie: 80
"Carol," directed by Todd Haynes and based on Patricia Highsmith's novel "The Price of Salt," is an intricate and elegant portrayal of a forbidden romance in the 1950s. Cate Blanchett stars as Carol, a sophisticated woman entangled in a turbulent divorce, while Rooney Mara plays Therese, a young department store clerk with dreams of becoming a photographer. Their emotional journey begins with a chance meeting, leading to a deeply nuanced and evolving relationship.
Haynes' film is characterized by its meticulous attention to detail and superb artistry. Shot on Super 16mm film, "Carol" boasts a grainy texture that enhances its period authenticity and emotional intimacy. The muted color palette and soft lighting complement the film's delicate yet emotionally charged narrative. The cinematography by Edward Lachman is most notable, capturing each frame with a blend of warmth and visual poetry that transports viewers to the era with tactile precision and stylistic finesse.
The performances are undeniably the heart of "Carol." Blanchett delivers an expectedly stellar performance, embodying Carol with complexity and grace, while Mara shines remarkably, portraying Therese’s innocence and evolving self-awareness with extraordinary subtlety. The supporting cast, including Kyle Chandler and Sarah Paulson, provides substantial depth to the storyline, reflecting the societal pressures of the time.
The film deftly navigates its central themes without becoming preachy, focusing instead on the impassioned and tender bond between Carol and Therese. Its technical brilliance, along with the compelling performances, make "Carol" not only a significant cinematic achievement but also an emotionally resonant experience that still feels relevant. This Blu-ray edition encapsulates the film’s lush visuals and polished production, making it a must-watch for any cinephile or anyone appreciative of finely crafted romantic drama.
Total: 68
"Carol" is both a visually captivating and emotionally resonant film, directed masterfully to weave a tale of love and life that is both intimate and tragic. The narrative is powerfully driven by the exceptional performances of its lead actresses, who breathe life into their complex characters. The period-specific setting is authentically reproduced, providing a rich backdrop that enhances the overall storytelling and underscores the societal challenges faced by the protagonists. The technical craftsmanship displayed is remarkable, from meticulous production design to an evocative score that captures the era's essence.
Anchor Bay's Blu-ray release of "Carol" is a testament to high-quality home entertainment. The video presentation is superb, offering a crisp and vibrant display that brings the film's carefully composed visuals to striking life. The lossless audio track ensures a pristine sound experience, where dialogue is clear, and the subtly powerful soundtrack is perfectly rendered. The bonus content is notably comprehensive, featuring insightful interviews and detailed discussions about the production process, adding significant value for enthusiasts and film scholars alike.
In conclusion, "Carol" tells a strongly developed and well-characterized story of life and love. The narrative combines harsh realities with tender intimacies, supported by terrific lead performances and amazing technical assemblage. Anchor Bay's Blu-ray release of Carol features standout video and good lossless audio. Supplements are informative. Highly recommended.
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 90
As noted above, the movie is inherently grainy and soft, but details are refined within the image's constraints and context....
Audio: 80
A blaring alarm signals in the back and, with the camera's 180-degree shift moments later, transitions effortlessly in the home soundstage as well....
Extras: 50
Interview clips from several different sit-downs, including a Q&A with Rooney Mara and Screenwriter Phyllis Nagy from Los Angeles, October 22, 2015; a Q&A with Cate Blanchett, Roomy Mara & Director Todd...
Movie: 80
Though it's taken more than six decades, the film has finally earned a screen adaptation and arrives when issues of nontraditional sexuality dominate the headlines and popular culture....
Total: 80
The narrative combines harsh realities with tender intimacies, supported by terrific lead performances and amazing technical assemblage....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
Black levels are strong throughout and details are surprisingly good, despite the fact that the movie is shot on Super 16....
Audio: 80
Despite the movie being one that focuses so heavily on the spoken word, the rear speakers are used more often than you might suspect – not only to enhance Composer Carter Burwell's haunting score, but...
Extras: 20
This bonus is made up of the following: an October 22, 2015 Q&A with Rooney Mara and Screenwriter Phyllis Nagy in Los Angeles, moderated by Deadline Awards Columnist Pete Hammond; an October 10, 2015 Q&A...
Movie: 80
As noted numerous times in the bonus features of this release, this is one of the few stories that Highsmith ever wrote (she's best known for Strangers on a Train and The Talented Mr. Ripley) that wasn't...
Total: 60
Given what transpires here, I'm not sure how rewatchable the movie is, but that doesn't stop me from giving it a hearty recommendation – particularly if you're a fan of period pieces and either (or both)...
Why So Blu?Read review here
Video: 90
Some of the depth and spacing on display is pretty impressive, especially a moment where Carol confronts someone with a gun, the way the display and camera movements come together....
Audio: 100
Low Frequency Extension: Engines humming, doors closing, shoes clip clopping and even a gun firing are some of the effects that get a good jump from the LFE.Surround Sound Presentation: Rear speakers provide...
Extras: 60
Behind the Scenes Gallery (HD, 35:56) – A full on making of look at the film with cast and crew interviews focusing on different aspects, split into segments; “Cate Blanchett”, “Rooney Mara”, “Todd Haynes,...
Movie: 90
Not to mention that the camera in this film absolutely loves her and makes a portrait of her every frame and movement....
Total: 90
This Blu-ray has an absolutely marvelous looking display of picture and sound while giving you a rich vault of interviews from cast and crew on various subjects of the film’s production....
Director: Todd Haynes
Actors: Cate Blanchett, Rooney Mara, Sarah Paulson
PlotIn 1950s New York, a young aspiring photographer named Therese Belivet works in a department store where she meets an elegant and sophisticated older woman named Carol Aird. Carol is in the midst of a difficult divorce and custody battle for her young daughter Rindy. The chance meeting sparks a connection between the two women, leading to an invitation for Therese to visit Carol's home. As they grow closer, their friendship begins to evolve into something more profound, forcing both women to confront their feelings and the societal constraints around them.
Carol's estranged husband, Harge, becomes suspicious of her relationship with Therese and uses it against her in their custody negotiations. Simultaneously, Therese navigates her personal relationships and career ambitions as she grapples with her romantic feelings for Carol. The mounting pressures from family, society, and their personal lives challenge the intensity and future of their bond.
Writers: Phyllis Nagy, Patricia Highsmith
Release Date: 15 Jan 2016
Runtime: 118 min
Rating: R
Country: United Kingdom, France, Australia, United States
Language: English