Monsieur Hire Blu-ray Review
Score: 79
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Monsieur Hire Blu-ray offers a Hitchcockian thrill with standout technical quality and insightful extras, essential for any film enthusiast.
Disc Release Date
Video: 86
The 1080p Blu-ray of 'Monsieur Hire', derived from a 4K scan of the 35mm original, offers an exceptional viewing experience with finely resolved textures and an intentionally cool color palette emphasizing greens and blues. This meticulous restoration by Pathé delivers extraordinary clarity, capturing the film's unique visual style with precision.
Audio: 79
Monsieur Hire's DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 track delivers a subtle sound design with a clear dialogue and evocative Michael Nyman score. While environmental effects enhance the cinematic experience, forced English subtitles accompany the original French audio, maintaining the film's artistic intention.
Extra: 64
Engaging extras include an amusing interview with Director Patrice Leconte and Star Sandrine Bonnaire, subtitled in English, where their separate insights interweave charmingly. Wade Major's audio commentary expertly deciphers the film’s Hitchcockian nuances, offering a deeper understanding of visual storytelling and character dynamics.
Movie: 89
Monsieur Hire's Blu-ray by Cohen Media Group offers engaging commentary and interviews providing profound insights into Georges Simenon's 1933 novel's adaptation nuances. The film artfully integrates elements of suspense and tragedy, while subtly addressing themes of social marginalization and antisemitism, with a compelling power play between characters.
Video: 86
The Blu-ray presentation of "Monsieur Hire" by Cohen Film Collection, utilizing a 1080p AVC encoded transfer in the 2.40:1 aspect ratio, offers an impressive visual experience rooted in meticulous restoration work conducted by Pathé in 2020. This transfer maintains a cool tonal palette with a deliberate emphasis on green and blue hues, often resulting in almost desaturated scenes. These artistic choices, as noted by Director Patrice Leconte in accompanying supplements, are reflective of the film's thematic undertones. Some sequences shift toward warmer, yellow tones that contrast with the predominantly muted, wintry visuals, creating a visually compelling narrative journey.
Shot on 35 mm film with Panavision cameras utilizing anamorphic lenses, "Monsieur Hire" benefits from a 4K scan of the original camera negative, expertly restored by Pathé and CNC in Paris. The transfer excels in clarity and detail, capturing every nuance of Michel Blanc’s and Sandrine Bonnaire’s performances with precision. The grain is finely resolved and managed adeptly in this encode, attributed to Hiventy's commendable restoration efforts. Notably, the bleach bypass process employed by Cinematographer Denis Lenoir lends a distinctive contrast to the image while subtly desaturating colors, which is accurately reproduced here.
Despite the inherent coldness in its visual style, the presentation serves as a testament to the film's cinematic intent, enveloping viewers in its uniquely stylized aesthetic. While a 4K Ultra HD release might allow for further enhancement, the current Blu-ray offering is as close to exceptional as 1080p can achieve, showcasing Pathé’s mastery in restoration and faithfully preserving the film's visual artistry.
Audio: 79
The Blu-ray of "Monsieur Hire" features an immersive DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 track in the original French, delivering a soundscape that is both subtle and effective. Michael Nyman’s evocative score plays a pivotal role in setting the film's mood, and it maintains a refined presence throughout the presentation. The audio track ensures that dialogue is rendered with exceptional clarity, allowing viewers to fully engage with the narrative. Environmental sound effects, such as the memorable thunderstorm scene, are artfully integrated, highlighting the meticulous sound design without overshadowing the primary focus on the characters and their interactions.
The audio offering is presented in French 2.0 mono DTS-HD Master Audio, reinforcing the film’s quiet yet compelling ambience. The mix prioritizes character-driven elements, with the environmental sounds serving as a subtle backdrop that enhances rather than detracts. While English subtitles are non-optional, which may not appeal to all viewers, they ensure accessibility without compromising the overall auditory experience.
Overall, this release masterfully captures the restrained yet impactful sound design intended for "Monsieur Hire," creating an engaging and authentically immersive experience for the audience.
Extras: 64
The extras on the "Monsieur Hire" Blu Ray provide enriching insights, expertly balancing technical analysis and engaging commentary. The new interview with director Patrice Leconte and star Sandrine Bonnaire offers a lively and humorous exchange, even though the duo was interviewed separately. Leconte's playful persona shines through, adding a layer of charm. Wade Major's audio commentary broadens viewers' understanding of the film's narrative and visual intricacies. Drawing comparisons between Julien Duvivier's "Panique" and Leconte's rendition, he meticulously dissects the Hitchcockian approach in "Monsieur Hire," highlighting storytelling through visuals over dialogue. Major's insights into costuming color codes and characters' non-verbal communication provide a deeper understanding of the film's subtleties, transforming a casual viewing into a comprehensive narrative exploration.
Extras included in this disc:
- New Interview with Director Patrice Leconte and Star Sandrine Bonnaire: An engaging discussion highlighting the film’s creation.
- Monsieur Hire Trailer: A brief teaser offering a glimpse into the film.
- Audio Commentary by Wade Major: Comprehensive analysis enhancing understanding of narrative techniques and visual details.
Movie: 89
"Monsieur Hire," directed by Patrice Leconte, stands as a compelling exploration of Georges Simenon's 1933 novel, "Les Fiançailles de M. Hire." This film adaptation draws viewers into a nuanced narrative that gracefully intertwines themes of marginalization and societal otherness. Leconte skillfully navigates the rich source material, eschewing overt references to the Jewish heritage of the protagonist, Hire, portrayed with enigmatic depth by Michel Blanc. Instead, the film elevates Hire as a universally marginalized figure within "polite" society, much like in the earlier adaptation, "Panique" by Julien Duvivier.
The film adeptly balances its thriller elements with complex character dynamics, notably in the tense interplay between Hire and Inspector (André Wilms), which is depicted as a cerebral cat-and-mouse game. This dynamic forms the crux of the narrative, where layers of suspicion unfurl, entwining Hire’s voyeuristic tendencies and his incapacity to forge ordinary relationships with women—an aspect intricately depicted through his fascination with Alice (Sandrine Bonnaire). The narrative's progression is marked by a suspenseful omniscient perspective that enriches the unfolding drama, especially highlighting how Hire's and Alice's lives intersect in an unexpectedly precarious manner.
Leconte elevates a conventional ménage à trois into a complex array involving Hire, Alice, Émile (Luc Thuillier), and the Inspector, crafting a narrative tension that crescendoes toward inevitable tragedy. The blurring of victim and perpetrator roles adds depth to the film’s psychological layers. Wade Major's commentary enhances understanding of these intricate themes and the unique cinematic techniques employed by Leconte—including the arresting final scenes which mirror more contemporary works like "Men." Consequently, "Monsieur Hire" remains a stimulating exploration of identity and exclusion, executed with Leconte's characteristic precision and atmospheric flair.
Total: 79
"Monsieur Hire" on Blu-Ray presents a captivating viewing experience that rivals classic Hitchcockian suspense while offering its own unique narrative flavor. The film masterfully combines psychological tension with a depth that some viewers might find even more unsettling than traditional Hitchcock thrillers. The protagonist is portrayed with complexity, inviting both empathy and discomfort—a testament to the film's distinctive impact. The Blu-Ray release is commendable for its exceptional technical quality, offering crisp visuals that illuminate the film's original aesthetic. While the lack of optional subtitles is a minor drawback, the overall presentation remains compelling.
The newly mastered version by Pathé stands as a monumental improvement over previous standard definition formats. This edition reveals the film's visual depth and artistic intention more vividly than ever before, immersing audiences in the richly detailed world crafted by director Patrice Leconte and cinematographer Denis Lenoir. Additionally, the supplemental materials featuring insightful commentary from Wade Major and other extras enhance the viewer's understanding and appreciation, making it a well-rounded package for cinephiles.
In conclusion, this Blu-Ray edition of "Monsieur Hire" is an essential acquisition for any serious film collection. The meticulous restoration brings new life to a cinematic gem, ensuring that its haunting narrative and visual beauty can be fully appreciated. Despite the absence of subtitles, the release's strengths far outweigh this minor limitation. Enthusiasts of nuanced suspense cinema will find this offering from Cohen Media Group and Kino Lorber to be both indispensable and highly recommended.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 90
The film begins with a brief text card announcing the restoration in 2020 done by Path� in 4K. This is a pretty stunning looking transfer a lot of the time, though it is intentionally on the cool side...
Audio: 80
The film's sound design isn't especially baroque, though there are occasional nice bursts of sound effects, as in the big thunderstorm where Alice finally sees Hire spying on her....
Extras: 50
New Interview with Director Patrice Leconte and Star Sandrine Bonnaire (HD; 38:41) is a lot of fun, and has been edited so that the two (who were apparently interviewed separately) are often commenting...
Movie: 90
As Wade Major gets into, the Jewish element doesn't necessarily mean observant in a religious sense, but at least culturally, and with a suggestion that this Jewishness is overt enough that making Hire...
Total: 90
Monsieur Hire is touted both in some reviews and on Wade Major's commentary track as "Hitchcockian", but while it does offer some of the psychological suspense that Hitchcock's films often did, along with...
The Digital Bits review by Stephen BjorkRead review here
Video: 95
Lenoir employed a bleach bypass process to enhance the contrast while slightly desaturating the colors, and that stylized palette has been reproduced accurately for this transfer....
Audio: 90
It’s a quiet mix, with the environmental sound effects always playing second fiddle the main characters, who always remain front and center both visually and aurally....
Extras: 85
As the film progresses, Major points out the ways that Leconte uses the visuals to convey story details rather than dialogue, noting how the changing colors of the costuming is coded to indicate the shifting...
Movie: 95
Hire’s Jewish heritage is only referenced obliquely in Leconte’s film, and while it’s still easy to read the way that he’s treated by others as being antisemitic, this version of Hire is more of a universal...
Total: 91
Both of these extras are particularly insightful, so they’re a nice addition to this package from Cohen Media Group and Kino Lorber....
Director: Patrice Leconte
Actors: Michel Blanc, Sandrine Bonnaire, Luc Thuillier
PlotIn a dreary French apartment complex, Monsieur Hire, a reclusive and peculiar tailor, becomes the subject of neighborhood suspicion when a young woman is found murdered nearby. His aloof demeanor and solitary habits make him an easy target, but his secret world revolves around a more personal obsession. Hire spends his evenings peering through his window into the apartment across the courtyard, where his beautiful neighbor, Alice, lives. He observes her with a mix of longing and fascination, creating an intimate yet one-sided connection with her life, unbeknownst to Alice herself. As police scrutiny on Hire intensifies due to the murder investigation, his voyeuristic ritual with Alice continues to draw him deeper into a complex web of emotion and intrigue.
Meanwhile, Alice is entwined in her own complicated relationship with her boyfriend, Emile, who remains oblivious to the attention of their quiet neighbor. The mounting tension around the unsolved crime stirs chaos in this small community where everyone is under heightened suspicion. As Monsieur Hire's secluded world begins to unravel, questions of trust, motive, and human connection come to the forefront. Underneath the layers of mystery and deception, secrets are poised to disrupt lives as both Hire and Alice grapple with unexpected revelations that could change everything. Through the tension of an unresolved murder and covert obsession, themes of isolation and yearning unfold amidst the ordinary backdrop of urban life.
Writers: Georges Simenon, Patrice Leconte, Patrick Dewolf
Release Date: 01 Jun 1990
Runtime: 81 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: France
Language: French