The Diary of Anne Frank Blu-ray Review
50th Anniversary Edition
Score: 58
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Anne Frank's film is a timeless masterpiece, deeply moving with its human tale, now impressively released on Blu-ray. Highly recommended.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 50
The Diary of Anne Frank's Blu-ray transfer is faithful but flawed, with intermittent pops and grain, yet offers decent detail and depth, lacking the HD wow factor compared to other classics.
Audio: 45
The Blu-ray's DTS-HD MA 5.1 soundtrack enhances clarity and dialogue while lacking rear-channel and bass impact, preserving the film's nuanced soundscape and tension.
Extra: 81
The 50th anniversary Blu-ray of 'The Diary of Anne Frank' dazzles with a rich array of supplements, blending historical insights, technical filmmaking details, and emotional anecdotes, underscoring Fox's commitment to preserving and enhancing classic films.
Movie: 86
Fox's Blu-ray release of 'The Diary of Anne Frank' excellently captures the tragic yet inspiring story of two Jewish families hiding during WWII, honored by Oscars.
Video: 50
"The Diary of Anne Frank" arrives on Blu-ray sporting a 1080p, 2.35:1-framed transfer, showcasing an effort to balance authenticity with the limitations of its source material. Right from the outset, viewers will notice a range of imperfections typical of older film stock, including pops, white speckles, and a variable grain field. These flaws, though not constant, remind us of the film's age and original filming conditions. Despite these artifacts, several scenes manage to convey impressive details—rainwater on a hat or the textures of curtains—with a clarity that varies across the board. Some portions of the imagery veer towards softness or slight blurriness, particularly in the background and around the edges, but central elements often retain a commendable level of sharpness and detail. The presence of a consistent, albeit slight, grain adds a film-like texture, enhancing the viewing experience by maintaining the movie's original aesthetic feel.
However, when drawing comparisons to the 2004 DVD release and other classic films upgraded to Blu-ray, this version of "The Diary of Anne Frank" reveals its shortcomings. The HD transfer, likely sourced from the same master used for the DVD, exhibits only marginal improvements in clarity, black levels, and contrast. Despite these enhancements, it falls short of the visual splendor achieved by other titles in Fox's catalogue. Imperfections from the original transfer persist, including minor blemishes and faint vertical lines. Scenes exhibit uneven grain distribution, occasionally detracting from the viewing experience. Yet, close-ups reveal a striking level of detail unseen in previous versions, showcasing vivid textures and contrasts.
Moreover, the depth achieved in black tones and the nuanced grayscale add a dramatic dimension to the cinematography, underpinning both tension and tenderness with visual finesse. The occasional appearance of edge enhancement is noted without the overuse of digital noise reduction (DNR), preserving filmic integrity. This Blu-ray edition portrays an earnest attempt to honor the original film through its transfer, yet it also underscores a missed opportunity for a more polished restoration that might have offered a definitive high-definition experience. Through its preservation of detail and commitment to authenticity, it represents a valuable addition to any collection but leaves room for future endeavors to fully realize the classic's visual potential.
Audio: 45
The audio presentation of "The Diary of Anne Frank" on Blu-ray, featuring a DTS-HD MA 5.1 lossless soundtrack alongside an excellent Dolby Digital 4.0 mix, delivers a sound experience that is mostly competent yet leaves a bit to be desired in terms of immersive audio depth and dynamic range. The 5.1 track, although a step up from the DD 4.0 mix in clarity and the removal of age-related imperfections such as pops and hisses, does not fully exploit the potential of its lossless upgrade, particularly in terms of surround sound engagement and low-end punch during critical sequences. The front-heavy mix results in a soundstage that, while clear, particularly in the reproduction of dialogue, does not significantly enhance the viewing experience beyond what was available in the 2004 DVD release.
The film's sound design plays a crucial role, with silence often serving as a powerful narrative tool amidst the tension-filled atmosphere of the attic hideout. Sound effects, from the subtle to the startling—such as distant sirens, footsteps, and the eerie calm before a bombing raid—are rendered with finesse, creating moments of palpable suspense. However, the soundtrack's musical components, specifically Alfred Newman's Oscar-nominated score, lack consistency in their impact. While certain sequences benefit from well-rounded bass and clear orchestration, others fall short, missing the visceral impact necessary to fully complement the on-screen drama, particularly during sequences meant to be underscored by powerful auditory cues.
In conclusion, while the audio presentation is clean and free of technical flaws, with dialogue consistently clear and certain sound effects meticulously crafted to enhance the narrative tension, it does not fully embrace the opportunities afforded by the 5.1 lossless format. The absence of robust rear-channel use and somewhat underwhelming low-frequency effects during key scenes means that, although solid, the track functions more as a serviceable enhancement to the film rather than a transformative audio experience.
Extras: 81
The Blu-ray release of "The Diary of Anne Frank" enriches the viewing experience with an extensive suite of extras that offers a deep dive into the film's creation and its historical context. Central to these materials is an insightful audio commentary by George Stevens, Jr. and actress Millie Perkins, providing nuanced details about the real-life events, set design, and filming techniques. Additional standout features include a range of documentaries such as "George Stevens in WWII," which showcases rare color war footage, and "The Making of 'The Diary of Anne Frank': A Son's Memories," offering personal recollections from Stevens, Jr. Actresses Millie Perkins and Diane Baker share poignant memories of their time on set in another featurette, supplementing the package’s historical richness. The extras do not shy away from the technical aspects, with discussions on sound design and Alfred Newman’s score, alongside a variety of featurettes, press conferences, screen tests, and an interactive press book gallery. These components collectively enhance the Blu-ray, highlighting Fox’s commitment to preserving the legacy of classic cinema.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary: By George Stevens Jr. and Millie Perkins.
- George Stevens in WWII: Rare color footage from WWII.
- The Making of 'The Diary of Anne Frank': A Son's Memories: Stevens Jr.'s reflections.
- 'The Diary of Anne Frank': Memories from Millie Perkins and Diane Baker: Cast recollections.
- Shelley Winters and 'The Diary of Anne Frank': Interview excerpts with Shelley Winters.
- The Sound and Music of 'The Diary of Anne Frank': Focus on the film’s score.
- 'The Diary of Anne Frank': Correspondence: Reading of significant letters.
- Fox Movie Channel Presents: Fox Legacy with Tom Rothman: Studio retrospect.
- The Diary of Anne Frank: Echoes from the Past: Comprehensive documentary.
- 'George Stevens: A Filmmaker's Journey' Excerpt: Spotlight on George Stevens’ career.
- George Stevens Press Conference: Pre-production insights.
- Millie Perkins Screen Test: Early footage of Perkins.
- Fox Movietonews Clips: Compilation of historical clips.
- Behind-the-Scenes Gallery: Collection of images from the set.
- Interactive Pressbook Gallery: Digital version of original pressbook.
- Theatrical Trailers: Both American and international trailers.
Movie: 86
Fox's Blu-ray presentation of "The Diary of Anne Frank" brings George Stevens' emotionally stirring, Oscar-nominated film into the homes of contemporary viewers with remarkable clarity and reverence. This cinematic adaptation of Anne Frank's poignant diary - a document of her life in hiding during the Nazi occupation of Amsterdam - excels as a heartfelt reenactment of one of history's most harrowing personal narratives. It adeptly captures the claustrophobia, tension, and fleeting moments of joy experienced by the Frank and Van Daan families in their secret annex. The film's technical achievements are especially noteworthy; despite its confined setting and reliance on dialogue-driven storytelling over physical action, it demonstrates compelling cinematography, making substantial use of its limited space to draw audiences into the characters' secluded world.
The meticulous reconstruction of the annex, alongside stellar performances by a cast led by Millie Perkins (Anne), Joseph Schildkraut (Otto Frank), and Shelley Winters (Petronella Van Daan), whose role earned her an Oscar, paints a vivid picture of life under constant threat. The interaction among characters, infused with realism and depth, reflects the varying dynamics of family life, adolescence, and survival under extreme conditions. Notably, the film doesn't shy away from showcasing the strain and despair that occasionally fissured relationships within the tight-knit group, providing a balanced narrative that acknowledges both the strengths and vulnerabilities of the human spirit in the face of adversity.
George Stevens' direction ensures that the film remains faithful to its source material while employing cinematic techniques that enhance the story's emotional impact without overshadowing its authentic essence. His restrained approach, focusing on subtle shifts in mood and perspective, imbues the film with a timeless quality that transcends its historical setting. Despite debates over casting choices and narrative pacing, "The Diary of Anne Frank" stands as a poignant testament to hope, resilience, and the indomitable nature of the human spirit. Its ability to resonate with audiences, even years after its initial release, underscores not only its artistic merit but also its enduring significance in memorializing one of the darkest chapters of human history through the lens of personal struggle and endurance.
Total: 58
"The Diary of Anne Frank" emerges on Blu-ray as an indelible classic, transforming its heartbreaking narrative into an immersive experience that transcends typical cinematic triumphs. Its ability to convey the profundity of human resilience and spirit amidst the darkest chapters of history is unmatched, ensuring its esteemed position within the realm of classic cinema. The release by 20th Century Fox, commemorating the film's 50th anniversary, showcases a respectful and adept handling of the material, providing a quality of picture and sound that, while may not dazzle with modern high-definition expectations, greatly enhances the viewing experience over prior DVD editions. Coupled with an extensive array of special features, this edition secures its must-have status for cinephiles and historians alike.
Director George Stevens' meticulous approach to "The Diary of Anne Frank" pays off in a production that remains sensitive, yet evocative, a touching tribute to its young heroine whose legacy continues to inspire. The Blu-ray presentation carefully balances the authenticity and gravity of Anne's story with the technological enhancements available, resulting in a product that respects the source material’s integrity while offering a palpable improvement for contemporary audiences. The special features accompanying this release further enrich viewers’ understanding and appreciation, rendering it a comprehensive package worthy of the film's monumental impact.
In conclusion, this 50th anniversary Blu-ray edition of "The Diary of Anne Frank" is an essential addition to any collection, admirably serving as both a testament to Anne Frank's enduring spirit and a reminder of cinema's power to captivate and communicate profound truths. It showcases the painstaking efforts of 20th Century Fox to honor this unforgettable story with a presentation that, while subtly upgraded, respects its historical and emotional essence, solidifying its recommendation not just as a film, but as an experience that continues to resonate deeply with audiences worldwide.
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 80
Most of the blurry imagery appears in backgrounds and on the sides of the frame, but center-frame objects generally take on a fairly sharp, clear, detailed appearance....
Audio: 70
Sound effects, too, play nicely enough in context; whether the heavy clanking of soldiers' boots on the streets below the loft, the screaming siren attached to a vehicle rolling by, or explosions heard...
Extras: 90
The Diary of Anne Frank': Echoes from the Past (480p, 1:30:07) is another of the excellent documentaries that accompany many of the classic Fox releases, this one recalling both the film and the actual...
Movie: 100
Driven by the power of its story and the performances of its actors, particularly Joseph Schildkraut as Anne's father, Otto, The Diary of Anne Frank excels from the first frame to its last, with the film's...
Total: 90
A film that cannot be watched but only experienced, The Diary of Anne Frank stands apart from its peers as one of the most powerful and moving pictures in memory, its story one of the greats that reflect...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 60
Although grain is present throughout, some scenes (and some cutaways within scenes) display a heavier layer than others, and the patchiness becomes slightly annoying over time....
Audio: 60
Some well-rounded bass infuses the music with good weight, but during the bombing raid, low-end frequencies don't possess the necessary heft to make the sequence realistic....
Extras: 80
Featurette: "The Making of 'The Diary of Anne Frank': A Son's Memories" (SD, 25 minutes) – Another excellent featurette, this reminiscence by Stevens, Jr. uses clips, stills, and storyboard sketches to...
Movie: 80
At just under three hours, 'The Diary of Anne Frank' is a long film; occasionally it drags, but much of it is riveting, and that's due in large part to Stevens' marvelous visual sense, the fine performances...
Total: 80
Though the video and audio don't take full advantage of the high-def format, they're still a nice improvement over the previous DVD transfers, while the terrific supplemental package alone makes this 50th...
Director: George Stevens
Actors: Millie Perkins, Shelley Winters, Joseph Schildkraut
PlotIn Nazi-occupied Amsterdam, a Jewish teenage girl named Anne Frank and her family go into hiding to escape persecution. Along with another family, the Van Daans, and a dentist, Mr. Dussel, they take refuge in a secret annex behind her father's business premises. The reality of their situation is grim - they must remain silent during the day to avoid detection, rely on outside help for food and news, and grapple with the constant fear of being discovered. Despite the ever-present danger and the cramped living conditions, Anne's youthful spirit and imaginative mind flourish. She begins to document her experiences, thoughts, and the dynamics within the secret annex in her diary, offering a poignant and insightful perspective on the human condition during such a harrowing time.
As days turn into months, the group's initial solidarity starts to fray under the strain of confinement and the stress of their precarious existence. Personalities clash, resources become increasingly scarce, and the tangible threat outside their hidden door looms larger with each passing day. Yet, in the midst of despair, Anne finds solace in her burgeoning relationship with Peter Van Daan, the teenage son of the other family. Their friendship evolves into a tender first love, providing a glimmer of hope and normalcy against the backdrop of war and the encroaching harshness of reality. Through her writing, Anne captures the essence of their shared human experience, embodying a spirit of resilience and an unwavering belief in the goodness of people despite the surrounding horrors.
Writers: Frances Goodrich, Albert Hackett, Anne Frank
Release Date: 17 Apr 1959
Runtime: 180 min
Rating: Approved
Country: United States
Language: English, German