The Bat Whispers Blu-ray Review

The Blu-ray presentation of "The Bat Whispers" offers three distinct versions of the film across two discs, utilizing the AVC codec. The set features the U.S. and British full-frame versions in 1.32:1, alongside the Magnifilm widescreen version, originally restored from 2.00:1 65mm prints, presented in a 1.85:1 format. This widescreen version stands out due to its superior grayscale consistency and richer, more vibrant contrast levels, which elevate the atmospheric tension and enhance the film's suspenseful elements. Notably, this version's darker, haunting black levels contribute to a formidable portrayal of the titular Bat, whether visible or concealed.

In contrast, both the U.S. and UK 1.32:1 versions exhibit varied image qualities. The brighter appearance of these full-frame cuts sometimes lacks the finer detailing seen in the Magnifilm transfer. However, specific scenes benefit from improved delineation, highlighting the intricate production design as a character in itself. A notable difference is in the British version, which is intermittently marred by vertical lines; although faint and infrequent, they can occasionally be distracting. While all three transfers have experienced some level of de-graining or filtering, edge definition and texture clarity remain admirably preserved.

Overall, this diverse collection of film cuts provides viewers with an opportunity to explore different aesthetic qualities and contrast levels inherent in each version. These elements collectively enhance and affect the viewing experience, allowing audiences to appreciate the historical significance and visual presentation of "The Bat Whispers" from multiple cinematic perspectives.

The audio presentation of "The Bat Whispers" on Blu-ray is delivered through uncompressed LPCM 2.0 mono tracks across all film versions. These tracks provide a solid representation of the original sound design, achieving a balance between preserving historical authenticity and offering clarity. Dialogue remains clean and intelligible, ensuring the narrative's flow is uninterrupted by audio artifacts. While the sound effects retain a vintage quality, characteristic of early cinematic audio with their canned and tinny qualities, they effectively enhance the atmospheric ambiance of the film's "old, dark house" setting.

Some technical elements contribute to both strengths and minor challenges in the audio experience. The audio mix is notably effective, maintaining dynamic musical support that complements the film's eerie tone. However, reviewers have noted the presence of soft air hiss, particularly noticeable in later reels. This hiss is generally benign and does not significantly detract from the listening experience but may be slightly more pronounced during quieter scenes. Additionally, there are slight synchronization issues reported in the U.S. full frame version, primarily in the first third of the movie, which can momentarily disrupt viewer immersion.

Overall, the audio presentation on this Blu-ray release maintains a commendable fidelity to the source material while maximizing clarity and effectiveness within the constraints of its historical production context. It achieves a suitable balance for audiences seeking both an authentic and engaging auditory experience.

The Blu-ray of "The Bat Whispers" offers a comprehensive collection of extras that enhance the viewing experience for cinephiles and historians alike. The included content provides a nuanced look at different versions and adaptations of the film, with detailed comparisons highlighting the technical differences across formats. Notably, the audio commentary by Mick LaSalle brings a critical lens, though opinions might provoke mixed reactions from viewers. The restoration features illustrate the diligent craftsmanship involved in preserving cinematic history, while the engaging photo gallery adds a nostalgic visual touch. Overall, these extras not only enrich understanding but also celebrate the legacy of "The Bat" adaptations.

Extras included in this disc:

• US vs UK Version Comparisons: Split-screen montage highlighting notable scene differences between US and British versions.
• US 1.32:1 vs Widescreen Version Comparisons: Comparison of 1.32:1 and widescreen formats.
• The Bat (1959) with Vincent Price: Full film included starring Vincent Price.
• The Bat (1926) vs The Bat Whispers: Scene comparisons between the 1926 original and 1930 remake.
• The Bat (1926) Before & After Restoration: Featurette showcasing restoration efforts.
• Photo Gallery: Animated display of posters, production stills, and other visual memorabilia.

"The Bat Whispers," directed by Roland West, is a noteworthy 1930 pre-Code adaptation of Mary Roberts Rinehart and Avery Hopwood's stage play, "The Bat." It stands as a pioneering piece of early sound cinema, offering audiences a compelling, if dated, mystery-thriller. This Blu-ray release intriguingly features three distinct cuts: two in 1.32:1 aspect ratio for the US and UK with subtle variations and a 1.85:1 US widescreen version showcasing innovative use of widescreen technology for its time.

The narrative centers on a menacing thief known as The Bat, whose escapades include thefts and murders that baffle the police. The setting is a tension-filled mansion belonging to Cornelia van Gorder, unknowingly harboring stolen bank money targeted by The Bat. Rollicking through secret rooms and elongated shadows, the story interlaces suspense with comedic elements, although some slapstick moments misfire. West's direction employs creative techniques such as dolly shots and expressionistic lighting, enhancing the atmospheric tension and cinematic experience.

The acting is a mixed bag, with top-billed Chester Morris delivering a somewhat rigid performance as Detective Anderson, which diminishes his character's potential sympathy. Gustav von Seyffertitz portrays Dr. Venrees with a puzzling accent but maintains an enigmatic quality crucial to the plot’s mystery. Grayce Hampton provides a resolute portrayal as Cornelia van Gorder, while Una Merkel and William Bakewell offer chemistry as young sweethearts embroiled in the convoluted narrative. Comic relief attempts by Maude Eburne, Spencer Charters, and Charles Dow Clark introduce vaudevillian antics that occasionally overstay their welcome. Nevertheless, despite its uneven elements, "The Bat Whispers" remains a significant historical artifact of early sound cinema, meriting attention for its innovative cinematic approaches and intriguing story foundation.

The Blu-ray release of "The Bat Whispers" by VCI stands as a significant effort in film restoration, highlighting a largely overlooked classic from the early sound period. Historically relevant, as it remains one of only two widescreen American films from that era, Roland West's masterpiece has been carefully brought back to life. The Blu-ray package includes three different cuts of the original film, along with its 1959 remake featuring Vincent Price, demonstrating VCI's dedication to preserving cinematic history despite the constraints of smaller budgets and resources.

This extensive two-disc set features a presentation that, while not without its imperfections, presents a commendable visual and auditory experience. The video quality might have some minor issues, but they are overshadowed by the impressive historical context and the care evident in its production. The uncompressed audio serves as a strong complement, ensuring the film’s eerie atmosphere remains intact. Additionally, the bonus features are well-curated, providing substantial added value for film enthusiasts and scholars alike.

In conclusion, VCI's Blu-ray release of "The Bat Whispers" is an essential acquisition for those passionate about classic cinema and restoration work. It is a testament to the label's commitment to doing justice to the films it acquires. Collectors and historians should support such efforts by investing in this release, facilitating further restorations and enabling a deeper appreciation of our cinematic heritage. This set not only preserves an important piece of film history but also affirms that, despite resource limitations, remarkable preservation efforts can still emerge.