The Plot Against Harry Blu-ray Review

The Blu-ray release of "The Plot Against Harry" delivers a visually engaging experience through its AVC encoded image, presented in a 1.85:1 aspect ratio. The transfer is based on a new 4K restoration specifically crafted for the 2023 theatrical re-release. This technical upgrade ensures the film's visual elements are stunningly clear and sharp, maintaining the documentary-flavored style typical of New York cinema from the 1970s while avoiding the pitfalls of sloppiness or distracting softness. Skin details and costume textures highlight the nuanced character portrayals, and both interior and exterior scenes showcase impressive depth, enhancing the overall narrative immersion.

Visual fidelity is further refined with crisp whites and deep blacks, which robustly define Robert M. Young's black-and-white cinematography. The grain is competently resolved, adding a layer of authenticity without overwhelming the viewer. Though sourced material does present minor flaws such as some scratches and occasional jumpy frames, these imperfections are minimal and do not detract significantly from the viewing experience. Overall, the high-definition transfer allows images to truly come alive, making this release a valuable addition for aficionados of classic cinema, particularly those who appreciate the meticulous restoration process that underscored this edition's creation.

The Blu-ray audio presentation of "The Plot Against Harry" features a 5.1 DTS-HD MA mix that primarily emphasizes a frontal auditory experience. Dialogue clarity is a highlight, effectively capturing the nuance of character interactions and the lively atmosphere of crowd scenes. Musical elements receive commendable treatment in terms of instrumentation, although the low-end spectrum remains largely unchallenged. An English DTS-HD MA 2.0 option is available, preserving the original mono mix and serving those who prefer a classic audio profile.

Interestingly, the 5.1 surround mix, not mentioned on packaging, seems to have been developed for a recent theatrical re-release. While usually preferable to maintain original mixes for dialogue-centric films, this new remix subtly enhances without overwhelming with directional ambience. It maintains a front-focused approach, but the added spatial dimension contributes to a more naturalistic feel for the film. This aligns well with the narrative's demands, despite occasional muffling and warble issues that appear unsalvageable. For those needing accessibility aids, there is also an available subtitle option: English SDH.

Overall, the audio presentation's restrained enhancements and clear dialogue delivery offer an engaging, authentic experience that aligns well with the film’s character-driven storytelling.

The Blu-ray extras for "The Plot Against Harry" provide an insightful deep-dive into the film's history and creative process, focusing largely on interviews and discussions with director Michael Roemer. The material spans pivotal moments from the film’s belated world distribution in 1990 to its recent re-release in 2023, offering a rich perspective on its intriguing journey. The highlight is the 2005 conversation between Roemer and producer Robert M. Young, offering a thorough exploration of their dynamic and the film's production challenges. The 2023 Q&A session adds further depth, although marred by subtitle errors. Overall, the extras are technically well-executed and provide substantial content for aficionados of the director's work.

Extras included in this disc:

• Booklet: Essays and an introduction providing context by noted critics.
• Audio Interview: 1990 discussion at Cannes with Roemer.
• Making the Movie: 2005 interview with Roemer and Young.
• Q&A: 2023 discussion post-screening in New York.
• Newly Created Trailer: Promo for the 2023 theatrical re-release.

The Plot Against Harry presents a fascinating cinematic rediscovery narrative. Originally shot in 1969, this film directed by Michael Roemer initially faced a muted reception and an early shelving after a brief release in 1971. Resurrected in the late '80s, the film found new life through festival circuits, gaining critical acclaim for its unique portrayal of a criminal's struggle. With Martin Priest portraying Harry, Roemer crafts a fast-paced exploration of personal and professional chaos, marked by nuanced performances and an authentic portrayal of underworld pressures and familial revelations.

Despite being labeled a comedy, the film offers a subtler form of humor, woven intricately with Harry’s bewildering attempts to reconcile his criminal endeavors with newfound family responsibilities. After serving prison time, Harry attempts to regain control over his faltering criminal enterprise and reconnect with an estranged family he previously neglected. The narrative cleverly balances Harry's oscillations between legal and illegal pursuits, further complicated by health concerns and relentless societal demands. It’s a study in disorientation, capturing Harry’s efforts to navigate relationships within the vibrant social circles of New York City.

Roemer populates his narrative with non-traditional actors, enhancing the film’s naturalistic style and authentic tone. This approach offers a glimpse into the life of small-time racketeering entwined with personal rediscovery. Particularly noteworthy are performances by Ben Lang and Margo Solin, providing layers of complexity and charm to their interactions with Harry. The film’s unrepentant Jewish humor complements its narrative style, contributing to its perception as a precursor to modern works by Albert Brooks and Larry David. A must-watch for its originality and historical cinematic value, The Plot Against Harry stands as an absorbing artifact deserving recognition beyond its initial obscurity.

"The Plot Against Harry," directed by Michael Roemer, is a cinematic gem that expertly captures the nuances of community and personal struggles. Roemer creates an immersive atmosphere as he delves into various Jewish communal settings, effectively pulling viewers into the heart of Harry's tumultuous journey. The narrative, driven by a well-crafted script, deftly balances humor and tension without lingering excessively on any single theme. The film’s strength lies in its capacity to portray extraordinary turmoil and guilt through richly developed characters, with Martin Priest delivering a standout performance as the multifaceted protagonist, Harry.

Initially shelved for nearly two decades due to perceived comedic shortcomings, "The Plot Against Harry" now finds resonance with an audience familiar with today's character-focused dramas such as "The Bear." This film evokes more smiles than laughter as it subtly unfolds its story, yet it captivates from the very beginning with its relatable characters and authentic world-building. Priest’s natural charm keeps viewers engaged, portraying the misadventures of Harry with remarkable ease and depth.

The Film Desk has done an exemplary job with the Blu Ray restoration, ensuring pristine visual quality that honors Roemer’s vision. The packaging matches the content in excellence, offering an aesthetically pleasing presentation even in editions lacking the limited slipcover. In conclusion, "The Plot Against Harry" is a vivid, personality-rich exploration of character conflict and existential reflection, deserving of its newfound appreciation and high recommendation.