The Kite Runner Blu-ray Review
Score: 64
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
The Kite Runner film shines brilliantly, yet its extras lack depth; high-end home cinema gear elevates the viewing experience.
Disc Release Date
Dolby TrueHD
Video: 64
The Kite Runner's Blu-ray offers a beautifully sharp and realistic HD transfer, praised for its vivid colors and detailed scenes despite minor CGI and noise reduction flaws.
Audio: 68
The Kite Runner's Dolby TrueHD soundtrack excels in clarity, authentic dialogue, and enchanting score, with precise sound effects and balanced bass, offering an immersive audio experience.
Extra: 47
The disc's extras, in both SD and HD, offer insights into the film's adaptation and production, with a focus on Afghan culture, though lacking broader educational scope on Afghanistan.
Movie: 80
The Kite Runner, a tale of redemption amid Afghan turmoil, contrasts violence with friendship's bond and ethnic divides, captured in stunning 1080p.
Video: 64
DreamWorks' 2.35:1 MPEG-4 AVC High Definition transfer of "The Kite Runner" on Blu-ray showcases a beautiful widescreen presentation that breathes life into the cinematically rich and emotionally compelling narrative. The video's pristine quality, devoid of blemishes, dirt, or unwanted digital noise reduction (DNR), upholds a high standard of visual authenticity, complete with a natural film grain that enhances its cinematic feel. The attention to detail is evident in the meticulous preservation of fine textures and complexions, contributing to a presentation that's both attractive and stylized. Despite these high points, the video presentation is not without its minor flaws. Instances of softness occasionally permeate the picture, attributable more to the original filming techniques than the transfer process itself. Similarly, the use of CGI, particularly in the kite-flying sequences, while ambitious, introduces a slightly artificial layer to an otherwise convincingly realistic setting.
The Blu-ray edition excels in rendering colors with impressive fidelity, striking a balance between vibrant hues and realistic tones that enhance the visual storytelling. The cooler color temperature does not detract from the solidity and depth of the image, especially during scenes capturing the distinct hues of Peshawar and the textured landscapes of Afghanistan. Although blacks are generally deep, contributing to the film's dynamic contrast, they occasionally fall short of perfection, showing limitations in scenes lacking three-dimensional depth or exhibiting flatness in darker sequences. However, these occurrences are few and do not significantly mar the overall viewing experience.
While close-up shots ooze with detail, revealing subtle textures and expressions that lend a tangible quality to the characters and their environments, there is a consensus among videophiles that there's room for improvement regarding shadow detail and nighttime scene presentation. Despite these technical critiques, including a less than ideal choice for subtitle font and color, "The Kite Runner" Blu-ray delivers an engaging visual experience. Its portrayal of breathtaking landscapes and intricate human emotions is deeply enhanced by high definition intricacies and a careful balance between artistic intention and technical execution.
Audio: 68
The Dolby TrueHD 5.1 soundtrack provided with "The Kite Runner" Blu Ray is a masterclass in audio clarity and authenticity, primarily delivered in Dari and elegantly subtitled in English. Focused on leveraging the centre channel for dialogue, the vocal performances are rendered with such fidelity that they imbue a sense of presence, as if the actors were conversing directly in the listener’s space. This precise capture of vocal timbres, combined with an astutely managed soundstage across the front channels, highlights both the spoken word and the beautifully intricate score by Alberto Iglesias. While the rear channels are less utilized, their selective engagement during key scenes like kite competitions and bustling street life enriches the auditory experience without overwhelming the central narrative elements.
The mix excels at blending dialogue, music, and environmental sounds into a cohesive auditory journey that extends well from the screen and into the room, courtesy of its Dolby TrueHD encoding. Noteworthy is the sonic layering during scenes enriched by traditional Afghan instrumentation and compositions by Ahmad Zahir, Ehsan Aman, and Sami Yusaf, contributing to a sound that ranges from very good to excellent. The sound effects—be it the rustle of nylon kites or the ambient hustle of crowded markets—are detailed and contribute significantly to the auditory depth of the movie. Mid-range levels are robustly represented, ensuring that each nuance, from lower-toned dialogues to the midbass of urban ambiences, is felt with clarity and depth without overpowering the delicate balance of the film’s score and natural soundscapes.
Bass response and LFE channels, though not excessively pronounced, provide a solid foundation adding subtle emphasis when necessary, enhancing the overall emotional and atmospheric impact of key moments. The mix’s ability to maintain this delicate balance is commendable, ensuring that even amidst complex layers of sound, there's no loss of detail or dilution of impact. The craftsmanship involved in capturing and reproducing the rich acoustic environment of "The Kite Runner" makes its audio presentation not just a technical achievement but an essential part of the storytelling process, delivering an listening experience that is as compelling as the visual narrative.
Extras: 47
The Blu-ray extras for "The Kite Runner" deliver a decent, though not groundbreaking, array of supplementary material, primarily ported over from the DVD release but still managing to add value through the insights they offer. The standout is undoubtedly the audio commentary with director Marc Forster, author Khaled Hosseini, and screenwriter David Benioff, who discuss not only the technical and cultural aspects of the film's production but also illuminate the improvisational nature of the acting and the post-production magic that brought the kite flying scenes to life. Despite some initial hesitancy, their commentary evolves into an engaging narrative that, albeit heavily focused on the novel, offers intriguing tidbits about the adaptation process and the challenges of shooting in various locations. The visual extras, including featurettes on the making of the film and Hosseini's personal reflections, coupled with a public service announcement and the film's theatrical trailer in HD, round out the package. However, a missed opportunity lies in deepening the exploration of Afghanistan's complexities beyond what's presented.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary: Insight by Marc Forster, Khaled Hosseini, and David Benioff.
- Words from The Kite Runner: A featurette on the novel and screenplay adaptation.
- Images from The Kite Runner: Behind-the-scenes look at film production.
- Public Service Announcement with Khaled Hosseini: Remarks about Afghanistan.
- Theatrical Trailer: The film's cinematic trailer in HD.
Movie: 80
"The Kite Runner," presented in a stunning 1080p Blu-ray format, stands out as a profoundly moving cinematic adaptation of Khaled Hosseini’s bestselling novel. Crafted with an eye for detail and a deep understanding of human emotions, the film navigates through the complexities of friendship, betrayal, and redemption against the tumultuous backdrop of Afghanistan's history. The visuals are crisp, enhancing the contrast between the vibrant yet strife-torn streets of Kabul and the serene, hopeful landscape of California, effectively supported by a masterful Dolby TrueHD 5.1 audio track that immerses viewers in the narrative's emotional depth and cultural richness.
At the heart of this epic journey are the intertwined lives of two young boys, Amir and Hassan, whose friendship is tested by societal divides and personal failures. Portrayed with remarkable sensitivity by Zekeria Ebrahimi and Ahmad Khan Mahmoodzada respectively, their relationship encapsulates the innocence of childhood amidst the harsh realities of ethnic discrimination and political turmoil. The film's shift from the innocent pleasures of kite flying to the harrowing realities of Afghan politics and successive waves of occupation is rendered with an authenticity that brings Hosseini’s characters vividly to life. The kite flying scenes, symbolic of the characters' aspirations and guilt, are particularly memorable, showcasing the director’s ability to blend visual storytelling with thematic depth.
What makes "The Kite Runner" a compelling watch on Blu-ray is not just its technical superiority but also its unflinching portrayal of a country's socio-political landscape through personal stories of love, loss, and atonement. Director Marc Forster navigates these narratives with a deft hand, ensuring that each frame resonates with the emotional gravity of the story being told. The performances, especially by the child actors, are understated yet powerful, capturing the essence of Hosseini’s characters and their journeys. This version not only magnifies the film’s visual and auditory appeal but also its poignancy and relevance, making "The Kite Runner" an unforgettable experience that extends beyond the screen into the conscience of its audience.
Total: 64
The release of "The Kite Runner" on Blu-ray by DreamWorks stands as a testament to the powerful adaption of Khaled Hosseini's novel, delivering a visually stunning and emotionally gripping experience. The film itself, lauded as an instant classic, captivates with its brilliant storytelling and masterful cinematic execution. It's a rare gem that resonates deeply, promising to draw viewers back time and again. While the film's adaptation receives high praise for preserving the novel's essence and delivering an impactful narrative, the Blu-ray presentation complements this with excellent visual quality and crisp audio that does justice to the scenic beauty and the engaging soundtrack of the film, enhancing the overall viewing experience.
However, it's not without its shortcomings. The extras included in the Blu-ray edition leave much to be desired, presenting a missed opportunity to deepen the understanding and appreciation of this complex narrative and its cultural backdrop. This aspect may slightly mar an otherwise exceptional package, but it does not detract significantly from the richness that the film itself offers. It’s worth noting that the viewing experience is greatly enhanced when paired with high-quality audiovisual equipment, such as the JVC DLA-RS20 1080p High Definition Front Projector and the accompanying high-end audio setups, guaranteeing an immersive cinematic experience at home.
Conclusively, "The Kite Runner" on Blu-ray is highly recommended for its impeccable on-screen adaptation, superb visual, and audio quality, despite falling short in its supplementary offerings. This release not only allows viewers to revisit Hosseini’s compelling narrative in a visually rich format but also highlights the stark contrasts between cultures and eras depicted in the film. Whether or not one is familiar with the novel, this Blu-ray edition offers a valuable addition to any collection, inviting repeated viewings to fully appreciate the depth and nuances of this extraordinary story.
avforums review by AVForumsRead review here
Video: 90
There is some obvious use of CGI, especially in the kiting scenes and admittedly whilst it's not great, it doesn't significantly deter from the overall enjoyment, which is astonishingly good....
Audio: 90
The timbre and tone of the vocals are virtually spot-on and along with the clarity you would swear that the actors were standing in the same room as you when they speak....
Extras: 60
The locations and settings are varied and it's just as interesting a view upon the interesting cultures they were surrounded by....
Movie: 90
As humans we all do wrongs and make mistakes, but it's not the mistakes that count; it's what we do to try put them right which eventually makes us even more humane....
Total: 80
Still, it's not something I can overly criticise the film for, but I must detract marks for a missed opportunity to complete the package....
Blu-ray.com review by Greg MaltzRead review here
Video: 70
Another nit to pick, though not directly related to picture quality, is the font and color of the subtitles, which appear a bit amateur....
Audio: 90
The music of the score, crowd noises, dialog and halftime speech by a local Taliban chief (Mohamad Amin Rahimi) are solidly mixed and deliver a palpable experience, drawing in the listener--so much so...
Extras: 40
For example, Benioff comments that one of the actors speaking in Dari is not adhering to the script and therefore the English subtitles are not the real translation....
Movie: 80
Rarely can a film transport an audience to the other side of the world in a multidimensional way that contrasts the past and the future, the old world and the new and ultimately injustice with justice....
Total: 80
After a tough day at work, I sometimes treat myself to one of my favorite restaurants, The Afghan House, here in Silicon Valley not far from where the protagonist of The Kite Runner lives....
AVSForumRead review here
Video: 90
Images are firmly resolved with dynamic contrast and a near infinite level of depth that is impressive during the film’s many long range camera shots....
Audio: 82
Envelopment was readily apparent during the kite flying competition and some of the crowded street sequences which contained a mixture of ambient and discrete directional sounds that filled the listening...
Extras: 50
Commentary with Marc Forster, Khaled Hosseini, and David Benioff Words from Kite Runner – 14 minute featurette Images from Kite Runner – 24 minute featurette Public service announcement from Khaled Hosseini...
Movie: 80
Amir and Hassan become separated, and as first the Soviets and then the Taliban seize control of Afghanistan, Amir and his father escape to the United States to pursue a new life....
Total: 76
Marantz DV7001 Universal Disc Player Denon AVR 5308CI THX Ultra 2 Preamp/Video Processor B&K Reference 200.7 Series 2 seven Channel amplifier Philips TSU9400 Pro Series Touch Panel Remote Control Canton...
Director: Marc Forster
Actors: Khalid Abdalla, Ahmad Khan Mahmoodzada, Atossa Leoni
PlotIn Kabul, Afghanistan, during the late 1970s, two young boys, Amir and Hassan, form a close yet complicated friendship. Amir is the son of a wealthy merchant, while Hassan is the son of Amir’s father’s servant. They share a bond over kite flying, with Amir competing in kite-fighting tournaments and Hassan serving as his loyal kite runner, retrieving the kites Amir cuts down. Their relationship is tested by the harsh realities of the caste system, personal jealousy, and a violent incident that changes their lives forever. The societal divisions and personal betrayals set the stage for a story about guilt, redemption, and the lengths one will go to for forgiveness.
Years later, Amir, now an adult living in the United States, receives a call that compels him to confront his past. With Afghanistan under Taliban rule, the country he once knew is drastically changed, and he must navigate these dangers to atone for his childhood missteps. This journey is not just about facing external threats but also about an inner quest for redemption, as Amir seeks to forgive himself and heal the deep wounds inflicted by his actions and inactions during childhood. Through this personal odyssey, the narrative explores themes of friendship, loyalty, betrayal, and the possibility of redemption against the backdrop of Afghanistan’s turbulent history.
Writers: David Benioff, Khaled Hosseini
Release Date: 11 Jan 2008
Runtime: 128 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: United Kingdom, China, United States
Language: Arabic, Dari, English, Pashtu, Russian, Urdu