Shin Ultraman Blu-ray Review
Score: 58
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
Shin Ultraman shines with excellent video but suffers from lossy audio and limited extras, yet remains a must-see for fans needing English options.
Disc Release Date
Video: 68
Shin Ultraman's Blu-ray presentation features an AVC encoded 1080p transfer with commendable sharpness yet feels flat due to its eclectic camera usage, including iPhones. Despite the impressive CGI, it suffers from lossy Dolby Digital audio without the expected lossless or Dolby Atmos enhancements, unlike its Japanese 4K counterpart.
Audio: 68
Shin Ultraman's Blu-ray audio presentation features a disappointingly compressed Dolby Digital 5.1 mix that falls short of the desired lossless quality. While lacking a Dolby Atmos track, the surround mix is still immersive with active channels, decent bass, and satisfying dynamic impact, despite noticeable compression.
Extra: 18
The Blu-ray extras for 'Shin Ultraman' are limited to a stills slideshow and trailers, with noticeable video compression and lossy audio, yet remain a necessary choice for English-speaking fans due to the inclusion of subtitles or dubbing, distinguishing it from Toho’s subtitle-less Japanese releases.
Movie: 67
Shin Ultraman delivers a chaotic blend of nostalgic homage and bold satire, with its all-digital effects offering eccentric visuals but missing Japan's famed practical artistry. Balancing political criticism with bizarre fantasy, it presents a whimsical yet thoughtful update on the kaiju genre, despite technical hiccups in the Blu Ray release.
Video: 68
"Shin Ultraman" is presented on Blu-ray with an AVC encoded 1080p transfer in a 2.39:1 aspect ratio. The transfer showcases a diverse array of cameras used during filming, including the Alexa Amira and even an iPhone, which contribute to a mix in visual quality. The result is a presentation that succeeds in delivering commendable sharpness and detail, although it often appears flat and dimensionless. CGI elements vary in quality, with some sequences reflecting animation giant Khara's influence, imparting a cartoonish appearance at times. While Ultraman's sleek, metallic design limits potential for fine detail, the Kaiju characters feature satisfying texturing. However, issues like occasional green screen anomalies detract from the overall consistency.
The audio offerings are limited to lossy Japanese 5.1 Dolby Digital and English 5.1 and 2.0 Dolby Digital tracks with optional English subtitles, disappointing those expecting a higher fidelity experience akin to the Japanese 4K Ultra HD version's Dolby Atmos track. Despite the lossy compression, the 5.1 mix remains effective, providing an active surround environment and satisfactory bass levels. Shirô Sagisu's score enhances the auditory experience, echoing themes from his "Evangelion" work. Although the mix lacks surround channels compared to its theatrical IMAX release, it manages to deliver decent dynamic impact and contributes to the film's engagement.
Visually, the digital shoot's varied methods create inconsistencies in definition and sharpness, particularly due to certain angles captured on smartphones. A distinct digital softness pervades most frames, coupled with occasional artifacting and noise issues. Despite this, the Blu-ray showcases a vivid color palette that accentuates the warm flesh tones and contrasts beautifully with the colorful beam attacks and explosions. Deep black levels are maintained effectively, although dimensionality fluctuates throughout the presentation.
Audio: 68
The audio presentation of the "Shin Ultraman" Blu-ray is a mixed bag, predominantly hindered by the reliance on lossy Dolby Digital 5.1 tracks for both the Japanese and English versions, with an additional English 2.0 track. While the DTS or Dolby Atmos formats would have been preferable, particularly given the film’s theatrical IMAX release, the provided tracks manage to capture the action-driven essence of the film adequately. Despite this, there remains noticeable room for improvement regarding channel separation and fidelity, crucial for capturing immersive surround experiences.
Surprisingly, the audio mix, though compressed, delivers effective surround activity with active rear channels and substantial bass presence during monster action sequences. Shirô Sagisu's score adds a notable weight to the soundtrack, borrowing elements from his previous work on "Shin Godzilla" and "Evangelion." The sound elements in this mix balance dialogue, action beats, and monster roars effectively, though the audio lacks the vibrancy and spatial clarity audiophiles might expect from a higher-quality lossless track.
Overall, while "Shin Ultraman" showcases a decent audio experience given its limitations, the decision to omit a lossless format is perplexing. It leaves a discernible gap in maximizing the home viewing atmosphere for those accustomed to more dynamic and immersive offerings seen in similar releases. This shortfall is further highlighted by the non-translation of on-screen text—a concern given the film's reliance on textual narration in certain sequences.
Extras: 18
The Blu-ray release of "Shin Ultraman" by Cleopatra Entertainment includes limited supplemental content. It features basic extras, primarily consisting of trailers and a brief slideshow. While the inclusion of English subtitles and dubbing makes it an appealing option for international Ultraman fans, the technical quality of the extras is subpar, with noticeable video compression and lossy audio quality. This may be somewhat disappointing for viewers expecting more comprehensive or high-quality bonus features. However, given the rarity of subtitle-supported releases for this title, this offering remains a crucial acquisition for dedicated fans, albeit with several significant drawbacks.
Extras included in this disc:
- Trailer: A promotional video for "Shin Ultraman".
- Slideshow: A brief gallery of still images.
- Additional Trailers: Trailers for other releases by Cleopatra Entertainment.
Movie: 67
"Shin Ultraman," the latest entry in the Shin Japan Heroes Universe, integrates elements of vintage and modern Japanese pop culture, making it an intriguing blend for both long-time fans and new viewers. Ultraman, traditionally seen as Japan's televised superhero since the 1960s, is reimagined within this film, which merges its iconography with narrative depth. The movie intriguingly splits into three episodes, gradually escalating stakes from national to global threats. While maintaining reverence for the original TV series, the film navigates between whimsical fantasy and biting political commentary. Notably, it critiques Japan's post-WWII defense policies and portrays backroom negotiations for nuclear armament amidst threats from kaiju, adding philosophical undertones atypical of its genre.
Visually, "Shin Ultraman" delivers a peculiar mix of CGI and gonzo practical effects—choices that reflect a lunatic yet somewhat unkempt aesthetic. This results in a unique viewing experience that sometimes struggles with cohesion but ultimately embraces its eccentricity. The decision to employ all-digital monster effects, while enabling stunning creative leeway, detracts slightly from the nostalgic physical effects that fans might expect from a series stalwart in practical sets and costumes. Nevertheless, director Shinji Higuchi's stylistic choices underscore a commitment to maintaining a singular tone that distinguishes itself from Western comic adaptations. The CG rendering cleverly mimics practical folds of a suit, maintaining an homage to the show's roots amidst the visual spectacle.
"Shin Ultraman" broadens its scope beyond mere kaiju battles, engaging with political themes and international tensions, especially with pointed critiques of the U.S.'s opportunistic stance towards alien technology. Though it remains deeply embedded in fantastical elements, the film’s social critique embeds a level of sophistication not always expected in this genre. Despite its occasionally convoluted plotlines and gratuitous emotional hooks, this incarnation of Ultraman forges a daring narrative path that juxtaposes Japan's political landscape with a vibrant kaiju spectacle.
Total: 58
"Shin Ultraman" on Blu-ray offers a compelling blend of modern reinterpretation and nostalgic homage, making it intriguing even for those who aren't die-hard fans of the original series. The film's narrative is both wild and expressive, serving as a playful yet incisive commentary on Japanese politics, showcasing a creative approach to the cherished franchise. The technical presentation of this Blu-ray displays generally excellent video quality, accentuating the film's dynamic visuals. However, a significant drawback lies in the audio department; Cleopatra Entertainment opts for lossy audio, which undermines the powerful and bombastic soundtrack critical to the full viewing experience.
The disc's supplemental content is minimalistic, comprising mainly of a brief stills gallery and trailers. Cleopatra Entertainment appears constrained by limited resources, as evidenced by the lack of substantial extras commonly expected in modern home media releases. Additionally, the international audience faces a language barrier since Toho's Japanese releases do not support English subtitles. Consequently, Cleopatra’s Blu-ray becomes a vital option for Ultraman enthusiasts requiring English subtitles or dubbing, yet it comes with notable compromises.
In conclusion, despite its shortcomings in audio fidelity and bonus features, "Shin Ultraman" on Blu-ray is a recommended purchase for fans and newcomers alike. The film itself offers a satisfactory viewing experience with visually arresting elements. While the audio limitations may detract from some aspects, the availability of English subtitles and dubbing remains crucial for non-Japanese speakers, solidifying its place as an essential addition to any Ultraman collection with some reservations.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 80
The fact that Ultraman is so sleek and metallic deprives images of him from offering any substantial fine detail, but that is counterweighed by some good texturing on some of the Kaiju as well as good...
Audio: 60
I've been on my own little soapbox about how head scratching it is that Cleopatra doesn't include lossy audio on its Blu-ray releases, and that's only more of an issue with a film like this which exploits...
Extras: 10
...
Movie: 70
Ultraman is, however, just the latest "update" to be offered by the so-called Shin Japan Heroes Universe, a rather interesting concatenation of four former (and maybe in other contexts continuing) competitors...
Total: 70
I actually got a kick out of Shin Ultraman, even though I was never that big of a fan of the original series and have certainly not kept up with the manifold other offerings in the franchise....
The Digital Bits review by Stephen BjorkRead review here
Video: 80
Unlike Shin Godzilla, where Anno opted for a retro 3.1 mix with no surround channels, Shin Ultraman does have a full surround soundtrack—although this 5.1 version is the bare minimum, since Ultraman was...
Audio: 80
Unlike Shin Godzilla, where Anno opted for a retro 3.1 mix with no surround channels, Shin Ultraman does have a full surround soundtrack—although this 5.1 version is the bare minimum, since Ultraman was...
Extras: 35
So, Cleopatra’s disc is still recommended for ardent Ultraman fans who want the subtitles or the dubbing, but with some major caveats....
Movie: 60
document.getElementById('cloak629e4ade272adbd5f443bf4ed4f0fbef').innerHTML = ''; var prefix = 'ma' + 'il' + 'to'; var path = 'hr' + 'ef' + '='; var addy629e4ade272adbd5f443bf4ed4f0fbef =...
Total: 64
So, Cleopatra’s disc is still recommended for ardent Ultraman fans who want the subtitles or the dubbing, but with some major caveats....
DoBlu review by Matt PaprockiRead review here
Video: 60
Colorful beam attacks show the greatest contrast, blindingly bright, including the resulting explosions too....
Audio: 80
The stereo split is the stronger one, used liberally to the extent of the 2.35:1 visual frame....
Extras: 20
...
Movie: 80
While allowing for creative leeway and wow factor, it’s also disappointing to not see Japan’s physical effects prowess, especially in a project that calls for it....
Total: 60
...
Director: Shinji Higuchi, Ikki Todoroki
Actors: Takumi Saitô, Masami Nagasawa, Hidetoshi Nishijima
PlotGiant, mysterious creatures known as "Kaiju" suddenly appear in Japan, wreaking havoc and destruction. The government forms the S-Class Species Suppression Protocol (SSSP), a special task force intended to combat these formidable threats. As the team, led by seasoned officer Kimio Tamura, struggles to counteract the overwhelming power of the Kaiju, a luminous giant clad in silver appears from the sky. This extraordinary being, later referred to as Ultraman, swiftly defeats one of the monstrous invaders, saving countless lives and leaving humanity to speculate about its origins and intentions. Team member Shinji Kaminaga, an efficient but enigmatic strategist, catches interest in Ultraman’s repeated interventions and raises questions about the entity's connection to these terrestrial events.
As society grapples with the presence of both Kaiju and Ultraman, the team intensifies its investigation under growing pressure. As conversations about diplomacy and defense escalate, international interests get involved, each hoping to exploit Ultraman's presence for their own gain. Meanwhile, the arrival of another extraterrestrial, Zarab, complicates the already tense situation, with intentions that aren't immediately clear. As Zarab sends humanity deeper into chaos and manipulation unfolds on several fronts, the SSSP must deduce whom to trust. With the fate of the Earth hanging in balance, alliances are tested and secrets unveiled, leaving the team racing against time to find a solution amid a web of evolving threats. Through mounting adversities, they must align with Ultraman’s mysterious agenda or find themselves isolated against insurmountable odds.
Writers: Hideaki Anno, Eiji Tsuburaya
Release Date: 13 May 2022
Runtime: 118 min
Rating: N/A
Country: Japan
Language: Japanese, English, Russian