Russian Ark Blu-ray Review
Русский ковчег Russkiy kovcheg
Score: 54
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
A bravura technical and artistic masterpiece, 'Russian Ark' seamlessly intertwines 300 years of Russian history in an artistically potent single 96-minute shot.
Disc Release Date
Video: 45
The Blu-ray of 'Russian Ark' showcases a pioneering 1080p/AVC MPEG-4 transfer, though early HD recording technology results in noticeable banding, chroma noise, and occasional false contouring. Despite these technical anomalies, the improved clarity, richer color, and exquisite detail provide a significant upgrade from the DVD.
Audio: 65
The uncompressed LPCM 2.0 track on 'Russian Ark' provides impressive stereo separation, clear dialogue, and an enveloping sound design that enhances the film's theatrical artifice. Despite post-production dubbing issues, the music and sound effects create an immersive, spacious audio experience.
Extra: 36
The 'In One Breath' documentary offers a detailed examination of the ambitious one-shot, one-day production of 'Russian Ark,' with extensive interviews and on-set footage chronicling the technical and logistical challenges faced, including the director's three failed takes before final success. The trailer is also provided in 1080i with LPCM 2.0 sound.
Movie: 81
Russian Ark's stunning single-take Steadicam shot effortlessly blends technical prowess with artistic grace, offering an immersive journey through 300 years of Russian history within the Hermitage museum, enhanced by meticulous production design and ethereal storytelling that elevates its historic and cultural narrative.
Video: 45
The Blu-ray presentation of "Russian Ark" showcases the film's groundbreaking use of early high-definition digital video, captured with the Sony HDW-F900 camera at 24 fps, a technology equally notable for its use in "Star Wars: Episode II". From a technical standpoint, the Blu-ray transfer to a 1080p/AVC MPEG-4 format with a 1.78:1 aspect ratio reveals both the advancements and limitations of early digital filmmaking. The transfer does improve on the previous DVD release by offering richer colors and better clarity, though it retains a natural softness inherent in the original capture.
However, several technical anomalies accompany these improvements. Frequent banding and digital chroma noise, particularly noticeable in color gradients and darker scenes, hint at the limitations of the 8-bit digital source. Additionally, despite delivering pleasing detail through fine textures and production design, the image sometimes appears soft when compared to modern standards. The color palette transitions from warm to cool tones effectively but vivid splashes of color can occasionally struggle against inconsistent black levels and faded shadows.
While "Russian Ark" remains a visually stunning film, pushing the boundaries of digital filmmaking in its time, the Blu-ray transfer reflects some unavoidable artifacts and digital anomalies from its early HD recording methods. Yet this presentation is still a marked improvement over earlier formats, providing a richer viewing experience even with its technical quirks.
Audio: 65
The audio presentation of "Russian Ark" on Blu-ray is distinctly characterized by its Russian LPCM 2.0 track, which delivers a remarkably immersive experience despite being limited to two channels. Given that all the film's sound was added in post-production, there is a noticeable misalignment between dialogue and lip movements. However, this dubbing lends a unique theatrical quality that complements the film's overall atmosphere. The clarity of dialogue and narration is robust, although native Russian speakers may occasionally find overlapping and mumbled lines challenging to follow—mitigated thankfully by the well-executed English subtitles.
This uncompressed Linear PCM 2.0 track excels in creating a wide and spacious soundscape, delivering impressive stereo separation and a sense of depth that enhances the film’s world. Incidental sounds such as wind, birds, footsteps, and ambient background chatter are meticulously rendered, contributing to an enveloping and immersive ambiance. The film's score and various classical music selections, particularly during the climactic ballroom scene, are beautifully reproduced with strong clarity and range, further enriching the cinematic experience. While bass activity is minimal, its absence is appropriate given the film's artistic focus on delicate sound elements rather than aggressive low frequencies.
Extras: 36
The Blu-ray extras for "Russian Ark" are a treasure trove for film aficionados, offering comprehensive insights into its groundbreaking single-take production. The centerpiece, "In One Breath," is a detailed making-of documentary, presented in upscaled 1080i with LPCM 2.0 audio, which methodically documents the intricate one-day shoot and the dedication required to complete it in a single take after three failed attempts. Extensive interviews with the director, cinematographer, and cast provide a fascinating look into the various challenges faced during the production, including lighting, costume preparation, and historical context.
Extras included in this disc:
- In One Breath: An exhaustive behind-the-scenes featurette detailing the film's intense single-day shoot.
- Trailer: Official trailer presented in SD format.
Movie: 81
Alexander Sokurov's 'Russian Ark' is an extraordinary cinematic accomplishment, filmed in a single uninterrupted 96-minute take. This unparalleled technical feat seamlessly blends the thematic and logistical elements, offering an immersive guided tour through 300 years of Russian history. The narrative is presented through the eyes of an unseen narrator, who drifts ghost-like through the Hermitage Museum in St. Petersburg. Cinematographer Tilman Büttner’s Steadicam work captures the intricate choreography required for the film's real-time exploration. His fluid movements enhance the ethereal, dreamlike atmosphere, making each transition from one era to the next feel organic and mesmerizing.
Setting the entire film within the Hermitage allows for breathtaking visuals of its vast art collections and baroque architecture, reinforcing the museum as a symbolic ark of Russian cultural heritage. The narration, delivered by Sokurov himself, guides the viewers through opulent scenes featuring historical figures like Peter the Great, Catherine the Great, and Nicholas II. These vignettes are not only visually stunning but also contextualize Russia's rich history and its tumultuous past. The periodic intrusions of The European (Sergey Dreyden), a figure based on Marquis de Custine, provide an external perspective that critiques and praises Russian culture, adding a layer of introspective tension to the viewing experience.
The meticulous production design and period-accurate costumes—crafted for the film's 2,000-strong cast—are impressive in their attention to detail. Despite the complex logistical challenges, Sokurov’s innovative use of digital filmmaking extends beyond mere technical bravado; it fosters a profound connection between the audience and Russian history. The unbroken shot draws viewers into an intimate, real-time experience, enhancing both the narrative's mystery and its vivid portrayal of cultural continuity. Ultimately, 'Russian Ark' stands as a monumental artistic achievement that transcends its technical prowess to deliver a compelling and lavish journey through Russia’s cultural essence.
Total: 54
"Russian Ark" on Blu-Ray is an unparalleled cinematic experience, immortalizing a 96-minute single take that navigates seamlessly through 300 years of Russian history. The film's one-shot construction is not just a technical marvel but an artistically profound element that enhances its dream-like narrative. This unique storytelling method melds beautifully with the lush depiction of Russian culture, creating an immersive, almost phantasmagoric experience that captivates viewers from start to finish.
Visually, the Blu-Ray transfer is solid, though not without minor artifacts, likely reflective of the limitations of early digital cinematography. Nevertheless, these issues do little to detract from the overall visual splendor. The audio, delivered in a robust 2.0 mix, complements the visual experience, enriching the viewer’s immersion into this historical journey. The disc includes a single supplement—a making-of documentary—offering deep insights into the complex logistics and choreography required to bring such an ambitious project to fruition.
Tour de force is an overused descriptor when it comes to cinema, but if it applies anywhere, it applies to "Russian Ark", a bravura piece of filmmaking that marries technical achievement with artistic insight into the soul of Russian culture. Despite a few picture quality issues that may originate from the source material, this Blu-Ray edition arrives highly recommended. Make sure to watch the included documentary to gain a fuller appreciation of the extraordinary effort behind this one-of-a-kind film.
Blu-ray.com review by Casey BroadwaterRead review here
Video: 60
When it comes to the film's Blu-ray presentation, it's somewhat difficult to tell what picture quality quirks are inherent in the source material, and what may have been introduced in the prepping of this...
Audio: 80
It should come as no surprise that all of the film's audio was dubbed in post-production, allowing Sokurov to give direction on set (and Tilman Büttner to curse whenever he made a slight mistake, as he...
Extras: 60
In One Breath (SD, 43:41): An exhaustive making-of documentary about the film's intense single-day, single-shot production, which took four tries to complete....
Movie: 90
The Romanov Family, pre-Bolshevik Revolution Our tour is guided by none other than Sokurov himself, who provides the mumbling voice of the film's narrator, the spirit of a nameless Russian man who died...
Total: 80
The single take premise might sound like a gimmick, but it proves to be a beautiful, dream-like way to move seamlessly through 300 years of history....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 60
Though the visuals and production design themselves are quite stunning, there are unfortunately a few technical anomalies that hold the transfer back....
Audio: 80
Though only two channels, this is a surprisingly engrossing mix that helps to extend the film's world through enveloping sound design....
Extras: 20
In One Breath (HD, 44 min) – Presented in upscaled 1080i with LPCM 2.0 sound and hardcoded English subs for the foreign language portions, this is a comprehensive behind-the-scenes featurette that chronicles...
Movie: 80
The movie is never quite clear, but this mystery helps to give the film a certain ethereal quality, and despite their comparatively underdeveloped characterizations, the two leads remain oddly compelling....
Total: 60
More than just a gimmick, the film's one shot construction becomes an artistically potent part of its success, helping to create a fantastical and extravagant celebration of art, history, and culture....
Director: Aleksandr Sokurov
Actors: Sergey Dreyden, Mariya Kuznetsova, Leonid Mozgovoy
PlotIn this visually captivating exploration of Russian history, an unnamed narrator finds himself mysteriously transported to the Winter Palace in St. Petersburg. Guided by a cynical French aristocrat, the narrator traverses the palace's grandiose corridors and opulent chambers, witnessing various significant events from three centuries of Russian history. Each room they enter reveals a different era and scene, featuring figures like Peter the Great, Catherine the Great, and Nicholas II, as well as ordinary citizens, artists, and courtiers. The narrator and his guide immerse themselves in these vignettes, which seamlessly flow from one epoch to another, all within the confines of the majestic palace.
As they move deeper into the labyrinthine structure, the journey becomes a meditation on culture, art, and the essence of Russian identity. The guide often expresses disdain for Russian customs and praises European refinement, provoking a complex dialogue about national pride and cultural influence. The setting remains fluid with the two observers encountering grand balls, intense performances, and intimate moments frozen in time. With each scene unfolding in a single continuous shot, the narrative lays a mesmerizing tapestry that captures the ephemeral beauty and tragic weight of Russia's historical legacy.
Writers: Boris Khaimsky, Anatoli Nikiforov, Svetlana Proskurina
Release Date: 19 Apr 2003
Runtime: 99 min
Rating: Not Rated
Country: Russia, Germany, Japan, Canada, Finland, Denmark
Language: Russian, Persian