Thief Blu-ray Review

Presented in its original aspect ratio of 1.85:1 and brought to life with a stunning 1080p/AVC-MPEG-4 encoded transfer, Michael Mann's directorial marvel, Thief, has been meticulously restored for the Criterion Collection Blu-ray release. Derived from the 35mm original camera negative, the transfer underwent a careful 4K resolution digital overhaul using a Northlight film scanner. The director's own 35mm answer print served as a critical reference for color fidelity, ensuring that Michael Mann's exacting standards were met throughout this process. The restoration effort included the remediation of thousands of instances of dirt, debris, scratches, and warps, employing notable technologies like MTI's DRS for major flaws and Digital Vision's Phoenix for finer issues like grain and noise management. This painstaking attention to detail ensures that the visual presentation of Thief not only respects its source material but elevates it, providing an experience that feels both authentic and refreshingly pristine.

The visual finesse of the Blu-ray release is immediately evident in its handling of contrast and color. Scenes once marred by the flat and murky æsthetics of previous DVD releases now reveal an enriched palette and deep, atmospheric shadows that underscore the film's stylish neo-noir essence. Notably, the nighttime sequences—replete with neon lights—exhibit a clarity and vibrancy that significantly enhance the viewing experience. The color reproduction is nuanced, unveiling a spectrum of cold hues that are pivotal to the film's mood. Moreover, the restoration ensures a faithful rendering of the original cinematography's intentions, marked by a deliberate use of darkness and shadow to shape the narrative's visual tone. Such fidelity extends to the film's meticulous framing and camera movements, which gain newfound appreciation through the improved sharpness and stability of the transfer. While occasional fluctuations in sharpness are present, they are inherently tied to the film's intentional visual design rather than being artefactual.

This ambitious restoration, approved and supervised by Michael Mann himself, alongside the convergence of modern restoration techniques and respect for the original artistic vision, culminates in a presentation that is not just a mere viewing but an immersive experience. Thief on Blu-ray not only revisits but redefines its visual legacy, making it an essential addition to the collection of cinephiles and enthusiasts eager to witness Michael Mann's neo-noir masterpiece in its most authentic and visually arresting form yet.

The audio presentation of "Thief" on Blu-ray, featuring a DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track, marks a significant upgrade from previous formats. This release showcases a meticulously remastered soundtrack that both purists and newcomers will appreciate. The remastering process involved a transition from the original stereo soundtrack to 5.1 surround sound, sourced from 35mm 4-track magnetic audio stems, and has received Michael Mann's approval. The technical efforts to clean the track — using Pro Tools HD for manual removal of clicks, thumps, hiss, and hums, while crackle was diminished via AudioCube's integrated workstation — have resulted in an audio experience free from age-related wear, providing a pristine listening environment.

In terms of auditory experience, the Blu-ray excels in delivering immersive and dynamic audio that enhances every aspect of the film. From the opening scenes where the sound of rain surrounds the viewer, to the legendary electro/ambient tones of Tangerine Dream's score, the soundtrack envelops and transports the audience into the film's atmosphere. The soundtrack's depth and clarity significantly uplift the viewing experience, with well-prioritized dialogue and effects, alongside impressive LFE and directionality that contribute to an authentic and encompassing sound stage. Ambient sounds like passing cars and atmospheric effects are rendered with precise imaging, though occasional moments such as a directional mishap during a truck pass might slightly distract.

Furthermore, the action sequences and casual conversations are remarkably clear, with no signs of audio imperfections such as pops, cracks, or distortions noted. However, there are slight drawbacks noted in the vocal delivery in some scenes due to ADR limitations and a minor imbalance during a live music scene in a bar; these are minor when compared to the overall excellency of the audio presentation. The Criterion release also includes optional English SDH subtitles for accessibility, ensuring that all viewers can fully enjoy the richness of Thief’s sonic landscape. This audiophile-approved restoration serves not only as a testament to the film's enduring legacy but also as a benchmark for home media presentations.

The Criterion Collection's Blu-ray release of "Thief" shines not just with its main feature but its carefully curated extras, providing a comprehensive look into the movie's creation and legacy. The original theatrical trailer offers a glimpse into its cinematic debut. Notably, the included interviews with director Michael Mann, actor James Caan, and Tangerine Dream's Johannes Schmoelling are standout additions. Mann's discussion reveals fascinating insights into the film's aesthetic choices, casting, and narrative inspiration drawn from real-life figures. Caan's reflections on his role and preparation techniques affirm the film's significance in his career, while Schmoelling's commentary on the evocative score, including a nod to Pink Floyd, underscores the film's auditory impact. Additionally, the included audio commentary by Mann and Caan, originally recorded in 1995, offers a nostalgic and engaging listening experience. An illustrated booklet featuring an essay provides further critical perspective, enriching this definitive edition for both new audiences and long-time fans.

Extras included in this disc:

• Trailer: Original theatrical trailer for "Thief."
• Michael Mann: In-depth interview with director Michael Mann.
• James Caan: Reflective interview with actor James Caan.
• Tangerine Dream: Insightful interview with Johannes Schmoelling about the film's soundtrack.
• Commentary: Engaging audio commentary with director Michael Mann and James Caan.
• Booklet: Illustrated booklet with an essay by critic Nick James.

Michael Mann's "Thief," a milestone in the crime genre, makes an impressive debut on Blu-ray, beckoning aficionados with its blend of stark realism and stylistic flourishes. This Criterion Collection release highlights the film’s significant impact since its 1981 release, bolstered by an array of supplemental features that enrich the viewer's experience. Through interviews with key contributors, including Mann and lead actor James Caan, along with insights from Tangerine Dream's Johannes Schmoelling on the film’s seminal score, this edition provides a comprehensive look at the craftsmanship behind the movie. The set is commendably rounded off with an illustrated booklet, offering critical essays that delve into the film’s thematic and aesthetic complexities.

Set against the gritty backdrop of Chicago, "Thief" vividly captures the city's dual nature through its mesmerizing nighttime aesthetic, underpinned by neon lights that cast an otherworldly glow on the unfolding drama. The film benefits from Mann's rigorous attention to detail, employing real-life thieves as consultants and insisting on the use of actual tools and procedures in the heist scenes, thus lending an unparalleled authenticity to its depiction of the criminal underworld. The narrative follows Frank (James Caan), a seasoned thief aiming for one final score, and delves into his quest for a semblance of a normal life, a theme accentuated by Caan's compelling portrayal, which flawlessly embodies Frank’s complexities and contradictions.

The ingenious employment of Tangerine Dream's electronic score not only sets a new precedent for movie soundtracks but also perfectly complements Donald Thorin's evocative cinematography, further amplifying the film's atmospheric tension. As Frank navigates through the dangerous liaisons with both comrades and foes, the music and visuals synergize to create a captivating cinematic experience that remains engaging throughout. "Thief" stands as a testament to Michael Mann’s directorial prowess, heralding the inception of a career that would continually redefine and push the boundaries of the crime genre.

Michael Mann's "Thief," a hallmark of early '80s gangster cinema, has been meticulously remastered for its Blu-ray release, offering a rich and atmospheric experience that both preserves and revitalizes the original film's gritty ambiance. Criterion's treatment of this directorial debut is praiseworthy, featuring a high-definition presentation that accentuates the film's detailed aesthetic and moody score. The Blu-ray is complemented by a suite of carefully curated extras, including insightful video interviews with key figures such as Michael Mann, James Caan, and former Tangerine Dream member Johannes Schmoelling, conducted by Criterion. The inclusion of an audio commentary track featuring Mann and Caan adds a personal touch, allowing viewers to delve deeper into the creative process behind this cinematic gem.

The bonus material, though not vast in quantity, is exceptional in quality. It strikes a fine balance, avoiding an overflow of content while ensuring each addition is meaningful. Alongside the interviews and commentary, the package includes the film's original theatrical trailer and a 20-page insert booklet featuring an essay by Nick James of "Sight & Sound" magazine, enriching the viewing experience with critical insights into the film's impact and legacy. An additional DVD version mirrors the Blu-ray's content, ensuring accessibility across different formats.

In conclusion, Criterion's release of "Thief" stands as a definitive edition of Michael Mann's impactful debut. The careful remastering process, paired with a thoughtful selection of supplementary materials, makes this release a must-have for both aficionados of Mann's work and lovers of classic gangster films. Its technical excellence and the historical significance captured in the bonus features solidify its highly recommended status, making it an essential addition to any cinephile's collection.