She Done Him Wrong Blu-ray Review
Score: 73
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
She Done Him Wrong features Mae West and Cary Grant in a compelling blend of comedy and controversy, with a standout Blu-ray presentation.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 73
The Blu-ray release of 'She Done Him Wrong' by Kino Lorber presents a well-preserved 1080p transfer in the original 1.33:1 aspect ratio using the AVC codec, showcasing impressive black-and-white cinematography with only minor, sporadic scratches, and rich black levels.
Audio: 75
Presented in DTS-HD Master Audio mono, the Blu-ray audio for 'She Done Him Wrong' is top-notch with clear, crisp dialogue and well-balanced ambient sounds, delivering a professional mix free from notable imperfections such as hiss or pops, ensuring a satisfying listening experience.
Extra: 68
The Blu-ray extras for 'She Done Him Wrong' feature engaging yet informal audio commentaries by historians David Del Valle and Kat Ellinger, with insights into Mae West's unique Hollywood influence, plus a nostalgic introduction by Robert Osborne. Complementary period trailers and a 'Pooch the Pup' cartoon further enrich this classic release.
Movie: 77
She Done Him Wrong, an engaging 66-minute comedic classic, showcases Mae West’s unique charm and Cary Grant's emerging talent against a well-crafted 1890s backdrop. The film's exceptional art direction, costumes, and score elevate its amusing plot and memorable performances, making it a must-watch for classic cinema enthusiasts.
Video: 73
Kino Lorber’s Blu-ray release of "She Done Him Wrong" delivers a compelling visual experience with its 1080p MPEG-4 AVC encoded high-definition transfer. The integrity of the film’s original theatrical aspect ratio, presented in 1.33:1 full frame, is commendably preserved, showcasing the black-and-white cinematography with remarkable clarity. Throughout the transfer, the encode remains robust, exhibiting minimal issues with print wear or damage that could detract from the viewing experience. Black levels are satisfactorily deep, contributing to the film’s striking grayscale that highlights rich blacks and pristine whites.
While the occasional black and white scratch is visible, these do not significantly impact the overall clarity and cleanliness of the presentation. The 1.37:1 aspect ratio is faithfully rendered, offering a crisp image quality that, aside from sporadic instances of softness, maintains impressive sharpness. The grayscale performance is notably strong, enhancing the visual dynamics of the film. Divided into eight chapters, this release allows for straightforward navigation while appreciating the restored visual aesthetics.
Audio: 75
The Blu-ray release of "She Done Him Wrong" is presented in DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 mono, delivering an impressively clear and refined audio experience that complements this early sound-era film. The dialogue, crucial due to the film's dialogue-driven nature, is crisp and distinct, allowing Mae West's iconic quips and double entendres to resonate effectively. The sound mix successfully balances ambient saloon chatter with the main dialogue, enhancing the film's setting without overshadowing the spoken word. Notably, Fred Santley's performance of "Darling, I Am Growing Old" is supported by a male chorus, capturing the elocutionary style of the period with remarkable fidelity.
Technically, the audio track exhibits a high-quality execution seldom marred by minor scratching typical of earlier sound recording techniques. The lossless DTS-HD Master Audio ensures an engaging listening experience without any significant hiss, crackle, pops, or clicks that could detract from the authenticity of the film's auditory presentation. The occasional touches of scratchiness do little to detract from the overall clarity and professional mixing of dialogue with music and sound effects.
Optional English SDH subtitles are included, ensuring accessibility while maintaining the integrity of the original soundscape. The combination of technical competence and the attention to preserving the film's tone ensures that "She Done Him Wrong" remains an appealing audio experience for both historical film enthusiasts and new audiences.
Extras: 68
The Blu-ray extras for "She Done Him Wrong" offer a blend of insightful and nostalgic elements. Two audio commentaries by film historians David Del Valle and Kat Ellinger provide varied insights—Del Valle shares personal anecdotes about Mae West, showcasing his deep respect for her career, while Ellinger’s commentary highlights West’s independence but lacks coherence. An exclusive introduction by the late Robert Osborne from Turner Classic Movies provides valuable context, enriching viewers' understanding of the production’s historical significance. Additionally, the inclusion of a 1933 animated short, "She Does Him Right," offers an entertaining vintage touch. The Kino Lorber release is complemented by a selection of trailers that enhance the nostalgic feel, featuring titles like "Night After Night" and "I'm No Angel," further showcasing the era’s cinematic richness.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary by Film Historian David Del Valle: Personal anecdotes and admiration for Mae West.
- Audio Commentary by Film Historian Kat Ellinger: Celebrates Mae West's independence.
- Exclusive Introduction by Turner Classic Movies Host Robert Osborne: Background on movie production.
- She Does Him Right Cartoon: A 1933 Pooch the Pup short.
- Kino Trailers: Previews of various classic films.
Movie: 77
"She Done Him Wrong" on Blu-ray is an essential glimpse into the Golden Age of Hollywood, showcasing the undeniable charisma of Mae West and Cary Grant. Set against the bawdy backdrop of the 1890s Bowery, Mae West shines as Lady Lou, a saloon singer with a penchant for diamonds and men alike. The film’s narrative is adorned with humor, reflecting West's sharp wit through a script that preserves her legendary dialogue. Despite the film’s brisk 66-minute runtime, it manages to weave an intricate web of rivalry and romance, juxtaposed alongside a vibrant portrait of New York's underbelly.
The craftsmanship behind the movie is meticulously orchestrated, with art direction by Robert Usher and costume design by Edith Head vividly rendering the era. The black-and-white cinematography by Charles Lang accents the noir aesthetic, enhancing the film’s energy. These elements meld seamlessly with John Leipold’s music, which imbues scenes with light-hearted charm while complementing the visual narrative skillfully orchestrated by director Lowell Sherman.
The storyline, derived from Mae West's stage success "Diamond Lil" and adapted for the screen by Mae West, Harvey F. Thew, and John Bright, is filled with cleverly constructed characters that grant the plot both depth and comedy. Despite minor subplots occasionally receiving less emphasis amid a focus on Mae West's riveting performances, the screenplay delivers ample charm and humor. Cary Grant's appearances, although brief, introduce another layer of suave wit that foreshadows his later iconic roles. This timeless comedy-drama remains a testament to Mae West's star power and has justifiably earned its place as a classic. It remains a showcase of enduring film art grounded in brilliant performances and a lively, unforgettable narrative.
Total: 73
"She Done Him Wrong" is an iconic comedy-drama from 1933 that captures the charisma and wit of Mae West, alongside a young Cary Grant. This film, directed by Lowell Sherman, serves as a platform for West’s vivacious persona, elevating her to stardom. As a slightly altered adaptation of her stage play, "Diamond Lil," the film presents West at her boldest, epitomizing liberated attitudes that challenged cinematic norms of the era. The resulting controversy sparked by West's portrayal marked a significant cultural moment, leading to stricter censorship in American cinema.
The Blu-ray release of "She Done Him Wrong" offers an impressive presentation that does justice to this classic film. The restoration captures the vintage charm and intricate production details with remarkable clarity, enhancing the cinematic experience for modern audiences. The sound quality complements the visual restoration, making West and Grant’s performances all the more compelling and enjoyable. This meticulously crafted release is an essential addition to any cinephile’s collection, thanks to its historical significance and high-quality preservation.
In conclusion, "She Done Him Wrong" remains an entertaining and influential piece of cinema history. Its combination of sharp performances and strategic humor solidified its status as a timeless classic. The Blu-ray version elevates the viewing experience with its stellar technical presentation, reinforcing the film's revered position in Hollywood's golden age. Highly recommended for fans of classic cinema and those interested in the sociocultural evolution of filmmaking.
Blu-ray.com review by Neil LumbardRead review here
Video: 70
The Blu-ray release is impressive and manages to preserve the presentation of the film well....
Audio: 70
The lossless audio on the release is top-notch and sounds clear throughout the presentation....
Extras: 60
The release also includes a selection of trailers promoting other releases available from distributor Kino Lorber: Night After Night (SD, 2:39), I'm No Angel (SD, 1:58), Belle of the Nineties (HD, 1:54),...
Movie: 80
Directed by Lowell Sherman (The Royal Bed, Bachelor Apartment), She Done Him Wrong is an altogether entertaining classic that has withstood the test of time....
Total: 80
The real star of the show is the cast: Mae West and Cary Grant are both terrific here and their performances help to make the film the beloved classic that it is....
The Digital Bits review by Dennis SeulingRead review here
Video: 90
Audio: 85
A singing waiter (Fred Santley) has a nice piece of screen time, performing Darling, I Am Growing Old, backed by a male chorus, in the elocutionary style of the time, complete with rolled r’s....
Extras: 95
Movie: 90
Set in the bawdy Bowery of the Gay Nineties, She Done Him Wrong stars Mae West as Lady Lou, a saloon singer who has a talent for juggling the men in her life and accumulating diamonds in the process....
Total: 90
Pushing boundaries, the film was both a showcase for West and the death knell of suggestive content on American screens for decades to come....
Home Theater Forum review by Matt HoughRead review here
Video: 80
Except for a soft shot here and there, the images are very crisp, and the grayscale is most impressive with rich black levels and clear whites....
Audio: 90
There’s a little bit of scratchiness early on, but for the most part, the track is free of hiss, crackle, pops, and flutter....
Extras: 60
Robert Osborne Introduction (2:18, SD): the late host of TCM takes a few moments to offer some background on the production of the movie ported over from the DVD release....
Movie: 70
Renamed She Done Him Wrong and slightly rewritten to step around the Production Code office that had strictly forbidden a big screen adaptation of the notorious play, the movie was a tremendous box-office...
Total: 70
Mae West comes into her own as a full-fledged movie star in Lowell Sherman’s She Done Him Wrong, a comedy-drama that establishes West’s persona in Hollywood and brings her celebrated play Diamond Lil to...
Director: Lowell Sherman
Actors: Mae West, Cary Grant, Owen Moore
PlotIn a seedy 1890s New York City nightclub, sultry singer Lady Lou works for owner Gus Jordan. Lou is romantically involved with Gus, unaware of his illicit activities, including a counterfeiting ring and exploitation of young women. She charms all the men around her, earning their devotion and stirring up jealousy among the women. The suave Captain Cummings, who runs a nearby mission, visits the club, appearing to show only disdain for Lou’s lifestyle. However, there's more beneath his stern exterior.
As tension builds, Lou's past begins to catch up with her when an ex-lover, Chick Clark, escapes from prison. Clark is determined to reclaim Lou's affections, creating further complications in her life. Meanwhile, with the law closing in on Gus's criminal enterprises, suspicion falls on everyone at the club. Lou navigates a web of deceit and temptation, balancing her desire for attention with the dangerous liaisons surrounding her. Amidst the chaos, she must decide where her loyalties lie while facing tough choices that may change her life forever.
Writers: Mae West, Harvey F. Thew, John Bright
Release Date: 09 Feb 1933
Runtime: 66 min
Rating: Passed
Country: United States
Language: English