Human Lanterns Blu-ray Review
Ren pi deng long
Score: 61
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
Human Lanterns merges gruesome horror with martial arts in a bizarre cult classic; 88 Films' Blu-ray delivers excellent video and engaging extras.
Disc Release Date
Video: 64
The Blu-ray of 'Human Lanterns,' presented in 1080p with a 2.35:1 AVC encode, revitalizes the film's visual quality with vivid colors and robust contrast, despite occasional grain and brightness variances, making it the definitive version for fans and a significant upgrade from earlier editions.
Audio: 54
The Audio presentation of 'Human Lanterns' features a 2.0 LPCM Mono track and a DTS-HD MA Mono Mandarin option, both of which exhibit a thin and occasionally harsh high-end typical of vintage Hong Kong cinema. Dialogue remains clear despite noticeable post-dubbing, and optional English subtitles are available.
Extra: 63
88 Films delivers a visually stunning release of 'Human Lanterns' with premium packaging and insightful extras, featuring engaging commentary by Kenneth Brorsson and Phil Gillon, revealing interviews with Susan Shaw and Linda Chu, and despite audio issues, an extensive feature with Lau Wing. A/V quality is superior, making it a top recommendation.
Movie: 67
Human Lanterns uniquely blends the traditional Shaw Brothers martial arts style with a gruesome horror twist, highlighted by intricate narrative elements and disturbingly vivid violence. The film's complex plotline, inspired by slasher films, and Chung Sun's adept direction make it a striking departure from conventional wuxia fare, shocking both new and seasoned audiences.
Video: 64
The Blu-ray presentation of "Human Lanterns," courtesy of 88 Asia Collection, delivers an impressive AVC encoded 1080p transfer in a 2.35:1 aspect ratio. The restoration, which runs at an uncut 99 minutes on a BD-50 disc, significantly outshines previous DVD iterations through meticulous enhancements. Sourced from the original negative, the transfer incorporates scenes restored from lesser quality elements, demonstrating a film-like fidelity. The vivid and luminous color palette is especially striking, with rich reds and purples enhancing the film's visual appeal, although some may find these hues occasionally exaggerated. The misty, eerie ambiance is well-preserved with commendable shadow detail and consistent black levels.
Despite its mostly cohesive appearance, the transfer exhibits a few technical variances. Viewers may observe minor inconsistencies in brightness and grain resolution as the grain fluctuates across different sequences. Anomalies in brightness can manifest visibly, particularly in scenes like the opening balcony vignette involving characters Lung Shuai and Tan Fu. Additionally, some anamorphic distortions, possibly due to fisheye lens effects, appear at various points. Nonetheless, these factors do not detract significantly from the overall quality.
The presentation aims for a darker visual tone with subdued lighting, aligning with Shaw Brothers' customary cinematographic style. Despite its darker palette, it avoids major contrast issues while maintaining respectable black levels. The clarity and fine detail are preserved well, though it doesn’t achieve the razor-sharp precision seen in other Shaw Brothers films. The new transfer underscores the film's moodiness and offers the audience a compelling viewing experience that is undoubtedly the best to date for "Human Lanterns."
Audio: 54
The Blu-ray presentation of "Human Lanterns" comes with an LPCM 2.0 Mono track in the original Mandarin, reflecting the typical audio characteristics of vintage Hong Kong cinema. The high-end frequencies can be noticeably harsh, particularly during loud effects such as the Shaw Brothers fanfare and sequences with lightning. This brashness extends to some underscore moments later in the film. Despite these audio challenges, dialogue is delivered with clarity, although some synchronization issues may arise due to post-looping of actor lines. Optional English subtitles are provided, offering a new translation from the original Mandarin.
The monaural mix of the soundtrack, delivered through a DTS-HD MA Mono Mandarin track, is characterized by an audible thinness that shows the age of the source material. While adequate, the dialogue reproduction is constrained by the vintage dubbing typical of the era. There is moderate audio distortion present throughout, which may affect the fidelity of higher notes during more intense scenes, such as sounds of torture or natural elements like lightning. Nonetheless, the soundtrack exhibits decent extension and range, capturing the signature vintage texture of the Shaw Brothers production music.
The 2.0 PCM mix is serviceable but runs hot at times, reflecting the standard limitations of vintage tracks. The recording extends sufficiently to avoid impairing the impactful musical score. Despite its flaws, the track remains faithful to the original sound design of "Human Lanterns," maintaining an engaging yet nostalgic audio experience for listeners.
Extras: 63
The Blu-ray release of "Human Lanterns" by 88 Films is impressive, offering a treasure trove of extras that enrich the viewing experience. The packaging is exquisite, featuring a slipcover with brand-new artwork by Kung Fu Bob O'Brien, a reversible cover sleeve, and a 22-page booklet with an insightful essay by Barry Forshaw. Each interview provides unique insights into the Shaw Brothers Studio era, though the audio quality in the Lau Wing interview is notably poor, detracting slightly from its potential impact. The commentary by Kenneth Brorsson and Phil Gillon is engaging but may lack depth for some. This collection offers an immersive dive into the film's background and presents an undeniable upgrade over previous versions, making it a must-have for collectors.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary: Engaging discussion by Kenneth Brorsson and Phil Gillon.
- A Shaw Story: Interview with actress Susan Shaw.
- The Beauty and the Beasts: Interview with actress Linda Chu.
- Lau Wing - The Ambiguous Hero: Interview with actor Lau Wing.
- Original Trailer: The film's original theatrical trailer.
Movie: 67
"Human Lanterns," directed by Chung Sun, stands as a vivid amalgamation of Hong Kong horror and traditional wuxia drama, marking a notable departure from the typical Shaw Brothers martial arts films. The narrative intricately weaves a dark storyline involving a rivalry between two affluent men—Lung Shuai (Tony Liu) and Tan Fu (Chen Kuan-tai)—who compete for prestige through the annual lantern festival. Unbeknownst to Lung, his chosen lantern maker, the secluded Chao Chun Fang (Lo Lieh), harbors a longstanding grudge against him, spawning a gruesome tale of vengeance. This story unfolds against a backdrop of eerie horror elements influenced by American slasher tropes and inspired by real-life serial killer narratives.
The film skillfully blends bright, traditional wuxia aesthetics with unsettling elements of graphic violence. Chao's character dons a chilling monkey costume equipped with a skull mask and metallic claws, committing heinous acts against those close to Lung. These sequences introduce an unexpected layer of horror into the high-society plot, as victims are skinned for lanterns and further tortured in gory detail. Such explicit scenes contrast sharply with the lush production design typical of Shaw Brothers' productions, creating a jarring yet thrilling viewing experience.
Chung Sun's directorial approach shines through, utilizing innovative camera work that enhances both the opera-like drama and slasher-style horror. The film’s framing often shifts from wide shots showcasing choreographed fight scenes to disorienting close-ups during torture sequences, intensifying its chilling ambiance. While "Human Lanterns" may not soar as a traditional martial arts masterpiece, its genre-blending narrative and stunning yet macabre visuals secure its place as a distinctive entry in the Shaw Brothers collection. Its shocking yet fascinating presentation continues to intrigue fans seeking more than the conventional martial arts fare.
Total: 61
"Human Lanterns," a cult classic from the Shaw Brothers collection, offers a unique fusion of horror and martial arts, blending visceral, gruesome elements with dynamic kung fu action. Directed by Sun Chung, this film challenges traditional genre boundaries, making it both a distinctive and engaging cinematic experience. The narrative intricately deconstructs the traditional rivalry trope, presenting a storyline where allegiances blur and audience sympathies may oscillate unexpectedly. While the film's graphic violence may perturb more sensitive viewers, its audacious plot progression and sinister aesthetic are likely to captivate die-hard genre fans.
The 88 Films Blu-ray release of "Human Lanterns" brings noteworthy technical attributes to the table. The video quality is presented with clarity that enhances the film's vivid and sometimes haunting visuals, though perfectionists might argue the potential benefits of a more comprehensive restoration. The audio quality is serviceable, if not exceptional, adequately supporting the overall presentation. This release also includes an insightful essay by Barry Forshaw that delves into the film's genre-defying nature and encourages viewers to discard traditional categorization, embracing the film's unconventional charm without preconceptions.
In conclusion, "Human Lanterns" stands as a testament to the Shaw Brothers' ability to defy genre norms and deliver a compelling narrative that merges horror and martial arts. Though not flawless, the Blu-ray release from 88 Films brings this remarkable film to new audiences with commendable packaging and valuable supplements. For fans of Wuxia, kung fu, and Hong Kong cinema’s unique history, this edition is undoubtedly recommended.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 90
Human Lanterns does show a few variances in brightness and grain resolution but is on the whole a really gorgeous looking transfer, especially with regard to an almost luminous palette which offers some...
Audio: 60
This has a pretty brash, thin and frankly harsh high end at times, as is almost immediately disclosed in the opening Shaw Brothers fanfare, but also even during the credits sequence every time lightning...
Extras: 60
Lau Wing - The Ambiguous Hero (HD; 51:11) comes with a warning about the audio for the interview, which is indeed quite bad (it sounds like it was recorded in an enclosed space with a lot of background...
Movie: 70
Considering the weirdness of some parts of this film, it's kind of a model of narrative succinctness, as evidenced by the very opening scene mentioned above, which almost instantly introduces the rivalry...
Total: 70
The more gruesome presentational aspects here may make more squeamish types squirm, but a pretty traditional rivalry plot device is rather interestingly deconstructed here, with the result being that you...
DoBlu review by Christopher ZabelRead review here
Video: 60
The new film transfer is taken from the original camera negative, splicing in a few previously cut scenes from lesser elements....
Audio: 60
Extras: 80
The A/V quality, the completely uncut presentation, and swag make this an easy recommendation over earlier versions of the film....
Movie: 60
While not one of the best films from Shaw Brothers, Sun Chung’s dark thriller is a welcome change of pace for those bored with straight martial arts flicks....
Total: 65
A darker entry in the Shaw Brothers oeuvre, Sun Chung weds graphic horror elements to the usual martial arts theatrics for a notorious piece in Hong Kong cinematic history....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 60
Some may critique the presentation for being a bit too bright, especially in the horror-focused sequences, yet this is without a doubt the best the film has ever looked....
Audio: 60
The DTS-HD MA Mono Mandarin track should be approached with a bit of kindness, as the high-end of the film’s soundscape (and many other kung fu entries) can be rather harsh at times....
Extras: 60
The interview with Lau Wing also has some terrible audio, as noted by a title screen in the beginning of the feature, which is especially depressing given the interview is nearly an hour long....
Movie: 80
While the auteur theory is frequently applied to describe clear aesthetic touches and narrative movements that frequently appear across a filmmaker’s works, it’s not a working theory that’s easily applied...
Total: 80
And even though the transfer could probably be better with a proper restoration, there’s so much for Wuxia and kung fu fans to enjoy in this package....
Director: Chung Sun
Actors: Tony Liu, Kuan Tai Chen, Lieh Lo
PlotSet in a small Chinese town, the story follows two prominent and rival martial artists, Master Lung and Master Tan. Both men are consumed with outdoing each other, escalating their rivalry when the annual lantern festival approaches, as they each aspire to have the most impressive display. In a bid to secure victory, Lung hires an exceptional craftsman named Chao, unbeknownst to him, Chao harbors a deep-seated grudge against both men. Chao schemes to take revenge by creating exquisite lanterns made from human skin, a twisted form of art that requires him to abduct and murder innocent women to fulfill his dark ambition.
As the lantern festival draws nearer, tension mounts as several local women mysteriously disappear, including those close to Lung and Tan. Each disappearance deepens the suspicion and hostility between the martial arts masters, who are unaware of Chao's sinister role in the unfolding nightmare. The town becomes increasingly fearful as whisperings of a monstrous killer among them spread, yet the search for answers leads Lung and Tan back to old grievances and conflicts. With personal stakes rising and time running out before the festival, revelations from the past and present converge in a chilling climax as the true extent of Chao's vengeance is revealed. The atmosphere grows even grimmer, amplifying the sense of dread as the community grapples with a horror lurking just beneath the surface of their traditional festivities.
Writers: Kuang Ni, Chung Sun
Release Date: 14 Jul 1982
Runtime: 99 min
Rating: N/A
Country: Hong Kong
Language: Mandarin