The Shadow Boxing Blu-ray Review
The Spiritual Boxer Part 2 Mao shan jiang shi quan 茅山殭屍拳
Score: 63
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
A vibrant blend of humor and action with effective technical merits, offering an energetic yet moderate engagement in martial arts comedy.
Disc Release Date
Video: 76
The Shadow Boxing on Blu-ray offers an AVC encoded 1080p transfer in 2.36:1, reportedly sourced from the original negative. While it shows occasional anamorphic anomalies and slight blurring, it delivers vibrant color saturation, tight grain resolution, and a satisfying visual experience surpassing prior DVD versions.
Audio: 76
The Shadow Boxing's LPCM 2.0 Mono track in Mandarin delivers a surprisingly clean audio experience, avoiding typical boxy sound of vintage Chinese films. With decent dynamic range, clear dialogue—despite loose sync—and well-recorded fight effects and music, it stands out despite missing 5.1 or Cantonese options.
Extra: 16
The Shadow Boxing's Blu-ray offers limited extras featuring an HD trailer and stills gallery, but collectors will appreciate the appealing slipcover, new artwork by Mark Bell, and collectible art cards. The reversible cover art includes the original Hong Kong poster, enhancing its appeal.
Movie: 66
The Shadow Boxing entertains with its unique blend of kung fu action and comedic horror elements, featuring superb martial arts choreography and an engaging cast. While the scares may not resonate strongly, the film's playful energy and humorous adventure, including hopping vampires and a bumbling apprentice, offer delightful, if somewhat cheesy, viewing.
Video: 76
The Shadow Boxing Blu-ray presentation by 88 Films showcases a commendable AVC encoded 1080p transfer with a 2.36:1 aspect ratio. Hailing from the original camera negative, the transfer boasts an organic scan of the film's elements, resulting in quality definition and excellent clarity. The palette is beautifully suffused, with colorful highlights and high contrast that appeal particularly well to the vibrant exterior shots, delivering an authentic and engaging viewing experience.
However, the transfer does present some technical anomalies typical of Shaw Brothers productions, such as occasional lens malfunctions leading to slight blurriness and quasi-ghosting effects with refracted edges around objects. Anamorphic distortions are also present, with extreme edge squeezing and sporadic central shifts. Despite these issues, this Blu-ray ranks impressively high for texture and definition compared to other releases of its era.
Overall, while minor shortcomings exist in the most challenging scenes, such as darker interiors with reasonable shadow delineation, black levels maintain a consistent presence throughout. The grain is tightly resolved, adding to the cinematic charm of this 1979 classic. The overall video quality is significantly superior to earlier DVD versions, making this release a valuable upgrade for enthusiasts of vintage ShawScope cinema.
Audio: 76
The Blu-ray release of "The Shadow Boxing" presents the original monaural Mandarin audio in a 2.0 PCM format, preserving the film's authenticity. While the omission of a Cantonese dub and an English vintage dub might disappoint some, the audio quality remains notably crisp and clean. The track departs from the usual boxy, reverberant sounds typical of vintage Chinese productions, showcasing a surprisingly well-modulated dynamic range with an especially robust midrange. This helps support nuanced sound effects and music scoring that include both eerie cues and more generic themes.
Dialogue is presented with clarity, despite the evident dubbing with slightly loose synchronization. Overall, speech intelligibility is excellent, making it unremarkable only in its plainness. Notably, the absence of a previously available faux 5.1 surround mix does not detract from the experience, as the original sound elements maintain a commendable balance. Optional English subtitles are provided in a white font, carefully aligned within the scope of the presentation, thus enhancing accessibility without compromising on visual integrity.
Extras: 16
The Blu-ray release of "The Shadow Boxing" offers collectors a limited selection of extras, though the packaging itself is noteworthy. The first pressing boasts a slipcover adorned with new artwork by Mark Bell and features a reversible sleeve showcasing the original Hong Kong movie poster, accompanied by four collectible art cards on heavy stock. While the extras themselves are sparse, lacking commentary or in-depth features, they include an HD trailer and a stills gallery with the film's unique sound effects. This release is globally accessible, being coded for both Region A and B, fulfilling both aesthetical and functional aspects for fans and collectors alike.
Extras included in this disc:
- Trailer: High-definition presentation of the movie trailer.
- Stills Gallery: A humorous slideshow accompanied by the film's distinctive scream cue.
Movie: 66
"The Shadow Boxing," envisioned under the astute direction of Lau Kar-leung, serves as a delightful follow-up to "The Spiritual Boxer" and embodies a unique blend of martial arts and comedy while introducing kung fu horror elements. The film thrives on its engaging premise, drawing from Chinese folklore with hopping vampires that are controlled by magic, diverging significantly from Western vampire traditions. Master Chen, played by Lau Kar-Wing, alongside his inept disciple portrayed by Wong Yu, navigates the quasi-undertaking world where black magic intersects with martial prowess. Their adventures are buoyed by spirited performances, though the narrative's reliance on slapstick humor may not resonate universally. Despite this, the allure of the film remains undeniable for fans and those appreciative of Shaw Brothers productions.
Characterized by inventive martial arts choreography, the film presents a series of intricately designed set pieces replete with gravity-defying stunts and seamlessly executed combat sequences. Gordon Liu, in a buoyant if mostly subdued role, showcases his physical artistry as a supposedly 'restless' Chinese vampire. Although his character is predominantly non-verbal, Liu manages to inject charm and energy into his performance, particularly during the film's dynamic climax filled with spirited battles. The disciple's comedic misadventures with Cecilia Wong’s character create memorable moments that sustain viewer engagement amidst the action.
While it might not leap to the forefront of the era's kung fu genre solely on its narrative depth or comedic strength, "The Shadow Boxing" offers a refreshingly quirky take on martial arts cinema. It's an enjoyable and atypical entry within the Shaw Brothers catalog, capturing the essence of late seventies cinematic experimentation through its merry blend of fun and fight.
Total: 63
"The Shadow Boxing" on Blu-ray offers an energetic, if uneven, viewing experience. This Shaw Brothers classic, featuring Gordon Liu, melds martial arts with supernatural elements in a vibrant and colorful manner. The film delivers on its promise of exhilarating action sequences, with Liu's performance as a vampire corpse being a standout element. While the martial arts choreography is impressive and engaging, the comedic and spooky elements often hit-or-miss, providing more charm than chills.
From a technical perspective, the Blu-ray edition presents the film with generally solid audiovisual quality. The restoration effort shines through in the film's bright and colorful presentation, enhancing the viewing experience. Despite this, there are moments where the audio mix feels a bit dated, lacking the fullness that modern audiences might expect. However, considering the film's age, these shortcomings are minor and do not significantly detract from the overall enjoyment.
In conclusion, "The Shadow Boxing" Blu-ray is a worthwhile pursuit for martial arts enthusiasts and collectors of classic cinema. While it may not consistently maintain viewer engagement or deliver consistent humor or spookiness, its lively action scenes and colorful palette provide enough entertainment value. Technical merits are robust enough to justify purchase consideration, promising a nostalgic trip into the vibrant world of Shaw Brothers' cinema.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 80
All of that said, this is still a really nice looking transfer for the most part, with a beautifully suffused palette and some very appealing detail levels on things like props and costumes....
Audio: 80
Kind of surprisingly, this doesn't have the overly boxy, highly reverberant sound that often accompanies "vintage" Chinese productions in particular (not just Shaw Brothers outings)....
Extras: 20
If the on disc supplements don't really add up to much, 88 Films may help sweeten the pot (magic cauldron?) for some prospective consumers by also offering a keepcase with a reversible sleeve and which...
Movie: 60
I've joked recently about the sheer glut of Shaw Brothers releases coming out on Blu-ray (get prepared now for the latest huge Arrow set, Shawscope Volume Three, due in about two months as this review...
Total: 60
This is a generally energetic film with some passingly effective comedy and probably not all that effective spookiness, but it's bright and colorful and has some fun action sequences....
DoBlu review by Christopher ZabelRead review here
Video: 80
Having seen a number of similar vintage Shaw Brothers’ films on Blu-ray, video quality is in the upper echelon for texture and definition....
Audio: 80
Fight effects and music are nicely recorded, presented in decent dynamics with little audible compression....
Extras: 20
I’ll highly recommend collectors hunt down The Shadow Boxing’s first pressing on Blu-ray, which comes with an impressive slipcover made up with new artwork from Mark Bell and a set of four collectible...
Movie: 80
It’s a thrilling, funny Shaw Brothers production from the late Seventies packed with classic kung fu fights and hopping vampires....
Total: 65
Exhilarating, humorous martial arts romp from Shaw Brothers with Gordon Liu hopping around as a vampire corpse...
Director: Chia-Liang Liu
Actors: Yue Wong, Cecilia Wong, Chia-Hui Liu
PlotThe story follows a skilled kung fu artist who is known for his shadow boxing technique, a style that emphasizes speed and agility. Living peacefully in a small village, he draws attention after effortlessly defeating a local bully, which catches the eye of an established martial arts master. The master, impressed by the fighter's abilities, decides to take him under his wing to refine his technique and impart deeper knowledge of the martial arts. However, the young fighter soon becomes embroiled in a local power struggle when corrupt officials seek to exploit the village for their own gain. As tensions rise, the hero must decide where his loyalties lie while attempting to maintain balance and protect his newfound home.
As the protagonist trains diligently with the master, he learns advanced techniques that enhance his shadow boxing abilities. The corrupt officials, realizing the threat posed by this growing talent, employ mercenaries and rival fighters to challenge him. With pressure mounting and the safety of the village hanging in the balance, the young kung fu artist faces a series of increasingly difficult battles, testing not only his physical strength but also his resolve and sense of justice. As he confronts these challenges, he must draw upon everything he has learned to preserve peace and thwart those who threaten his community. Along the way, personal friendships are forged and tested, leading him to fully understand the importance of inner strength and resilience in the face of adversity.
Writers: Kuang Ni
Release Date: 15 Feb 1979
Runtime: 101 min
Rating: N/A
Country: Hong Kong
Language: Mandarin