Conviction Blu-ray Review
Score: 53
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
Conviction offers an inspiring true story with superb acting and impressive video quality, despite limited special features and a reserved audio mix.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 65
Conviction's 1080p Blu-ray presentation is commendable with highly refined textures, sharp detail, and natural colors. Despite some minor variability in contrast and flesh tones, the transfer remains clear and dynamic, maintaining deep black levels and fine grain structure without compression issues or digital anomalies.
Audio: 55
Conviction's DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track is clear, dynamically full, and unblemished, delivering well-articulated dialogue with limited yet effective use of surround channels for ambient sounds and a quiet score—perfectly aligned with the film's dialogue-driven nature.
Extra: 20
A Conversation with Tony Goldwyn and Betty Anne Waters (HD, 10 min) offers insightful discussion on the arduous journey of completing the film, but the Blu-ray disappointingly lacks additional special features that could have enriched the viewing experience.
Movie: 67
Though Conviction occasionally leans into melodrama, it remains genuinely inspiring thanks to the powerful performances of Hilary Swank and Sam Rockwell, capturing the emotional and procedural complexities of a sister’s relentless pursuit of justice for her wrongfully convicted brother.
Video: 65
The Blu-ray transfer of "Conviction" is an excellent example of video quality, offering a detailed and largely natural presentation. The 1080p/AVC-encoded transfer ensures sharp and refined textures, capturing minute details such as the individual hairs on Sam Rockwell's goatee and the subtle wrinkles in his facial expressions. The color palette, while generally subdued to match the film's period settings, maintains a strong and consistent presence throughout different time periods depicted in the movie. Whites have a creamy cast, and while blacks aren't inky, they provide good dynamic range and depth in shadowy scenes. The high bitrate encoding displays pristine quality without noticeable compression artifacts or digital anomalies.
Contrast and grain structure are well-balanced, resulting in a stable and crisp image that enhances on-screen depth. The picture does justice to the film's varied environments, from bleak prison walls to more colorful, dream-like sequences of youth, maintaining clarity across all scenes. Though not particularly flashy, the transfer's clean and noise-free presentation adds to its strengths. Shadow details are robust, avoiding crushing and enhancing the overall depth of the film’s visuals.
This high-definition transfer provides a satisfying and immersive viewing experience, making "Conviction" notable for its natural look and technical precision. Even though it may not top the list for standout visuals of its release year, it remains a rock-solid presentation that does justice to the film's atmospheric settings and nuanced performances.
Audio: 55
The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 surround track for "Conviction" is proficient yet understated. As a dialogue-heavy film, it adeptly handles the primary need for clear, intelligible speech reproduction. Dialogue is consistently front-loaded and well-articulated, ensuring clarity whether characters are yelling or whispering. This high-bitrate encoding excels with no noticeable compression artifacts, offering a clean and unblemished audio experience devoid of hisses or crackles.
The rear channels provide subtle yet effective support, primarily reserved for Paul Cantelon's score and ambient effects such as barroom chatter or incidental music. Moments demanding low-frequency effects, like door slams or the clanging of prison bars, are handled with nuanced restraint, adding depth to the audio without overwhelming the viewer. Though not elaborate, the occasional spatial cues in the surround channels enhance the immersive experience within the film's limited demands.
Overall, this lossless DTS-HD Master Audio mix complements the film's tone perfectly, eschewing bombast for precision and clarity. It seamlessly integrates dialogue with minimal but meaningful surround activity, ensuring a focused and uninterrupted viewing experience that aligns well with the story's requirements.
Extras: 20
The Blu Ray extras for "Conviction" offer insightful yet disappointingly limited supplemental material. A standout feature is the in-depth conversation between Director Tony Goldwyn and Betty Anne Waters, offering a poignant look at the project's long journey to fruition. This engaging, albeit brief, behind-the-scenes discussion is complemented by a trailer for another film, "Cyrus." The potential for a more comprehensive special features package, such as a commentary track, is notably absent, leaving room for improvement in providing a more extensive exploration of the film's background.
Extras included in this disc:
- A Conversation with Tony Goldwyn and Betty Anne Waters: Director Tony Goldwyn and the real Betty Anne Waters discuss the film's lengthy development.
- Sneak Peak: A trailer for "Cyrus."
- Trailer: The trailer for "Conviction."
Movie: 67
"Conviction" showcases the tenacious journey of Betty Anne Waters, portrayed by Hilary Swank, who dedicates 18 years to exonerate her wrongfully convicted brother, Kenny (Sam Rockwell). The film’s strength lies in its exceptional performances, bringing a genuine emotional depth to a story often marred by melodrama. While the narrative sometimes hints at a larger-than-life TV movie format, it nevertheless manages to remain inspiring and stirring.
Swank excels in her role, imbuing Betty with a determined yet nuanced resilience, embodying a woman willing to reshape her life to navigate an unjust legal system. Rockwell matches her intensity, offering a layered portrayal of Kenny that oscillates between anger and vulnerability, making the reality of his wrongful conviction simultaneously harrowing and believable. The supporting cast, including a steely performance by Melissa Leo as the vindictive detective, adds weight to the storytelling.
The film delves into the procedural intricacies of Betty’s mission and introduces elements like the Innocence Project, lending authenticity to the narrative but occasionally bogging down the pacing. Jumping through different timelines, we get a comprehensive view of Betty and Kenny's past, highlighting their familial bond and personal sacrifice. Despite some predictable turns, "Conviction" remains grounded in its true story roots, avoiding hyperbolic dramatization, and delivering a compelling depiction of one woman's extraordinary fight for justice.
Total: 53
"Conviction" delivers a powerful tale of real-life perseverance and injustice. The film, led by remarkable performances including a standout by Sam Rockwell, captures the prolonged battle of Betty Anne Waters to free her wrongfully convicted brother. While the story's adherence to real events may limit its dramatic impact, it remains an engaging and inspiring narrative about overcoming seemingly insurmountable obstacles. For those who appreciate stories rooted in reality, “Conviction” offers a deeply human and stirring experience.
The Blu Ray presentation of "Conviction" is notable for its exceptional video quality. High-definition aficionados will appreciate the impressive detail and depth throughout the film, making it a valuable addition to any HD collection. The audio mix, although subdued, complements the tone of the movie effectively, enriching the viewing experience without overshadowing the poignant storyline. On the downside, the package is somewhat lacking in special features, offering only a single 10-minute featurette and no commentary track—a disservice to such an impactful narrative.
In conclusion, despite its shortcomings in supplementary content, "Conviction" remains a highly recommended viewing, thanks to its compelling story and superior technical presentation. The Blu Ray format enhances the film's visual appeal, making it a worthwhile investment for any fan of true crime dramas or inspirational stories.
Blu-ray.com review by Casey BroadwaterRead review here
Video: 80
The film goes for a largely natural, unstylized color scheme�although white highlights are intentionally given a creamy cast�and while there's nothing especially vivid or eye catching here, the image has...
Audio: 80
This is a talky drama, and as such, there's really no place for any insane audio theatrics; rather, this is one of those quiet tracks that gets the job done, and does it well, without drawing any attention...
Extras: 20
A Conversation with Tony Goldwyn and Betty Anne Waters (1080p, 10:19): Director Tony Goldwyn and the real Betty Anne Waters sit down to discuss the extremely long road to completing the film....
Movie: 60
Occasionally, though, you hear about an intrepid lawyer who finds reasonable doubt in the evidence and mounts a new case to clear the good name of some long-imprisoned innocent....
Total: 70
Such is the case with Conviction, a true story about injustice in the justice system that's sad, yes, and even momentarily triumphant, but never quite makes the dramatic impact it could if it weren't so...
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
The scenes of young Betty and Kenny take on a diffused, dream-like look, but the clarity is still there....
Audio: 60
Whether it be yelling or whispering, the center and front channels pick up all of the movie's dialogue and produce it with a clearly audible signal....
Extras: 20
Could've had a commentary track, at least, with the real Betty Anne Waters commenting specifically on the movie and the liberties it did or didn't take....
Movie: 80
Since we already know the outcome, because of this trial's somewhat high-profile notoriety, there's no spoiler in saying that Kenny really is innocent even though he seems, at times, to be a nasty human...
Total: 60
Even though you already know the eventual outcome, it's still a heroic story, watching Betty Anne Waters fight over the course of a decade trying to get her brother, who was wrongfully convicted, out of...
AVSForumRead review here
Video: 88
Colors were natural looking with a pleasing and reserved quality that capably handled the somewhat limited palette used to represent the period settings and clothing featured in the film....
Audio: 78
Colors were natural looking with a pleasing and reserved quality that capably handled the somewhat limited palette used to represent the period settings and clothing featured in the film....
Extras: 30
...
Movie: 70
Steadfastly convinced of his innocence, Betty Anne embarks on an 18-year journey to set Kenny free, using state-of-the-art forensic technology....
Total: 67
THX Ultra 2 Preamp/Video Processor Sherbourn Technologies - 7/200 Seven Channel Amplifier Oppo BDP-93 Universal Disc/3D capable Blu-ray Player (HDMI Audio/Video)...
Director: Tony Goldwyn
Actors: Hilary Swank, Sam Rockwell, Melissa Leo
PlotBetty Anne Waters is a working-class mother whose brother, Kenny, is convicted of a brutal murder. Convinced of his innocence, Betty Anne dedicates herself to exonerating him. As a high school dropout, she embarks on a long and challenging journey that involves earning her GED, then a bachelor's degree, and eventually a law degree, so she can represent her brother personally. Along the way, Betty Anne faces numerous obstacles, including balancing her dedication to her brother with the demands of her own family and personal life. Her unwavering commitment strains her relationships but also fuels her relentless pursuit for justice.
Betty Anne forms alliances with various individuals who aid her quest, including a close friend from law school and an advocacy lawyer who specializes in wrongful convictions. She meticulously reviews old evidence, attempts to uncover new information, and struggles against an often uncooperative legal system. Betty Anne encounters corrupt officials and hidden records that suggest the possibility of Kenny's innocence. These barriers test her resolve and resourcefulness, but she remains determined to free her brother, believing that the truth will ultimately prevail.
Writers: Pamela Gray
Release Date: 05 Nov 2010
Runtime: 107 min
Rating: R
Country: Switzerland, United Kingdom, United States
Language: English