All Is Bright Blu-ray Review
Score: 57
from 4 reviewers
Review Date:
All is Bright is a well-acted, dark holiday comedy with superb video and good audio, but it struggles with tonal balance and lacks special features.
Disc Release Date
Dolby TrueHD
Video: 73
The Blu-ray of "All Is Bright" boasts a solid 1080p AVC/MPEG-4 encoded transfer, delivering a crisp, stable image with muted colors that accurately convey the film's intended visual tone. Detail is exemplary, particularly in facial textures and clothing, while black levels and resolution remain consistently high.
Audio: 69
The Dolby TrueHD 5.1 soundtrack for 'All Is Bright' provides a clear and precise dialogue-focused audio experience, with solid front spacing and nuanced details in music, though surround activity is minimal and occasionally uneven, impacting balance slightly but not detracting from overall sound quality.
Extra: 6
The Blu-ray of 'All Is Bright' lacks any substantial extra content, featuring only some trailers and an UltraViolet digital copy code.
Movie: 56
Phil Morrison’s 'All Is Bright,' featuring stellar performances by Paul Giamatti and Paul Rudd, delivers a bleak, darkly humorous narrative of two ex-cons selling Christmas trees in NYC. The film's unrelenting realism and somber tone capture the hardships of survival and the challenge of finding hope amidst desolation.
Video: 73
The Blu-ray release of "All is Bright" presents a solid 1080p transfer that adeptly captures the film’s muted visual aesthetic. Dominated by gray, overcast skies and a naturally dull color palette, the image remains stable and precise within its intended confines. The colors are deliberately unsaturated, which feeds into the filmmakers' creative choice, resulting in a visually cohesive but subdued experience. Flesh tones display respectable complexity, although sometimes they can appear flat due to certain lighting conditions. Black levels are strong, contributing positively to scenes shot in limited lighting, though they aren't exemplary in delineation. Despite the overall visual harmony, the film's cold and steely look avoids crossing into overly drab territory, even providing transitions to warmer interiors that stand out.
Detail retrieval stands out in this Blu-ray edition, with close-ups revealing intricate facial and clothing textures. Noteworthy mentions include the stark detail on a border crossing officer's hat and the fine lines of weariness on characters’ faces. This level of detail extends to the portrayal of snowy landscapes, pine needles, and various fabric textures, making the environment feel palpably cold. The consistency and clarity of the image provide a real sense of depth, particularly during night scenes lit minimally by fires or small Christmas lights. Contrast levels commendably enhance the perception of depth and dimensionality.
From a technical perspective, this AVC/MPEG-4 encoded transfer is exceptionally clean and free from major instances of banding, blocking, or noise. It judiciously handles a relatively narrow color palette to deliver a picture that is crisp and detailed. The sharp resolution ensures that elements such as snow-covered scenes maintain impressive clarity. This focus on precision and texture allows the audience to fully appreciate the minutiae within each frame, reinforcing the somber and cold thematic undertones of "All is Bright."
Audio: 69
The audio presentation of "All Is Bright" on Blu-ray is well-executed with a solid Dolby TrueHD 5.1 lossless soundtrack that provides a largely front-oriented, tonally neutral sound field. Dialogue is centrally located and delivered with clarity, maintaining discernible intonation throughout. The Jazzy Christmas music and heavier piano notes in the film exhibit a quality presence, supported by a deep low end that adds realism. Instrument details are precise, and despite limited surround activity, subtle ambiances and occasional background elements enhance spatial dimension.
While centered on dialogue, which is mostly clear and precise, minor balance issues occasionally cause dialogue to feel soft against background sounds like bustling tree lots or busy diners. However, these instances do not significantly detract from the overall listening experience. Front spacing is adequate, with the right and left channels handling sound effects and music effectively. The rear channels pick up atmospheric elements, lending an immersive quality to the film's primary New York setting.
In summary, though not dynamically aggressive, this Dolby TrueHD 5.1 track captures the film's nuanced audio details crisply and robustly, delivering music and atmospheric effects commendably well. Despite minor issues, the audio quality meets expectations for its creative score and sound design.
Extras: 6
The Blu-ray of "All Is Bright" delivers a minimalist approach with its supplementary content. Despite the apparent lack of substantial bonus features, it compensates somewhat by including a UV digital copy code, ensuring viewers can enjoy the film across various platforms. The absence of in-depth behind-the-scenes material or commentaries might disappoint fans seeking more insight into the movie's production. The primary highlight is the inclusion of several trailers, which provide a glimpse into other available titles but offer minimal value in terms of additional content related to the main film. The overall presentation is sparse, focusing mainly on the digital copy utility.
Extras included in this disc:
- Ultraviolet Digital Copy: A code for accessing a digital version of the movie.
- Previews: A selection of trailers for other titles.
Movie: 56
"All Is Bright" is a thought-provoking exploration of life's harsher realities wrapped within the context of a holiday season. Director Phil Morrison eschews traditional holiday cheer, presenting a somber tale about ex-convict Dennis (Paul Giamatti) and his former partner-in-crime Rene (Paul Rudd), who are struggling to make ends meet by selling Christmas trees in New York. Giamatti delivers an exceptional performance as Dennis, a man desperate to reconnect with his family while navigating the tough terrain of post-imprisonment life. The film’s bleak outlook on their efforts to find fleeting joy or purpose during the holiday season is accentuated by its dark, sometimes humorous undertones.
From the stark opening scenes of Dennis trudging down a desolate highway to the grim struggle on Brooklyn streets, "All Is Bright" portrays a continuous onslaught of life's adversities, capturing the essence of humanity’s struggle for survival. Melissa James Gibson's writing adds a layer of irony and melancholy, with characters painted in shades of despair that are only mildly alleviated by moments of dark humor. Paul Rudd contributes a balanced yet ineffective portrayal, primarily serving as a catalyst for Dennis's character development. The inclusion of Sally Hawkins’ Olga introduces a glimmer of external warmth, offering Dennis rare solace amidst his dire circumstances.
Though the film meticulously builds an atmosphere of desolation and struggle, it falters in balancing its stark realism with its black comedy elements. The unrelenting bleakness and lack of character depth for supporting roles like Rene and Olga prevent the audience from fully engaging with their personal stories. Despite this imbalance, "All Is Bright" succeeds in presenting an authentic depiction of hardship and perseverance during what is typically viewed as a season of joy, making it a noteworthy albeit somber holiday film experience.
Total: 57
"All Is Bright" stands out as an unconventional holiday film, diverging sharply from the expected feel-good fare typical of the season. This dark comedy, starring Paul Giamatti and Paul Rudd, weaves a narrative around two men struggling to make ends meet during Christmastime, all the while conflicted over their mutual affection for the same woman. While the central premise holds potential, the film grapples with achieving a consistent balance between its comedic undertones and the heartfelt moments it ambitiously aims to incorporate. The performances from Giamatti and Rudd are commendable, breathing life into characters who might have benefited from more complex development.
Anchor Bay’s Blu-ray release of "All Is Bright" offers an impressive audiovisual experience. The video quality is superb, providing crisp and clear visuals that ensure the film’s murky tones and somber settings are vividly realized. The audio is solid, with well-mixed sound that complements the narrative effectively, although it does not reach extraordinary levels of immersion. Unfortunately, the disc's lack of supplementary content stands out as a notable drawback, as there are no special features included to enhance the viewer's experience.
In conclusion, "All Is Bright" is an apt choice for those in search of an alternative holiday viewing option. It pairs well with other offbeat seasonal films like "Bad Santa" and "The Ice Harvest," offering a bleak yet engaging take on Christmastime. While it may not be a quintessential example of its genre, it presents enough merit to warrant a rental, especially for audiences interested in a darker reflection of the holiday spirit.
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 90
Though the image is defined by gray overcast skies and naturally muddy, bland colors, the image proves incredibly stable and accurate within its natural parameters....
Audio: 80
There's a quality presence to heavier piano notes that play later in the film, supported by a good, deep low end that promotes a very realistic sensation....
Extras: 0
...
Movie: 70
Dennis and Rene's idea of a quality Christmas season is an extra sale, a few more dollars, maybe a bit of good news if the pull of family and the conflict that stems from their peculiar relationship doesn't...
Total: 60
It's a dim, sometimes depressing picture of struggle at Christmastime, of two men doing all they can to make ends meet all the while battling over the woman they both love from afar....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 80
Contrast levels are also high, giving the image a real sense of depth, even during night scenes where they only thing lighting the characters is a small fire and some white Christmas lights....
Audio: 80
There is a slight issue with balance, as the dialogue tends to feel a little soft in some places, giving way to the sound of, say, a bustling tree lot, traffic, or the din of a busy diner....
Extras: 0
...
Movie: 40
To the film's credit, it sticks with this negative tonal trajectory for as long as possible, using a too short conflict with competing tree salesmen for some awkward but needed laughs until Olga, a Ukrainian...
Total: 60
The disc has nothing to offer in terms of special features, but it does have a very nice picture and good sound....
AVSForumRead review here
Video: 84
This seems to coincide with the creative decisions of the filmmakers and results in stable imagery that lacks the eye popping definition that some may expect from a newer film....
Audio: 80
The Dolby TrueHD (sampled at 96 khz) sound quality is solid and offers a one dimensional, front oriented perspective that sounded smooth, tonally neutral and exquisitely detailed....
Extras: 10
...
Movie: 60
For Dennis it’s a chance to go straight, and for his best friend and former partner-in-crime, Rene, it’s a chance to make some easy cash so he can marry Dennis’s ex-wife....
Total: 59
Sony Playstation 3 Blu-ray disc Player (HDMI Audio/Video) System Controller: Apple iPad/iRule Pro HD Universal Remote Control Canton "Ergo" Series speakers Axiom Audio QS8 Quadpolar speakers SV Sound PB-13...
Why So Blu?Read review here
Video: 90
I tend to say this quite a bit, but snow is always my favorite thing to see presented on Blu-ray and All is Bright is full of snow....
Audio: 90
All is Bright is equipped with a Dolby TrueHD 5.1 surround track, which is a great way to let audiences here the creatively, near satirical score for this film, which is more hopeful than what we’d expect,...
Extras: 0
Apparently no one had anything to say…Features Include:Some trailers and an UltraViolet copy, ho ho ho....
Movie: 60
Total: 60
I would actually put this next to films like Bad Santa and The Ice Harvest, as far as alternative holiday films are concerned, not to mention the much underseen film The Merry Gentlemen, directed by and...
Director: Phil Morrison
Actors: Paul Giamatti, Paul Rudd, Sally Hawkins
PlotDennis, a recently paroled ex-convict, returns to his hometown in Quebec, only to find that his wife has moved on and his daughter believes he is dead. Desperate to reconnect with his family and find a sense of normalcy, Dennis reluctantly teams up with his old friend and former partner in crime, Rene. Together, they head to New York City to sell Christmas trees as a last-ditch effort to make some quick cash. As they settle into their makeshift business setup on a Brooklyn sidewalk, Dennis struggles to adapt to life outside of prison and build a bridge back to his estranged daughter.
While navigating the challenges of their seasonal venture, tension mounts between the ill-matched duo. Dennis, determined to go straight and make a fresh start, often finds himself at odds with the carefree and sometimes deceptive Rene. Their burgeoning competition with other tree vendors adds to the pressure. Amidst the hustle and bustle of the city, unexpected encounters and heartwarming interactions gradually shift their perspectives. Dennis is on a mission to reclaim his life, while Rene faces his own dilemmas, leading them both into a journey of redemption and self-discovery during the festive season.
Writers: Melissa James Gibson
Release Date: 10 Sep 2013
Runtime: 107 min
Rating: R
Country: United States
Language: English, French, Russian