Re-cycle Blu-ray Review
Score: 46
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Re-cycle features commendable CGI and audio but lacks tension and compelling extras, making it more suitable for rental than purchase.
Disc Release Date
Video: 40
Re-Cycle's 1080p AVC-encoded transfer at 2.35:1 delivers an artistic yet inconsistent visual experience with desaturated colors, some crushed blacks, and slight noise; while facial details and textures hold up, the image lacks depth and pop, often feeling flat and washed-out.
Audio: 60
Re-Cycle's DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track delivers a rich, immersive soundscape with excellent clarity, directional audio, and well-integrated LFE, though vocals can occasionally be inconsistent due to dubbing. The sound design meticulously enhances the chilling ambiance, crucial for a compelling ghost story experience.
Extra: 31
The Blu-ray extras for 'Re-cycle' primarily feature insightful but repetitive discussions on CGI and thematic content, with a limited behind-the-scenes look and uneventful deleted scenes, complemented by brief cast Q&A sessions and a celebratory yet superficial Gala Premiere segment—all mostly in Chinese with English subtitles.
Movie: 51
Re-Cycle shifts from a chilling ghost story into a fantasy journey, ultimately attempting to refresh worn horror tropes but faltering with diminished scares and an unearned emotional core. Despite its imaginative visuals and commendable ambitions, it struggles to maintain consistent tension and originality.
Video: 40
The Blu Ray transfer of "Re-cycle" is presented in 1080p and framed at 2.35:1 using the MPEG-4/AVC codec. While this transfer isn't exceptional, it provides a decent viewing experience. The film's reliance on shadows is somewhat undercut by inconsistent black levels that tend to lean more towards grey, affecting the shadow detail. Certain scenes reveal interesting figures, but some details appear washed out. On a positive note, despite the limited and often bleak color palette, color enhancement around borders is minimal, and the sharpness of the image, though variable, generally supports the film’s visual storytelling.
Artistic and functionally desaturated, the alternate dimension within "Re-cycle" is distinct but visually uneven. Scenes flit between sickly greens, vivid reds, and other hues meant to emulate video game level aesthetics. This selective use of saturation and desaturation can come off as amateurish, akin to outdated photo editing styles. Skin tones fluctuate dramatically, adding to the inconsistency, and while depth in certain scenes is commendable—such as the steps Tsui navigates or the floating rocks—there is noticeable noise in some stylised sky sequences. Despite these drawbacks, the transfer maintains facial details and clothing textures relatively well without evident edge enhancements or compression artifacts.
In summary, the video quality of "Re-cycle" offers a mixed experience. Though plagued by inconsistent color usage, fluctuating black levels, and occasional contrast issues, the film does manage to uphold a certain level of depth and sharpness throughout its run. Fans of stylized, surreal environments might find it appealing despite its technical inconsistencies.
Audio: 60
The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track of "Re-Cycle" offers an immersive and engaging auditory experience, distinctly outperforming the standard Dolby Digital 5.1 options. The soundtrack boasts excellent clarity and depth, with a particularly rich and wide frontal stage. The dynamic sound design significantly contributes to the film's chilling ambiance, enhancing suspense and atmosphere through precise placement and steerage of audio elements. Notable moments include footsteps traveling seamlessly from the left surround to the right, creating an eerie sense of movement, and bodies hitting the ground with a heart-thumping thud. The strategic use of environmental sound effects, such as metallic scrapings, creaks, and unnatural swooshes, effectively sustains tension across various scenes.
Low Frequency Effects (LFE) are utilized sporadically but competently, delivering impactful bass when necessary to heighten suspense. The score's orchestral strings and piano incorporate both high-end and deep bass notes, enriching the overall audio depth. While English subtitles are required due to the absence of an English audio track, the dialogue remains clear and intelligible, although there is a slight dubbing issue with certain characters, possibly due to language differences. Overall, this DTS-HD track showcases how meticulous audio design and mixing can substantially elevate the viewing experience of a horror film.
Extras: 31
The extras on the Blu-ray release of "Re-Cycle" offer a mixed bag of content that provides some insight into the film's production, though they are often repetitive and lack depth. The Making of Re-Cycle gives a decent overview of the themes and CGI usage but suffers from recycled footage and redundancy. The Deleted Scenes add little value, offering brief, grainy clips that barely extend the narrative. The CG Renderings: Before and After segment is too short to adequately showcase the impressive visual effects. The Cast & Crew Q&A Session provides minimal new information, echoing points from the making-of featurette. The Gala Premiere, Interviews and Celebration Party is more celebratory than informative, with overenthusiastic presenters and simple, repetitive questions. The Theatrical Trailer is a standard inclusion but doesn't add significant context.
Extras included in this disc:
- The Making of Re-Cycle: Behind-the-scenes featurette focused on CGI and thematic discussions.
- Deleted Scenes: Brief, grainy clips that offer little additional narrative context.
- CG Renderings: Before and After: Short comparison of green screen work versus finished scenes.
- Cast & Crew Q&A Session: Post-screening Q&A with repetitive thematic discussions.
- Gala Premiere, Interviews and Celebration Party: Overenthusiastic segment with isolated, repeated questions.
- Theatrical Trailer: Standard trailer offering limited additional value.
Movie: 51
"Re-Cycle" is a creative endeavor by the Pang brothers, initially presenting as a captivating ghost story before transforming into a fantastical journey involving lost souls. Angelica Lee stars as Ting-Yin, a successful writer exploring supernatural themes in her new book. The film begins with eerie sequences typical of Asian horror—unsettling phone calls, mysterious apparitions, and disturbing discoveries tied to water sources. This traditional approach sets up a genuinely chilling atmosphere, although the tropes are familiar and sometimes rely heavily on audio-induced jump scares for impact.
As the narrative progresses, "Re-Cycle" transitions into a more complex tale. Ting-Yin is thrust into a surreal parallel universe where discarded thoughts and forgotten souls reside. This dimension resembles an evocative blend of M.C. Escher's architectural impossibilities and Jean-Pierre Jeunet’s darkly whimsical aesthetics. From an abandoned cityscape to a bizarre wasteland of neglected relics, the movie explores themes of abandonment and existential reflections. Despite these imaginative visuals, the underworld's ghouls and zombies quickly lose their initial menace due to repetitive appearances that diminish their impact.
In summary, "Re-Cycle" ambitiously blends horror with fantasy but struggles to effectively sustain its intended psychological tension or emotional depth. While the Pang brothers are commendably trying to innovate within their genre, the film's lack of genuine threat and originality ultimately leaves much to be desired. The narrative’s shift from ghost story to allegorical adventure feels disjointed, and the fantastical elements fail to deliver the profundity seen in films like "The Cell" or "What Dreams May Come." Despite its stylistic efforts, "Re-Cycle" does not quite achieve the cohesive climax one might hope for.
Total: 46
"Re-cycle" presents an intriguing blend of horror and fantasy, narrating a story that dives into a vividly imaginative yet unsettling world. The film utilizes a mix of live-action and CGI to create an evocative and immersive environment, showcasing competent cinematography and visual effects that make its surreal settings believable and enthralling. However, the acting performances, while competent, do not elevate the narrative beyond its visual spectacle. The lack of tension and compelling motivation in the storyline fails to deliver the scare factor one might expect from a film in this genre.
On the technical front, the Blu-ray release is a mixed bag. The audio quality stands out with an immersive surround sound experience that effectively draws viewers into the chilling atmosphere of the film. The video quality, however, is slightly underwhelming, presenting a merely adequate visual presentation that does not fully capitalize on the high-definition format. Moreover, the supplementary materials included in the set fall short, offering extras that contribute little to enhancing the overall viewing experience or providing significant insights into the film's production.
In conclusion, "Re-cycle" is a visually inventive journey that might appeal to dedicated fans of Asian horror looking for something new. However, its lack of genuine scares and mediocre Blu-ray presentation makes it hard to recommend wholeheartedly. The film may be worth a single viewing but likely does not merit a place in your permanent collection. Given its shortcomings, "Re-cycle" might be best enjoyed as a rental rather than a purchase.
avforums review by AVForumsRead review here
Video: 60
A good ghost story relies on the use of shadows and whilst this feature has them scattered throughout there is some details to be found there but it is not the best that I have seen, there tends to be...
Audio: 80
There's excellent clarity to the backing score and still the vocals come through sharp and distinct, even some which emanate from your surrounds, the whole frontal stage though is rich, wide and deep....
Extras: 40
Making of Re-Cycle. - 0:15:41 - 480i/MPEG-2 This covers the extensive use of CGI which enabled this feature to be brought the big screen, the themes the Pang Brothers tried to convey, the locations they...
Movie: 60
Re-Cycleis a mixed bag in some respects, it certainly starts out as an interesting and chilling ghost story but then deviates from this path becoming more of a fantasy journey involving lost souls....
Total: 60
The disc quality is a little of a let down though, with only more than adequate video but much better audio which pulls you right into the frame....
Blu-ray.com review by Casey BroadwaterRead review here
Video: 60
They certainly make their point, but the selective saturation and desaturation often looks amateurish and hokey, like those cheesy wedding portraits where the bouquet is in color but the rest of the image...
Audio: 80
While it may not provide the non-stop shocks, thrills, and stabs of other, more sound- centric horror films, Re-Cycle has its share of clever audio design....
Extras: 30
This behind-the-scenes featurette, which includes interviews with the Pang brothers and star Angelica Lee, examines the CGI and sets, but spends most of its running time in discussion about the film's...
Movie: 50
There's really no sense of menace in the film at all, no impetus for Ting-Yin to get the hell out of Dodge, so to speak, and Re-Cycle starts to rely a little too heavily on an unearned emotional connection...
Total: 60
It's an imaginative ride�it would make a great attraction at some hypothetical anti- Disney�but it has a serious lack of tension and motivation....
Director: Danny Pang, Oxide Chun Pang
Actors: Angelica Lee, Soi Cheang, Lawrence Chou
PlotTing-Yin, a successful author of romance novels, struggles with writer's block as she attempts to write a new book focused on the supernatural. Her life takes a mysterious turn when she begins to experience strange events that seem linked to her writing. As she delves deeper into her work, Ting-Yin encounters eerie occurrences, including sightings of a ghostly figure and inexplicable sounds. Her sense of reality starts to blur as she finds herself drawn into an alternate dimension, an eerie realm where abandoned and unfinished thoughts and projects reside.
In this surreal world, Ting-Yin meets other lost souls and faces a series of bizarre and terrifying challenges. She roams through twisted landscapes and confronts the remnants of discarded ideas, each more unsettling than the last. Along the way, she must navigate the hidden depths of this otherworldly environment to find a way out. With her mental and emotional state increasingly tested, Ting-Yin's journey becomes a haunting exploration of creativity, loss, and the ghosts of our past endeavors. As the narrative unfolds, her quest intertwines with her own inner fears and unresolved issues, making her desperate to escape this nightmare.
Writers: Danny Pang, Oxide Chun Pang, Thomas Pang
Release Date: 01 Jul 2006
Runtime: 108 min
Rating: R
Country: Thailand, Hong Kong
Language: Mandarin, Cantonese