Black Hawk Down 4K Ultra HD Blu-ray Review
Score: 92
from 8 reviewers
Review Date:
Black Hawk Down's 4K UHD Blu-Ray offers exceptional visual and audio upgrades with stunning native 4K, immersive Dolby Atmos, and comprehensive extras—highly recommended.
Disc Release Date
True 4K
HDR10
Dolby Atmos
DTS-HD MA
Dolby TrueHD
Video: 92
“Black Hawk Down's UHD release provides a stunning upgrade with its native 4K resolution, HDR10, and WCG, revealing unparalleled detail, refined grain structure, and enhanced colors. The transfer maintains the film's gritty aesthetic while offering breathtaking clarity and lifelike textures, ultimately delivering demo-quality visuals."
Audio: 91
The Dolby Atmos track for 'Black Hawk Down' delivers a stunning, immersive audio experience, outclassing previous mixes with exceptional dynamic range, precise directionality, and intense LFE input, transforming the living room into a chaotic, war-torn battlefield.
Extra: 96
The 4K UHD Blu-ray 'Black Hawk Down' package excels with the theatrical and extended cuts in HDR10, complemented by three insightful commentaries including one from U.S. Special Forces veterans. Key supplements include a comprehensive six-part making-of documentary and two compelling documentaries on the real events, ensuring a thorough and engaging experience.
Movie: 92
Ridley Scott’s "Black Hawk Down" 4K UHD Blu Ray delivers an intense depiction of the Battle of Mogadishu, enhanced by exceptional video and audio quality, despite limited character development and some criticisms of Josh Hartnett's performance; the package includes both theatrical and extended cuts with notable extras.
Video: 92
Sony’s 4K Ultra HD Blu-ray release of Black Hawk Down offers an absolutely stunning native 4K presentation that stands head and shoulders above its predecessors. The disc utilizes a native 3840 x 2160p resolution, with the original widescreen 2.39:1 aspect ratio preserved. This presentation benefits greatly from 10-bit video depth, a Wide Colour Gamut (WCG), and High Dynamic Range (HDR), all encoded using the HEVC (H.265) codec. The combination of these technologies delivers a picture quality that is both striking and faithful to the film's original elements, demonstrating sophisticated handling of grain structure and textural details without sacrificing cinematic intent.
The detail present in this UHD release is remarkable, revealing every pore, wrinkle, and bead of sweat with unprecedented clarity. Ridley Scott’s meticulous use of shadows and highlights is exquisitely rendered, with HDR bringing out vibrant golden tones amidst the heat of the Somali sun, contrasting beautifully with the cooler blue hues. The HDR implementation ensures inky blacks that preserve shadow detail, offering depth and razor-sharp clarity across various scenes from close-ups to broad, sweeping aerial shots. Additionally, the grain structure appears natural and well-managed, highlighting the film's gritty aesthetic. Skin tones are exquisitely detailed, capturing the war-weary faces of the characters in all their nuanced glory.
The color enhancements via HDR10 and WCG are equally impressive. Saturation, vibrancy, and contrast are all meticulously balanced to maintain the film's distinct look while offering a refined viewing experience. Explosions and fiery sequences exhibit brighter, more intense oranges compared to the older Blu-ray versions, whereas night scenes benefit from deeper, richer blacks without losing detail. This UHD transfer not only handles sunlight deftly but also showcases the brutal beauty of war-torn environments with improved detail in textures like uniform fabrics and facial hair. Overall, it is a notable leap forward from the previous Blu-ray iterations, embodying a pristine yet authentic visual fidelity.
Audio: 91
The Dolby Atmos soundtrack for "Black Hawk Down" delivers a truly immersive and intense auditory experience. As anticipated from a war movie of this caliber, the audio track dramatically utilizes the Atmos format to create a three-dimensional soundstage that will undoubtedly engage every corner of your living room. The constant array of gunfire, coupled with the explosive sounds of grenades and RPGs, turns the viewing environment into a chaotic war zone. This mix stands out thanks to its exceptional directionality, allowing bullets to zip past the listener from various angles while the LFE channel ensures each explosion and artillery shell reverberates with palpable force. Dialogue remains clear and easily discernible amid the bedlam, solidifying this track as a quintessential demo material.
Comparatively superior to the preceding 5.1 mixes, the Dolby Atmos track significantly elevates low-level detail and widens the dynamic range, adding layers of acoustic depth. The seamless integration of overhead sound objects produces an authentic auditory experience, exemplified by helicopters soaring above and debris showering down. Hans Zimmer’s haunting score accentuates the narrative and blends effortlessly with the sound effects to envelop the listener entirely. The surround channels effectively distribute city atmospherics and battlefield noises, ensuring that the viewer is fully engrossed in the film's sonic environment.
For audiophiles, this mix offers both technical prowess and a viscerally satisfying performance. The front soundstage is broad and spacious, allowing sound effects to pan fluidly between speakers, creating an engaging half-dome environment. Even during quieter, character-driven moments, the dialogue remains pristine against the backdrop of war. Notably, the robust low-end impact during scenes like the iconic "Irene!" sequence highlights the mix's ability to push subwoofers to their limit, providing a room-pressurizing experience that is sure to impress and potentially test the physical limits of your equipment.
Extras: 96
The 4K UHD Blu-ray release of "Black Hawk Down" is a comprehensive package, offering both the Theatrical and Extended cuts of the film in stunning 4K HDR10, presented via seamless branching. The majority of the original extras are included on two accompanying Blu-ray discs. The first disc mirrors the 2006 Blu-ray release, featuring three notable audio commentaries and an extensive six-part making-of documentary. Disc two offers a wealth of vintage bonus material, such as 20 minutes of deleted scenes, multi-angle scene breakdowns with optional commentary, deep-dive documentaries from the History Channel and PBS, and various featurettes and Q&A sessions. Highlights include insightful commentaries by Ridley Scott, Jerry Bruckheimer, Mark Bowden, Ken Nolan, and Task Force Ranger veterans, enhancing understanding of both the filmmaking process and the historic events portrayed.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary by Ridley Scott & Jerry Bruckheimer: In-depth production discussion.
- Audio Commentary by Mark Bowden & Ken Nolan: Script and adaptation insights.
- Audio Commentary by Task Force Ranger Veterans: Expert analysis on real events.
- The Essence of Combat: Making Black Hawk Down: Six-part production documentary.
- The History Channel Presents: The True Story of Black Hawk Down: Detailed historical exploration.
- PBS Presents: Frontline: Ambush in Mogadishu: Comprehensive PBS documentary.
- Deleted & Alternate Scenes: Eight scenes with optional commentary.
- Designing Mogadishu: Featurette on production design.
- Q&A Forums: Discussions with cast and crew from BAFTA, Editor’s Guild, and American Cinematheque.
- Music Video - Gortoz A Ran - J’Attends: Performance by Denez Prigent & Lisa Gerrard.
- Photo Galleries: Production photos, design stills, and poster explorations.
- Theatrical Trailers & TV Spots: Promotional material.
Movie: 92
Ridley Scott's "Black Hawk Down" stands as an unparalleled depiction of modern warfare, masterfully capturing the chaos and intensity of the 1993 Battle of Mogadishu. Adapted from Mark Bowden's non-fiction book, the film eschews character-driven narratives for a relentless onslaught of combat, immersing viewers in a near two-hour-long action sequence. Scott's visual prowess shines through with sharp, erratic close-ups and aerial views that highlight the overwhelming scale and dire circumstances the soldiers faced. The film's grim and gritty aesthetic, brought to life by cinematographer Slawomir Idziak, suits the story's harrowing events perfectly, amplifying the tension and brutality of urban warfare.
The ensemble cast, featuring early performances from now-recognizable actors such as Eric Bana, Josh Hartnett, and Tom Hardy, among others, brings the sheer desperation and camaraderie of the soldiers to life. While the film doesn’t delve deeply into personal backstories or emotional arcs, it prioritizes a realistic depiction of combat scenarios—intense gunfights, massive explosions, and the nerve-wracking struggle for survival. This approach underscores the unvarnished reality of war, contrasting sharply with more patriotic or emotionally driven war films. The visceral portrayal earned the film Academy Awards for Best Editing and Best Sound, solidifying "Black Hawk Down" as a critical and technical achievement.
One standout aspect is the film’s balanced script by Ken Nolan, which while minimally focusing on Somali characters, ensures that their suffering under a corrupt warlord is not ignored. Despite some criticism for jingoistic undertones and lack of deep character development, "Black Hawk Down" excels in creating an authentic and chaotic war atmosphere. The high-definition 4K UHD release by Sony elevates this experience with exceptional video clarity and immersive audio, making it not just a film to watch but an experience to endure.
Total: 92
Ridley Scott's "Black Hawk Down" makes its UK 4K Ultra HD Blu-ray debut in a stunning native 4K presentation. Astounding visuals, made possible by the exquisite HDR10 video transfer, are visibly superior to its previous Blu-ray incarnation. The immersive Dolby Atmos soundtrack accentuates the film’s intense battle sequences and brings the harrowing, almost surreal chaos of modern warfare into vivid relief. This edition not only includes the theatrical and extended versions but also boasts an extensive collection of extra features from prior releases, ensuring a comprehensive and gratifying package for both new buyers and loyal fans.
"Black Hawk Down" firmly stands as one of the most impactful war films in modern cinema, offering a raw depiction of the Battle of Mogadishu. This UHD release provides a whole new level of picture quality excellence, with crisp, detailed imagery that sets a high benchmark for future 4K presentations. The sound design remains a technical marvel, with the Dolby Atmos track providing an enveloping and authentic auditory experience. Despite minor drawbacks, such as the absence of remastered HD versions and some missing extras, these are negligible compared to the overwhelming quality furnished by this release.
In conclusion, "Black Hawk Down" on 4K Ultra HD Blu-ray is a masterful exploration of a horrific cascading tragedy and one of the finest modern war films. Sony’s diligence in preserving this landmark film with enhanced audio-visual quality and comprehensive extras makes it a must-have for film enthusiasts. Highly recommended.
avforums review by Casimir HarlowRead review here
Video: 100
A stunning native 4K presentation Detail is simply unparalleled, with the near-20 year old movie showing off some utterly spectacular sequences right from the get-go, as close-ups of sweaty, dirty visages,...
Audio: 100
A tremendous Atmos track which will give your sound system one hell of a workout Thrumming with intensity, but underpinned by a haunting score by Hans Zimmer, there's some wonderful directionality afforded...
Extras: 100
The remainder of the extras reside on the accompanying Blu-rays, with the first of the two being an exact match to the original Blu-ray release of the film from over a decade ago, and sporting a trio of...
Movie: 90
As politically unsavoury as the fictionalised elements might be, leaving very little grey area when it comes to the motivations of each party, what plays out is an absolutely stunning depiction of military...
Total: 100
A masterful exploration of a horrific cascading tragedy, and one of the finest modern war films Ridley Scott's epic Black Hawk Down comes to UK 4K Ultra HD Blu-ray courtesy of Sony, who deliver it with...
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 100
The UHD reveals the movie's gritty grain structure with a level of sophistication, clarity and even distribution that the Blu-ray simply cannot touch....
Audio: 100
Nevertheless, it's an astonishingly good track in all areas of concern: clarity, action, music, width, depth, and total immersion into the combat zone....
Extras: 100
With Commentary (1080i upscaled, 4x3, 5:55): First Assistant Director Terry Needham discusses working with Ridley Scott and continues with a breakdown of one of the film's key scenes atop (usually) six...
Movie: 100
The package is fantastic, featuring exceptional video, terrific audio, and plenty of extra content....
Total: 100
This is a whole new level of picture quality excellence for the film and if not a new standard for the UHD format certainly one of its very best presentations....
Blu-ray Authority review by Matt Brighton and Fusion3600Read review here
Video: 100
This is a hard transfer to judge on the usual scale, but the visuals reflect the theatrical presentation, so all is well here....
Audio: 100
It has all the power to burn and handles more reserved scenes well, but there’s a small level of refinement that is absent, something I just can’t put my finger on....
Extras: 80
Production Design Archive – While not as comprehensive, this has some smaller segments all centering around the production design....
Movie: 0
As the enemy closes in, the survivors hold firm, but time is starting to run out… This is not your typical war movie, as it doesn’t deal as much with personal stories, emotional content, or grandiose heroics,...
Total: 90
This is, by far, the best the film has ever looked and sounded and all of the supplements from the previously-released Deluxe Edition have made the leap....
The Digital Bits review by Bill HuntRead review here
Video: 100
Likewise, the brightest areas of the frame are just shy of eye-reactive, but they too offer more detail (the flames in the pig roast on the base early in the film are a perfect example)....
Audio: 100
Listening to the LPCM mix now (the uncompressed option), while it had fine dynamic range and low end, it does sound a little contained by today’s standards....
Extras: 100
Recorded separately, each talks about what brought them to the project, what they were attempting by making the film and the effect the filming had on the public, considering the historical events were...
Movie: 95
As we sat transfixed in our homes, the bodies of American military soldiers were dragged through the streets by an angry group of men, women, and children....
Total: 99
It’s a shame that the HD version of the film isn’t remastered from the new 4K scan too, that the Extended Cut isn’t in HD, and that a few extras are missing, but those are really the only strikes on an...
DoBlu review by Matt PaprockiRead review here
Video: 100
Even when facing smoke or haze, artifacting holds back, the benefit of expanded color as well as compression work....
Audio: 100
Arguably, Black Hawk Down becomes the champion of debris, full, rich, and real as chewed up sand falls through each channel....
Extras: 100
Some 20-minutes of deleted scenes, four featurettes, and a slew of promo material (trailers and galleries both) bring this to a complete close....
Movie: 100
Bodies sever, legs separate, arteries squirt, but the sights counteract the government’s then recent glorification of military service....
Total: 100
Black Hawk Down shattered the glory of modern combat with a ceaseless battle, careful dialog, and uniquely honest brutality....
High-Def Digest review by M. Enois DuarteRead review here
Video: 90
Still, shadows are silkier and velvety without sacrificing visibility within the murkiest corners, and while awash in a thick, coarse layer of grain from start to finish, the 2.35:1 image appears very...
Audio: 90
Still, a good portion of the story is a character-driven drama with priority given to the soft-spoken dialogue and various conversations, along with the constant yelling and screaming....
Extras: 100
Q&A Forums (SD, 11 min): BAFTA Editor's Guild American Cinematheque Ridleygrams with Commentary (SD, 7 min)....
Movie: 70
The triple-layered UHD100 disc sits comfortably atop the same Region Free, BD50 disc as the previous release while a second Region Free, BD50 disc is on the opposing panel containing a new set of bonus...
Total: 90
Porting over the same set of supplements as its predecessor, the overall package is highly recommended, making an awesome addition to the UHD library....
Home Theater Forum review by Todd ErwinRead review here
Video: 100
On the Blu-ray, the contents of the container are barely visible and bottom of the container almost appears to glow, yet on the UHD the contents are more distinct and the container is more uniform in color...
Audio: 90
LFE is very active, giving your subwoofer a good workout, although for those who may like to play movies with their subs extra loud may want to consider reducing their volume level at first....
Extras: 90
Editor’s Guild (upscaled to 1080i; 10:30) Question and Answer Forum: American Cinematheque (upscaled to 1080i; 11:43) “Target Building Insertion” (6 Angles) with Commentary (upscaled to 1080i; 5:44) Deleted...
Movie: 90
In 1993 Somalia, the United States, under authorization from the United Nations, deploys three special operations forces consisting of Army Rangers, Delta Force operators, and SOAR Night Stalker helicopter...
Total: 90
Black Hawk Down is yet another example of how great Sony treats its catalog on the UHD format....
AVSForum review by Ralph PottsRead review here
Video: 96
A film like Black Hawk Down has an aesthetic that incorporates film grain and the use of cinematography that won't result in the type of high gloss, tack-like sharpness of many newer films shot today....
Audio: 96
When compared to the original 5.1 track the Atmos mix offers a noticeable improvement by opening up the soundstage, elevating the perception of low-level detail and seemingly offering broader dynamic range....
Extras: 100
PBS Presents: “Frontline: Ambush in Mogadishu” o 8 Deleted & Alternate Scenes with Optional Commentary o...
Movie: 100
In 1993, an elite group of American Rangers and Delta Force soldiers are sent to Somalia on a critical mission to capture a violent warlord whose corrupt regime has led to the starvation of hundreds of...
Total: 98
needs no introduction among cinephiles and is a landmark film that bristles with emotion, making it a powerful and gripping war drama that fires on all cylinders....
Director: Ridley Scott
Actors: Josh Hartnett, Ewan McGregor, Tom Sizemore
PlotIn 1993, amid the chaos of the Somali Civil War, an elite group of American soldiers from the Delta Force, the 75th Rangers, and the 160th SOAR are dispatched on a critical mission in the capital city of Mogadishu. Their objective is to capture two top lieutenants of the Somali warlord Mohamed Farrah Aidid, who has been hindering the United Nations' humanitarian efforts by seizing international food shipments meant for the starving population. The mission is planned as a swift and precise raid, with the soldiers intending to infiltrate the city, apprehend their targets, and return to their base within the hour.
The operation, initially seeming straightforward, quickly unravels when one of their Black Hawk helicopters is shot down by a rocket-propelled grenade. With the crash of the helicopter, the mission's objective changes from capture to rescue. The soldiers find themselves in an intense urban warfare situation, surrounded by hostile Somali militia and civilians. Trapped in the hostile district of the city and with their escape route cut off, they must defend their positions and fight for survival while facing overwhelming odds and a ferocious enemy.
Writers: Mark Bowden, Ken Nolan
Release Date: 18 Jan 2002
Runtime: 144 min
Rating: R
Country: United States, United Kingdom
Language: English, Somali, Arabic