Mirage Blu-ray Review
Score: 65
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
Mirage, although slightly absurd, captivates with engaging writing and strong leads. The Blu-ray boasts solid audio and special features despite mixed video quality.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 56
The Blu-ray of 'Mirage' presents a highly variable 1080p transfer in 1.85:1, with decent detail and healthy contrast despite occasional digital-looking grain and filtering that affects texture. Minor scratches and blemishes are present, yet it marks a significant improvement over the DVD, likely the best on home video.
Audio: 76
The DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 Mono track delivers clear dialogue and a compelling Quincy Jones score, with surprising force and clarity in its spacier cues, marking this as potentially the best audio presentation of 'Mirage' on home video.
Extra: 56
A rich suite of extras features insightful audio commentary by Berger, Mitchell, and Thompson, who dissect 'Mirage' beyond its false Hitchcockian label, along with Diane Baker's engaging interview offering personal film insights, an extensive animated still gallery, and vintage theatrical trailers.
Movie: 71
Mirage is a thrilling, if improbable, mid-century noir that captivates with its fragmented narrative and exceptional performances by Gregory Peck and Diane Baker. Though lacking Hitchcock's wit, director Edward Dmytryk crafts an engaging mystery rife with knockout visual style, reminiscent yet distinct from Hitchcockian suspense.
Video: 56
The Blu-ray release of "Mirage" by Kino Lorber's Studio Classics features a 1080p AVC encoded transfer with an original aspect ratio of 1.85:1. The transfer seems to originate from an older master, indicated by a certain processed appearance. This presentation wavers between showing an odd enhancement effect where sharpening combines with filtering, affecting the natural grain structure and rendering some scenes with a smooth, almost textureless quality. Despite these processing idiosyncrasies, the black and white cinematography delivers adequate detail levels, particularly on fabrics, with notable healthy contrast and solid blacks. However, viewers will encounter the occasional age-related artifacts such as minor scratches and nicks.
In terms of film grain, the presentation maintains a generally organic feel, although density shifts are noticeable from scene to scene. These shifts bring variable but occasionally commendable levels of detail and grayscale fidelity. While dirt, dust, and scratches present themselves, they are subtle enough not to detract significantly from the viewing experience. Overall, this iteration is a marked improvement over previous DVD releases and arguably the best rendition available for home viewing, despite its apparent reliance on a less than pristine source. The presentation could benefit from more rigorous restoration efforts to fully realize the film's potential in the current high-definition format.
Audio: 76
The "Mirage" Blu-ray disc presents a remarkably refined audio experience through its DTS-HD Master Audio 2.0 Mono track. Quincy Jones' iconic score is a standout feature, delivering both spacey cues and more traditional melodies with impressive clarity and rich tonality. Celestas and reverb-infused accompaniments have notable force and vividness, while the more conventional themes resonate with warmth and a welcoming soundscapes, showcasing the intricacies of Jones’ compositions.
The dialogue across this mono track is exceptionally crisp and well-balanced, ensuring that every spoken word is communicated with precision and without interference from the music or background audio elements. This release establishes a sophisticated sound mix that enhances the viewing experience, making it arguably the definitive audio presentation of the film for home viewing audiences. Optional English subtitles are available for those who require them.
For enthusiasts and collectors, this Blu-ray likely represents the pinnacle of home video audio quality for "Mirage." It surpasses previous DVD iterations, confirming noticeable improvements in ambiance and fidelity, all while maintaining the integrity of the original soundtrack. The blending of Jones' memorable score with articulate dialogue signifies a polished audio production, heightening the immersion for dedicated fans and newcomers alike.
Extras: 56
The Blu-ray extras for "Mirage" offer an insightful and engaging collection of content that delves deeply into the film's production and legacy. A notable addition is the Audio Commentary featuring historians Howard S. Berger, Steve Mitchell, and Nathaniel Thompson, who unequivocally argue against the film's categorization as a Hitchcockian thriller, offering a fresh perspective on its elements. Diane Baker's A Face in the Dark interview provides valuable personal anecdotes and insights about her role and experiences during the film's production. The Animated Image Gallery showcases a curated selection of 96 stills, comprising behind-the-scenes shots and original advertising materials that reveal the visual history surrounding the film's release. The Theatrical Trailer offers a nostalgia-drenched glimpse into the original marketing approach. Additionally, trailers for other Kino Lorber releases enrich this comprehensive package.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary: In-depth analysis by film historians.
- A Face in the Dark: Diane Baker shares her memories.
- Animated Image Gallery: Collection of promotional materials.
- Theatrical Trailer: Original film trailer.
- Bonus KLSC Trailers: Includes various additional trailers.
Movie: 71
"Mirage" emerges as a thrilling cinematic endeavor directed by Edward Dmytryk, with a plot that intricately winds through the realm of amnesia and mystery. Gregory Peck stars as David Stillwell, an accountant plunged into turmoil after emerging from a blackout with no memory of the past two years. As he seeks to unravel his mysterious predicament, the film sets forth on a visual and narrative journey reminiscent of midcentury noir, yet with a unique modern flair. Joseph McDonald's cinematography and Dmytryk's direction highlight New York City's brief but effective contributions to the mise-en-scène, bolstering the film’s tense atmosphere. Peck delivers a compelling portrayal of Stillwell, his performance nuanced and resonant as he navigates alliances and threats from characters like Shela (Diane Baker) and enigmatic figures such as “the Major” (Leif Erickson).
The multi-layered narrative, penned by Peter Stone, employs fractured storytelling techniques with flashbacks that initially disorient but eventually coalesce into a coherent whole upon subsequent viewings. The suspense is intensified by the underlying question of trust and nefarious motives that plague Stillwell's quandary. While the film's ultimate revelations veer toward incredulity, they contribute to a late-blooming political theme, exposing societal mistrust and exploring the dichotomy between peace and conflict. The script’s cleverness, as noted in related commentary, positions "Mirage" as an intriguing follow-up to "Charade" and a thematic sibling to "Arabesque," marking it as an essential part of a vintage suspense triptych.
The ensemble cast elevates the film’s appeal, with Walter Matthau as the amiable detective Ted Caselle and George Kennedy offering gravitas in villainous roles. The commentary on character dynamics and plot devices recalls Hitchcockian influences, albeit more symbolic than direct, creating a thrilling tapestry that has earned "Mirage" critical reevaluation over time as one of the finest thrillers from its era.
Total: 65
"Mirage" has achieved a certain level of intrigue that leaves audiences both curious and entertained, although it doesn't quite reach the iconic status of films like "Charade." The chemistry between Gregory Peck and Diane Baker is charming, though somewhat understated. Peter Stone's writing keeps viewers engaged with its complex twists and turns that align with the protagonist's journey. Despite this strong narrative, technical aspects of the Blu-ray release present some caveats.
Kino's efforts to bring "Mirage" to Blu-ray should be recognized, especially given the movie's newfound appreciation as an overlooked thriller. While video quality has room for improvement, particularly in delivering a crisp viewing experience, the audio quality is robust, enhancing the overall ambience. The disc is supplemented with a variety of special features that are sure to appeal to fans and film aficionados alike who seek a deeper understanding of its production and thematic constructs.
In conclusion, the Blu-ray release of "Mirage" is a testament to its elevated status over time. Although there are issues with video quality, the film's re-evaluation as a thriller gem makes it a worthy consideration for thriller enthusiasts. The supplementary content and reliable audio deliver added value, making this edition a recommendable upgrade for collectors and new fans seeking to discover its classic appeal.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 50
There's a rather peculiar "processed" look to this presentation that kind of oddly combines sharpening, which can make "grain" look weirdly digital, with an at least intermittently filtered appearance...
Audio: 80
Quincy Jones' score is one of the highlights of the film, and the spacier cues, which feature things like celestas, sound like they're awash in reverb, have surprising force and clarity....
Extras: 50
A Face in the Dark (HD; 14;09) is a lovely contemporary interview with Diane Baker, who gives a bit of career background information before discussing this particular film....
Movie: 70
One of the lists I found online at least mentioned "Slim" Pickens' memorable ride aboard a bomb at the close of Dr. Strangelove or: How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Love the Bomb, which some may argue...
Total: 60
Unfortunately, video quality of this release is iffy, but audio is fine and the supplements appealing, for anyone who may be considering making a purchase....
Home Theater Forum review by t1g3r5fanRead review here
Video: 80
Issues like dirt, dust, and scratches are fairly minor throughout; overall, the transfer is an improvement over the previous DVD and likely represents the best the movie will ever look on home video....
Audio: 90
Overall, this is likely the best the movie will ever sound on home video and is another improvement on the previous DVD....
Extras: 70
A Face in the Dark: Diane Baker on Mirage (14:08) – Newly recorded for this release, the actress talks about the movie as well as some of the memories she had from making the film....
Movie: 80
Also making memorable impressions here are Leif Erickson as the mysterious major, Walter Abel as a noted peace activist whose supposed suicide is key to the mystery, Robert H. Harris as a psychiatrist...
Total: 80
Kino should be commended for bringing the film to Blu-ray, with solid scores for both picture and audio quality and nice bunch of special features....
Director: Edward Dmytryk
Actors: Gregory Peck, Diane Baker, Walter Matthau
PlotIn a New York City office building, David Stillwell experiences a blackout moment during a power failure, triggering confusion and anxiety. As he makes his way down the stairs, he encounters a woman named Shela who seems to recognize him, yet he has no recollection of her. David soon discovers someone has jumped from the roof and is dead. As he tries to piece together the events, he is confronted by confusing and disjointed memories, suspecting that he's suffering from amnesia. Seeking answers, David encounters a series of enigmatic figures and becomes embroiled in a web of mystery and danger. With the help of Ted Caselle, a novice private investigator, David strives to uncover the truth about his identity and the past that eludes him.
Joined by Shela, David races against time to piece together fragments of his memory. He discovers that he is entangled in a covert operation involving high-level corporate intrigue and treachery. As cryptic clues lead him to revisit places he can't remember, David finds himself pursued by menacing enemies who stop at nothing to prevent the truth from surfacing. Uncertain of whom to trust, including Shela, whose intentions remain ambiguous, David must rely on his instincts to navigate through deception and danger. As the layers of mystery unfold, David inches closer to uncovering the elusive truth, facing risks that threaten his life and sanity in his relentless pursuit of understanding his own fragmented past.
Writers: Peter Stone, Howard Fast
Release Date: 23 Sep 1965
Runtime: 108 min
Rating: Approved
Country: United States
Language: English