The Others Blu-ray Review
Score: 88
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
The Others dazzles with its 4K remaster, enhanced features, and Dolby Atmos sound, making it a must-see for psychological horror enthusiasts.
Disc Release Date
Dolby Atmos
Dolby TrueHD
Video: 95
The Others Blu-ray offers a meticulously restored 1080p transfer from a 4K master, presenting enhanced dark scenes and outstanding color reproduction. With strong image stability and detail, it rivals the 4K version, though the 4K edition remains superior for those prioritizing image quality.
Audio: 90
The Others' Blu-ray features a Dolby Atmos track that delivers dynamic contrasts with subtlety and precision, effectively using silence and sudden sound cues to enhance tension. The surround sound remains active and immersive, ensuring a high-quality audiophile experience without the need for additional purchases.
Extra: 81
The Blu-ray extras of "The Others" provide a rich, multi-faceted exploration of the film's production, featuring insightful commentary by Alejandro Amenábar on its stylistic and narrative choices, engaging conversations with cast and crew about its cultural symbolism, and archival content, from set design to soundtrack recording, offering technical and nostalgic insights.
Movie: 66
Alejandro Amenábar's "The Others" offers a masterful blend of atmospheric horror and psychological tension, vividly brought to life by Nicole Kidman's compelling performance. The Blu-ray release by Criterion is enriched with exclusive features, though the film's reliance on traditional genre elements occasionally inhibits its originality.
Video: 95
"The Others" Blu-ray release by Criterion, maintaining its native aspect ratio of 1.85:1, delivers a 1080p video transfer encoded with MPEG-4 AVC. Sourced from a 4K master approved by director Alejandro Amenábar, the film exhibits a significantly enhanced visual experience. The 35mm original camera negative was meticulously scanned in 4K, resulting in a superior transfer that attends to even the most intricate details of its frequently dark scenes. The transfer notably enhances the visual depth, with improved delineation and stability, making dark scenes remarkably more defined and impactful—crucial for a film where dim lighting prevails.
Color reproduction on this Blu-ray edition is commendable; primary colors are well-saturated and balanced, while secondary hues exhibit an expanded range of subtle nuances. This extension of color depth contributes to an aesthetically pleasing presentation that is essential for such a visually atmospheric film. Even without a 4K setup, the 1080p version offers compelling image integrity, framed by excellent density levels and fluidity throughout the film. Criterion ensures a spotless presentation devoid of visual artifacts such as grain instability or macroblocking, maintaining a flawless viewing experience.
While the Blu-ray edition impresses with its strong black levels and shadow detailing, it's clear the 4K version might offer an elevated visual experience. Nonetheless, for those lacking a 4K system, this Blu-ray release remains an excellent alternative. The consistency in flesh tones, despite their slightly muted appearance, complements the film's visual intent—delivering a pristine refinement of its original cinematic presentation. Enthusiasts will appreciate this Blu-ray for its exemplary image quality and the care invested in its production. Note: Region-A compatibility is required to access this content.
Audio: 90
The audio presentation of "The Others" on Blu-ray is anchored by an impressive English Dolby Atmos track, seamlessly downscaling to an English Dolby TrueHD 7.1 for systems that lack Atmos capability. This inclusion is notable for providing an immersive sound experience without demanding extra cost from the consumer. Optional English SDH subtitles enhance accessibility for all viewers.
In execution, the Dolby Atmos track impresses with its substantial dynamic range, sometimes bordering on overwhelming. Specific scenes demonstrate such intense contrasts that adjustments in audio settings are advisable to avoid overpowering your home theater environment. This intensity might surpass what was originally experienced in a theatrical setting, possibly elevating the film to uncharted auditory levels. Interestingly, no encoding anomalies were found, highlighting the technical precision of the audio mix.
Characterized by its subtle yet effective use of sound, the track captures the unique atmospheric tension of this iconic film. Dialogues are impeccably clear and appropriately localized, while surround channels contribute actively to crafting an enveloping aural landscape. Key moments feature sudden bursts of sound that skillfully utilize silence to heighten suspense, adhering to horror genre conventions without falling into cliché. Although less ostentatious than some contemporary offerings, the mix accomplishes a balance that serves the narrative and enhances the viewer's experience, solidifying its standing on an audiophile level.
Extras: 81
The Blu-ray extras for "The Others" offer a comprehensive exploration of the film's production and thematic elements, particularly through the Audio Commentary by Alejandro Amenábar. Recorded in 2022, this insightful track dissects the film's conception, stylistic choices, and character revelations with considerable depth. Other notable features include a new discussion between Alejandro Amenábar and Pau Gomez, emphasizing religious symbolism, and reflective interviews with the cast and crew in A Look Back at The Others. Archival content enriches the experience with behind-the-scenes insights into cinematography, direction, and artistic decisions. Each feature is presented with English subtitles where necessary, offering a deep dive into various production aspects that fans will appreciate.
Extras included in this disc:
- Alejandro Amenabar and Pau Gomez: Discussion on the film’s themes and symbolism.
- A Look Back at The Others: Cast and crew reflections on their roles and the film’s appeal.
- The Making of The Others: Archival production footage and interviews.
- On the Set: Insights into Amenábar's directing methods.
- Art Direction: Set design and costume illustrations with commentary.
- Visual Effects: Overview of digital effects with supervisor commentary.
- Recording the Soundtrack: Footage from a soundtrack recording session.
- Photographing the Dead: Session footage for a key prop, with commentary.
- Audition Footage: Archival auditions of child actors.
- Deleted Scenes: Collection of scenes omitted from the final cut.
- Trailer: Vintage U.S. trailer.
- Leaflet: Essay by critic Philip Horne and technical credits.
Movie: 66
Alejandro Amenábar's "The Others" is a distinguished entry in the psychological horror genre, presenting a sophisticated blend of atmospheric tension and narrative misdirection. The film is set in a cavernous Victorian mansion, where shadows and dim lighting create an unsettling stage for what seems like an inexorable unveiling of supernatural disturbances. The sparse use of light enhances the gothic aesthetics, reinforcing the chilling ambiance, wherein Nicole Kidman's portrayal of Grace, a mother safeguarding her photosensitive children, stands as a visual and emotional centerpiece.
The plot unfolds post-World War II in England, adding a historical layer to the eerie occurrences within the mansion. Grace's husband is missing in action, deepening her isolation, while three enigmatic servants join her household under suspiciously convenient circumstances. The narrative thrives on a psychological puzzle, reminiscent of contemporaneous hits like "The Sixth Sense," challenging viewers to parse its intricacies without premature revelations. Amenábar intelligently crafts an experience where the less disclosed initially, the better, leveraging ambiguity to elevate tension.
Despite some sections tending towards monotony with repetitive demonstrations of Kidman's acting prowess—which scarcely detracts from her compelling performance—the film maintains its stature through meticulous craftsmanship. Amenábar expertly utilizes traditional Spanish horror motifs modernized through adept cinematography and storytelling. While some critics argue that repetitiveness may slow the pace, "The Others" remains a testament to genre films' capacity to reimagine familiar elements while sustaining engagement with masterful narrative resets. In essence, "The Others" is a richly atmospheric horror film that continues to resonate years after its release, a true reflection of Amenábar's directorial acumen.
Total: 88
The Blu-ray release of "The Others" presents a remarkable upgrade that aligns with the meticulous 4K remastering overseen by Alejandro Amenábar. The transformation is stunning; the upgrade opens up new visual details that even ardent fans will find revelatory. The Atmos soundtrack elevates the film’s eerie atmosphere, significantly enhancing the immersive experience. This edition also benefits from improved transfer quality and additional features, making it a definitive release of this psychological horror classic.
This release situates "The Others" comfortably alongside early 2000s genre staples such as "What Lies Beneath," "The Skeleton Key," and "The Sixth Sense." It preserves the film's core intrigue while adding layers of depth through its refined audio and video treatment. The stark, moody cinematography is accentuated by the high-definition presentation, revealing nuances previously unnoticed. Coupled with new content from Criterion, this disc offers a comprehensive package that will captivate both new viewers and longtime fans.
In conclusion, the 4K remastering of "The Others" breathes new life into this haunting narrative, offering both clarity and immersive storytelling. The release options, including a standard Blu-ray and a 4K Blu-ray/Blu-ray combo pack, are highly accessible and recommended for enthusiasts of the genre. Overall, this release is a definitive version that should not be missed by fans of psychological horror—highly recommended.
Blu-ray.com review by Dr. Svet AtanasovRead review here
Video: 100
A lot of the darker areas in particular look vastly superior and this makes a crucial difference because more than two-thirds of the film are quite dark....
Audio: 100
I did not see The Others at my local theater, but I have to wonder if this type of dynamic intensity is accurately replicated or the Dolby Atmos track simply elevates everything to a whole new level....
Extras: 90
Visual Effects - this archival program focuses on some of the digital effects that were used in several scenes in The Others, with audio commentary by visual effects supervisor Felix Berger....
Movie: 70
For a while, it seems like the servants are not only meeting the expectations of the woman but the house is slowly being reformed for the better....
Total: 80
I think that even some of the film's biggest fans will be quite surprised by the new 4K makeover because there is simply a lot more to see and hear on it....
Blu-ray Authority review by Matt BrightonRead review here
Video: 100
If image quality is important to you (and it should be), I’d honestly go for the 4K version, but if this one sits fine with you – it does deliver....
Audio: 90
There are other films out there that are a bit more “in your face”, but for what it is – I found The Others to deliver the goods on an audiophile leve....
Extras: 80
Alejandro Amenabar, Nicole Kidman, Christopher Eccleston, and producer Fernando Bovaira discuss the film, as well as what we’d expect – what led them to it, some of the undertones and its long-lasting...
Movie: 0
I felt as if we were thrown into the lives of these characters midway through and that sense of confusion helps make the film what it was (and is)....
Total: 80
And, thankfully, the early 2000’s was littered with movies like these with What Lies Beneath, The Skeleton Key and The Sixth Sense just to name a few....
Director: Alejandro Amenábar
Actors: Nicole Kidman, Christopher Eccleston, Fionnula Flanagan
PlotIn the aftermath of World War II, Grace Stewart lives with her two photosensitive children, Anne and Nicholas, in a remote country house on the Channel Island of Jersey. The children's ailment prevents them from being exposed to natural light, compelling Grace to establish strict rules: no open doors, no forgotten curtains, and only lamplight during the day. Their quiet lives are disrupted when Grace hires a trio of new servants – Mrs. Bertha Mills, Mr. Edmund Tuttle, and a mute girl named Lydia, to help run the house after the unexplained disappearance of the previous staff.
Tensions escalate when mysterious occurrences begin to unravel the fabric of their secluded existence. Anne claims to see strange apparitions and persistently shares stories of her encounters with 'the others,' which Grace initially dismisses as a child's imagination. Yet, as unaccountable noises, inexplicable shifts in the house's state, and the children's increasing agitation persist, Grace begins to confront the possibility that their home may be inhabited by unseen entities. With events becoming progressively more unsettling and the fog-shrouded house growing ever claustrophobic, Grace's skepticism turns to desperation, compelling her to investigate the haunting mysteries that engulf her isolated abode.
Writers: Alejandro Amenábar
Release Date: 10 Aug 2001
Runtime: 104 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: Spain, United States, France, Italy
Language: English