Seal Team Six: The Raid on Osama Bin Laden Blu-ray Review
Seal Team 6: The Raid on Osama Bin Laden Code Name: Geronimo - The Hunt for Osama Bin Laden Codename: Geronimo - The Hunt for Osama Bin Laden
Score: 51
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
Seal Team Six: The Raid on Osama Bin Laden blends a compelling portrayal of military operations with careful character studies, despite some cliched dramatizations.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 54
The 1080p AVC/MPEG-4 transfer of 'Seal Team Six' delivers a mix of crisp, well-defined moments and disappointing scenes with flat, glossy visuals. Highlights include superbly detailed Afghani terrains and sharp military uniform lines, but darker scenes suffer from poor color transitions and low details, creating an uneven viewing experience.
Audio: 64
SEAL Team Six: The Raid on Osama Bin Laden's DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track delivers an immersive and commendable audio experience, excelling in clarity of dialogue and authenticity of gunfire, while ambient effects and music are well-balanced and precisely detailed.
Extra: 20
The Blu-ray extra, a 17-minute 'Making of SEAL Team Six,' thoroughly explores the film's production, including crew insights, real-life mission parallels, character perspectives, military training, and action scene execution, focusing predominantly on screenwriter Kendall Lampkin and director John Stockwell.
Movie: 53
While 'SEAL Team Six: The Raid on Osama Bin Laden' effectively captures the complexity and intensity of one of the decade’s most pivotal events with well-choreographed action sequences and a multipart narrative, it struggles with uneven dramatization and occasionally falters due to melodramatic character moments and underwhelming performances.
Video: 54
The 1080p AVC/MPEG-4 transfer of "SEAL Team Six: The Raid on Osama Bin Laden" presents a mixed but generally well-executed visual experience. Several scenes showcase exceptional detail, particularly in the depiction of Afghani terrain, military uniforms, and facial textures, achieving near reference quality. Conversely, some sequences exhibit a glossy and flat appearance with questionable stylistic choices reminiscent of Michael Mann’s HD approach in “Collateral,” leading to inconsistencies in overall image quality. The picture maintains stable colors, though they rarely pop, with decent black levels and flesh tones throughout.
The film's visual quality varies significantly across different segments. Procedural scenes and daylight sequences of the SEAL team are particularly sharp with high fine detail, crisp contrast levels, and vivid earth tones that look especially good in outdoor environments. However, post-mission debriefings and darker scenes often lack detail, plagued by aliasing, poor color transitions, and balky shadow delineation. Additionally, real-life footage integrated into the narrative appears blocky and web-like, further disrupting visual coherence.
Despite its variability, the video presentation of "SEAL Team Six: The Raid on Osama Bin Laden," given its made-for-TV origins and budget constraints, remains largely adequate. The pristine depiction of CIA headquarters and clean visuals in brightly lit scenes contrast starkly with the deliberately lower-grade portrayal of the raid itself, where blacks tend to swallow finer details. Overall, while not reaching the pinnacle of Blu Ray video quality, the transfer succeeds in highlighting critical elements and maintaining engagement with solid baseline fidelity.
Audio: 64
The DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 lossless soundtrack for "Seal Team Six: The Raid on Osama Bin Laden" demonstrates substantial technical prowess, adeptly bringing the production’s intense action and nuanced dialogue to life. Dialogue, primarily projected through the center channel, remains consistently clear and precise even amidst the cacophony of firefights or bustling environments like marketplaces. The track's dynamic range and imaging are particularly noteworthy, enhancing spatial awareness during scenes by placing voices and effects across front and rear channels. This meticulous positioning is especially impactful during the team’s training drills, where a mix of shouts, confirmations, explosions, and gunfire create an immersive audio landscape without compromising clarity.
The auditory experience truly excels during action sequences. The authenticity of automatic weapons fire and the tactical discharge of SEALs’ M-4 rifles envelops the listener, achieving a compelling sense of immersion. Every weapon and explosive device produces distinct, high-fidelity sounds that heighten the audience’s engagement, effectively anticipating the film's climactic moments. Ambient effects, like helicopter rotors and foot movements, reliably deliver sound from all angles, further reinforcing the atmosphere within war zones or intelligence offices. Although some listeners might desire a bit more punch from specific effects such as ricochets or dramatic gasps, the track’s comprehensive delivery successfully captures the essence of this military thriller. Ultimately, the DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track for "Seal Team Six" offers a robust and immersive auditory experience that underpins the film's narrative strength.
Extras: 20
The single extra feature on the Blu-ray of "Seal Team Six: The Raid on Osama Bin Laden" offers a comprehensive and engaging look behind the scenes of the film. This well-crafted featurette, presented in high definition, includes in-depth interviews with cast, crew, and key creative figures such as screenwriter Kendall Lampkin and director John Stockwell. It explores an array of topics, from the differentiation between the on-screen mission details and public knowledge to the rigorous military training undertaken by the cast. Additionally, it delves into the recreation of the Abbottabad compound in New Mexico, shooting action sequences, working with firearms, and Director Stockwell's distinct style. The thorough exploration also touches on the multiple character perspectives depicted in the film and the challenges faced during production.
Extras included in this disc:
The Making of 'SEAL Team Six: The Raid on Osama Bin Laden': Features interviews with cast and crew, exploring the film's development, technical aspects of shooting, and cast training processes.
Movie: 53
"SEAL Team Six: The Raid on Osama Bin Laden" provides a compelling retelling of one of the most significant military operations in recent history. The film, directed by John Stockwell, integrates descriptive narratives from after-action interviews, depicting the journey from the identification of a Bin Laden courier in 2002 to the climactic raid on May 2, 2011. While it doesn’t enjoy the comprehensive access or budget of its cinematic counterpart "Zero Dark Thirty," it still achieves an engaging portrayal of the raid, balancing character-driven drama with flashes of high-stakes action. The cast, including Cam Gigandet and Kathleen Robertson, delivers credible performances despite occasional lapses into melodramatic interpretations.
The technical elements and verisimilitude are evident, though some creative liberties are taken for dramatic purposes. The film’s strength lies in its ability to weave together the perspectives of CIA analysts, SEALs, and Pakistani intelligence agents, delivering a nuanced view of the intelligence gathering and procedural intricacies leading up to the raid. The film particularly excels in portraying the broader scope of military operations, highlighting both low-tech and high-tech logistics that span years. Notable action sequences include a raw ambush-shootout in Afghanistan and the iconic raid on the Abbottabad compound, albeit the latter feeling somewhat commercialized compared to the authentic ambiance of the former.
Ultimately, "SEAL Team Six" is recognized for its swift pacing and compelling narrative structure. Despite its made-for-TV constraints, it offers an engaging viewing experience, blending factual elements with dramatized personal accounts to maintain suspense and drive home the arduous journey towards eliminating one of the world's most infamous terrorists. The film's ability to create a sense of camaraderie among its characters, alongside its exploration of both political and operational elements, ensures it stands as a notable entry in the cinematic chronicles of post-9/11 global conflict narratives.
Total: 51
"Seal Team Six: The Raid on Osama Bin Laden" offers a captivating portrayal of one of the most significant military operations in recent history. Despite its limited budget and made-for-television origins, the film excels in delivering a compelling, straightforward narrative that focuses on the human aspects of military engagement. This production provides a nuanced look into the complexities surrounding the operation, effectively capturing the tension and stakes involved. The attention to the strategic and technological aspects adds an engaging layer for viewers interested in military procedures and history.
The movie successfully humanizes its characters without succumbing to excessive dramatization. Though it faces scrutiny regarding its historical accuracy, the film’s strength lies in its character-driven storytelling and strong performances, which elevate it above typical genre fare. The procedural depiction is well-executed, although some may find it lacking in deeper explorations of the political implications and moral ambiguities. These choices may make the film more accessible to a broader audience, even if it leaves more critical viewers wanting further depth.
In conclusion, "Seal Team Six: The Raid on Osama Bin Laden" surpasses initial expectations associated with its budgetary and TV origins. It manages to be both insightful and entertaining, blending thoughtful character studies with the excitement of a high-stakes military mission. Anchor Bay's Blu-ray release supplements this experience with decent video and audio quality, alongside valuable extras. It's a worthwhile addition for anyone interested in military dramas or modern historical events, meriting both rental and purchase considerations for genre enthusiasts.
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 70
The transfer finds many of its problems during the after-action debriefings dotted throughout the film; pale blacks, poor color transitions across faces, aliasing, and low details all contribute to a bland...
Audio: 80
The first firefight, free of music and permitting the shots to dominate the stage, offers an excellent sonic experience as shots crack out from various corners of the stage and from several distances....
Extras: 20
The Making of 'SEAL Team Six: The Raid on Osama Bin Laden' (HD, 17:30) features cast and crew taking a look at the story, mission details in the film versus public knowledge in real life, the film's character...
Movie: 70
Of course, the movie can only do so much in ninety minutes and with so many pivotal players, but it does manage to create a true sense of "team" amongst the men and a determination within the intelligence...
Total: 60
It's well-acted and well-made, a movie that should please all viewers who appreciate a good story inside the military and political arenas....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 60
At a certain point, it looks like the decision was made to shoot in a style that felt reminiscent of Michael Mann's somewhat divisive HD style on 'Collateral,' while other portions appear to be filmed...
Audio: 80
As much of the film is laden with dialogue, the first task of the mix is to ensure that each character is heard clearly, and that spoken lines are combined with things like score and sound effects in a...
Extras: 20
This featurette manages to get interviews with nearly everyone involved in the making of the film, but focuses mainly on screenwriter Kendall Lampkin and director John Stockwell....
Movie: 40
Like the family moments, these confessionals only serve to take a semi-factual thriller, and fill it with elements that are focused too much on the individual, too independent of the actual account and,...
Total: 60
On one hand the raid on Bin Laden's compound is still incredibly fresh in the minds of the viewing audience, which helps to make the militaristic aspects of 'SEAL Team Six' that much more compelling; certainly,...
Why So Blu?Read review here
Video: 80
For the most part, the scenes came across grit-free with naturally vivid-looking earth tones in the arid Pakistan terrain and the very sterile hallways of the CIA headquarters....
Audio: 80
The dialogue, as expected, arrives from the front speakers while other effects like the thumping helicopter rotors and foot scrambles to a post result in a delivery at all angles....
Extras: 30
Movie: 60
We get to see it from the points of view of the CIA, SEAL Team Six and a Pakistani intelligence duo assisting the U.S.A. Director Stockwell does a proficient job in connecting the three bodies and displaying...
Total: 60
Director: John Stockwell, Paulette Victor Lifton
Actors: Cam Gigandet, Jenny Gabrielle, Anson Mount
PlotIn the aftermath of the September 11 attacks, the CIA receives crucial intelligence indicating the possible whereabouts of Osama bin Laden. Assembling an elite team of Navy SEALs, the agency embarks on a mission to confirm his location inside a fortified compound in Pakistan. The SEAL Team Six operators undergo rigorous preparation, analyzing satellite images, and rehearsing tactical maneuvers to ensure they can execute the mission with precision. Despite limited concrete evidence, pressure mounts from high-level government officials to proceed, ramping up the urgency and stakes of the operation.
As the night of the assault approaches, tensions rise within the team, grappling with the profound implications of their task. They must rely on their training, trust, and technology to navigate the dangerous and complex raid. The mission's risky nature demands quick, decisive actions and impeccable coordination. The success or failure of their mission has the potential to alter global geopolitics and bring closure to years of exhaustive pursuit. The narrative focuses on the bravery, meticulous planning, and the ethical and emotional challenges the SEALs face as they prepare to strike at the heart of global terrorism.
Writers: Kendall Lampkin
Release Date: 04 Nov 2012
Runtime: 90 min
Rating: Not Rated
Country: United States
Language: English, Arabic, Pashtu