Max Payne Blu-ray Review
Score: 67
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
Max Payne film disappoints yet shines in technical prowess; a mixed experience best enjoyed on Blu-ray.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 70
Max Payne's Blu-ray offers a stunningly dark, stylistic visual feast with perfect blacks, incredible depth, and a gritty, desaturated look, closely mirroring its video game origin.
Audio: 75
The movie disappoints, but its DTS-HD MA 5.1 soundtrack dazzles with its ferocious, room-shaking audio quality, making it a technical marvel worth experiencing.
Extra: 60
Rich DVD set offers in-depth commentary, HD and SD extras, but leans towards the technical side with insights and making-of content, though some features feel standard.
Movie: 43
High hopes for 'Max Payne' lead to disappointment; its mix of dark, supernatural elements and a revenge storyline underwhelms. Despite Wahlberg's effort, the film's mundane script and forgettable action fails to captivate or innovate within its video game-to-movie transition.
Video: 70
"Max Payne" shines on Blu-ray, presented in a widescreen 2.35:1 ratio with an AVC MPEG-4 codec, delivering a high-definition experience that is aesthetically reminiscent of "Sin City" yet distinct in its execution. The film's visual style is meticulously crafted, featuring inky blacks and a striking contrast that unveils remarkable depth and detail throughout. The clarity is exceptional, with no signs of digital compression or edge enhancement, and a subtle grain that adds texture without detracting from the overall sharpness. Colors are purposefully de-saturated, casting the film in deep blues and grays that enhance its moody atmosphere, while flesh tones remain natural yet chillingly cold.
The video presentation of "Max Payne" excels in recreating the look and feel of its video game origin, particularly in scenes where blacks and shadow details are showcased, presenting an unparalleled depth of field and three-dimensional quality in the falling snow against a multi-layered black backdrop. The selective use of vibrant primaries amidst the predominantly dark palette brings a punch to the visual narrative, with scenes utilizing CGI elements benefiting from superb depth and clarity that highlight even the most minute details.
Fox's Blu-ray release ensures that "Max Payne" is viewed as intended: dark, bleak, yet visually astounding. The 1080p, 2.40:1-framed transfer boasts fine clarity in its dark hues and shadows, maintaining realistic detail in every frame, from facial expressions to the nuances of the urban environment. Light grain preserves the film's gritty aesthetic, complementing the drab color scheme and resulting in flesh tones that are fittingly ghastly yet coherent within the film's icy veneer. This Blu-ray image achieves a near-theatrical quality presentation, evidencing Fox's commitment to delivering top-tier visual experiences.
Audio: 75
The audio presentation of "Max Payne" on Blu-ray, featuring a DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 track, delivers an exemplary home theater experience that may well compensate for the film's shortcomings. This mix stands out for its aggressive and immersive sound field, pushing the capabilities of each channel to create a surround sound experience that truly envelops the listener. From the very beginning, it's clear that this is an aggressive mix, designed to showcase the higher fidelity that lossless audio can provide. The soundtrack's dynamic range is impressive, with scenes filled with crisp detail and a low-level punch that brings every gunshot and ambient sound to life with startling clarity. Every bullets' whizz, explosions' roar, and gunfire's echo are rendered with such cohesive aural precision that one might find themselves instinctively looking over their shoulder, misled by the realism of the discrete sound effects.
This technical marvel doesn't stop at action scenes; its excellence extends to creating atmospheric sounds that enrich the storytelling. Ambient sounds like the bustling of an office or the flickering of a fluoresce light, and even the subtle rumble of quieter moments, are all conveyed with finesse, adding layers of depth to every scene. The LFE channel, in particular, is a powerhouse of deep, room-filling bass that will test the mettle of subwoofers and might just leave viewers grinning in disbelief at the sheer impact. Dialogue is consistently crisp and clear, ensuring that every line cuts through the densest action scenes without losing integrity. Sections like chapter 17’s shoot-out and chapter 24’s hallucinatory Valkyrie attack stand as testament to this soundtrack's refined balance between sheer power and intricate detail, enveloping viewers in a sound wave that comes from all directions—truly placing them in the heart of the action.
In essence, while "Max Payne" may not be universally celebrated for its cinematic achievements, its Blu-ray audio track is undeniably reference-quality material, boasting a visceral and technically precise sound design that amplifies the film's most thrilling moments. It's a showcase of how a well-orchestrated audio mix can elevate the viewing experience, making it a must-listen for audiophiles and an enticing reason to revisit the film, if only to experience the high-octane sonic extravaganza that this DTS-HD MA 5.1 lossless soundtrack offers.
Extras: 60
The Blu-Ray presentation of "Max Payne" boasts a suite of extras that collectively provide an in-depth behind-the-scenes look, although not all content impresses equally. The highlight is an engaging audio commentary led by Director John Moore, Production Designer Daniel Dorrance, and Visual Effects Supervisor Everett Burrell, offering technical insights and unknow anecdotes without unnecessary pauses. "Michelle Payne - Graphic Novel," presented in HD, adds depth to the narrative by exploring the backstory of Max's wife, though it's viewed as a slightly underwhelming addition. The two-part Picture Documentary offers a more conventional making-of glimpse filled with cast and crew interviews but struggles to move beyond the basics. The BonusView feature, "Walkthroughs and Cheats," exclusive to the theatrical version, attempts innovation but might test the patience with its PiP format. Completing the package are standard-definition trailers and a digital copy of the film on a second disc, providing flexible viewing options but with expected limitations in audio-visual quality.
Extras included in this disc:
Audio Commentary: Insightful commentary from the film's director and key behind-the-scenes figures.
Michelle Payne - Graphic Novel: An HD animated feature focusing on the backstory of Max's wife.
Picture Documentary - Part 1 & 2: Behind-the-scenes look featuring interviews and on-set footage.
Bonus View: "Walkthroughs and Cheats" featurette for an enhanced viewing experience.
Trailers: Previews for "Babylon A.D." and "Mirrors".
Digital Copy of Max Payne: Offers the film in a portable format for varied playback options.
Movie: 43
"Max Payne," starring Mark Wahlberg, makes its notch in the realm of video game adaptations with a presentation that tries earnestly to encapsulate the essence of its source material but ultimately lands in the realm of the forgettable. The movie transcends a simple narrative of revenge and introduces its audience to a world where the line between reality and dark fantasy begins to blur. Max, a tormented detective delving into the cold case files by day and piecing together the murder of his family by night, uncovers a mysterious drug with hallucinogenic powers tied to military experiments gone awry. This discovery leads him on a spiraling journey of betrayal and vendetta, marked by a blend of supernal elements that seem at once out of place and integral to the film's attempt at depth.
The film tries to position itself within a trio of genres: the gritty police drama, the supernatural thriller, and the all-guns-blazing action film, but its execution leaves much to be desired. While Wahlberg’s performance as Max Payne is solid if not stellar, suitable for the grim, vengeful detective he portrays, it’s not enough to elevate a script that struggles under the weight of its ambitions. The rest of the cast fulfill their roles in what feels like a backdrop to Max's tortured journey, contributing to a story that is more successful in its quieter, more introspective moments than in its frenetic action sequences. These sequences, though visually appealing and bolstered by impressive Blu-ray audio quality, fail to set the movie apart from countless others in the action genre.
Director John Moore attempts to infuse "Max Payne" with a visually stark, melancholic atmosphere reflective of its protagonist's inner turmoil. Despite these efforts and the film's faithful nods to its video game origins, including game-inspired scenes and a muted supernatural twist, "Max Payne" struggles to find its unique voice. The narrative drags through a middle section that feels disconnected from the ambitious thematic undercurrents it attempts to weave together. By its conclusion, the film presents a visually compelling but ultimately disjointed experience, emblematic of the challenges inherent in translating video games to cinema. It mirrors the fate of many before it—ambitious, aesthetically minded, but lacking the cohesion and depth to render it memorable beyond the immediacy of its action sequences.
Total: 67
Max Payne's transition from video game to silver screen is a journey fraught with the expected pitfalls of such adaptations, manifesting a product that nearly teeters on the brink of the forgettable. Its primary downfall lies in its inability to transcend the cursory narrative and underdeveloped characters that plague many of its peers, casting it into the abyss of missed opportunities for what could have been a rich cinematic experience. The film attempts to navigate the troubled waters of translating a deeply interactive experience into a passive one, resulting in a disjointed and at times confusing plot that strays too far from its roots, diluting the essence of what made Max Payne a household name among gamers.
Despite these shortcomings, it's impossible to overlook the Blu-ray presentation of Max Payne, which emerges as a phoenix from the ashes, offering an audio-visual feast that elevates the material far beyond its intrinsic value. The Unrated Cut, with an additional three minutes of content, hints at what might have been but ultimately serves as a band-aid on a wound too large. The technical excellence of the Blu-ray, highlighted by an astoundingly clear video quality and an audibly dynamic soundtrack that promises to test the limits of any home theater system, partially redeems this adaptation. Equipped with a high-definition projector or a state-of-the-art Blu-ray player, viewers can expect an immersive experience that showcases the film's few but notable strengths.
In conclusion, while Max Payne as a film may not have delivered on its promise of a compelling narrative faithful to its video game origins, its Blu-ray incarnation offers a redemption of sorts. It stands as a testament to how far superior audio and video quality can enhance the viewing experience, making it a worthwhile addition for aficionados seeking to showcase their high-end home theater setups. Despite its flaws, the Blu-ray's technical prowess makes it a must-own for collectors, albeit more for its demonstration of audio-visual capabilities than for the movie itself. It's a clear reminder that sometimes, the medium can indeed rise above the message, offering a sensory experience that almost justifies the venture.
avforums review by AVForumsRead review here
Video: 90
Visually, this film is incredibly stylistic and bears more than a passing resemblance to Sin City....
Audio: 90
The action scenes are so immersive that you'll be left drowning, gasping for air in the midst of it all....
Extras: 70
The beauty of both of these extras is that whilst there is some joviality going on, everyone was caught at opportune moments for them to make some rather intelligent comments....
Movie: 50
The enemy appeared to have a bit of the supernatural about them and my appetite had been suitably whetted....
Total: 70
It's not enough to save it but what lifts the film and more so the worth of this disc set is how technically good it is....
Blu-ray.com review by Martin LiebmanRead review here
Video: 90
This is definitely not the kind of film that jumps off the screen with vibrant hues and amazing depth, but what it does is shine in the context of its intended look, and the results often blow viewers...
Audio: 100
Although likely to be enjoyed first and foremost for its amazing action segments, this track also creates a strong atmosphere, with all the channels working to bring a subtle rumble during some scenes,...
Extras: 50
Picture is a two-part documentary (480p, 29:01 & 29:39) that is a lengthy but still rather basic piece that chronicles the making of the film, featuring a bevy of cast and crew interviews, behind-the-scenes...
Movie: 50
At day's end, the movie is entitled Max Payne, a title that, whether the viewer has played the game or not, instantly brings to mind visions of extreme violence, a one-man wrecking crew pulling off his...
Total: 70
The film succeeds as a character study of a man coping with the loss of his family; works well enough, though not memorably, as an action picture; and fails in trying to be too much rather staying focused,...
AVSForumRead review here
Video: 88
Many scenes in the film use a stylized look compromised mostly of dark blues, grays, browns and blacks which does a decent job of conveying the film's CGI based elements....
Audio: 94
Extras: 70
Bonusview PiP - Walk throughs and cheats, behind the scenes featurette, interview with Director John Moore Theatrical and Unrated versions of the film (HD) BD Previews - Babylon A.D. and Mirrors Digital...
Movie: 40
Hell-bent on revenge, he's determined to track down those responsible for the brutal murder of his family, but his obsessive investigation takes him on a nightmarish journey where dark fantasy collides...
Total: 73
Marantz DV7001 Universal Disc Player Denon AVR 5308CI THX Ultra 2 Preamp/Video Processor B&K Reference 200.7 Series 2 seven Channel amplifier Philips TSU9400 Pro Series Touch Panel Remote Control Canton...
Director: John Moore
Actors: Mark Wahlberg, Mila Kunis, Beau Bridges
PlotMax Payne is a maverick New York City detective whose life is shattered when his wife and baby are brutally murdered. Obsessed with finding those responsible, he leaves his job and dives into the city's underworld, seeking vengeance. He operates outside the law, trusting no one, as he embarks on a relentless quest for justice. His investigation leads him into a dark, complex world, where truths are buried, and betrayal is a constant threat. The pain from his past fuels his determination, pushing him to the edge of sanity in his search for answers.
As he delves deeper, he uncovers a conspiracy tied to a new, highly addictive drug that gives its users superhuman abilities but with lethal side effects. Allies are hard to come by, but he finds an unexpected one in Mona Sax, a woman seeking revenge for her sister's death, which is mysteriously linked to the same shadowy figures behind his family's murder. Together, they navigate a maze of corporate corruption and criminal intrigue, discovering that his family's death might not have been random but part of a much larger, more sinister plot. As he gets closer to the truth, the line between justice and vengeance begins to blur, challenging his notions of right and wrong.
Writers: Beau Thorne, Sam Lake
Release Date: 17 Oct 2008
Runtime: 100 min
Rating: PG-13
Country: United States, Canada
Language: English, Russian, Spanish