Humpback Whales 4K Ultra HD Blu-ray Review
Score: 75
from 3 reviewers
Review Date:
Humpback Whales: A visually stunning, informative journey with superb Ultra HD quality but few extras.
Disc Release Date
True 4K
HDR10
Dolby Atmos
DTS-HD MA
Dolby TrueHD
Video: 81
Despite HDR's current standards and calibration challenges, the review highlights Shout! Factory's 4K UHD presentation of 'Humpback Whales' with HDR and SDR options, superior detail, and immersive Dolby Atmos, though noting some fidelity and depth variation.
Audio: 80
The Dolby Atmos mix offers immersive, moderate surround activity, enriching underwater scenes with natural soundscapes and a well-balanced score, enhancing the documentary's engagement without overwhelming the narrative.
Extra: 50
The Humpback Whales set includes Ultra HD and 2D/3D Blu-rays with a 17-minute HD making-of documentary, 4K IMAX trailers, and a digital copy. Both Blu-rays feature the same extras, highlighting filming techniques and interviews.
Movie: 82
IMAX film 'Humpback Whales' explores humpbacks' recovery from near extinction, showcasing their acrobatics, songs, and motherly care, contrasting past whaling brutality with hopeful conservation progress.
Video: 81
The 4K UHD presentation of "Humpback Whales" by Shout! Factory is a visually fetching endeavor, encapsulating the majesty of its subjects with an enhanced level of detail and color depth, particularly through its HDR rendition. The package boasts a dual offering of HDR and SDR viewing options on the 4K disc, encoded via the modern HEVC / H.265 standard, ensuring compatibility and optimal viewing across a range of UHD setups. This release prominently benefits from the original IMAX footage being digitally scanned at an astonishing 11K resolution, then meticulously down-sampled to 4K. Such high-fidelity source material contributes to an outstanding clarity and depth of field in the imagery, especially noticeable in the nuanced textures of the whales and the vibrant undersea environments.
Visual nuances are further emphasized through HDR’s capability to delineate subtle tonal variations, especially within the documentary’s predominant shades of blue. This attribute is vital in conveying the natural beauty and serenity of the underwater realm and its inhabitants. The inclusion of both 2D and 3D Blu-ray versions—encoded via AVC and MVC respectively—offers a versatility in viewing preference, with the 3D version adding a layer of depth to certain scenes, albeit with variable success. While the standard Blu-ray excels in detail, particularly in underwater sequences, it marginally lacks the sharpness and dimensional consistency found in the 4K UHD version.
This release highlights a nuanced yet significant uplift in visual quality from standard 1080p presentations. Although there are mentions of minor HDMI handshake issues and a somewhat flat portrayal in select 3D sequences, these do not detract significantly from the overall experience. Shout! Factory's commitment to delivering a superior audio experience is also evident, with an immersive English Dolby Atmos soundtrack accompanying the visuals, alongside additional audio options catering to varied linguistic preferences. This comprehensive approach to both audio and visual elements firmly establishes "Humpback Whales" as a noteworthy addition to the highest echelons of nature documentary presentations in the 4K UHD format.
Audio: 80
The audio presentation of "Humpback Whales" on its 4K UHD Blu-ray release is highlighted by a Dolby Atmos track that offers a moderately active surround sound experience, effectively enhancing the immersive quality of the documentary. This Atmos mix effectively utilizes audio object placements including atmospheric sounds, acoustic nuances, and near-field effects, particularly noticeable during underwater sequences. These implementations capitalize on the documentary's sound design, ensuring an engaging auditory experience that complements the visual spectacle. Notably, the music is artfully blended into the soundscape, adding depth without overshadowing the intricate details of whale vocalizations and the narrated content, ensuring that the essence of the documentary is preserved and accentuated through sound.
The technical superiority of this release is underscored by its thoughtful audio configurations. The primary English Dolby Atmos track is complemented by alternate language tracks in DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 for French and Spanish audiences, with the standard Blu-ray version offering a lower resolution Dolby Digital 5.1 option. This variety in audio quality highlights the release’s versatility and commitment to delivering a rich auditory experience across different formats. Moreover, specific sequences in the film, such as the opening scene's venture into space and underwater explorations, showcase meticulous sound mixing with effective panning effects and a keen utilization of the surround channels to create a vivid and dynamic auditory environment.
Despite the occasional challenge where the narration by McGregor is slightly overpowered by the musical score, the overall mix maintains a well-balanced clarity and depth. The audio presentation notably benefits from the original IMAX footage's high-resolution scanning process, ensuring that the transition to home theater systems retains the detail and clarity intended by the filmmakers. The inclusion of two 4K versions of the film, one with HDR and one without, alongside a highly detailed audio mix, underscores a commitment to quality that audiophiles and casual viewers alike will appreciate. This audio presentation successfully enriches the viewing experience, allowing audiences to immerse themselves fully in the majestic world of humpback whales.
Extras: 50
The extra presentation of the 4K UHD Blu-ray of "Humpback Whales" offers a modest yet compelling suite of supplementary material across both its 4K UHD and 1080p Blu-ray discs, harmonizing technical prowess with insightful behind-the-scenes content. The highlight is the "Making Of" documentary, running just over 17 minutes, superbly showcasing the intricate processes behind capturing the stunning sequences featured in the main feature, complemented by enlightening interviews with the crew. Though typically not considered in evaluation, the inclusion of 4K IMAX Trailers of other films adds a touch of cinematic breadth to the package, providing viewers a glimpse into the broader world of IMAX documentaries. This collection, despite its brevity, enriches the viewing experience by detailing the meticulous efforts involved in bringing the majestic humpback whales to screen.
Extras included in this disc:
- Making of Documentary: An insightful behind-the-scenes look at capturing the film’s sequences, featuring interviews with the production team.
- 4K IMAX Trailers: Preview trailers for other IMAX films, highlighting the expansive nature of IMAX documentaries.
Movie: 82
The IMAX 3D presentation "Humpback Whales," now gloriously presented on 4K UHD Blu-ray by Shout! Factory, dives deep into the resplendent waters of Alaska, Hawaii, and the secluded isles of Tonga to bring audiences face-to-face with the profound intricacies of humpback whales. This short yet profound documentary captivates with stunning visuals and Ewan McGregor’s engaging narration, drawing a vivid comparison between the immensity of these creatures and more familiar objects like school buses and Lear jets for perspective. The bewitching imagery serves a poignant reminder of the humpbacks’ near-extinction due to the whaling industry's grim past, contrasted with their slow yet hopeful recovery. Viewers are treated to breathtaking scenes of these majestic beings communicating, nurturing their young, and displaying unparalleled grace beneath the waves.
"A synthesis of awe, concern, and enlightenment" could well describe the film's oscillation between showcasing the splendor of humpback whales in their natural habitats and the somber history of human interactions with them. Archival footage and McGregor’s narrative introduce a darker chapter on whaling alongside the marvels of whale vocalizations which spearheaded the environmental movements toward their preservation. The film does not shy away from addressing ongoing threats—entanglement in fishing nets, the impacts of noise pollution on their communication—yet it also highlights the strides made in conservation. Through intimate glimpses of these 55-foot marvels, particularly the nurturing relationship between mothers and calves, "Humpback Whales" elucidates both the enigmatic nature of these cetaceans and humanity’s evolving rapport with them.
Running at a concise 39 minutes, this 4K UHD release matches its visual grandeur with a compelling narrative that underscores humanity's changing relationship with humpback whales—from exploitation to conservation. The film's exploration into their complex communication, showcased through sequences that delineate their songs and social behaviors, echoes a broader reflection on human empathy and our capacity for change. As much as "Humpback Whales" displays the ethereal beauty and acrobatic feats of its subjects, it equally serves as a beacon of hope for the preservation of these once nearly-extinct giants, urging a harmonious coexistence with the majestic inhabitants of our oceans.
Total: 75
"Humpback Whales" on 4K UHD Blu-ray presents an exceptional blend of breathtaking visuals and enriching content that dives deep into the life and mysteries surrounding humpback whales. Released by Shout Factory, this package not only offers a stunning Ultra HD visual experience but also treats viewers to an immersive Dolby Atmos soundtrack. However, it's notable that while the audio-visual aspects receive high praise, the extras included in this release could be seen as somewhat thin on the ground. The centerpiece among the bonus materials is a 17-minute behind-the-scenes featurette, "The Making of Humpback Whales," accompanied by trailers for other notable documentaries available or soon to be released by Shout in 4K UHD.
As an educational piece, "Humpback Whales" doesn't fall short, providing insightful details about these magnificent marine creatures and the ongoing efforts by scientists to unravel their mysteries. It also does not shy away from discussing the complex relationship humans have had with whales, highlighting both the awe they inspire and the conservation challenges they face. The technical execution of this documentary stands out, with its visual splendor being a hallmark of IMAX productions and its sound design leveraging the latest in audio technology to create a rewarding viewing experience.
In conclusion, "Humpback Whales" on 4K UHD Blu-ray is a must-have for both documentary enthusiasts and nature lovers. Its top-tier visual and audio presentation sets a high standard, although the package could benefit from a richer selection of special features. Despite this minor quibble, the documentary stands as a testament to the beauty and mystery of humpback whales, offering viewers a captivating and educational experience that is highly recommended.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 90
There's still a bit of variable sharpness at various times, and some of the quick views of humpbacks jumping above the water line look just slightly coarser than the bulk of the presentation (something...
Audio: 90
The documentary's enjoyable score provides a glut of spill through the side and rear channels, and an opening scene that ventures into outer space for a moment (don't ask me) features some wonderful panning...
Extras: 60
Both the 4K UHD and standard 1080p Blu-ray discs contain the same supplemental material: Making Of (1080p; 17:07) has some fantastic shots showing how various sequences were filmed, along with some good...
Movie: 80
The almost pathological need by Mankind to impose dominance over the various other species inhabiting this planet provides part of the backdrop to the appealing IMAX film Humpback Whales, a relatively...
Total: 100
Humpbacks continue to be one of the great mysteries of our planet, and Humpback Whales does a good job in detailing what contemporary scientists are attempting to learn about them, while also showing how...
The Digital Bits review by Bill HuntRead review here
Video: 90
The first is a 4K Ultra HD Blu-ray disc that includes two versions of the film in 4K – one with HDR and one without....
Audio: 95
The first is a 4K Ultra HD Blu-ray disc that includes two versions of the film in 4K – one with HDR and one without....
Extras: 60
Movie: 95
When it was realized that these giant mammals actually speak with a complex underwater song language, and that they seem to exhibit empathy – even to the extent of protecting other species of animals from...
Total: 85
Extras on the 4K disc include the 17-minute featurette, The Making of Humpback Whales, as well as trailers for The Last Reef, Wonders of the Arctic, Rocky Mountain Express, Journey to Space, Flight of...
AVSForum review by Ralph PottsRead review here
Video: 100
With that in mind, my approach to reviewing Ultra HD Blu-ray will be to assess the elements observed which I find to generate the most significant visual impact when compared to standard high definition...
Audio: 90
This is done to good effect when implemented and creates an enriching level of immersion that coincides with the onscreen events nicely....
Extras: 40
...
Movie: 80
Join a team of researchers as they unlock the secrets of the humpback and find out why humpbacks are the most acrobatic of all whales, why they sing their haunting songs, and why these intelligent, 55-foot,...
Total: 78
It comes to home video in the Ultra HD/3D/2D Blu-ray Combo pack from Shout Factory featuring sparking Ultra HD video quality, rewarding lossless surround sound, including a Dolby Atmos mix, and a lackluster...
Director: Greg MacGillivray
Actors: Ewan McGregor
PlotEmbarking on an eye-opening journey into the mysterious world of one of the planet's most awe-inspiring marine mammals, viewers are introduced to the humpback whales that traverse the globe's expansive oceans. These whales, known for their incredible size and acrobatic breaches, possess a complex and engaging behavior that has intrigued scientists and nature lovers alike. The documentary focuses on the lives of these ocean giants, following them through their annual migrations which cover thousands of miles, from the warm breeding grounds near the equator to their feeding grounds in the polar waters. The film captures the intimate behaviors of the whales, from nurturing their young to their playful interactions and their use of complex songs, which reverberate throughout the deep.
With a narrative that underscores the fragile interconnectedness between humans and the natural environment, the film explores the efforts taken by researchers and conservationists to understand and protect the humpback whale population. The audience is taken to spectacular underwater landscapes in Alaska, Hawaii, and the remote islands of Tonga, where they witness both the beauty and the challenges faced by these magnificent creatures. Showcasing the importance of preserving the fragile ecosystems that humpback whales, and countless other species, depend on, the documentary shines a light on the pressing need for conservation and the role that every individual can play in safeguarding the future of the planet's biodiversity.
Writers: Stephen Judson
Release Date: 13 Feb 2015
Runtime: 40 min
Rating: N/A
Country: United States
Language: English