Song of Norway Blu-ray Review
Score: 62
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
An unwieldy film with limited emotional depth, but visually splendid with superb orchestrations and standout performances in music and cinematography.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 76
Kino Lorber's Blu-ray release of 'Song of Norway' boasts an AVC encoded 1080p transfer in 2.35:1, showcasing splendid cinematography with vibrant outdoor scenes and sharp, natural grain. However, occasional scratches, slight color shifts, and center-screen crimping are minor detractors from an otherwise clear presentation.
Audio: 71
The Blu-ray of 'Song of Norway' features DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 and 2.0 tracks, providing superb symphonic treatments of Grieg's music and clean dialogue. While rear channel activity is minimal, the front soundstage is full with excellent fidelity, and ambient effects are well-placed in outdoor scenes.
Extra: 26
The engaging commentary by Lee Gambin and John Harrison, while often diverging into discussions of other film musicals and the era's popular movies, adds valuable context alongside trailers for Kino Lorber releases like 'Sweet Charity' and 'Clambake,' though it notably omits a trailer for 'Song of Norway' itself.
Movie: 51
Despite stunning Norwegian landscapes and lush orchestrations by the London Symphony Orchestra, 'Song of Norway' suffers from an outdated operetta structure, unengaging narrative, lackluster casting, and mismanaged musical numbers that miss the mark for 1970s audiences.
Video: 76
Kino Lorber's Studio Classics brings "Song of Norway" to Blu-ray with an AVC encoded 1080p transfer, presented in a 2.35:1 aspect ratio. This transfer captures the film’s stunning cinematography beautifully, with outdoor scenes rendered in a warmly suffused palette that highlights the precise resolutions of mountain mists and the intricate textures of natural elements like grasses and flowers. The presentation handles fine patterns on elaborate costumes skillfully, ensuring they resolve clearly. Natural grain is consistently maintained throughout the film, adding to the authentic cinematic feel.
While the presentation is commendable in many areas with excellent sharpness, robust color, and precise contrast, it isn't without minor flaws. Occasional signs of damage are visible in the form of small scratches and dirt. Moreover, there are curious instances of crimping in the center of the screen in some scenes, which is a notable distraction. Another minor issue is a slight purplish undertone observed in several scenes, yet these issues do not significantly detract from the overall enjoyment. The film unfolds seamlessly across ten chapters, providing a clean and high-quality viewing experience overall.
Audio: 71
The audio presentation of "Song of Norway" on Blu-ray features both DTS-HD Master Audio 5.1 and 2.0 tracks, delivering a high-fidelity auditory experience. The symphonic treatments of Edvard Grieg's music are superbly rendered, with the surround track providing a spacious and immersive atmosphere. Instrumental clarity is particularly noteworthy, effectively supporting the vocal performances. Ambient environmental effects are thoughtfully placed, enhancing the plethora of outdoor scenes that the movie offers. While the dialogue is generally clean and clear, some performers’ heavy accents are occasionally noticeable. Optional English subtitles are available to assist viewers.
Both audio tracks, while excellent in their own right, exhibit a full front soundstage that ensures dialogue and song lyrics are primarily directed towards the center channel. Fans will appreciate the absence of age-related anomalies such as hiss, pops, crackle, and flutter, which often plague older releases. However, it is essential to note that this Blu-ray version does not include overture, intermission, or exit music. Despite lacking dynamic rear channel activity, the DTS-HD Master Audio tracks excel in delivering a pristine and pleasurable audio experience that complements the film's visual grandeur.
Extras: 26
The Blu-ray extras of "Song of Norway" offer a mixed bag for enthusiasts and historians. The highlight is the in-depth audio commentary featuring film historians Lee Gambin and John Harrison. Their discussion, while at times meandering into topics beyond the film, provides engaging insights into the era's musicals, other contemporary movies, and interesting anecdotes about the real-life figures portrayed. Kino Lorber trailers for other releases are included, but notably, the trailer for "Song of Norway" is missing.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary by Film Historian/Author Lee Gambin and Film Historian/Author John Harrison: In-depth but digressive commentary on film musicals, contemporary movies, and historical figures.
- Kino Trailers: Trailers for "Sweet Charity," "A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Forum," "Clambake," and "Daddy Long Legs."
Movie: 51
"Song of Norway" is an ambitious adaptation of the 1944 Broadway operetta, directed by Andrew L. Stone and released in 1970, during an era when operettas were largely out of favor. The film dramatizes the life of Norwegian composer Edvard Grieg, featuring a largely fictionalized plot that attempts to position the work within the same family-friendly musical space as "The Sound of Music." However, it falls short due to its disengaging narrative and misaligned casting choices. Although the lead Toralv Maurstad's performance is lackluster, Frank Porretta's portrayal of composer Richard Nordraak offers some vocal relief with his operatic tenor. Florence Henderson contributes a pleasant soprano, yet doesn't possess the dynamic presence that might have elevated the film's musical moments.
Technically, the film showcases some stunning location photography by Davis Boulton, capturing Norway's picturesque landscapes in breathtaking detail. This visual appeal is complemented by lush orchestrations from Roland Shaw, performed fervently by the London Symphony Orchestra. These elements are undoubtedly among the film's highlights, alongside memorable musical numbers like "Hill of Dreams" and "Three There Were." Yet, many songs feel awkwardly integrated into the storyline, disrupting the film’s flow and limiting its emotional impact.
"Song of Norway" was an odd choice for a musical revival in 1970, reflecting its misjudged timing in a period that favored more contemporary themes. While the movie offers visually captivating scenes and a few standout musical performances, the overall experience suffers from a cumbersome plot and unremarkable casting that prevent it from achieving the widespread appeal it so desperately seeks.
Total: 62
"Song of Norway," despite its notoriety as a flop, manages to present itself as a visually splendid piece with superb orchestration. Frank Porretta and Florence Henderson's singing enhances the film's distinction, which keeps it afloat. While the emotional content is nearly non-existent, the film compensates with its picturesque cinematography and polished technical presentation.
The Blu-ray release ensures that these visual and musical elements are considerably well-preserved. The high-definition transfer accentuates the vibrant Norwegian landscapes and the intricate period details which are pivotal in creating the immersive environment. Despite some minor issues, such as occasional inconsistencies in color grading and grain, the audio quality remains robust, allowing the lush orchestrations and vocals to shine through.
In conclusion, "Song of Norway" isn't revitalizing the genre of film musicals. It's an unwieldy production lacking deep emotional resonance but somewhat redeemed by its visual appeal and strong musical components. The Blu-ray technical merits make it a worthwhile consideration for enthusiasts of classic musicals.
Blu-ray.com review by Jeffrey KauffmanRead review here
Video: 80
As mentioned above in the main body of the review, one of the film's undeniable assets is its gorgeous cinematography, and it's generally very well rendered in this presentation....
Audio: 80
The surround track offers a good, spacious accounting of the instrumental forces, while also offering excellent support for the singing....
Extras: 20
Author John Harrison Additionally, trailers for other Kino Lorber releases are included, but not the trailer for Song of Norway....
Movie: 50
The most successful of these was Kismet, which adapted the music of chemist turned composer Alexander Borodin, but the pair also attempted the same technique, albeit with considerably less success, with...
Total: 50
Kind of incredibly, despite the fact that Song of Norway was at least perceived as a notorious flop (it actually made a little money, if not a huge profit), producer and director Andrew L. Stone somehow...
Home Theater Forum review by Matt HoughRead review here
Video: 90
Though most of the film looks simply splendid with excellent sharpness, robust color, and precise contrast, there are some curious instances of crimping in the center of the screen on a couple of occasions,...
Audio: 80
Neither offers great activity in the rear channels though the front soundstage is full and offers good fidelity....
Extras: 40
Audio Commentary: film historians Lee Gambin and John Harrison contribute a talky commentary more notable for talking about almost everything but Song of Norway taking frequent side roads to discussing...
Movie: 60
Director Andrew L. Stone took only some of the narrative ideas from the Broadway operetta created by Robert Wright and George Forrest (who also took the Grieg classical pieces and restructured them into...
Total: 60
It’s not a great film musical, but there is some great music contained in Song of Norway, and its picturesque cinematography and great singing by Frank Porretta and Florence Henderson give it some distinction....
Director: Andrew L. Stone
Actors: Florence Henderson, Toralv Maurstad, Christina Schollin
PlotIn a picturesque Norwegian village during the 19th century, young Edvard Grieg shows immense talent for music, captivating everyone with his piano skills. Encouraged by his parents and inspired by the natural beauty surrounding him, Edvard decides to pursue a career as a composer, striving to capture the spirit of Norway in his compositions. He receives guidance from prominent musicians and falls in love with a local girl, Nina, who dreams of sharing his musical journey. With her support, Edvard moves to Copenhagen to further his studies and make a name for himself in the world of classical music.
As Edvard immerses himself in his work, he faces numerous challenges including financial hardships and creative struggles. Nina remains his steadfast partner, standing by him through the highs and lows. Despite initial setbacks, Edvard's unique compositions begin to gain recognition, slowly transforming him into a celebrated artist. As success beckons, Edvard grapples with the demands of fame and the pressures to compromise his artistic integrity. Throughout his journey, he remains committed to honoring his homeland and expressing its essence through his music while navigating the complexities of love and ambition.
Writers: Homer Curran, Milton Lazarus, Andrew L. Stone
Release Date: 04 Nov 1970
Runtime: 138 min
Rating: G
Country: United States
Language: English