The Good Book Blu-ray Review
Slipcover in Original Pressing
Score: 47
from 2 reviewers
Review Date:
The Good Book offers an ambitious exploration of techno-paranoia with notable tension, yet suffers from execution flaws and filmmaking limitations.
Disc Release Date
DTS-HD MA
Video: 34
The Good Book's Blu-ray AVC-encoded 1080p image, with a 1.85:1 aspect ratio, suffers from analog fuzz, limited detail, and muddy colors. Smoothness filters obscure textures, while black levels are solid but struggle in poorly lit scenes.
Audio: 44
The 2.0 DTS-HD mix of 'The Good Book' offers clear dialogue with post-recorded tracks, respectably capturing the aged production's limitations. While music lacks crispness, the synth soundtrack remains appreciable, balancing effects and maintaining overall audio satisfaction.
Extra: 76
The Blu-ray extras for "The Good Book" offer a comprehensive dive into its production through engaging commentary and a 53-minute making-of featurette, featuring insights from key creators and cast. Highlights include isolated music cues with composer Chris Paine, behind-the-scenes photos, and short films by Matthew Giaquinto.
Movie: 41
The Good Book, a low-budget shot-on-video film by Matthew Giaquinto, ambitiously explores themes of cyber paranoia and faith amidst a dystopian future dominated by internet control; while visually limited and hindered by wooden performances, it delivers an engaging philosophical narrative with inventive editing and humor.
Video: 34
The Blu-ray presentation of "The Good Book" showcases the film in an AVC-encoded 1080p format, with its original aspect ratio of 1.85:1, aiming to endow a typically shot-on-video production with a more cinematic feel. Unfortunately, the extensive use of filtering to mitigate the "video-y" appearance significantly impacts the visual detail, stripping away any nuances of facial textures or costume particulars and leaving only a generic appreciation of objects and characters. The attempt to enhance the image often results in a loss of clarity, compounded by the analog fuzz that contributes little to the detail richness.
Color reproduction suffers notably, presenting muddy hues where primary colors lack vibrancy except in select broad set-pieces. The black levels are consistent but do not salvage the experience as much of the film engulfs into poorly lit scenes, challenging even high-end television setups like OLED screens to deliver a satisfying viewing experience. Despite these shortcomings, the source material is in decent condition given the production's inherent limitations, allowing some scenes to effectively maintain visual cohesion when lighting conditions permit.
Audio: 44
The audio presentation of "The Good Book" on Blu-Ray employs a 2.0 DTS-HD mix, which offers a nuanced yet distinctly dated auditory experience. This sound profile captures dialogue exchanges with clarity, albeit within the confines of its era's production capabilities and technical limitations. While dialogues primarily rely on post-recorded tracks to ensure a cleaner presentation, on-camera microphone use introduces noticeable echo, particularly in enclosed environments.
Complementing the dialogue, the mix delivers music and effects with a balanced prominence. The synthesized sound that characterizes the film's score is captured effectively, maintaining an appealing quality that resonates with the film's distinctive style. However, despite its clear articulation, the music lacks the sharpness expected from modern audio standards. Nonetheless, the music and effects are thoughtfully integrated, ensuring they enrich rather than overwhelm the film's texture.
Overall, while the 2.0 DTS-HD audio mix may exhibit aspects of antiquity reflective of its original production era, it succeeds in providing a satisfactory and immersive auditory experience. The balance between dialogue, music, and effects ensures that each component is distinct yet harmonious, contributing to the feature's enduring appeal.
Extras: 76
The Blu-ray edition of "The Good Book" offers an extensive collection of bonus features designed for enthusiasts interested in film production and behind-the-scenes insights. The package includes an intimate audio commentary by director Matthew Giaquinto and producer Barry Gerdsen, which provides a deeper understanding of the creative process. The standout feature is the comprehensive Making Of, a 53-minute documentary that includes input from various cast and crew members via video conferencing, offering a collaborative perspective on the film's creation. Composer Chris Paine's Isolated Music Cues delivers intriguing insights into the film’s score. Fans will appreciate the unique inclusion of the full version of "Vampire Girlfriend Roommates Part 5," presented in SD format. Additional content includes a photo gallery and a selection of Matthew Giaquinto's short films, highlighting his cinematic journey and narrative style.
Extras included in this disc:
- Audio Commentary: Features director Matthew Giaquinto and producer Barry Gerdsen.
- The Making of The Good Book: A detailed examination of the film's production.
- Isolated Music Cues: With insights from composer Chris Paine.
- Behind the Scenes Photos: A collection from the film's inception.
- Vampire Girlfriend Roommates Part 5: A complete film-within-a-film offering.
- Short Films by Matthew Giaquinto: Includes "The Day I Met My Mother," "Finding Destiny," and "Bad Feelings."
- The Between Time: Discussion and presentation of an animated short.
- Proof-of-Concept Trailer: An early promotional glimpse.
Movie: 41
"The Good Book" ventures into the speculative realm of a dystopian future where humanity is embroiled in the complex web of media control and cyber paranoia. Directed by Matthew Giaquinto, this ambitious shot-on-video project unfolds in a world where the internet governs societal behavior under a quasi-dictatorial regime. The protagonist, Cyrus (portrayed by Bryan Campbell), is a service technician navigating a wasteland populated by transformed, zombie-like outsiders. Tasked with maintaining digital connections for isolated citizens, Cyrus encounters an enigmatic deity figure played with zeal by Barry Gerdsen. This god-like entity pushes Cyrus towards a profound crisis of faith by urging him to deploy a catastrophic virus intended to dismantle society’s technological crutch.
The film's execution capitalizes on its modest budget, which confines much of the narrative to intimate spaces like rooms and garages. Despite these limitations, it defies its constraints through inventive editing techniques and digital effects that evoke a distinctly student-project ambiance reminiscent of early SOV (shot-on-video) filmmaking. The movie blends philosophical musings on faith with gritty B-movie elements, benefiting from brainstorms such as Mad Max-ian visual cues and suspenseful sequences. However, the film’s narrative depth occasionally flounders amid problematic camerawork and unpolished performances, giving scenes an energetically rough-edged yet captivating quality.
The Good Book draws on cyber-thriller conventions and layers them with a satirical undercurrent of humor, accentuated by its depiction of over-the-top zombie chaos and state-influenced media content. Despite the limitations in production, the film offers a notable exploration of cyber-driven dystopia. It succeeds in creating engaging discourse while delivering enough action and character-driven drama to spur viewer interest, even if just as an intriguing indie entry in the realm of cyberpunk cinema.
Total: 47
"The Good Book" taps into the mid-’90s vein of techno-paranoia, exploring the unsettling consequences of surrendering to the digital realm. The film is ambitious, striving for an elevated sense of paranoia and unreality that is both refreshing and thought-provoking. Despite its lofty goals, director Giaquinto encounters challenges due to amateur performances and budgetary constraints, which occasionally hinder the film's impact. However, his dedication to the thematic core is evident, consistently pushing the narrative towards a pressured and gripping climax.
The Blu-ray release by Saturn’s Core offers a commendable presentation, considering the inherent limitations of the source material. While the video quality meets expectations for a film of this era and budget, it is the audio where this release notably shines. The DTS 2.0 track provides a clear auditory experience, crucial for fully appreciating the film's tension and atmosphere. Additionally, the disc includes a range of bonus features, providing ample exploration opportunities for enthusiasts eager to delve deeper into the film's concept and production background.
In conclusion, "The Good Book" is an intriguing exploration of human detachment in the face of advancing digital control. While the execution may falter at times due to its constraints, the film’s intent and charisma remain poignant and engaging. The Blu-ray delivers a solid experience that complements the film’s ambition and is definitely worth a look for fans of niche '90s cinema and speculative narratives.
Blu-ray.com review by Brian OrndorfRead review here
Video: 40
Plenty of filtering has been employed to combat the video-y look of the feature, which eliminates all potential detail, leaving only a basic appreciation of objects and characters....
Audio: 60
The 2.0 DTS-HD mix provides an aged understanding of dialogue exchanges, which are also limited by production equipment and technical abilities....
Extras: 100
Making Of (53:10, HD) is hosted by director/co-writer Matthew Giaquinto and producer/co-writer/actor Barry Gerdsen, who walk through the production process on "The Good Book," periodically joined by members...
Movie: 50
"The Good Book" doesn't have the budget to imagine a futureworld of societal fracture, leaving Giaquinto to work with what he has, which means most of the action takes place in small rooms and garages,...
Total: 60
"The Good Book" is ambitious, which is refreshing, trying to mount a more stimulating level of paranoia and unreality, leading to a pressurized conclusion....
High-Def DigestRead review here
Video: 40
Colors are muddy with primaries showing no strength beyond their use in broad set pieces like the red vagina portal through which the deity passes....
Audio: 40
Dialogue is clear and clean though it uses post-recorded tracks for most of the exchanges....
Extras: 60
Matthew Giaquinto Short Films: The Day I Met My Mother (1995) (HD 11:47) -with optional commentary by Matthew Giaquinto and Barry Gerdsen Finding Destiny (2002) (HD 2:16)...
Movie: 40
Between the camera movement, scene blocking, and early digital editing effects it’s an amazing display of knowledge from the filmmakers....
Total: 60
The mid-’90s was a wellspring for techno-paranoia and The Good Book leaves no question about the consequences of losing your humanity as you give in to the digital overlords....
Director: Matthew Giaquinto
Actors: Bryan Campbell, Barry Gerdsen, Chris Paine
PlotIn a small, tightly-knit community, an ancient, mysterious book is discovered in the attic of a crumbling church. The book seems old, its origins elusive and its content bewildering to those who try to decipher it. As curiosity spreads through the town, different residents gather to unlock its secrets. Among them is Jack, a local librarian with a passion for historical artifacts. Alongside him are his friend Alex, a skeptic who questions the book’s powers, and Sarah, a new resident drawn strangely to the tome. The trio embarks on a quest to uncover the book's true purpose, suspecting it holds profound wisdom or perhaps even the key to some untapped potential that could benefit humanity.
As they delve deeper into their investigation, tension mounts within their group and the larger community. Differing interpretations of the book's meaning spark debates and fractures in relationships, revealing long-buried secrets and personal conflicts. Jack becomes increasingly obsessed, while Alex remains dubious about their chances of unveiling anything substantial. Amidst growing hostilities, they discover peculiar occurrences linked to the book, blurring the lines between reality and myth. Their journey takes them to unexpected places, challenging their beliefs and testing their friendships as shadows from the past threaten to overwhelm them. Unbeknownst to them, each step forward brings them closer to a revelation that could alter their perceptions forever, compelling them to face hidden truths and redefine what constitutes genuinely significant knowledge.
Writers: Barry Gerdsen, Matthew Giaquinto
Release Date: N/A
Runtime: 81 min
Rating: N/A
Country: United States
Language: English